Money Talks for Medicaid

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A natural experiment created by the Affordable Care Act showed that doctors were more likely to see Medicaid patients if the government reimbursement payments for doing so were increased. More: http://knlg.net/188HKwy 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so the the problem i'm trying to research is that medicaid underpays doctors and when medicaid underpays doctors it's
  2. hard for patients who have medicaid insurance to get to get to find the doctors they need
  3. to get the care they need either the providers that typically give care to low-income patients are you know
  4. struggling with their their finances or they they go out to doctors in the community and a lot of them don't want
  5. to see the patients that where they don't get paid a lot of money so as part of the affordable care act
  6. they decided to pay medicaid doctors more they pay them the same amount that they pay
  7. medicaid patients that like doubled the amount they got paid for those doctors that saw patients for
  8. for primary care um so the question is that we are studying um is are there more doctors willing to
  9. see these medicaid patients when they're paid like twice as much as they were before and as an economist it seems like
  10. a pretty obvious answer to that question that you know you you get paid more you're more
  11. likely to see patients but this was a critical policy question because this was a policy that was in
  12. and put in place for just two years just to see how well it worked um and and the hope was is that doctors
  13. would engage the system at a time where medicaid was expanding they're more patients available
  14. so what we did was we called up these practices pretended we had field workers who
  15. pretended they were patients and they said uh can i get a new patient appointment and then we just mark down
  16. whether they got an appointment or not it was as simple as that half the time those scripts included
  17. patients who had medicaid insurance and have time for a control group they had private insurance
  18. and we did this exact same study in 2012 before this policy went to effect and then again this past
  19. spring in 2014 right in the middle of the um of this implementation of this policy
  20. and we uh um and we saw about an eight percentage point jump in the percentage of uh patients who were
  21. getting appointments and uh what was really uh compelling about our findings was there's great variation between
  22. states in terms of how much pay increase because medicaid pays different amounts
  23. it's a state-run program and so for some states the jump was double 100 jump in others maybe 30 or 40
  24. percent in those states where the jump was double um the increase in appointment rates
  25. were about 15 and in those states where as much lower is about five percent so you saw this
  26. um much greater increase when they got paid even more and then when we looked in the private
  27. insurance group as a control to say you know maybe there's something else going on during
  28. the same time we saw no change at all so with some pretty compelling results it really suggested this policy worked
  29. to increase appointment availability for primary care physicians when you pay them more
  30. money in the medicaid system well this is a very uh timely research for um for policymakers
  31. it was a two-year policy that ended january 2015. so policymakers were really interested in whether this
  32. policy worked so the key takeaway is the policy worked um and another key takeaway
  33. is that um there's a debate about why patients why doctors don't see medicaid patients
  34. and what this suggests is that if you pay them reasonably they show up to see these patients that it's really about
  35. payment and it's not the fact that there may not be enough providers i mean there's some areas
  36. where there may not be enough providers overall but the solution if if physicians aren't seeing medicaid
  37. patients is to pay them adequately um this seems to our results seem to show it makes a difference
  38. when we started this study uh there was a lot of hesitation because it was the very beginning of
  39. this policy implementation as i said as a two-year policy it was starting up in 2013 and that was when we were getting
  40. ready for our second round um of data collection uh implementation was delayed by six
  41. months they had real trouble uh figuring out exactly how to pass through payments
  42. there's like capitated managed care it's a lot easier when it's a fee for service than when it's capitated so
  43. struggles with implementation and a lot of people said well the the payment is temporary
  44. and so doctors aren't going to change their patterns for a temporary policy and the other thing that we had heard is
  45. that a lot of physicians weren't really calling up the medicaid office and saying you know gee i really want to be
  46. in this program so a lot of the anecdotal evidence was pointing towards there really no
  47. being no action so at the end of the summer it was like september we took our first peek at the results
  48. and we were all very surprised um to see such a large unambiguous effect so really the surprise was that we found
  49. something particularly when the rhetoric at the time was that this policy really
  50. wasn't having an impact well i think the most practical implication um you know i guess i think about it for
  51. for policy makers a lot of discussion at the state level states were trying to decide if they
  52. wanted to you know extend this uh pay bump uh policy and uh what they were saying at the time
  53. was you know there's no evidence yet so we're not going to make a decision because there's no evidence but now we
  54. have evidence so i think the real practical um implication for people who are kind
  55. of on the front lines of deciding whether doctors should be paid more for this specific policy
  56. is that um you know there's there's evidence and evidence-based policy is an important way to make policy and here
  57. this policy seems to work but you know i think there's a a broader point that that can be made that's important
  58. for physicians who run businesses um and you know i think physicians are not um immune to the same economic
  59. incentives as anyone else running a business um you know i think that there's uh when you're talking about health
  60. there might be some you know maybe moral obligation to see everyone who comes in your office but you're you
  61. can't have an office that that can turn the light on unless you can pay the bills and
  62. when you don't pay enough to to you know turn the lights on to to see the patients who you know the
  63. reimbursement is like 30 or 40 dollars for a half hour of your time it's really hard for some of these doctors to
  64. justify that um in their day they're just trying to um you know have have a business where
  65. where they bring in more money than they spend so i think what this suggests is from a practical end particularly as
  66. someone who's running a business is that you know physicians are running businesses too um and they shouldn't be
  67. you know set up against different rules than than you know other businesses you know there's a lot of debate in
  68. congress right now i wouldn't say a lot of debate in congress but um this policy
  69. uh of this what we call the medicaid rate bump was introduced um in the president's budget just a couple weeks
  70. ago in february he he proposed to congress that they extend the pay bump for another two years and make some
  71. modifications and there's a lot that's going on in washington to to make some decisions
  72. about various aspects of health policy it's all very very political but from a practical end this is about a
  73. six billion dollar a year policy to pay medicaid providers for primary care at the same rate
  74. as uh as they pay for medic or pay medicaid doctors the same amount as medicare and cost six billion dollars which is
  75. really a drop in the bucket when you think of the trillion dollar medicaid you know aca bill um and so i
  76. think the practical implications is you know we know that there are some effects
  77. important effects for patients getting access to providers having continuity of care and there this
  78. provides some evidence that um that there's a benefit of this policy and you know that
  79. now the politicians have to decide um if that that payment you know that expenses is
  80. worth is worth it for the gain that you get the focus here was on primary care physicians
  81. in medicaid and that's what the policy was aimed at but uh in medicaid it's it's really difficult
  82. not only uh in some areas not only to get um access to primary care providers but
  83. if you have a need for specialty care it could be even more difficult the payment
  84. gaps for specialty care can be even more severe so the implications extend beyond primary
  85. care you pay doctors more they're more likely to extend appointment availability
  86. to patients with that insurance type and i think it would extend beyond primary care providers specialty care providers
  87. and in particular areas where that access is a real issue you know it suggests that that paying
  88. specialty providers more money would help address that problem there was a front page article
  89. in the times right in december when this two-year policy ended it was always a temporary policy
  90. and so payment rates doubled two years ago but when they went back down in uh january 1st the headline was doctors get
  91. pay cuts of 50 you know will they still see patients so i mean at that time it was a 50
  92. reduction in in the amount they were getting paid within medicaid but that was certainly a
  93. headline at the time um so i think uh what you know i believe you know what goes up is
  94. probably going to come down so in response to the headline what will happen now that rates
  95. uh payment rates have gone back down i think we can expect that the gains that we saw in the
  96. last two years in terms of more doctors participating in medicaid will probably go back down
  97. and you know we'll go back in the field and measure it but i think for for the impact on
  98. medicaid patients i think it's an important finding you know there's a perception
  99. that there are fewer doctors that see medicaid patients maybe it's because doctors
  100. don't want to see medicaid patients and what this research suggests is that if you pay them reasonably
  101. um they'll show up to to see these patients and and it's more about the payment rates than it is about something
  102. about this patient population this is the first time we've been able to look at the relationship
  103. between payment rates and physician appointment availability or just you know access participation
  104. medicaid program using experimental methods so other people have looked um in data those states that have higher
  105. payment rates tend to have more doctors that participate versus low but it could be
  106. for a number of reasons that doctors set up their era that that medicaid sets up payment rates that
  107. way and it's just observational but to be able to go into the field pose as um as patients actually seeking
  108. appointments measure real behavior and kind of this audit methodology in this experimental way where we
  109. randomized the scripts to having medicaid or private insurance we've controlled for other aspects of of
  110. access really sets us apart really clean design that is able to that has this compelling
  111. narrative that you know you actually are measuring it by calling up doctor's offices i think just that that audit
  112. methodology is very compelling for um people on the street if you say i ran a regression analysis and my p-value was
  113. whatever somehow you've already lost half the crowd so it was both a clean experimental design
  114. i think very compelling easily to relate to finding this uh paper that i was telling you
  115. about is is part of a much larger project larger data collection effort which is about um
  116. tracking how um how available physicians are for seeing patients around the insurance expansions of the
  117. affordable care act so in the past couple of years it's been a large group of people 10 15 million who didn't
  118. have insurance before and now have insurance and will be demanding uh to see doctors in ways that they haven't
  119. before because they have insurance to cover those visits so the fear is that that there won't be enough doctors to to
  120. meet this increased demand for care so we did our baseline measures in 2012 before insurance expanded and in a
  121. number of different domains we're studying whether um uh whether there's sufficient capacity
  122. in the um in the work in the physician workforce to meet this increased demand are we going to see a squeeze on the
  123. medicaid side our private uh um for private insurance and one of the questions that
  124. people are curious about is whether those people have always had insurance you know the question is will their care
  125. remain the same but if their doctors are so busy because they're more patients maybe for them even their care won't be
  126. the same and we'll be able to measure that we'll have you know these baseline data to know that what things are like
  127. before we can monitor changes we're going to look at changes look at the access issues
  128. that exist in health insurance exchanges so there's a lot of questions we're still pursuing with this larger
  129. ongoing work we're hoping to go back in the field to collect the third round of data
  130. within the next six to 12 months you

Brief Summary

Increased Medicaid payments led to more doctors accepting patients, improving access to care for Medicaid recipients.

Key points

  • Policy Effectiveness Confirmed. The study confirms that higher payments to Medicaid doctors increased appointment availability.
  • Impact of Medicaid Payment Rates. Research shows that increasing Medicaid payments leads to more doctors willing to see patients.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes