Diversity at Work: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace | Ingrid Nembhard — Ripple Effect

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Psychological safety is an important component to creating a workplace where everyone can thrive, but it takes on extra significance for people from underrepresented groups. Wharton’s Ingrid Nembhard explains why.

Topics and Questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:06 - Predicting workplace dynamics 3:25 - Defining psychological safety 7:25 - Consequences of risk-taking at work 12:03 - Becoming a DEI spokesperson 16:06 - Prioritizing inclusivity in the workplace 21:10 - Emphasizing the “Why” not “How”

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

In honor of Juneteenth, the Ripple Effect podcast is showcasing a special series of conversations on equity and opportunity, diving deep into the complex issues of racial inequality, bias, and representation within organizations. This special will be led by guest host Kenneth Shropshire, faculty director of Wharton’s Coalition for Equity and Opportunity.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#psychologicalsafety #dei #diversity #inclusion #workplaceculture ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. and unless an organization or your team leader in the organization has made a significant effort to be welcoming of
  2. all voices and all diversity and to create an inclusive space the default that we feel as individuals
  3. is to protect ourselves we don't take that risk because we know that there may be serious consequences and we have seen
  4. those consequences for others welcome to a special edition of the ripple effect I'm Dan Loney in honor of Juneteenth
  5. this month senior advisor to the dean for the Coalition of equity and opportunity Kenneth Shropshire will be
  6. your special guest host in each episode this month Ken and Wharton faculty are focusing on the critical themes of
  7. diversity equity and inclusion we'll be covering a diverse range of topics bringing you the latest insights and
  8. knowledge that you could apply to your life and work so get ready to dive into this special edition of the ripple
  9. effect with guest host Ken Shropshire well certainly lots of discussion continuing about the state of the
  10. workplace and how Dei factors in great to speak again with Ken Shropshire Ken it's an interesting Dynamic what we're
  11. seeing right now around the workplace here and the thought not only of the employee ease but also of the companies
  12. as well as to what that workplace is going to look like in the future now for sure and I'm excited to talk to
  13. Ingrid because a lot of the what the workplace has to think about is is how do we
  14. treat or how do we frame the workplace for these employees to be successful and Ingrid's work just thinking about this
  15. issue broadly it's almost like a Capstone kind of conversation about whatever the issue might be
  16. as an employer how do you provide provide a better setting a lot of her work is done in the healthcare space and
  17. in hospitals and research there and not necessarily thinking about the specific issues of Dei but in fact what
  18. she researches applies in any workplace well I will leave it to the two of you Ken Shropshire along with Ingrid
  19. nemheart who is a professor of Healthcare Management here at the Wharton School Ingrid great to have you
  20. with us and thanks for giving us some time today oh I'm thrilled to be here I think this is a nice opportunity to talk
  21. about something that's near and dear to my heart and I think as as Ken said relevant certainly relevant in the
  22. industry that I study of healthcare but broadly relevant to any industry in any place where people go to work
  23. Ken it's all yours all right thanks Dan so Ingrid as I said I'm excited to talk to you about this because I am always
  24. learning stuff I'm by training I'm a lawyer so we always take stuff that other people they would make arguments
  25. with it so so I'll try not to reframe anything to my advantage um but you know two things really really
  26. captured me about your work and it's so Broad and you've been at this for uh for
  27. a great deal of deal of time and have a tremendous body of work but psychological safety
  28. and organizational learning and so as I was reading the work I have the advantage to think about it in terms
  29. of this this Dei space and what workplaces are doing so so maybe we just start off if you
  30. explain to us what psychological safety is in the workplace sure so psychological safety is the
  31. belief that it's safe to take interpersonal risk at work so what do I mean by interpersonal risk Enterprise
  32. are you taking it in a personal risk at work when you do things like speak up with a question or a concern or raise an
  33. idea or point out a mistake or critique a plan that has been offered by someone else in any of those situations you're
  34. taking a risk you're taking a risk that you're voicing something that may be uncomfortable for other people to hear
  35. when you're psychologically safe you feel that it's okay to take that risk and that you're not going to be punished
  36. you're not going to be devalued you're not going to receive a promotion you're not going to get the worst office the
  37. worst schedule because you decided to share something in the organization that had not been said before so so there's
  38. actually a name for this this thing the idea of putting your head down and doing
  39. your work not doing anything else right I mean that's the that's what people do in the
  40. workplace when they don't feel psychologically safe they close in they don't voice and when they're not voicing
  41. they're not voicing things on both sides of the spectrum they're not voicing their more creative ideas or ideas for
  42. how to change work because that seems risky they're also not voicing things that are going wrong or problems that
  43. the organization needs to learn about in order to be better for both its employees and its customers and so
  44. there's a downside when people don't feel psychologically safe at work psychological safety is really the idea
  45. that you can speak candidly about whatever is on your mind relevant to the workplace and that that will not be held
  46. against you yeah I think a great what sucked me in on the work was uh epic is one of the
  47. earlier pieces that you did that that talked about a medical professional that wouldn't speak up to a more senior
  48. Medical Professional because of the psychological safety issue and I can only think about how devastating that
  49. that could be how that's exactly what you don't want in that kind of study exactly I it was my very first study
  50. actually that you're pointing out and we looked at this idea but we've I I've now
  51. seen it over and over again in healthcare and has been proven over and over again EU come from a legal
  52. background imagine the junior associate in the practice speaking up to the partner in the practice all those put
  53. you in vulnerable positions in healthcare we see it certainly it follows the status hierarchy so whether
  54. or not a nurse feels like she can speak up to a physician or a surgeon and say you know as bad as this is going to
  55. sound I'm going to say you're operating on the wrong body part thank you for this happens or I just
  56. need to wash your hands because we all know basic you need to wash your hands to prevent infection you see someone
  57. enter the room and we're in a busy workplace so it's not out of malice but you forget to wash your hand does
  58. someone raise you know does somebody lower in status say you forgot to wash your hands before you
  59. touch the patient it can have life or death consequences in the context of healthcare but it is just as significant
  60. in other Industries in other ways in terms of do you invest in that drug or not do you change the organizational
  61. process in that way or not and what are the ramifications of that yeah so it's really interesting to think
  62. about that the how I hate to personalize it but I do keep thinking about my you know first jobs
  63. and the and the ideas I said keep my head down I'm not going to say anything it is if something wrong is going on I
  64. mean my earliest jobs were in cheering steel bars in a warehouse and loading treat on box cars
  65. and I I can say I can see some things going on wrong and it's I'm just trying to get myself away from that right I'm
  66. not thinking about the whole I'm not thinking about the whole organization I'm thinking about
  67. me and that's exactly right when we look at the literature what the literature and the experience would suggest is that
  68. people think about what the consequences are for them as the individual not the consequences for the organization and
  69. we're pretty we can make a guess about what the consequences will be for us whether that would be positive or
  70. negative seeing the consequences for the organization can be much more uncertain
  71. they could be delayed My Punishment can be immediate if someone doesn't appreciate what I say
  72. so for just as another issue in the workplace so so Dei diversity issues something seems wrong to either a person
  73. who is a member of a diverse group who's Black Or Hispanic or a member of the lgbtq community or whatever it might be
  74. they see something wrong in the workplace or they hear something that they think is
  75. inappropriate the natural hesitation especially in a majority based organization is
  76. I don't want to be the one to raise that issue yeah so this fits squarely in in the
  77. kind of research that what you're doing because the end result is well you should say something because it
  78. it might make the organization better right exactly so I would knock as you said I would not be considered a Dei
  79. researcher I have been studying psychological safety for many years but the two I do believe are intertwined
  80. so you know even if you take you can be diverse along many dimensions you can be often when we talk about the
  81. reason diversity becomes relevant as people who are considered more diverse tend to have lower status in the
  82. organization so much like my nurse has lower status than my physician or my medical assistant has lower status than
  83. my nurse that puts you in a position where you're much more vulnerable and where you're much more likely to I would
  84. say there's a higher propensity to not feel psychological see safe because you know that you are different and you
  85. understand your place in the hierarchy and unless an organization or your team leader in the organization has made a
  86. significant effort to be welcoming of all voices and all diversity and to create an inclusive space
  87. the default that we feel as individuals is to protect ourselves we don't take that risk because we know that there may
  88. be serious consequences and we have seen those consequences for others the thing
  89. is that we know that we we learn right we're humans and we learn from experience so if I'm in a meeting with
  90. you and other people and I see someone else in the room who is maybe higher status than me because they are less
  91. diverse than me or whatever raise their hand and the reaction is not positive by
  92. others in the room I learn immediately that I should not raise my hand that that is even more likely to happen to me
  93. because I don't have the social capital to for people to say oh no they'll say oh that was a half-baked idea and then
  94. it goes on from there and so when you're a part of when you are diverse and you're typically aware
  95. you're diverse you're more conscious of you know you know when you're taking a risk
  96. and your car and we've said in some other other conversations too that and then this won't come out right but
  97. I'm old man so I sometimes say things that don't go all right you don't want to be I you don't want that diversity
  98. issue to be the dominant thing that people turn to you for either yes that's that's another reason
  99. that may be unique amongst reasons why you don't speak up I mean the idea that you're the the the
  100. the entry-level nurse and you're looking out for your job doesn't have a whole lot to do with the
  101. idea of I don't want to be identified as the smart nurse it says right right you're not pegging in the space but once
  102. as a diverse person you start to speak on these issues then you almost give license for
  103. leadership to turn to you and say you become responsible we've got the race the race issue today it's so wait a
  104. minute I'm a lawyer I don't study I'm here for the finance issues I experience this myself
  105. which is yes it I think right there is the becoming responsible for these issues is another
  106. um is itself its own issue right and how much do you want to speak about this issue how much do you want to be the
  107. bearer of this issue will you be included after you have spoken up about this issue if you were truthful about
  108. what you have observed in the organization it's wonderful yeah so my colleague Amy Edmondson who's
  109. at Harvard Business School and I introduced this concept of inclusive leadership or leadership inclusiveness
  110. in our work in the healthcare setting and in that we make this we make this argument that there is sort of the
  111. inclusive the invitation to speak and then the reaction that happens in their response to that
  112. and it's twofold and we've all been in situations where we've been invited so maybe we've been invited to sit on the
  113. Dei committee and then you actually participate because you think you have been invited
  114. and you have received a genuine invitation to to play a role in bringing the organization along in this in this
  115. way and then the consequences are not positive for you you have to have both right that we've
  116. all experienced the invitation not followed by uh the positive outcome that we hope for
  117. so so the great the greater frame to to your work with this Dei spaces it's fine to create
  118. whatever kind of Dei programs you want but you also have to have an awareness of the psychological safety issue as you
  119. do so exactly and not travel someone down inadvertently with all with all all well intended we need to initiate these
  120. programs let's let's call up Ken and Ingrid Too Perfect the added issue becomes frankly too
  121. for all you podcast listeners becomes as well if I sit on the couch myself and put this stuff out there
  122. um if I don't do inward gets out that I don't do it that's another issue from from my community is well you know he
  123. was asking asking he didn't he didn't do it he didn't want to support right his community so all this fits under that
  124. that banner I mean I love that you raised the point that which I think we're really seeing a
  125. lot of organizations are thinking about how to improve belonging and diversity include you know all of it and that is a
  126. wonderful thing we have hoped for this for many years and I think we're still figuring out how
  127. to do it I I I applaud organizations for the many efforts that they try but what you said is exactly right
  128. unless the climate really does allow for the free voicing for people to take a risk and deal with
  129. these topics truthfully and honestly and candidly it sort of doesn't matter how many
  130. initiatives you announce right because there's a there is a climate that you has to be built within
  131. the organization in order for the organization to do hard work that is hard work
  132. diversity and like Dei is hard work and it means that the organization for many organizations so this is going to tie
  133. into my other stream of research this is something that organizations have to learn they have to learn how to
  134. do this and learning is hard and you can't do learning teams can't learn to be different with each other unless
  135. they're a psychological safety so your point about sort of all these initiatives yes you know it's who you
  136. choose to be on them for sure there's also the process and what happens once you've put them together and they can't
  137. unless they have this Foundation it will be extremely hard for them to take flight in the way that you might
  138. hope okay so so far my education is so if I'm a leader and I'm going to be focused on psychological safety
  139. I I certainly need to contemplate inclusiveness in in what I do and which which also just might by
  140. necessity means make sure you're not excluding or you're going overboard with including
  141. and a good way to do that the other word that came up in our conversation is is to be aware of the vulnerability of of
  142. people as you engage in in this journey but and it's it's for as I said if we started off for any initiative
  143. or for any betterment of the the place of employment this idea of thinking about
  144. how do you not discourage the nurse from speaking up I mean he's got that Baseline idea which
  145. he said I didn't know I didn't know so the first part of the study but that sort of sets it up so clearly that you
  146. know it's about the same token it's really normal with that young intern doctor that that learned that thing in
  147. class that the senior doctor didn't learn and won't speak up in the operating room this is my heart's about
  148. to pick the last beat unless they give me the drug that this kid knows about yes
  149. so please speak up so so I do I do want to just in the remaining time talk about the learning
  150. part that you raised in organizational learning and how to how to best make that happen I think somewhere in your
  151. work I saw the the phrase something about how to learn better and faster and it's kind of the framing that goes into
  152. place what what kinds of things if we got leaders thinking about psychological safety what kinds of things do we want
  153. to leave them in terms of improving the learning that takes place in the organization to get on board with
  154. whatever it is the company is trying to drive so the psychological safety piece is
  155. about setting the foundation and the climate I think then the question becomes what do you do what are we able
  156. to do as a group of workers to make things better and that's the learning piece and what I think I've learned from my
  157. research well I think I've learned quite a few things about but maybe the thing that is most relevant for listeners is
  158. the importance of learning activities that really help people to understand how and why they are doing what they're
  159. doing so let me make that a little bit more concrete and some of our work we have
  160. distinguished between activities that are learning activities are really learned what
  161. um and then we have another class called learn how so you think about learning activity learn what activities as can
  162. let me give you an article about Dei so you will read the article and you will magically
  163. be my Dei Guru because I've given you an article our work doesn't show that that
  164. necessarily leads to the performance benefits and the improvements that you want to see on the not that I mean you
  165. have to educate but when you're using learning activities that allow people to understand why that important why that's
  166. important and how that is important and how that will manifest on the consequences that we desire those types
  167. of learning activities make a difference so sometimes that is about um you know in the healthcare space
  168. sometimes that is you know doing your plan do study act cycle let's put something in let's try it out let's
  169. learn from it let's Circle back around being very intentional about those and those more active learning activities
  170. those deliberate learning activities can make a huge difference but we know that
  171. workers are not excited about engaging in those activities unless they have that foundation and they feel safe to do
  172. it they have this you know that there's a safety there's the resources there's you know all the things we teach in
  173. business school about getting things done but we need these columns you have to have an environment
  174. and I will actually say you didn't ask this but I do think it is important as as we move forward in thinking about Dei
  175. that it might be useful to organizations to position it as we are learning how to
  176. do this better right so it's not the difference between sort of a performance like we're going
  177. to be great at this tomorrow versus we're on a journey together to be better at including all of the voices around
  178. the table and that allows for some failures to happen along the way and for us to
  179. recover and try something new again and keep at it and I was going to ask that that's
  180. really insightful and and you sort of answered this and it's fine now now we're talking
  181. about this I'm thinking all this in terms of my my now adult kids and and there of well
  182. they have been of that generation that that gets triggered and what's the other word that you know I want to bring my
  183. genuine self and sort of all your authentic being yeah authentic yeah which you know which is we we had it had
  184. a discussion of that's very very important so I'm just expressing the 70 year old kind of
  185. but it sounds like and as I'm thinking about my kids in this sense we don't often enough give the why the
  186. why we're you know because I said so right so it sounds like the best leaders are are not saying
  187. take this document do it because I said so and I don't care I don't care how you
  188. feel about it never get to tell people you don't care as a general principal as a leader we
  189. don't recommend that on the organization but it makes a huge difference to explain to people why they're doing
  190. something and what their role is and why their role matters it can it it's a Difference Maker people
  191. want I will say many people come to work wanting to deliver for themselves their
  192. teams and their clients and their customers they want they don't people don't go to work wanting to have bad
  193. days no nope so it's a matter of helping people understand how they fit and when they
  194. understand how they fit and they contribute to the greater good that's motivating
  195. and you want to provide that you also want to provide an opportunity for people who are at the front lines who
  196. really do know what's going on to share that with you you want to hear their creative ideas
  197. that sounds like a great place to end and a great takeaway in terms of how to improve the organization by making
  198. people feel safe but also having an atmosphere where learning is continuous and the people understand why why
  199. they're doing it and they are on board with making the organization a better one thank you thank you thanks for
  200. having me thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode
  201. informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  202. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School

Brief Summary

Ingrid Nemhart discusses psychological safety's role in fostering diversity and inclusion in the workplace with Kenneth Shropshire.

Key points

  • Understanding Psychological Safety. Ingrid defines psychological safety as the belief that it’s safe to take interpersonal risks at work.
  • The Impact of Diversity on Speaking Up. Ingrid explains how diversity can create hesitance in raising concerns within organizations.
  • The Importance of a Supportive Climate. Ingrid stresses that without a supportive climate, diversity initiatives will not succeed.
  • Learning and Psychological Safety. Ingrid discusses how learning is hindered without psychological safety in the workplace.
  • The Importance of Why. Great leaders explain the reasons behind actions, fostering understanding and motivation.
  • Motivation and Fit. Helping employees understand their role contributes to a more motivated workforce.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes