Affordable Care Act Subsidies, Coverage Losses, and What Comes Next
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Mark Vincent Pauly, professor emeritus of health care management at the Wharton School, analyzes the consequences of the Affordable Care Act’s enhanced subsidy expiration, its effects on insurance coverage and costs, and the potential implications of proposed reforms allowing individuals to choose plans using direct government funding.
ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.
#HealthPolicy #AffordableCareAct #HealthInsurance #Healthcare #HealthcareReform ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- We are seeing the impact of the benefits of federal subsidies with the Affordable Care Act, because we have also seen 1.5
- million people quit their health care plans through the ACA in 2026. This all because the subsidies were held up by
- members of Congress. That number also expected to rise due to the rising costs of health care. It shows just how important a
- financial component from the federal government is to this program. So what is the future for the ACA and what should we
- be thinking of an idea brought forward by President Trump of providing funds but letting people go pick the plan that
- they want? Pleasure to be joined by Mark Pauly, who is Professor Emeritus of Healthcare Management here at the Wharton
- School. Mark, great to have you back again. Thank you for your time. - Thanks, Dan.
- Obviously seeing people drop their plans en masse, this was kind of expected, especially if Congress
- was not going to be able to come to some sort of resolution on the— on the benefits.
- What's happened already is that the subsidies that were increased during the period of COVID have snapped back to their
- original design from 2014. And that has caused an estimated— well, we don't know yet, because the official sign-up period
- ends January 15, today. But the early returns suggest that when the dust clears, maybe up to 7 million people out of the
- 24 million or so, 21 million people who are buying insurance through the exchanges, they'll drop off of exchange coverage.
- There is a silver lining, though. Many of the— those who drop exchange coverage because it now becomes more expensive
- with a smaller subsidy, will go back onto employment-based coverage. Say, pick up a spouse's coverage or go to
- unsubsidized coverage, individual coverage off the exchange. So at least the smart money says that the net net
- impact on the number of people who are uninsured is going to be on the order of 2 million people. That's millions of
- Americans, of course, but that's less than 1% of the total population. So the sky's not falling here, although, if you
- remove any subsidy program, whether it was reasonable or unreasonable, the people who are getting the subsidy are going to
- suffer when the subsidy is taken away. Doesn't this, though, also highlight, again, something that
- I think you and I have talked about in the past, is, just the general need to focus on healthcare costs and look at
- what needs to be done in the future, if anything can be done, to make it more affordable for the public, en masse?
- Well, yes and no. I mean, most of what the consternation surrounding the ending of the enhanced Affordable Care Act
- subsidies is because of the subsidy. And of course, if your premiums are, for example— I actually looked these numbers
- up. A 50-year-old would have, under the enhanced subsidy, been paying only 7% of the total premium, and when the
- subsidy snaps back to the old level, that goes up to 19%. That more than doubles their premium. So they get a big kick in the
- head. But on the other hand, the amount of subsidy that's being provided by the rest of us isn't really reduced all that
- much. So mostly it's the subsidy removal that's causing the consternation here. If you look at, to get a more reasonable
- picture, what's happening to insurance coverage for people who get private insurance the way most people get private
- insurance, which is through their job, that premium is going up maybe five to 7%. Somewhat higher than average.
- And, you know— and it's not a good thing unless you're getting something for the money. But it's not near the doubling
- and tripling that CNN will tell you about that you should be concerned about. Of course, you know, frankly, I'm
- on Medicare, so this doesn't matter to me, personally. Other than that I'm such a soft- hearted person.
- So the idea being presented by President Trump of allowing the public to try and, you know, receive funds and go get their
- own healthcare, is that one that is a viable option in your mind? Well, it's probably viable in the sense that if it happened,
- it would happen. My guess is, depending on the rules— now, the rules in different bills are different. But depending on
- the rules, I would expect and would hope that most people would take that money and go buy the insurance they would
- have bought anyway. Maybe a little more affordable now, because they are getting the government subsidy. The
- alternative strategy of saying, "Well, I'll just put the money under my mattress and use it if I get sick." Well, that's okay,
- as long as you don't get too sick. But if you have a six-figure bill, you're not going to get a big enough subsidy to cover
- that, so you'll be exposed to financial risk. So I would advise people to take their subsidy money, if they call me,
- and go buy whatever insurance, with their enhanced income, they think they most prefer. The sort of mirror image that some people
- are talking about that could be linked with the cash subsidy from lump sum subsidy is either a health savings account or a
- much more limited coverage plan that people might be able to buy as short term insurance. But they could renew that year after
- year. That seems to be much less expensive insurance in terms of its premium than even the bronze plans. But again, you don't get
- something for nothing. That limited coverage insurance is limited coverage, and it exposes you to a fair amount of out of
- pocket risk if you get really sick. What do you think, then, has been the role that the ACA has
- played in our healthcare system over the last several years? Well, I think the main positive one, of course, is dramatic drop
- in the fraction of the population that's uninsured. Most of that drop occurred in the first round of the ACA. The
- enhanced subsidies pushed the percentage uninsured down a couple or three percentage points more to an all time
- low. But we're getting into the range of diminishing returns, where there are what I call the Evil Knievels of health
- insurance, people who think that they will never get sick and won't buy insurance unless you make them buy it. And even if
- it's free, you have to make them sign up for it. But so— but— but— so that's, I mean, putting in a plug here. That's why
- I favor a mandate that says, if you don't buy insurance, we're going to buy some insurance, some bare bones insurance for
- you. And if you want, you can— you will have to pay something for that, but it's— so it'd be like a tax. But— and then if you
- want, you can top up that coverage. But that idea of pairing a health savings account or a deposit type of subsidy
- with less generous, more catastrophic coverage, it's an old idea, actually an old Republican idea. It's been
- around for a long time. That seems to be what the President has in mind, although we don't know what the President really
- has in mind. Nor does he always. No, that's true. Yes. Mark, great to talk to you. Thanks
- very much for your time today. All the best. All right, thanks, Dan. You got it. Mark Pauly, who is a Professor Emeritus of
- Healthcare Management here at the Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Mark Pauly discusses ACA subsidies, their impact, and Trump's healthcare funding proposal.
Key points
- Impact of ACA Subsidies. The Affordable Care Act's subsidies are crucial, with millions expected to drop coverage.
- Future of ACA Under Trump. Discussion on Trump's proposal for healthcare funding and its implications.
- Insurance Coverage Changes. The ACA has led to a dramatic drop in the uninsured population.
Episode highlights
- Future of ACA Under TrumpDiscussion on Trump's proposal for healthcare funding and its implications.“So what is the future for the ACA?”0:28Jan 23, 2026
- Insurance Coverage ChangesThe ACA has led to a dramatic drop in the uninsured population.“The main positive one, of course, is dramatic drop in the fraction of the population that's uninsured.”6:44Jan 23, 2026





