Can't Be Yourself at Work? Why Some Employees "Cover" Their Identity — Leading Diversity at Work

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW In this episode of the Leading Diversity at Work podcast, Wharton’s Stephanie Creary speaks with two experts about why some employees feel the need to 'cover' aspects of their identity and how organizations can better support diversity in the workplace. She's joined by Kenji Yoshino -- a professor at NYU School of Law and faculty director of the Meltzer Center for Diversity, Inclusion, and Belonging -- and Joanne Stephane, executive director of Deloitte's DEI Institute™.

SERIES OVERVIEW Leading Diversity at Work is a podcast series featuring Wharton management professor Stephanie Creary in conversation with experts in diversity, equity and inclusion. Learn more at http://whr.tn/leadingdiversity.

PODCAST OVERVIEW The Knowledge at Wharton podcast features interviews with Wharton faculty and industry leaders about the business landscape and the impact of their work. Conversations range from the latest research and books by faculty authors, to Leading Diversity at Work with professor Stephanie Creary, and Dollars and Change with professor Katherine Klein.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowah [Music] Warton hello my name is Stephanie Cy and
  2. I'm an assistant professor of management at the Wharton School of the University
  3. of Pennsylvania and I'm delighted to welcome you to today's episode of the knowledge at Warton leading diversity at
  4. work podcast series which is focused on uncovering culture in the workplace joining me today are two very special
  5. guests first we have Kenji yino who is the Chief Justice Earl Warren professor of constitutional law at NYU School of
  6. Law and the faculty director of the Meltzer Center for diversity inclusion and belonging at NYU he specializes in
  7. constitutional law anti-discrimination law and law in literature in 2013 professor yino and deoy published a
  8. landmark study uncovering talent to surface the organizational challenges of covering This research and the topic of
  9. today's podcast draw on the insights from Professor Yo's 2006 book which is called covering the hidden assault on
  10. our civil rights and we'll talk a lot more about covering what that means what it looks like who does it in just a few
  11. moments but I'd like to also introduce our second guest today next we have Joanne Stefan who is executive director
  12. of deo's Dei Institute for more than 25 years Joanne has worked with seite Executives to Define design and
  13. operationalize their Workforce experience Vision she helps clients transform their talent in HR
  14. organizations and their strategy through implementation and Beyond to achieve sustainable results Joanne also leads
  15. deo's ushr strategy and solutions Talent Group in the HR transformation service offering and is the chief Dei officer
  16. officer of deo's us human capital practice welcome Kenji and Joanne so delighted to have you with me today for
  17. a conversation on uncovering culture so this is the title of a of a new report that was just released that you both
  18. co-authored um and it's in collaboration with the Meltzer Center for dersa inclusion and belonging at NYU School of
  19. Law and deoy and so I actually just want to start us off by talking about this concept of covering and I think a good
  20. way to enter into to it is to turn to Kenji to tell us a little bit about uh the Genesis of This research uh for him
  21. I I know of the work from the book uh covering in 2006 but can you just give us a brief definition of what covering
  22. means who does it and just a couple of insights um that you had in 2006 that perhaps evolved to
  23. 2013 yes absolutely so first of all Stephanie I want to thank you than you so much uh for having us on today uh
  24. you're uh such a star in the field and I have huge admiration for you so it's such a honor and privilege to be with
  25. you so to begin actually the levie article and no one reads L riew articles but you know I I have to say that the
  26. larv article version of covering was published in 2002 so this idea has now been kicking around for a couple of
  27. decades uh you're right that it sort of made its way into the mainstream with the 200 six book in that book I define
  28. covering as a strategy through which individuals with known Outsider identities you know uh modulate or edit
  29. their identities in order to blend into the mainstream so what would examples of
  30. this be this is the you know black individual who straightens her hair so that she'll be seen as more professional
  31. uh this is a gay man who says I'm not going to bring my samesex partner to a work function because that will increase
  32. inrease the salience of my sexual orientation this is a veteran who doesn't challenge the anti-military joke
  33. and the elevator Les to be seen as overly militant or strident this is a woman who doesn't talk about her child
  34. care responsibilities at work L should be seen as an inauthentic or less committed uh worker I think really
  35. importantly just so that your viewers know that we'll catch them here uh oftentimes what people get puzzled about
  36. is what the difference between covering and passing is I think we all know what passing is where you're literally hiding
  37. your identity and it's a question that we get so often that we have loaded it into uh the paper uh at the outset we
  38. say when you're passing people literally don't know that you belong to a particular group when you're covering
  39. people know that you belong to the group either because you're unable or unwilling to hide your membership in the
  40. group but they nonetheless put uh pressures on you to downplay or edit or mute that identity
  41. so that they can be more comfortable around you so to get to the last piece of the question you know what are the
  42. differences between 2013 and uh study uh issued uh just uh this week so in 2013 I
  43. had this really kind of magical collaboration uh with deoy where uh they uh came to me I said should say you
  44. Joanne and your colleagues came to me and said you know you have crunched a lot of cases in your uh book uh but
  45. you're not an empiricist like we can help we have a huge kind of agap uh practice we have data analytics teams
  46. like we'll put our money where our mouth is like we'll push this out right to our
  47. own uh clients we'll design the survey with you and so we collaborated on this and it was wonderful because really the
  48. world of many individuals who are listening to this podcast the world of the Fortune 500 or the Amon 100 are not
  49. going to react to anything unless it's backed by hard data right and so I think that that was the signal you know
  50. Advance right that we made made in uh 2013 with this paper in 2023 we delved into a lot of nuances that we can talk
  51. about we looked at intersectionality we looked at uh the ways in which white men
  52. sort of dominant cohorts you know tended to cover we also leaned heavily into Solutions like what the heck do we do
  53. about this right and came up with three sort of programmatic uh ways in which people could fight right the covering
  54. demands within the organization so I would say that this paper is again a kind of exponential Advance uh over the
  55. last one and uh the nuance and the practicality right of its approach I love the mirroring together the idea of
  56. Like This brilliant Theory and I actually did read I read the law review paper I do remember reading
  57. surpris that regard I read the theoretical take on it I also read the book um which you know has these
  58. wonderful illustrative examples and a framework that I think is is very accessible to to people who are
  59. non-academics um certainly followed the two 2013 work I've actually and related pieces that you've published with deoe
  60. or deoe collaborators in Harvard Business Review have had my students read those for required reading and so I
  61. was so delighted um when the note came across my inbox that you all were releasing this new study in 2023 so of
  62. course I've poured through that but before we get into the details of that I just want to turn to you Joanne and and
  63. help me to understand for deoy I mean proba also for you personally what was the goal behind this 2023 study what
  64. were you attempting to study or understand that you didn't quite get uh from the pre prior collaboration with
  65. Kenji thank you um well first I want to acknowledge that it's great to you know get this group back together um uh with
  66. you and uh Kenji um when we last connected at the CDI Forum in June so really great to to talk again um last
  67. time I asked the questions this time you're asking the question so it's great to be on the other side of that um and
  68. so as Kenji said our 2013 research introduced the concept of covering into in the corporate context and was for
  69. organizational leaders to understand what covering is um when we approached the 10-year anniversary uh of the a
  70. release of the uncovering talent the original paper we were curious you know about you know what extent uh to which
  71. workers still cover are they covering in the same way um what impact would this have on them
  72. you know what impact does it have on the organizations that they work for and you
  73. know especially in context of thinking of belonging as one of the outcomes that we aim for um so we also recognize that
  74. um our perspectives on identity and the ways those identities shape us are even more nuanced today and so previously we
  75. looked at gender race age sexual orientation to name a few um but we really wanted to explore with greater
  76. intentionality and ask our respondents specifically about the add additional identities that they have um and how
  77. that shapes the way they you know navigate the world so a few of those include caregiver status education level
  78. immigration status mental health status um military status religious affiliation
  79. socioeconomic status and so you can see how those um those uh let's say um more invisible identities would still
  80. influence how you show up you know with other people and um at work yeah so I'm sorry go ahead yeah no this is really
  81. interesting and really important I think about um you know the ways in which we often talk about social identity
  82. differences particularly here in the US the ones that we tend to talk about first or mention are things that we
  83. assume even though our assumptions can be wrong we assume to to be the case based on what we see and certainly you
  84. all can attest to this as much as I can in my own research in the last 10 years or so we've seen a lot of push often
  85. from our employees our clients right our students to talk more about the things that we couldn't guess um just from
  86. looking at someone and and I think about a lot mental health as being one of these um areas of difference that I
  87. would say the people who I speak to whether we're talking about students or workers are increasingly interested in
  88. making sure that it's aligned with how we talk about diversity Equity inclusion and belonging and certainly as we think
  89. about what are the implications of our culture and the way that we do here things in our culture for people who are
  90. um you know wrestling with but also navigating those very types of identity differences so I can imagine that that
  91. was quite a rich conversation you all had as you were trying to think about about how to broaden some of the work
  92. yes absolutely it also gave us the opportunity to look at the impact of intersectionality so the more uh let's
  93. say marginalized identities you um have you know what might that covering look like or what would the incidence of
  94. covering be um and really focus also on um you know what it would take as as Kenji said earlier to reduce the demand
  95. for covering coming to organization so so we got to dive into quite a bit of that yeah okay all right so let's dive a
  96. little bit more deep into the report and Joanne I'm come back to you and I want you to tell us a little bit about the
  97. study how is it conducted just some of the logistics so people can understand how we move from this sort of big big
  98. broad idea around covering to to as Ki put it the the empirics of it what did that look like of course um so first we
  99. were incredibly grateful to get to work with Kenji again and with his colleague uh David Glasgow um to collaborate on
  100. this reexploration of this topic so deo's Dei Institute you know the the organization that I I lead um with my
  101. colleagues is committed to providing datadriven insights back by sound research methodology and really we want
  102. to do that to you know speak to our business audience to help transform beliefs and
  103. behaviors so we engage a third-party research vendor to survey um one , 269 full and part-time adult workers over 18
  104. in five uh primary Industries and the sample was further waited to be representative of all adult workers in
  105. the US to allow us to draw the inferences you know regarding the population as a whole um so the
  106. quantitative and the qualitative insights we highlighted in the report really give us a deeper understanding of
  107. what covering looks like in the workplace how it feels um you know how it manifests if you will and the effects
  108. on not only individuals but really what the cost is to the organization great great great um Kenji
  109. okay so I I poured this report there's lots of good stuff in there I will share what I thought was particularly um
  110. interesting to me as I've followed your insights on covering for more than the last 10 years but I want to hear from
  111. you as a person who's been um you know thinking about this concept the longest um what insights did you gain like what
  112. were two to three key things that stood out to you as being oh that's interesting and different and this made
  113. it feel like the 2023 report added something beyond what we've previously done yeah so the biggest shift I think
  114. would be one in kind of Gestalt between the 2013 and the 20123 report and I think that's reflected in the title so
  115. the 2013 report is called uncovering talent and the 2023 report that was just released is called uncovering culture
  116. and that reflected you know the team's view that you know without meaning to focusing on uncovering Talent really put
  117. the onus on the individual within these organizations and focused on their covering performances and what we
  118. believe is that it's less productive to focus on people's covering behaviors and
  119. much more productive to uh think about it in terms of the covering demands uh that are placed by the organization on
  120. those individuals so the biggest kind of insight and aha for me was really Shifting the lens and saying it's not up
  121. to individuals the least empowered people in these exchanges to transform right the culture that they're working
  122. in it's actually up to the organizations themselves so it's a really important shift I won't say that we were totally
  123. uh careless or insucient about that in the 2013 report but we were insistent about keeping uh the lens steadily on
  124. the organization throughout this report all right other things that come to mind
  125. are the intersectional point that uh Joan mentioned so I always think about uh my fellow law professor uh Kimberly
  126. crenshaw's work here because she really drove the idea of intersectionality uh into diversity and inclusion discourse
  127. and the idea there is that if you belong to one uh more than one I should say subordinated identity then uh the whole
  128. of that subordination can be greater than the sum of its parts she you know true to her law background first
  129. analyzed this in court decisions where she looked at class actions that black women were bringing and she discovered
  130. that judges are really bad at ascertaining that that discrimination was happening because they would go
  131. access by AIS they would say are is there discrimination on the basis of race no because some black men have made
  132. it is there discrimination on the basis of gender no because some white woman have made it end of case right uh
  133. whereas the people who are being left out in the cold in that analysis were black women and so the idea of uh
  134. intersectionality was born so it's a very intuitive you know today obvious idea but it's still been kind of under
  135. theorized in multiple domains here what we really did was to drill down not just
  136. into access by AIS analysis as a 2013 analysis did but to rigorously look at intersectional effects so to just give
  137. one startling data point from the study if you look at black lgbtq plus individuals 100% of our respondents who
  138. belong to that cohort uh reported covering which was greater than either the black cohort or the lgbtq plus
  139. cohort you know generally right so I think that we have a really good sort of set of proof points about the power of
  140. intersectional analysis uh in this domain as well and finally in terms of key insights I would say that the
  141. solution set which Joanne also mentioned is really robust you know if you go back
  142. to the 2013 paper there's a kind of shrug Emoji frankly at the end and I'm not again G to apologize for that we
  143. didn't want to get ahead of our skis you know we didn't have solutions that we felt confident about offering here you
  144. know in the intervening decade like deoe as an organization I am my own research
  145. I've tested solution after solution after solution and we coales around these three solutions of diagnose
  146. allyship and share your story that we're very very confident provide the tools for organizations to redress uh the
  147. covering demands that uh their people are placing on their uh employees the final thing that I say uh because I know
  148. I'm talking at Wharton uh and you know your dear uh my dear friend and uh your colleague know Stu fredman is one of the
  149. drivers of this is that you know I I also noticed that uh there are these generational differences in how much
  150. people perceive uh covering so you know stud's point about this is that younger people are like unionized as a
  151. generation around the idea of authenticity and so we hope that this concept will resonate uh with this uh
  152. cohort we do think that you know this is a moment where um who's where the idea of covering uh it's time really has come
  153. right because I think uh the rising generation of individuals for one click or two below even you you know Stephanie
  154. are are really sort of adamant about the fact that they want to bring more of theirselves more of their passions more
  155. of their auth authenticity to the workplace so um super super interesting stuff I want to come back though to a
  156. point that you were making earlier and I don't want it to get lost because I think it's important um and part of this
  157. I think feels personal to me uh because it also reflect the evolution in my own research agenda and by that I mean when
  158. I started off being interested in organizational behavior scholarship it was all about what can I as an
  159. individual do to navigate this workplace with my multiple identities and convince
  160. my manager that this was meaningful to them and at some point I cannot remember exactly what happened but at some point
  161. I'm like why is the onus completely on me to figure out how to navigate this place as somebody who doesn't make
  162. decisions herself um but I think the interesting tension that I have found especially among more Junior Scholars or
  163. or younger people is this wanting to have a sense of agency and create my experience in my
  164. organization combined with the very real understanding that practices and policies are created by people who are
  165. not me and I'm not the only one who plays into culture so I just wanted to just talk a little bit more about this
  166. it's an opportunity but it's also a tension between your own personal agency and how you navigate who you should be
  167. but then there's this organization that sort of exists outside of you when we're
  168. talking about this topic of covering how what do you make of that yeah I think I
  169. can thread that needle and I'll begin with a a story after the book was published for a colleague of mine said
  170. you know can we go out to coffee so I can tell you what I hate about your book and I was like great you know that's
  171. always the coffee that I want to have so we had that coffee he said what I hate about your book is that it gives people
  172. more tools to psychoanalyze me in inappropriate ways so if I act in kind of Butch kind of quote unquote masculine
  173. ways you know at the law school as a woman uh then people are going to assume that I'm covering whereas I'm just being
  174. my authentic self right and so you given people another l through which to look at me that I find affirmatively help
  175. unhelpful and a diminishing of my personhood and my my authenticity and I gave her the same answer that I began to
  176. give to you Stephanie which is to say if we take the lens off of the individual and put it on the organization I think
  177. that helps a lot and that shift entails like stopping uh questioning uh individuals covering behaviors and
  178. starting to look at the organization's covering demand so with regard to this female colleag I'm kind of like how you
  179. choose to comport yourself as your business but if the institution is saying to you if you want to be accepted
  180. here you better behave in more stereotypically masculine ways and be as like feess and analytical and aggressive
  181. as a stereotypical man if you want to be accepted in this workplace and I would say that's the kind of demand that I
  182. would want to challenge and I think ultimately it resolves the tension that you were describing because if the
  183. culture is attentive to its covering demands and withdraws them that actually expands the space in which you or I or
  184. she right can bring their authentic selves to the workplace because they're no longer constrained with meeting that
  185. covering demand so we're actually able to engage in behaviors that are auth authentic to us whether or not they
  186. comport with you know stereotypes that people have about the groups that we belong to because the organization has
  187. made a self-conscious effort to retire those demands very helpful thank you so much for creating greater Clarity around
  188. that and I think you know what I walk away from this is feeling is that it's not an either or right there there
  189. there's an interplay and there's a dance between us and our organizations and you
  190. know we have to ensure that there is some thought given to what the organization is doing to shape people's
  191. willingness or unwillingness to show up in their authentic ways in as much as we're thinking about our individual
  192. choices around that that's sort of what I'm taking away from from that uh Joanne
  193. so you've you've been knee in this data in this report um what are your favorites your favorite key aspects
  194. insights that you that you would like to share with us as we um dive in ourselves
  195. sure I'll um I'll pick up on on kenji's first key Insight around intersectionality um in addition to
  196. having all of our black LGBT respondents say that they cover 93% of black work workers with a disability cover and when
  197. we looked at gender a much higher proportion of black women at 80% and Asian women at 86% cover than black men
  198. at 43% and Asian men at 55% so just even within the you know um race and ethnicity
  199. categories the other um finding that was really intriguing to me and and I found
  200. interesting was the finding around white men so 4% of white men cover along traditional lines of marginalization so
  201. you know either mental or physical disability age sexual orientation socioeconomic status as we would expect
  202. um but they also uh reported and we found in some of the um qualitative uh feedback they they cover along
  203. historically advantaged identities so they do cover for race and gender and religious affili
  204. based on the idea that these identities are now disfavored right so of course um
  205. historically uh we can imagine why um and based on what's been happening you know in in our working lifetimes um why
  206. they might think oh you know perhaps I should downplay these aspects of myself um
  207. so this the fact is white men continue to hold many advantages um and I feel like I'm saying something obvious but
  208. let's just put some data behind that so the senior leadership ranks of corporate
  209. America are disproportionately white and male relative to that group's population
  210. share of the population so in 2023 74% of the CEOs at Fortune 50 companies are white men despite that
  211. group comprising just 30% of the US population but this is an improvement right this is progress in 1980 all of
  212. the CEOs of the Fortune 50 were white men so um what we learned and what we saw was that as organizations work to
  213. address root causes of inequities um as organizations work to address root causes of inequities some
  214. white men might experience this decline in Advantage as a disadvantage really it's bringing things more in line with
  215. you know uh the actual proportion of the pop absolutely very fascinating interesting
  216. and I remember reading that section that was helping us to I think get a little bit more clarity around why um white men
  217. might cover and what they're covering and the fact that they're covering the the dimensions of their identities that
  218. we often see as advantage in the workplace um I thought that was super interesting another thing that I thought
  219. was super interesting in this report was this concept covering by proxy um and so
  220. in the report it's defined as covering on on uh behalf of someone else and and so here's a quote that struck me and I
  221. want to read it because I think it helps to provide some context and then Kendry
  222. I'm G to turn it to you to help us unpack this but the quote that I think spoke to me was the following from from
  223. one of the people who you collected data on qualitative data on um this is someone who says um this is tough to
  224. admit but I do this on multiple fronts I have one child that is multi-racial and
  225. outside of work I'm very vocal and supportive of the issues faced by being a minority but I tend to only listen and
  226. not vocally support the same view at work this is also true for my transgender child again away from work
  227. I'm very supportive but I fear that sharing my family struggles with this will isolate me and damage my potential
  228. for growth at work now as a human being that really um struck me um it made me feel quite sad but um I I just wanted to
  229. just say a little bit more about this covering by proxy and and certainly Kenji why this is problematic can you uh
  230. share a little bit more about this topic with us yeah I think that uh both of these ideas you know uh Joann's really
  231. wonderful point about uh how the dominant groups are covering their identities but also this notion of uh
  232. covering by proxy kind of go together in my mind because I think that we can view
  233. it as uh a kind of a place of of attack or we can view it as a place of solidarity and obviously we want to view
  234. it as a ladder so what I mean by that is that you could look at you know the white man who report um covering and you
  235. can say oh this is just like false equivalence you're comparing your paper cut to my flesh wound and so I'm just
  236. going to Discount this and you know we want to put this in context and say yes you know of course everything that
  237. Joanne said was right right you know white men are still vastly disproportionately you know over
  238. represented you know say in the Fortune 50 uh CEO ranks right but at the same time the message that we want to draw
  239. from the study is no cohort is immune from the covering demand so don't make assumptions to go back to what you were
  240. saying earlier Stephanie of like you can't just eyeball somebody and say oh you like all lights have turned green
  241. for you all the way down the highway of life right like nobody is that uh privileged we all just as human beings
  242. of vulnerability and once we see that no cohort even like sis hat you know straight man you know are covering uh
  243. various aspects of Our Lives this really becomes a universal project it isn't Like Us Versus Them and in the wake of
  244. the Supreme Court's SFA decision like I have to say as a lawyer like we're all looking for those Universal Solutions
  245. the things that don't pit one racial group against another racial group or one gender against another gender or
  246. what have you and I think covering really is that idea once we see that everyone is covering something uh and
  247. therefore every cohort has an interest and the name of bringing more of their passion and their authenticity to their
  248. work right in this uncovering culture uh project uh then the appeal of this can really be Universal because it's a
  249. rising tide that lifts all both I feel really similarly about the covering by proxy notion which is you could look at
  250. somebody who's saying oh I don't cover myself but like I don't talk about my child who is trans or who is
  251. multi-racial and you could say well that's not a direct harm that you suffer so I'm not really going to listen to
  252. that that's not a a particularly Salient aspect of this you know analysis or we could approach it in a more openhearted
  253. way and to say like you know that is you know a form of covering and if we acknowledge that what we're really
  254. acknowledging is that people are allies right people are connected to marginalized communities that they don't
  255. belong to themselves and oftentimes have to make really uh hard decisions right about how much to disclose or how how
  256. not to disclose and uh there's some suffering right involved in being that kind of Ally so again if we take the
  257. more kind of openhearted generous approach this project stops being like us versus them that stops being like
  258. you're a terrible person because you're straight and you're forcing me to be straight acting as a gay man right it's
  259. it's not really about that it's like how can we make this culture better for everyone who inhabits it right including
  260. individuals and dominant groups including people who are uh covering by proy even if they're not directly
  261. covering themselves I think you make a very important point and I I forget who coined the term but I often use it when
  262. I'm um in in sort of like informal context and it's called the you know the term the oppression Olympics so let me
  263. know if you remember who who coined this term but you know we often use this term
  264. to talk about marginalized groups and sometimes it's like my marginalized group is suffering more than your
  265. marginalized group but I started thinking about that term slightly differently Kenji based on what you just
  266. said is if we can recognize that an unfortunate aspect of The Human Experience is that a lot of people feel
  267. that they are suffering in fact I'm sure if you walk down the street and you ask
  268. somebody did they do is something like challenging for them I would venture to say that most people feel like there are
  269. some challenges that they are facing and and while we can you know think about perhaps on one level how someone might
  270. have more Advantage than we have I'm not sure we would encounter too many people
  271. who said my life is great and it's fine all of the time and I'm never are suffering and and so when I think about
  272. what you're saying we're think about the current context right now I know so many
  273. Chief diversity Equity inclusion officers are struggling in their jobs right now as they're trying to you know
  274. drum up support for the continued work on this space um one of the things that I hear you saying Kenji which is also
  275. the benefit of this covering research is um sometimes it becomes really important
  276. to help us also understand the the ways in which we all are challenged in our workplaces and to address those and
  277. covering and uncovering these are um Universal challenges and issues and opportunities that exist in our
  278. organization that can create negative impacts for all of us and for all of our organizations um and it is inherently A
  279. diversity Equity inclusion and belonging issue that affects lots of different people no matter their intersectional or
  280. lack there of experience so I think I'm going to take that away with me as I'm listening to people talk about the value
  281. of Dei right now and all the legislation and what that means is is um sometimes there are issues like covering and
  282. uncovering which um we're not addressing that are to everyone's benefit that we talk about more broadly so with the last
  283. few minutes that we have I just want to get into I'm so sorry can I jump in on that important point that you're raising
  284. you want to take us to Solutions too Kenji that would be great because that's where we're going next great absolutely
  285. so I will I will try to be very succinct about this but this is one of the things
  286. that I just not to embarrass you Joanne but really learned a lot from Joan on of
  287. like the importance of keeping both sides of that tension steadily visible and like not forcing ourselves to choose
  288. in between the two of them yes on the one hand I want to say I don't want to participate in the oppression Olympics
  289. but on the other hand I also don't want to treat all forms of human pain as being completely equal and to fall into
  290. the trial of false equivalence right so I don't want to say the fact that you had to cover you that your fact that you
  291. were Humanities major when you went into the tech company is the same thing as you know a black person having to
  292. modulate their identity with regard to uh anti-black Prejudice right those are not the same thing right so how do we
  293. keep both Notions steadily visible that everyone covers right but also that some
  294. this tax is being exacted more heavily on some cohorts than it is on others and framed in that way I actually don't
  295. think that there is attention I think that we can say both things so saying yes everyone covers this is a universal
  296. phenomenon but also please just in the name of our common Humanity like please don't engage in false equivalences right
  297. and from a strategic perspective like I also think that people are much more able to hear I think a lot of the ranti
  298. ma on the part of dominant groups and you know as a man I can speak to this is you know the the notion of if you don't
  299. recognize if you if you treat me like you know everything has been great in my life and like I have no forms of
  300. vulnerability whatsoever I'm going to bristle at that right but if you can acknowledge in this Universal way of
  301. like we all as human beings have vulnerabilities that's GNA open a conversation rather than close it down
  302. and I'm much more likely to be able to hear that I may be engaging in false equivalences by treating the various
  303. kind of slings and arrows that I've suffered in my life uh to somebody else's experience so I think we need to
  304. keep both truths steadily visible everyone every cohort covers uh and this taxes assessed of everyone but it is not
  305. assessed evenly across c-port we we have data backed ways and saying you know people of color women lgbtq plus
  306. individuals have uh much higher rates of covering than uh the general population
  307. so this is something that was so such a productive conversation uh with between our team and deo's team and and I think
  308. we landed in a really good place and I just wanted to communicate that now with regard to Solutions which I also as I
  309. mentioned earlier the the kind of really one of the the kind of Mark key contributions of uh this study so as I
  310. said the 2013 study again I make no apologies for this that's where we were at the time was very thin on Solutions
  311. so here we have three solutions that we are offering as a way of moving a a covering culture into uh a culture of
  312. where individuals can uncover so the first one is diagnos and this isn't just identifying the phenomenon although
  313. that's really important before we uh had the term unconscious bias and hammered it into our public vocabulary we could
  314. do anything about it so to with covering but I just want to say that it's not just diagnosing like the fact that
  315. you're covering along or four axes of appearance affiliation advocacy or Association and the definitions are all
  316. in the paper I won't detain us here with that but it's also saying like if you do
  317. cover does it hurt because some people are like what we imagine Margaret Thatcher to be that's our kind of go-to
  318. example like she was forced into go voice coaching to scrub her workingclass accent and to lower the timber of her
  319. voice uh so she exuded more gravitas but she never complained about it so we can
  320. imagine a lot of people who would say like oh yeah I was asked to cover but no harm no foul it was just what I needed
  321. to do to get to the next level of my career and I didn't experience it as a privation to the ex other to the
  322. contrary I experienced it as constructive feedback so if you're covering but it's not harmful then you
  323. know you're one of the lucky ones like no further action required right even if you're covering and it hurts we still
  324. want you to ask the question of like is the covering demand backed by an organizational value value right so
  325. often times for us are all forms of covering bad like if I show up at Wharton or I show up at at deoe and I'm
  326. rabidly obnoxious and you say knock it off and I say this is my authentic self deal with it right that's not gonna get
  327. very far right and so we have to come to the conclusion that some forms of covering are beneficial right uh to the
  328. smooth functioning of an organization so how do we winnow out the good from the bad forms our answer is organizational
  329. Valu so if you can back with a neutral organizational value the fact that you don't want people to be obnoxious in the
  330. workplace it's a kind of silly example but you get where I'm going then you're fine but often times what we find in our
  331. research is that people are being asked to cover in ways that would kind of horrify the organization at a higher
  332. level of generality so G people are being told be straight acting or you know don't work on gay rights issues
  333. right if you want to be a member of this organization and the organization thinks
  334. of itself as Pro lgbtq Plus and it's horrified when it's confronted by uh the mismatch between the ideals that ports
  335. of live under and the ideals that it's actually living up to so diagnos is that first bucket the second bucket is to be
  336. an active Ally uh and this sort of draws on the general research that we know this is Heckman and Johnson this is kind
  337. of your neck of the woods Stephanie sort of organizational psych right but this is the Allies are much more effective at
  338. intervening uh with regard to all issues of bias and affected parties themselves
  339. so you're much less likely to take a hit uh in terms of your reputation you're much more likely to be listen to if you
  340. come in as an ally rather than if you are uh the person directly targeted or affected so it's a broads spectrum
  341. antibiotic it works for a lot of dni issues but it also works for covering so you know if you know a latinx individual
  342. walks in late for a meeting and someone says oh I see on Latino time then I'm gonna be much more effective as someone
  343. who doesn't belong to that Community Stepping in and saying and a smart sort of hopefully effective sensitive way you
  344. know saying you know I I don't you know think that that was a helpful comment I don't need to drag the affective person
  345. into it but I can say I as someone who um invested in inclusive culture was troubled by that comment could you
  346. please explain our refres and I'll be much more effective in intervening from the side as an ally than I will be as
  347. the affected person so if we all do that for each other we're going to get much further right and combating covering
  348. demands than if everyone is forced to deal with the covering demands that are directed at them and the final solution
  349. which I have to admit is my favorite is share your story and we open with stories of our own you know covering
  350. experiences and what we covered as co-authors of the study so my executive director David Glasgow uh Joann's you
  351. know colleagues Heather and sine all write their stories because we thought we have to Pony up here and model uh
  352. what we're trying to ask of people and it's not a huge lift uh these are stories that you know are not like too
  353. much information stories but they nonetheless color outside the bounds of a traditional resume right and so we say
  354. it's really important when you're introducing yourself to an internal external audience particularly if you're
  355. a leader to say something that shows your Humanity beyond your uh traditional work credentials and just as importantly
  356. in these kind of infinite but infinitesimal moments like you can share in ways that are not like set pieces but
  357. like offhand Grace notes or comments that say I'm leaving work to go to my daughter's soccer game right rather than
  358. not giving a reason or lying about it and say I'm leaving work to go to a client meeting or to go to my own
  359. doctor's appointment or something that is to be more acceptable in a traditional workplace it's by pushing
  360. against those kind of daily uh Norms right that we can actually create the space by sharing our stories for other
  361. people to share their stories with us thank you thank you so much for those really practical tips Kenji Joanne I
  362. want to close out with you uh managers and non-managers I like to refer to I know as dee does as well non-managers as
  363. individual contributors but can you give us a couple of tips for managers and individual contributors as we're
  364. thinking about the implications of what you all found in this study uh sure uh so um with regard to leaders and
  365. managers as Kenji mentioned our um you know recommendation is that they create the environment or Foster you know
  366. psychological safety um where they have influence in order to um enable uncovering and a very effective way to
  367. do that is to start with your own uncovering or um at minimum to help others understand you know that it is
  368. acceptable um for them to uncover and that their identity is accepted and and appreciated and everything that comes
  369. with that um and so you know workers uh believe that um their leaders uh create psychological safety our respondents
  370. said at about 50% and they also believe that leaders actually want their authenticity that's at about
  371. 61% I'll say I think we can do better than that um certainly uh and um you know when we are able to um be active
  372. allies regardless of our role I think that that makes a significant difference so um when I think about um my
  373. experience I I'll give an example uh so I was you know up for partner at the firm and um you know sort of navigating
  374. my way through that that's a difficult uh and and a very big U Milestone and I had a coach working with me and he said
  375. to me that his leader his manager was holding him accountable for my success or basically holding us accountable for
  376. our joint success and that was a turning point for me in our relationship and also how I showed up you know because a
  377. couple of things one it signaled to me that you know who I was and the way I showed up you know was not only
  378. acceptable but valued um but also you know when I sort of prodded him on and I said well yeah she wants you to help me
  379. and all that she's like he's like no no she's holding me accountable so maybe you think you're out in the middle of
  380. the lake in the rowboat by yourself rowing and I'm on the shore waving at you and wishing you good luck no we're
  381. both in the boat and we're rowing together we're in it together and my reaction was to say oh all right well
  382. then I can tell you what's really going on you know because before I wasn't sure
  383. and I wasn't sure that I was safe but because this colleague um was able to signal that you know it was safe to be
  384. myself and I was being accepted and valued then I was able to uncover um uh for other individuals you know in active
  385. allyship as um Kenji mentioned you know standing up or showing up for others particularly those that don't share that
  386. particular identity um makes the most difference I I know that you know you've seen in your work where you know people
  387. who who um let's say are show up for or stand up for those who share an identity
  388. um are both you know Lo both lose credibility but when we show up for those who are um of a different identity
  389. you know that makes a real difference and so I had someone remind me the other day um we were talking about what active
  390. allyship looks like and he said you don't have to be white to be an ally which is you know sounds obvious of
  391. course but what that means is that we can all be active allies to each other regardless of our role regardless of our
  392. level if we show up for each other if we make the space and we signal um in obvious and and subtle ways that you
  393. know this is acceptable and this is valued then that gives all of us the courage to show up and demonstrate you
  394. know who we really are and you know counteract the negative impacts of covering within the organization
  395. absolutely great great great stuff Joanne in Kenji this report is wonderful um I hope everyone reads it uncovering
  396. culture it is available everywhere but where can people access it besides everywhere if they want to get a copy of
  397. that we can certainly link to it in the article that we publish but is there a a
  398. good googleable term that we should send to certainly Google uncovering culture a
  399. few other things might show up I'm not gonna lie but the easiest way to get to it is you
  400. know www.d.com usus uncovering excellent you'll have access to everything we have there excellent
  401. all right um it's a good read it's not too academic it has the right balance of empirics and I think people who are in
  402. organizations and and certainly researchers like myself who are always always looking for ways to sort of frame
  403. practical issues um in academic ways will find this uh beneficial as as well so I want to thank you Kenji and Joanne
  404. for joining us today thank you for sharing your insights and your expertise with us truly appreciate you for being
  405. here I know the guests or the the uh the listeners the audience always uh loves the chance to hear from experts like
  406. yourself on these topics that are very really really real and Salient to them in their daily work lives uh so thank
  407. you to the audience for joining us uh and for listening to this episode of the knowledge at wart and leading diversity
  408. at work podcast series goodbye for now for more insight from knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won.
  409. up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Kenji Yoshino and Joanne Stefan discuss covering in the workplace and present solutions for fostering an inclusive culture in their new report.

Key points

  • Uncovering Culture. The 2023 report shifts focus from individual covering to organizational demands.
  • Intersectionality in Covering. The study reveals that 100% of black LGBTQ+ individuals reported covering.
  • Authenticity vs. Covering. The struggle between being authentic and conforming to workplace expectations is explored.
  • Challenging Stereotypical Demands. A call to challenge the demands for stereotypical behavior in organizations.
  • Universal Vulnerabilities. Everyone faces covering demands, highlighting a shared human experience.
  • The Importance of Allies. Being an active ally can help address bias and covering issues effectively.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes