Under Pressure: The Shifting Landscape of Banking Regulations

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research analyzes how external auditors and bank regulations affect the discretion that banks have in loan loss provision estimates. More: http://knlg.net/2iWLv2f 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton accounting professor Allison Nicoletti to talk about her latest research Allison thanks
  2. for being here thanks for having me so you're going to talk to us today a little bit about your dissertation so
  3. first of all could you give us kind of a broad overview of what you looked at sure so my dissertation examines how
  4. external auditors and bank regulators affect Lomas provision decisions so the Lomas provision it's analogous to
  5. bad debt expense for a non financial firm and for banks it's one of the most important accruals it makes up a large
  6. part of their income statement and then also it has implications because it's tied to their loan quality so this is a
  7. really important decision that banks care about and also that the bank regulators and external auditors are
  8. concerned with and there's a lot of discretion that goes into coming up with the Lomas provision estimate so what's
  9. interesting is that bank regulators are involved in on-site safety and soundness
  10. examinations and external auditors come in and actually audit the financial statements but these two groups have
  11. very different objectives and incentives where bank regulators are coming at it more from the safety and soundness for
  12. SEC perspective whereas auditors are coming at it from a do the financial statements comply with generally
  13. accepted accounting principles so what I find in my paper is that bank regulators
  14. and auditors both seem to increase the timing with which banks recognize loan losses but at banks where there's both a
  15. strict regulator and an external auditor these banks are actually less timely compared to banks that are unaudited but
  16. have a strict regulator so what this seems to suggest is that the auditor is constraining timeliness relative to what
  17. the bank regulator would prefer and this is again probably tied to the objectives
  18. and incentives that they have where auditors are concerned about earnings management and other discretionary
  19. choices that banks might be making that aren't necessarily tied to loan quality whereas the regulator is less concerned
  20. with that so what is the implications there for first of all for a bank or for even is there implications for like a
  21. customer who's coming in to get a loan well there's definitely implications for the bank because the bank manager is
  22. trying to balance these two potentially opposing viewpoints so we have bank regulators who are pushing more
  23. timeliness versus the auditor who maybe prefers less timeliness relative to the regulator so that's one of the takeaways
  24. is that bank managers do have to balance that but more importantly is that Lomas
  25. Accounting Standards are actually changing and this was the direct result of the financial crisis so one of the
  26. concerns with the current rules is that auditors are concerned about the discretion that banks have and that was
  27. why they restricted is that they're concerned that banks are managing earnings or doing other opportunistic
  28. things with the accounting this was all this was a problem of in the financial crisis because the threshold to
  29. recognize the loss was very high so we saw banks waiting quite a bit of time before they recognized any losses so the
  30. new accounting standards will be more of an expected approach so banks will be recognizing losses over the life of the
  31. loan but there's going to be a lot more discretion that goes into that so as far
  32. as how this regulator auditor conflict its resolved or actually gets worse under the new accounting standards is an
  33. open question now are there any implications for just the average person who's trying to get a loan or even a
  34. business trying to get a loan or is this more on the bank side well there could be some implications as far as the new
  35. accounting standards going into place so to the extent that banks are going to have to recognize greater loan losses
  36. that has to hit somewhere on their balance sheet so if it's coming out of their capital and there's bank capital
  37. requirements so that may actually result in restricting lending purposes so it could have an effect like that
  38. my research probably can't speak to that quite as much just because I'm looking at a different accounting standard but
  39. it does really just more speak to the bank managers themselves and then probably regulators auditors and groups
  40. that are involved in overseeing the audit profession now is there with bank managers I mean has there been sort of
  41. an historical in terms of like whether they would serve trend towards what the regulator's are looking for versus
  42. auditors or vice versa and are there ProGlide guess prevailing winds on as far as that go there just does it depend
  43. on the bank or so I think it probably depends is the the short answer but there's been a lot of conflict between
  44. the regulator and auditor over the last 20 or 25 years so in the late 1990s there was a conflict again between the
  45. regulators and auditors where it seemed that banks were trending more towards the regulator view where they were
  46. reserving to a great extent for loan losses even perhaps more than the economic of their loan portfolio would imply so
  47. the sec or so kind of a group that's more aligned probably with the external audit function was not happy about that
  48. because it was basically shifting income between reporting periods so there was a
  49. struggle between the bank regulators and the auditors or in the sec and what ended up happening was is that the bank
  50. regulators in the SEC issued new guidance saying this is what you should be doing for loan losses so actually the
  51. SEC ended up winning that battle but now following the crisis it seems that we're
  52. actually shifting more back to a standard that perhaps regulators would prefer so I think that we'll probably
  53. see Bank shifting more back to the regulator view but they were more in the audit SEC camp earlier in the decade and
  54. so what's next for this research what are you going to look at next so I have a different project that I'm going to be
  55. looking at that still related to bank regulation but it's looking at the dodd-frank act so what we're interested
  56. in this paper is looking at specific bright-line asset thresholds so many Bank regulations and other regulations
  57. in general but they have these thresholds like ten billion in total assets for instance we're above that
  58. threshold banks are subject to significant regulatory costs so what we're looking at is whether those
  59. bright-line thresholds seem to incentivize merger activity and if they do do these mergers and have different
  60. outcomes relative to other mergers so the preliminary findings of that would suggest that these thresholds do spur
  61. additional merger activity and at these mergers that result from these regulatory cost motivations do seem to
  62. end up having poor outcomes relative to other mergers great thank you so much for talking with us thing
  63. [Music] you [Music]

Brief Summary

Allison Nicoletti discusses her research on Lomas provisions, auditor-regulator conflicts, and implications for banks and lending practices.

Key points

  • The Lomas Provision Explained. Allison Nicoletti discusses the Lomas provision and its implications for banks.
  • Regulator vs. Auditor Conflict. Nicoletti highlights the differing objectives of bank regulators and auditors.
  • Impact of New Accounting Standards. The new accounting standards may affect how banks recognize loan losses.

Related episodes