Health Care Reform: The ACA and Beyond
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The U.S. Supreme Court recently heard arguments both for and against President Obama's health care reform initiative, known as the Affordable Care Act. The provision at the center of the legal debate, known as the "individual mandate," requires all adults to buy health insurance, either through their employers or by buying it themselves. Knowledge@Wharton talked with Wharton professor Scott Harrington about the possible outcomes of the court case; the potential implications for businesses and consumers, and ongoing questions about how to improve the country's health care system. 📂 Health Care Management;Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] um first of all I'd like to talk to you about the key provision of the slau what
- what it seem to spark the most of eight is known as the individual mandate which
- requires all adults to buy health insurance either through their employers or buying it themselves could you talk
- to me a little bit about your views on this on this provision well these reflect once attitude towards whether
- it's constitutional and then the attitude towards the economics I primarily have considered the economics
- of a mandate and in principle a mandate can help overcome a free rider problem where people might not buy health
- insurance and then they go get care and emergency rooms or other contexts for which they can't pay and to some extent
- the cost of that care may be shifted to other so any Economist says in principle
- if you force people to buy health insurance you can reduce that problem when you unpa though a mandate in
- practice if you're going to have a mandate you have to mandate that people bu something and you have to specify the
- characteristics of what they have to buy so it necessarily involves a considerable degree of government
- control over the underlying features of the insurance contract which in this case extends the federal government into
- defining the underlying l in features of an acceptable insurance contract in all
- states in contrast to our historical practice where the states have basically had most responsibility for making any
- kinds of determinations about health insurance the other things that I find questionable about a mandate one would
- be it's widely recognized that enforcement is likely to be imperfect the Mandate included in the Affordable
- Care Act the enforcement has several features that would like likely make enforcement less than perfect including
- Provisions in the law that say they're not going to really go after people that don't pay the penalties the other thing
- related to enforcement is that the penalties themselves are quite small they start out really small now to be
- sure after three or four years it'll be $695 for an individual up to 2 and a half% of a person's income and family
- penalties will be greater than that but the penalties themselves might be relatively modest so as a practical
- matter some people will avoid the Mandate the other the other thing that's really important about the Mandate
- enforcement and penalties however is I don't think anybody believes that we can have a law that says people have to buy
- medical insurance without providing extensive subsidies or exemptions to people or low penalties so that people
- with of modest means who predominantly are people who do not buy health insurance don't really get hammered by
- the imposition of the Mandate so if you Circle back then to this free rider problem the fact that people don't buy
- insurance they may get care that other people pay for my impression is that cost is relatively modest and when you
- fold in what the law has done in terms of stipulating the Mandate the cost of subsidies which will be paid by somebody
- taxpayers in general are going to be much greater than any uh benefit from reducing uncompensated care if you just
- look at the dollars the other thing that the Mandate involves as part of the overall law is that we're going to very
- much limit insurance companies ability to say set rates based on age which will in effect require younger people to pay
- much more for insurance than they would without the Mandate because of these rating restrictions under the law so to
- some extent we're going to fund this subsidy delivery system we're going to fund this procedure that's designed to
- get more people to have coverage by having young people face higher premiums than what they would if we remain if we
- stayed with the status quo to be sure many young people will be eligible for subsidies so now they're going to face a
- product where they may get a premium subsidy but they're facing a premium that apart from any subsidy is higher
- perhaps significantly higher than what they would pay without this law and overall that tax subsidy package the way
- that works I think is much more complicated and problematic compared to the simple view that if we mandate
- something we can overcome this free riter problem and what is your opinion of the overall of the Affordable Care
- Act sort of getting away from the Mandate I actively participated in in writing op-eds during the debate over
- the law and I published numerous op-eds where I explained why I thought specific
- parts of the law were not in the public interest and that we could take an alternative incremental approach to
- improve healthc care before moving in a fairly compreh comprehensive direction as we did with the Affordable Care Act
- the the package that I believe would be appropriate if we change the Affordable Care Act we get rid of the Affordable
- Care Act would rely more on altering the system to improve incentives for consumers to consider uh the cost of
- their care to shop for coverage to be able to choose among insurance policies and similar Market driven Market
- oriented changes now spe just specifically I think most people agree we needed to do something to improve the
- portability of insurance coverage for people that have insurance say at work and then they lose their jobs or they
- want to change jobs and there's only an imperfect there's an imperfect mechanism
- for such people to be able to get coverage without being underwritten by an insurance company and thus face
- possibly High premiums for having adverse health conditions or or pre-existing conditions we could have
- done we could do many things things to improve portability one would have been a simple approach would basically have
- said if a person has been continuously covered by health insurance then if they lose coverage at one work site or they
- somehow lose their coverage they are able to get coverage without regard to health status and pre-existing
- conditions uh another thing I think we could have done to Target people that for some reason don't get insurance when
- they're young and then later on decide that they may need insurance or they they want to enter the market but they
- have ad conditions or pre-existing conditions we could have expanded Federal support for state run high-risk
- pools that would allow people to get limited coverage even though they have pre-existing conditions at rates that
- protect them from a lot of the increase that they would face on a perfectly private Market a third thing and I think
- a lot of economists would agree with this is we should have focused more attention on the tax code which
- historically for people in Middle the upper brackets has really encouraged them to accept compensation in the form
- of health insurance rather than the form of cash pay and over time the exclusion
- of the cost of health insurance from taxable income for people with middle and high incomes have encouraged them to
- load up on health insurance which provides broad choice and has limited co-payments deductibles and the like
- what you're doing with that system is encouraging perhaps the most educated part of the population specifically the
- most affluent part of the population not to choose their health insurance with an
- even tradeoff between health insurance and salary but to get more health insurance which discourages them from
- paying close attention to the costs and increase overall costs the Affordable Care Act does do something beginning in
- 2018 high cost plans are going to have to pay a 40% excise tax I regard that as a step in the right direction I'm not
- sure I would have endorsed the specifics but as an alternative to the Affordable
- Care Act there are many propos proposals that would limit the tax subsidy to health insurance in ways that would
- encourage people people that are working with coverage to consider more carefully
- whether they want policies with higher deductibles and higher co-payments in exchange for a lower premium and I
- believe it would also encourage many workers to be willing to voluntarily choose Managed Care Arrangements such as
- health maintenance organizations that would have other mechanisms built in to control costs if you offer someone a
- significant premium reduction for going into a health maintenance organization where they may need to see a primary
- care physician before getting access to specials without the with limits on the tax subsidy I believe you'll see more
- voluntar voluntary choice of those types of Arrangements now I would just add to
- all that when I view the TA limiting the tax subsidy there are technical details
- that can make it tough but I I think it would be very important to try to do that in a tax tax neutral way I
- certainly would not favor eliminating the tax subsidy for health insurance or limiting it if you didn't somehow
- provide some offsetting reductions in taxes the short version there is I wouldn't endorse a tax increase without
- some offsetting uh reductions of other taxes if we move towards neutralizing the tax treatment of health
- insurance now what do you see as some of I mean can you talk a little bit about the possible outcomes of the Supreme
- Court case and I mean given each one where would we where do we go from here the case of course is complicated there
- are three main issues one is whether the law is right for adjudication prior to 2014 another one is whether the
- expansion of Medicaid inappropriately compels the states to participate but really the central issue is the
- individual mandate and whether it violates the Constitution I'd be surprised if the
- decisions that come down really relate to I would be stunned if it relates to the issue of whether the law is right
- for adjudication I'm less certain about what the court will say about Medicaid expansion regarding the individual
- mandate there are basically four possible outcomes one is the court says it's constitutional the entire law
- stands the second is the court says the individual mandate is unconstitutional but they let the
- remainder of the law stand as it is including the insurance reforms Community rating guaranteed to issue of
- coverage no underwriting for pre-existing conditions the creation of health insurance exchanges and the like
- a third possible outcome is that the court says we invalidate the individual mandate and because the insurance
- reforms are into are integrated with the individual mandate and that the entire package really consists of an integrated
- ho they get rid of title one which basically is all the insurance reforms including the insurance exchanges
- the fourth possibility perhaps if they also frown upon the Medicaid expansion is for them to declare the individual
- mandate unconstitutional and void the entire act to basically say that the entire law is
- inseparable from the individual mandate I would be surprised I would I would say what's
- likely to happen I would be more surprised than not if the court allows the individual
- mandate to stand and just basically says the law is okay I think there's a good chance of that but I'm inclined based on
- reading the transcripts of the court and doing a little bit of Court watching like other people do I'm inclined to
- think that the court will declare the individual mandate unconstitutional if they do that I would
- be surprised if they declare the entire law unconstitutional I wouldn't be astounded
- but I would I would basically be surprised I think given they invalidate the individual mandate probably what
- we're going to get is they say We'll isolate the Mandate and everything else STS or they will get rid of large
- portions or all of title one which is the package of insurance reforms of which the individual mandate would be
- deemed to be an integral part so it's sort of in the ranking I think the two most likely outcomes are they repeal the
- Mandate and either leave everything else or they repeal the Mand mate and the related Insurance reforms so I mean if
- they repeal the Mandate or repeal the Mandate and the related Insurance reforms I mean what would you say is
- most likely to happen next I mean what needs to happen next does Congress and the admin Obama administration just
- completely go back to the drawing board is there a way to maybe improve what's there I mean what what would you see as
- where does Healthcare go from here if the court were to invalidate the individual mandate but leave everything
- else stand it's difficult to predict what the Congress might do for obvious reasons
- especially given the election and we might have a change of presidence if the entire law were to
- remain but for the Mandate I believe it would be likely that the Congress would take legislative action to reduce some
- of the adverse effects of having eliminated the Mandate if the Mandate is eliminated and everything else is
- allowed to stand it will exacerbate the problem that's going to arise with the current law which is there will be a
- disproportionate number of people in poor health that will comply with the Mandate and seek coverage under the
- guaranteed issue and Community rating of individual coverage now we call that the
- adverse selection issue some people call it a death spiral issue because the penalties for non-compliance with the
- Mandate are already low I'm one of the people who thinks there will be a non-trivial amount of adverse selection
- which will put upward pressure on in premiums in the exchanges and the individual coverage that there will be
- strong cost growth because of adverse selection in those markets the way the subsidies are designed the federal
- government will end up picking up a large part of the cost if we do see that disproportionate risk selection and more
- sick people going into the pools that will create more strains obviously on the federal budget and the deficit so we
- already are going to have that problem to some extent my esteemed colleagues like Mark Paulie
- and others some people have said the mandate's so weak to getting rid of it probably won't matter that much I have
- to think it'll matter uh I can't quantify how much but I I think there's a difference between a penalty that
- could be two and a half% of one's income and no penalty at all plus the the ethical component of some people comply
- with the government law an important government law they don't look just at the penalty and do an economic
- calculations so I think if we get rid of the Mandate the adverse selection problem will be worse I think it
- probably will create enough concern that if we don't revisit the entire healthc care space Congress will do something to
- limit adverse selection which would involve uh allowing a free a window of opportunity for people to get coverage
- without being underwritten and if they don't get coverage within a certain window maybe they face potentially
- higher premiums if they have health conditions there are steps that can be taken to limit the adverse selection but
- I think much more importantly in the big picture if the Mandate itself goes but everything else stands it makes it more
- likely that we're going to end up with the overall structure of the law going forward but for what could happen come
- November with the election if the Mandate goes and the health insurance reforms go Community rating pre-existing
- conditions uh limitations on pre-existing conditions even eliminating the part of the law that would create
- state-based health insurance exchanges I think that makes it more likely politically that some sort of overall
- alternative to the ACA gets legs in the Congress clearly if the Republicans were
- to get a majority in the Senate and if we had a Republican president certainly the campaigns are saying that we will do
- a repeal and replace kind of scenario regardless of what the court does I think the Court's decisions could
- influence the ultim m excuse me the ultimate outcome and given I mean are there any
- initiatives currently in progress or PL things going on elsewhere that I mean you could see as a model like in terms
- of that you think would work well I mean if there is going to be some adjustment
- of the law or even if given what would happen in the election a complete rejiggering there have been proposals
- around for for many years that I would describe as Market oriented consumer Centric proposals for report for
- reforming Healthcare and I talked a little bit about this a few minutes ago but no one in the political domain has
- really put out a hard and fast plan it's all sort of generic uh these are the broad points but I think the broad
- points are good ones and just sort of sort of to reiterate one thing is to look at how protect how current features
- of legal environments that don't allow portability of coverage for people that have had continuous coverage do
- something to allow people that have had coverage if they changed jobs to be able
- to get coverage without facing significantly higher premiums because they've got some adverse health
- condition we can do things to greatly improve portability we've already got laws that enhance portability
- significantly but there are gaps we can close those gaps the second thing I mentioned is think very carefully about
- the tax subsidies that exist that are especially pronounced for middle and upper income taxpayers to load up on
- generous insurance with free choice of providers which puts strong upward pressure on costs we can help reduce
- costs by rationalizing the tax treatment of health insurance and wages to make people more neutral about whether they
- want more generous health insurance with choice of Provider or they're willing to
- accept some restrictions on choice of provider and greater co-payments for their health insurance in exchange for
- getting take-home pay third thing I think we do need to look very carefully at targeted areas where we can provide
- as a nation greater subsidies to people of modest means to get health insurance clearly the Affordable Care Act that's a
- major part of the ACT there are less intrusive and less costly methods and more targeted methods of of basically
- saying how big do we want the safety net to be how can we provide subsidies that
- will provide as few distortions as possible for incentives of the people to work but I believe even most
- conservative uh members of Congress and people that are running for office would
- be open-minded to an expansion of the safety net now to be sure given Federal deficit concerns It's A Hard Sell and
- it's hard to think about how are we going to get the dollars but if the Affordable Care Act were replaced there
- is some room to maneuver to simultaneously think can we provide more help to people with low income in order
- in order for them to get health care then the fourth thing again is people that fall between the cracks end up
- without insurance ins don't have the portability they don't have continuous coverage they need insurance and now
- they've got a pre-existing condition that's very expensive to insure have a safety valve in place expanded state
- level highrisk pools more Federal money for those pools but it's important to have some sort of penalty if a person
- waits to get coverage until they really need it so you can't say we're going to give you coverage at the same terms and
- conditions you would get if you were healthy I I don't think that works but we can provide some overall level of
- expanded safety nets now the kind of the big picture here we have a big picture going forward is how do we help control
- costs and improve quality of care or at least not reduce quality of care one philosophical view is to say if we can
- engage consumers more in their decisions about their health care and their health
- insurance that that will overtime create incentives that will help control costs
- I think that it's worth it to move in that direction to see incrementally if we try a consumer oriented model and we
- get benefits we can see the benefits working that would be terrific if it doesn't work and we continue to have
- crises after crisis with Healthcare then you can think about more top- down centralized approaches to trying to
- limit the amount of care that's provided in order to make it affordable I would just I would just also add regardless of
- how the ACA plays out we're going to have a battle over Medicare funding and we'll probably have a big battle over
- Medicaid funding so even if the court allows the ACA to stand and even if the election doesn't change the Dynamics so
- that there could be a repeal of the law or a substantial modification of the law
- sometime during the next two three or four or five years we are going to have a major debate in the United States
- about what we should do about Medicare to make it fiscally sustainable over the long run we're also going to have a
- major debate about Medicaid and how to make it fiscally sustainable with the federal and the state level over the
- long run those battles are going to be fought with tremendous implications for the future of the country regardless of
- how the Affordable Care Act uh plays out before the courts or in the Congress [Music]
Brief Summary
The episode discusses the Affordable Care Act's individual mandate, its economic impact, and potential Supreme Court outcomes.
Key points
- The Individual Mandate Explained. The individual mandate requires all adults to buy health insurance, addressing the free rider problem.
- Supreme Court Speculation. The speaker discusses potential outcomes of the Supreme Court case regarding the Affordable Care Act.
- Medicare Funding Battle. A major debate is looming over Medicare funding, regardless of the ACA's fate.
- Future of Medicaid. Discussions on Medicaid sustainability will have significant implications for the country.
Episode highlights
- The Individual Mandate ExplainedThe individual mandate requires all adults to buy health insurance, addressing the free rider problem.“If you force people to buy health insurance, you can reduce that problem.”1:02Apr 11, 2012
- Supreme Court SpeculationThe speaker discusses potential outcomes of the Supreme Court case regarding the Affordable Care Act.“I would be surprised if the court allows the individual mandate to stand.”11:31Apr 11, 2012
- Medicare Funding BattleA major debate is looming over Medicare funding, regardless of the ACA's fate.“We’re going to have a battle over Medicare funding.”20:54Apr 11, 2012
- Future of MedicaidDiscussions on Medicaid sustainability will have significant implications for the country.“Those battles are going to be fought with tremendous implications for the future of the country.”21:39Apr 11, 2012





