Does Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Have a Future?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Some thought Obamacare would mean the end of employment-based insurance. While that did not happen, the threat has not fully lifted, according to Wharton’s Mark Pauly. More: http://knlg.net/1LtFbHp 📂 Health Care Management;Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. knowledge at Wharton would like to welcome mark Pauli who joins us today and mark is a Wharton professor of
  2. healthcare management and he's going to talk about a very a potentially very important aspect of
  3. Obamacare or the Affordable Care Act that it's kind of a sleeper issue that people haven't paid attention to
  4. but it's potentially really quite important and potentially quite expensive so I think the title of your
  5. new briefing paper on this topic puts it fairly succinctly you ask is there a future for employer-sponsored healthcare
  6. who knew that there might not be a future and I think it's a surprising question for a lot of folks and this has
  7. to do with the idea that there may be incentives to employers out there to give up some some health insurance plans
  8. because of the way that Obamacare affects at least some people and their companies or at least some companies of
  9. a certain size and generally smaller companies right let me leave it to you to spell this out so yeah so we've
  10. before the passage of the Affordable Care Act if you were not not a poor person eligible for Medicaid you
  11. basically could only get help from the government to get health insurance by getting insurance through your job and
  12. although you may not think of it this way that actually is potentially a way to provide substantial help because the
  13. fraction of your compensation that you would get as your employer's premium payment would not be subject to taxes
  14. then as most of us pay an explicit premium as well usually it's about a quarter of the total premium that's also
  15. excluded from taxation and if you have a creative enough employer that set up a flexible spending account you can
  16. exclude up to 2,500 dollars of spending not covered by insurance from taxation as well so before the ACA only people
  17. who got insurance through their job could get a help for the government from private insurance what the Affordable
  18. Care Act did was set up a system of subsidies related to income up to 400% of the poverty line income that a person
  19. could get if they got insurance through the exchanges that were set up by the by the law and the reaction to
  20. that in part was to say well this may be the end of the world as far as employment based insurance would go
  21. because especially if you are willing to believe despite so far I think evidence
  22. to the contrary that these exchanges will be terribly efficiently run and offer wonderful choices don't get me
  23. wrong there are some good exchanges but they're more the exception than the rule
  24. but if you thought they'd really be a wonderful thing maybe a lot of people would say gee I'd rather get my
  25. insurance through an exchange where perhaps I have more choice than I have in my job and then some employers said
  26. or even some consultants told them look you're now paying let's say an average of about $4,000 per worker for insurance
  27. there's a penalty if you're a large employer for not making that payment but the penalties only 2,000 2,000 being
  28. less than 4,000 why not drop insurance coverage and tell your employees to go to exchanges why is the penalty 2,000
  29. there's a there's an explicit penalty in the law for employers while it was it's
  30. called the employer mandate and the employer mandate says if you're an employer above a certain size you have
  31. to provide insurance to your workers and contribute a certain fraction of your premium of their premium but if it but
  32. if you didn't the it's complicated like everything in the law but roughly speaking you you would be subject to a
  33. penalty of $2,000 per worker but the calculation was well $2,000 is less than what I'm paying now wouldn't I come out
  34. ahead by dropping insurance coverage what the point that I make in this article is well it's not quite so easy
  35. so there are some employers and their workers who would come out ahead and I guess the key issue here really is not
  36. what's in the interest of the employer but what's in the interest of workers can workers on balance be better off by
  37. in effect taking the money that employers were spending on them for insurance and going to the exchanges and
  38. the answer would be if you were a worker and I'm especially a small firm with mostly low-wage workers there would
  39. be an advantage the advantage would be you aren't getting much of a tax break before because your taxable income is
  40. not that high but now with the same amount of money you could go to an exchange and say if
  41. your income was 200 percent of the poverty line which would be about thirty eight thousand dollars for a person you
  42. you could get a 50 percent subsidy so that's a much bigger break than you were getting before so the news is that there
  43. would be some workers and some firms where there would be an advantage and if this was a small firm under ultimately
  44. under 50 workers although it starts off with a threshold of a hundred workers there would be no penalty for the
  45. employer the only reason though why that doesn't necessarily signal a revolution
  46. is that the fraction of workers who work in small homogeneous low-wage firms who
  47. currently get health insurance is actually quite tiny less than five percent of the overall workforce so
  48. although those people would gain a lot there are a lot of them and at the other extreme if you are working in a large
  49. firm and your upper middle income worker and most people in that firm are if that
  50. employer canceled in their insurance then you as workers could go to the exchange but you would have to pay the
  51. full premium without a subsidy and you wouldn't get the tax break anymore so you would actually plead with the boss
  52. boss please don't drop insurance coverage because we'd actually rather get our compensation the way we're
  53. currently getting it rather than the way we would have to deal with in exchange so from the employers point of view
  54. let's say I'm a large employer and I think you said the average premium is four thousand dollars yeah even for a
  55. large firm does that include is that like after the the tax breaks that I get now that's before that's before so it's
  56. actually not close to me four thousand it's costing me something less because wax advantages yeah so depends of course
  57. what's marginal bracket you're in but you know if if you were a 30 percent tax bracket it's
  58. costing you twelve hundred dollars less than four thousand right okay so then so the employee would not want
  59. their employer to do that because it would be almost like a pay cut wouldn't it would be like a pay cut just explain
  60. how it would be like a pay cut well effectively it is like a pay cut if if you even though it let's take the simple
  61. case where the employer drops insurance but gives you back the money the four thousand dollars they were spending well
  62. you're now going to have to pay twelve hundred dollars more in taxes because you have four thousand dollars more in
  63. taxable income you go to the exchange you say where's my subsidy they say sorry you learn too much to be eligible
  64. for a subsidy you get zero subsidy or you're out twelve thousand dollars and at least in my simple example there was
  65. no the employer was neutral because they just transferred the money from kit from
  66. paying for benefits to Kashkari I shall 1200 or twelve twelve hundred dollars you're out twelve hundred dollars by
  67. losing the tax break so that's I guess that's a lose-lose proposition well it doesn't take into the take account of
  68. the idea that an employer not saying they would but in theory they could say I'm not providing insurance which would
  69. be like a pay cut oh and I'm not giving you the for that yeah well they could they could of course say I'm not giving
  70. you the money either but then you'd wonder that would be like a pay cut and you'd wonder you know you're kind of a
  71. sorry excuse for a capitalist because you must have been overpaying me in the first place if I will continue to work
  72. for you after this big pay cut because now you're less competitive you know we usually assume it's probably easier to
  73. assume in the current labor market than in the labor market had prevailed in 2010 when the ACA was passed we usually
  74. assume labor markets are pretty competitive workers are not being overpaid but if their compensation takes
  75. a big hit the employer that does that is actually going to lose rather than win because the workers will know
  76. want to work there so whether your pay is cut or your healthcare benefits are cut it feels the same - it feels the
  77. same and really that's that's kind of the main economic message here that employers don't give you health
  78. insurance they just either pay you in the form of cash or in the form of benefits and one advantage as I started
  79. off by saying of getting my getting paid in the form of benefits is that that's something I get a tax break for whereas
  80. if I get paid in this cash I've paid tax on is does the employer for the Social Security part yeah so the big split here
  81. seems to be bigger companies and smaller companies and and I think you're saying
  82. that the percentage of smaller companies doesn't add up to a very big percentage
  83. yeah that's right or at least if you look at the fraction of people who are getting private health insurance through
  84. their job which was more than 90 percent of all people getting private health insurance the great bulk of those people
  85. are not working in small homogeneous low-wage firms they're working in large firms that either have high average
  86. wages which was the story I was telling a few minutes ago or even if hasn't many
  87. large firms there are some low-wage workers the great bulk of the workers are not low wage so if the firm cancels
  88. the whole deal it's going to do more harm to the larger number of high wage workers then it's going to benefit the
  89. small number of low-wage workers so and then if you add on top of that the fact that there's this $2,000 penalty it
  90. would seem like a money losing proposition all around for a large firm to contemplate dropping health benefits
  91. so there's another intriguing line in your in your brief which says that there could be some incentive for some large
  92. companies to think about creating a separate company for lower wage workers in order to eliminate some health care
  93. insurance so yeah so my position on this my econometrics professor told me when you forecast the future never attach a
  94. date if you present a number but I'll put a date here so my my view is that in the short run let's say over the next
  95. five years I don't see a massive reduction and the provision of health insurance by employers just for the
  96. reason I mentioned that the great bulk of workers now getting health insurance through their jobs are in these large
  97. heterogeneous firms that there isn't going to be a net gain from dropping coverage a lot heterogeneous meaning
  98. meaning there are some low-wage workers but a lot of high wage orders but with enough time and with enough ingenuity on
  99. the part of Americans which we definitely have an adequate amount of it's a a large firm could see although
  100. it might not be politically correct how to make it possible for their low-wage workers to get this juicy tax subsidy
  101. that they could get in exchange what they would have to do at least the most straightforward way would be to
  102. reconfigure the way the firm is organized kind of spin off the tasks that are performed by low-wage workers
  103. into a firm hiring only low-wage people and preferably even still a small firm and then there wouldn't be a penalty and
  104. those workers could potentially claim a fairly hefty tax break my assumption is that would take a while for that change
  105. to happen but I guess it could eventually happen because in some ways saying well if you're a low-wage worker
  106. who worked for a small firm or if you were a self-employed low-wage person right now you're eligible for this quite
  107. generous subsidy but if you're the janitor and Microsoft you're not eligible for this subsidy that's sort of
  108. intrinsically unstable in addition to being unfair are there any industries where that
  109. might where the cleavage between the two groups might be more natural and well that's a good question I guess I don't
  110. know I think the answer I mean the answer is if if it's possible to separate out the low wage workers into a
  111. separate entity with separate management and still have production take place efficiently that would be an industry
  112. where that would happen now thinking of the industry I work in which is the higher education industry we have low
  113. wage workers here administrative staff and so forth and there are notice they're literally our partners it would
  114. be hard for me to think of handing over my my calendar planning or preparation of
  115. materials for my classes to somebody who works for a separate company other than
  116. the errors do Pennsylvania so I don't see Penn actually engaging in the spinning off low-wage workers for for
  117. the bulk of what people do here I mean we actually have already of course spun off things like campus security and some
  118. of the food services to other firms so that would be possible what about something like a mass manufacturing firm
  119. an assembly-line operation right where you've got thousands of workers doing that and then you know a smaller
  120. management yeah well again I think it comes back to can you separately carve out the tasks in a manufacturing firm a
  121. lot of the low-wage workers are just because their seniority they're just workers who haven't been there as long
  122. and it would be kind of hard to say we'll have a separate firm for the starting workers and then for the
  123. permanent workers although you know here at the University we do have adjuncts and you could imagine spinning them off
  124. into a separate firm but but it doesn't seem as I as I think about the question in general I think there's a reason why
  125. firms are heterogeneous why they employ high wage and low wage workers because it's more efficient to manage them
  126. collectively rather than managing them separately but if there's enough of a carrot dangled in front of people to
  127. switch the method of organization well somebody's always on the margin somebody might do it but I guess I'm programmed
  128. to say but that doesn't sound like a good idea for society because you are in effect subsidizing an inefficient way of
  129. organizing production if it really was more efficient to have have workers high and low wage as part of the same firm
  130. what haven't we covered on this that would be important for viewers to know about well there is a kind of current
  131. way to make event ages for low-wage workers to be spun out or to be separated and that
  132. is there's a considerable debate about this the law opinion Eliza's firms when they don't provide health insurance to
  133. full-time workers but not when they don't provide health insurance to part-time workers so this has been a big
  134. debate and one of the I believe adverse incentives present in the law is to say to an employer look if you can split
  135. your work into twice as many part-time workers instead of full-time workers and if they are also low-wage that's
  136. important if they're low-wage anyway but you can split them into part-time workers then those part-time workers
  137. there's an there's no penalty for sending them off to the exchange now I'm back again on my sermonette about how
  138. that doesn't sound like a good way to organize production because usually it doesn't make as much sense to have part
  139. a lot of part-time workers as some is a smaller number of full-time workers if you're producing things in ordinary kind
  140. of production setting although of course we know for some things like fast food and things like that it may not Matt may
  141. not be so inefficient when some companies are already doing that we're already limiting hours yeah but the and
  142. some companies are saying and they're probably right that this incentive will cause us to emphasize part-time work
  143. more than full-time work minoo intrinsic merit to full-time or part-time work but
  144. having the reason why you choose to employ people as part-timers is because of this subsidy is not a good reason
  145. from a point of view overall efficiency well thank you for coming in ok sure all
  146. right you

Brief Summary

Mark Pauli discusses how the ACA may threaten employer-sponsored healthcare by incentivizing companies to drop insurance coverage.

Key points

  • The Future of Employer-Sponsored Healthcare. Mark Pauli discusses the potential end of employer-sponsored healthcare due to Obamacare.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes