Improve Employee Engagement | Wharton Prof. Peter Cappelli — the Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW In the complex world of financial accounting, employees aren’t counted as corporate assets. Wharton’s Peter Cappelli explains why that’s a mistake.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 01:27 - Understanding financial accounting 05:01 - Investor strategies: past vs. present 08:25 - Company hiring approaches 11:23 - Discussing Prof. Cappelli’s book 14:40 - Modern CEOs vs. past CEOs 18:14 - Understanding investor incentives 21:47 - Impact of inexperienced C-Suite professionals

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#employeeengagement #humancapital #humanresources #HR #hiring #layoffs ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. financial accounting is not the same as internal accounting with its detailed categories of all costs and sources of
  2. revenue for the purposes of our discussion here though what is important is the odd way
  3. Financial Accounting treats employment costs as compared to other costs perhaps the best known example of this is
  4. investments in equipment are treated as assets that can be paid for and depreciated over time as we get value
  5. from them but investments in employees are treated as a current expense and must be paid in full in the year in
  6. which they accrued even though we get value from them over time wages and salaries are seen as worse than other
  7. current expenses because they are seen as fixed costs that somehow can't be cut in downturns even though layoffs are
  8. commonplace welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the
  9. minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind
  10. the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring
  11. how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse range of topics bringing you the latest
  12. insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get ready to dive into new ideas with the
  13. ripple effect Peter great to have you here it's great to see you again thanks for giving us a
  14. few moments today thank you Dan uh so this idea of financial accounting when do you think it really has has kind of
  15. started and kind of gained traction so that you're seeing this impact around companies right now
  16. you know one of the things that my father told me I should absolutely do is take accounting classes and I never did
  17. so my knowledge of accounting is very much as a kind of outsider on this stuff but I think there was a coming together
  18. of a couple of Trends so Financial Accounting my understanding of this modern Financial Accounting begins with
  19. a Great Depression the creation of a security Exchange Commission efforts to kind of standardize uh how financial
  20. accounting is done because you know if accounting is not consistent it's pretty useless right
  21. and that has been in place for a while the Financial Accounting Standards Board was created I think 1973 or so and they
  22. began to coordinate and consolidate the rules into clearer categories so they could be used and then again in 2009
  23. another effort in that so the standards the basic ideas of this are not new they
  24. got started at a time when in most companies the big deal was Capital Equipment it was machine or even
  25. manufacturing especially right so not too surprising that they focused on that and they didn't pay much attention to
  26. human capital and the key distinction that they made was that something could be an asset if you own it
  27. and then you could invest in it but only if you own it so once they thought about human capital
  28. and they were not to my knowledge thinking about it at the time this was all promulgated
  29. you know you don't own your employees so they can't be assets and you can't invest in them because you can only
  30. invest in assets so that's been around for a long time what begins to change is in the 1980s the rise of shareholder
  31. value as the new goal for companies they used to say that the goal of companies was
  32. explicitly to balance the interests of the stakeholders and investors were one but so were employees and so is the
  33. community around you and so were your customers when I first got to the Wharton School that is how people
  34. thought about it right and how we taught it there was a academic Revolution on that question that pushed sort of from
  35. the economics point of view the idea that really shareholders are the only stakeholder and it was one of those
  36. battles that was one without a fight because we didn't actually teach corporate governance here in most places
  37. so as it Advanced and finance became more important as investors became more important and some of that happened when
  38. we started to get bigger institutional investors you know groups like Calpers the
  39. California Pension Fund mutual funds like Vanguard and Fidelity these are now huge investment blocks and particularly
  40. when they're buying the market average right the idea that in the past is if they didn't like the way you were
  41. running their company they just dumped the stock and move on you can't do that if you're trying to buy the market
  42. average so you know a another development was this idea that the investors were pushing for this
  43. shareholder value goal so once you had that we had Financial Accounting already which Drew this distinction between
  44. human and physical assets there were no human assets right human capital broadly
  45. defined and then the idea that shareholder value was really the big goal and then institutional investors
  46. pushing that goal harder and harder all the time now we start to see some things change
  47. and especially now that we start to see so many companies where the real value seems to be the people and so those
  48. initial assumptions from you know the 1930s that people are not assets and they have no real value in
  49. the finances of a company now starts to really bite because you have so many companies where the physical assets
  50. don't matter and where investors are pushing harder on financial accounting outcomes because you know investors are
  51. not trying to maximize current profits investors are trying to make money on future profits the value of the shares
  52. is what will things look like in the future whether you're profitable today or not doesn't matter so much to them
  53. so now we have to start thinking about what the rules of the game look like and like in sports
  54. if you wanted to know how good a basketball team was you'd have to kind of Begin by understanding the game which
  55. means understanding the rules on which it is played and financial accounting sets out the rules on which companies
  56. are operating and what they're trying to do and those rules are financial accounting
  57. and because of the quirks of the way it handles or doesn't handle human capital we start to see bigger and bigger
  58. problems as human capital becomes in objective terms more important but in financial terms still worthless and
  59. shareholder value based on financial accounting terms becomes the issue so then with this shift especially in
  60. the last few years then the impact on the company and the employee ends up being a pattern where
  61. you obviously don't want to see you go down this pattern because as you and I have talked in a variety of different
  62. fronts in the past the value of the employee really has a significant strength towards the company's you know
  63. bottom line benefit yeah and a lot of our colleagues in strategy uh recognize that certainly the biggest
  64. uh benefit you've got the biggest competency comes from the people and the way you manage them right and we have so
  65. many companies like in the tech world where physical equipment doesn't matter at all and it's all about intellectual
  66. horsepower and the ability to execute things all those things are really kind of what matter and the investors have
  67. gotten onto this issue before anybody else and their problem with financial accounting is they can't tell
  68. uh how valuable companies are because they can't learn anything about its human capital because nothing about it
  69. is reported except for the total number of employees you have but not the total number of workers so we'll come back to
  70. that issue in a minute here right and it leads to all kinds of distortions as in
  71. any situation where you measure only a few things and you leave out some important ones you're going to get
  72. strange outcomes and that's what we get how then do you think this this shift then potentially impacts how companies
  73. think about things like hiring and and where you know the the level of employee involvement that they have within
  74. companies yes let's start with maybe the simplest one let's talk about layoffs which if
  75. you think about it let's say our employees had asset value if you leave the US accounting standards are different and
  76. some of those Accounting Standards do allow employees to be assets so let's say we thought employees were assets and
  77. head assets and we announced we're going to have a layoff and what layoffs meant
  78. is we're just going to take those assets and we're going to push them out the door
  79. you'd say that we're crazy right it's like okay we got a bunch of computers here we're going to give them away we're
  80. just pushing them out the door it wouldn't make any sense whatsoever and we see something like this if you
  81. see what's going on right now in the tech industry especially but elsewhere you see companies that struggled like
  82. crazy to fill those positions and get people and hold on to them and now they're dumping them and there's a
  83. pretty good bet that in six months they'll be trying to get new employees back and in the current context unlike
  84. you know the 1970s and before employees are not hanging around expecting to be rehired so you got to go back in and
  85. hire people right so that's maybe the most obvious strange example when you come to hiring
  86. you know the thing that employers measure in hiring is they measure the cost per hire perfectly sensible thing
  87. to do the reason they measure that is those costs are ones that show up at least aggregated inside your financial
  88. accounting and the other thing they worry about is cost sorry time to fill a vacancy those two things okay perfectly
  89. reasonable what they don't measure is the quality of the higher which if you think about it is exactly what you would
  90. think they would be looking at is how good are the people we're hiring you know you could hire lousy people
  91. cheaply yeah right but if you look at what is reported in accounting and the things that aggregate up that's your
  92. incentive uh hired cheaply uh don't worry about whether they're any good or not right I mean it seems crazy but that
  93. is literally what companies are doing the evidence on this is pretty overwhelming at least three different
  94. surveys show that employers are not trying to assess the quality of the people they hire and they see them as
  95. kind of interchangeable so you know one of the things that most all of us know is when you bring in somebody from
  96. outside it takes a while for them to become productive compared to the people who are already there
  97. there's no accounting for that I mean there's no literal accounting and there's no understanding of that either
  98. so we're starting to see investors care about this a lot particularly when they look at these Tech firms again because
  99. they can't figure out what the value is and they would really like to know so take us into the the the structure of
  100. doing a book about this uh your book our least important asset what was it that you have seen play out
  101. that have has really driven you to need to do a book about this topic right now yeah well you know I think most people
  102. who are honest and kind of curious will say that the book never turns out to be what you thought it was going to and you
  103. probably know this about writing even writing papers you don't write the introduction until the thing is done uh
  104. nor the conclusion because you don't really know what it's going to say so I started out thinking I was going to
  105. write a book about how we actually manage employees and that's different from what textbooks
  106. say like if you look at a textbook they'll talk about you know the issue of hiring for example how you craft a job
  107. description and then you post a job ad and then you see who applies and then you do these assessment tests and all
  108. this stuff right none of that really happens you know or rarely so the evidence from the Census indicates the
  109. average person at least a couple years ago when they asked this question reported that when they change jobs they
  110. were not looking for a job and they didn't really see a job ad somebody came and got them we don't do any of those
  111. fancy testing of employees we typically just rely on unstructured interviews which are pretty terrible as a way to
  112. hire especially when we get rid of recruiters because they're expensive and we just push the task off onto Line
  113. managers who aren't trained for this and they don't know what they're doing right
  114. so I started to look at practices by practice to see how we're actually doing on these things and it all seemed pretty
  115. lousy you know in ways that just wouldn't make sense to any of us if we knew just a little bit about how
  116. employees actually operate so then I started to say why are they doing this why do you see this same pattern
  117. everywhere and a simple description of this is It's the British phrase Pennywise and pound foolish right so
  118. that is their squeezing costs on some costs and they're completely ignoring other costs why is that and then I
  119. started to think about and look around to see what was driving this behavior and you know the usual view we hear
  120. about shareholder values is they're just trying to maximize profit so they're not
  121. paying attention you know to to anything on the cost side but that's not true and
  122. part of the problem is we were kind of misled about what companies do by our introductory
  123. economics classes which tell us that companies by definition are maximizing profits okay what's a profit you just
  124. look at your revenue and you look at your uh costs and you subtract them and that's your profit well that's not true
  125. at all uh anybody who sits down next to an accountant for a while will get a half hour lecture as an introduction yes
  126. as to why that stuff is not so obvious it's like thinking the game of basketball is simply about stuffing the
  127. ball in the hoop and stopping other people from doing it and you would think well let's just tackle people which you
  128. know does seem to happen in the NBA sometimes and let's just get a really huge guy standing of the basket and Pop
  129. the ball you know you play it differently once you understand the rules right and so I ended up sort of
  130. getting a sense of what the rules were big part of it is these Financial Accounting things there is another part
  131. and that is in part because of the importance of investors and that shareholder perspective the people who
  132. get to run companies now are different in systematic ways than they were a generation or two ago right they're much
  133. more likely to be Engineers who come to these tasks with assumptions about human
  134. behavior but also goals about optimization the data science world has given them lots of tools to optimize but
  135. optimize you got to optimize on something and generally they optimize on minimizing the number of employees and
  136. employment costs so that's what they end up driving and they haven't had as much
  137. Management training most companies corporations got rid of that it used to be that you'd get hired you'd be put
  138. into a management training program where they taught you all this stuff about managing people basically right right
  139. and those are gone so we have a lot more CEOs famous ones in the tech world who never managed anything really they are
  140. Engineers for the most part and you know their view about people was that they were not particularly important so that
  141. that component of of the investor in this process we've obviously seen in in the last few years how the investor and
  142. the employee have more of a voice in the in what's going on in the company these
  143. days do they have enough impact where they're able to affect change on on a topic like this on an
  144. issue like this on on that element of financial accounting yeah so the investors you would think have the big
  145. hammer right because they're driving what uh executives are doing um the accounting world and this is you
  146. know is an outsider to it but at least listening to our colleagues who are deep into this the accounting world is
  147. astonishingly conservative it is Run for the most part by associations of accountants and the
  148. Financial Accounting Standards Board sets the rules for accounting they are overseen by another board which is not
  149. elected it's sort of that industry of financial accounting but not Finance just Financial Accounting right the
  150. security exchange Community or Exchange Commission has delegated the task of creating those rules to the Financial
  151. Accounting Standards Board and they haven't been particularly concerned about what those rules do to the
  152. operation of companies right they have been concerned about being consistent and the idea of valuing human capital is
  153. something that's kind of off the charts for them it seems so weird so the investors have been pushing for a while
  154. to try to get more from companies on this in terms of reporting they've been pushing security Exchange Commission
  155. hard on this they haven't gotten very far yet so the little bit they got is in 2021 the security Exchange Commission
  156. required that companies report anything they thought was material about human capital their human capital to their
  157. business but they get to pick what that is right and they get to pick what they report and so what most of them report
  158. is just verbage about their principles so it's worthless if you're an investor you don't learn anything from it so
  159. these investor groups are big and they still aren't getting very far which shows you that this world of accounting
  160. standards is remarkably insular and I think everybody who looks at that is struck by it and lots of people have
  161. thought about it so the investors can't make much Headway on this at least not yet the employees have very low power
  162. the only Power employees ever really have is if a lot of them are quitting right A lot of them were quitting that
  163. might be slowing down a bit now I'd say the employers have largely resisted efforts to do make the changes that
  164. employees want so for example there's a big concern now about mental health in the workplace many employers are
  165. responding to that which is a nice thing but what they're responding to is helping you deal with the stress that we
  166. have created for you right they're not they're not trying to deal with the stress per se as we know wages are
  167. lagging inflation by a lot so it's not that employers are willing to up wages enough to maybe clear the labor market
  168. for them and one of the reasons for that again is that what investors see are the
  169. wage and salary costs that's a bad thing they really don't like those because those uh look to them like fixed costs
  170. even though they're not fixed historically they were more fixed and in economics we treated them as if they
  171. were fixed that is they couldn't go down in a downturn in the business but of course they can and one more thing which
  172. is particularly quirky is the security Exchange Commission requires that you report headcount which is the number of
  173. employees not the number of workers okay so if you bring in contractors that doesn't count so if you'd like to make
  174. your Revenue per employee or profit per employee jump up drop some of your employees and bring in non-employees to
  175. do that work the denominator fall all suddenly you look wildly more productive and efficient and valuable so that's
  176. another one of the quirks of this financial account well and I would think as well that when you talk about the
  177. successes and failures that employees and managers have that that obviously has to factor into this as well because
  178. the accountants are looking at the bottom line if you have projects that fail that's going to end up hurting your
  179. bottom line and then that's going to have a downstream impact on who managers are how many managers there are how many
  180. employees there are it's it's it is as the title of our podcast is there is a ripple effect that plays out here yeah I
  181. think the investors would love to see that the companies don't want to show them anything about their internal
  182. accounting right you know how are our projects doing what is our turnover of employees by the way this is what the
  183. proposals the new employees sorry the new proposals driven by investors in our accounting colleague Dan Taylor here in
  184. our accounting department is one of those people is asking for the same thing I was suggesting independently and
  185. that is let's ask companies to report turnover let's ask them to report how much they spend on training investors
  186. can't see that right now training doesn't count as any kind of investment because remember you can't invest in
  187. things that aren't assets your employees aren't asset so you can't do that so I think you know there are pressures on
  188. um to improve this but the resistance is so big so far not much is happening how you mentioned a moment ago about uh
  189. the c-suite level uh impact uh how then does that impact the longer term decision process at the c-suite when you
  190. have people that are in those roles that aren't really the ones that have made those type of decisions in the past
  191. yeah I think that's uh that is a big issue and you know CEOs in particular have a really difficult job and they
  192. can't know everything and they need people around them who can point out those things you know that you're
  193. supposed to know they're not experts on marketing they're not experts certainly on human resources very few anybody
  194. comes through that track and gets to the top right so somebody has to kind of point this stuff out to them and make
  195. the arguments to them that hasn't been happening I think over the last well since the 1980s basically the pressure
  196. has been on human resources to cut right because that's what improves the company's Financial Accounting outcomes
  197. and you know making an argument about why we really need to invest employees gets nowhere we're in a slightly
  198. different moment now because now there are enough concerns about employees some of these under the ESG umbrella you know
  199. social impact you should be nice to your employees some of it because frankly they're quitting and quitting is super
  200. important even though in financial accounting it doesn't show up Anywhere But as a CEO you can't miss the fact
  201. that a lot of your people are quitting and especially people close to you right so I think the you know again I think
  202. the pressure is on to do something about this but the CEOs themselves don't really understand a lot of this stuff
  203. they don't understand what the costs are of turnover most companies don't know it's a little hard to figure this stuff
  204. out most of them are not trying I think the human resource people understood that nobody really wanted to hear this
  205. stuff and they didn't want to get up on a soapbox and make the case now it's easier to do right once you see that
  206. your positions are vacant and you're not getting things done it's a little hard you know it's a little hard to miss that
  207. there is one place where I think we are seeing particularly quirky decisions I think by employers and the c-suite
  208. things and this is back to this optimization goal there are a lot of things that we have studied for a long
  209. time and lots of evidence for that show that engaging employees in some decisions makes much better outcomes
  210. they know things that are useful in the decision and they also care about it and
  211. so more invested in it when they do it themselves a lot of that a lot of those practices are going away and being
  212. replaced by software so here's an example let's set our work schedules we have 10 employees in my office the work
  213. has to be covered the office has to be covered but people always have emergencies and many of them have life
  214. concerns that they would like us to accommodate in some way well there's a couple ways you could do that
  215. one of the ways which has worked extremely well is something just called Flex time and flex time means that the
  216. employees get together and they work it out and they say Okay Dan's going to do this on Monday he's got to come in a
  217. little late uh but I can cover that if he will cover this later it it takes a little while to get good at this but it
  218. doesn't take long and it's quite flexible right the other way you could do it is you could delegate it to
  219. software and software will make sure that everybody has exactly the same number of hours everybody is treated
  220. equally but there's no flexibility in that and employees don't like it because they have no say why would you go with
  221. software when you could do this with employees and it's much simpler in the long run well because we want to be
  222. optimal and getting employees to do this I don't know how to do that work with employees so I'd like to just turn this
  223. over to software and let them do it so we get a worst solution which is more expensive but it seems to fit this goal
  224. of optimization right so we're seeing several of those situations play out in the workplace now Peter great to talk
  225. with you good luck with the book the book is titled our least important asset Peter Capelli the Wharton School thanks
  226. very much for coming in good thank you Dan thank you for listening to the ripple
  227. effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  228. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton School [Music]

Brief Summary

Peter Cappelli discusses the discrepancies in financial accounting regarding human capital and its implications for companies.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join host Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton professors.
  • The Shift in Corporate Goals. How the rise of shareholder value has changed corporate priorities.
  • Financial Accounting vs. Human Capital. A deep dive into how financial accounting undervalues human capital.
  • The Ripple Effect. The ripple effect of employee turnover impacts managers and the bottom line.
  • The Challenge for CEOs. CEOs face immense pressure and often lack the necessary insights about employee turnover.
  • Engagement vs. Software. Engaging employees in decision-making leads to better outcomes than relying solely on software.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes