Building Relationships with External Stakeholders

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Steve Cobrin professor of multinational management the Wharton School I'm here with v henish who is the
  2. elite touch professor of management at Wharton and author of corporate diplomacy building reputations and
  3. relationships with internal stakeholders hello V hi Steve uh tell us what is corporate diplomacy corporate diplomacy
  4. is the senior level capability to build and maintain relationships with external
  5. stakeholders deliver on the greatest needs or the greatest obje Ives of those stakeholders in a way that delivers
  6. shareholder value great why is it important it's important because firms are increasingly looking for growth
  7. opportunities and revenue opportunities abroad in Emerging Markets Frontier markets foreign markets and in these
  8. foreign markets they're necessarily interacting with more stakeholders stakeholders who vary in their economic
  9. philosophies in their ideologies who have different histories different language backgrounds different cultural
  10. backgrounds and so the the ability to deliver on the growth opportunity ities in these Emerging Markets requires
  11. successful interactions with more and more diverse stakeholders well if there's more and more diverse
  12. stakeholders how do you tell which are the most important which you really should be focusing on and deal with you
  13. know there's both a short and and a more uh subtle longer answer to that the short answer is the stakeholders who can
  14. do you the most Financial harm are the most important but that that can give rise to some uh shortcuts which are
  15. really damaging if we only pay attention to the squeaky wheel if we only pay attention to the stakeholder who
  16. threatens violence we're really creating perverse incentives so I think a fuller
  17. answer is we want to focus on the stakeholders with whom a productive relationship a relationship in which
  18. we're helping that stakeholder obtain his or her objectives is delivering on shareholder value so we both need to
  19. know how much they can hurt us how much they can help us and whether we can build and maintain a longlasting
  20. relationship with them well how do you figure that out how do you determine whether it can help you or hurt you
  21. you've just listed a whole list of stakeholders so it really takes a financial analysis you have to
  22. understand how they impact the bottom line in what way do they impact Reven VES or costs uh really doing the
  23. financial analysis and that's where this approach uh differentiates itself a lot
  24. from the corporate sustainability movement or corporate social responsibility movement it's not about
  25. just the moral case we're really working through step by step and trying to understand where it appears on the p&l
  26. statement what are the costs that could be avoided through a better relationship
  27. what are the revenue gains that could be obtained and how can the actions we undertake with stakeholders helping them
  28. achieve those objectives really show up on the balance sheet and then figuring out what the return is on them sure and
  29. you must have to engage stakeholders you certainly do you have to build that relationship with them and so it's not
  30. just about talking to them it's not just about a communication strategy it's really rolling up your sleeves working
  31. with them to attain their goals so you know a kind of a a simple story of this is you know if one of the biggest needs
  32. is uh housing for example you know one approach might be bring in some prefab housing from Florida um have some
  33. contractors put it up and and then wow you've created their homes but no you really haven't somebody else has you
  34. know if you can get your country manager if you can get your CFO to be out there
  35. laying mortar uh putting up cinder blocks helping someone build their home using local technology with local
  36. contractors creating local jobs and working side by side the resident then you've really started building a
  37. relationship with them and so you want to be in the trenches with them you want to be part of the action and you want to
  38. be working with them in the attainment of their goals so you're arguing then if that corporate diplomacy is really a
  39. Mainline management function is that correct absolutely it's not something that should be said segmented into well
  40. we have a government Affairs team we have a community uh Affairs team we have a sustainability team we're really
  41. thinking from a strategic perspective about how to integrate those and who's more responsible for integration than
  42. Senior Management whether it be the country manager the general manager or the seite if we're in a multinational
  43. corporation and that brings up an interesting point how do you integrate corporate diplomacy into the mainstream
  44. of the corporation into management great question I think it's it's another way in which this approach differentiates
  45. itself from the CSR movement we're not deciding what better what's right we're not just focused on what stakeholders
  46. care about we're speaking the language of Finance we're speaking npv Roi we're turning everything into the same
  47. decision calculus that Senior Management already uses so we're not going to present a parallel analysis or a
  48. parallel set of objectives we're not going to do triple bottom line we're going to turn everything into uh or link
  49. everything to the kpis that the managers are currently tracking whatever is on that dashboard that they look at in the
  50. morning whatever the indicators are that they're tracking on a daily basis we're
  51. going to figure out how external stakeholders link into that and how we can monitor that how we can improve upon
  52. those existing kpis if we're thinking about a big investment decision how do we decide whether we're going to go
  53. ahead with aund million or a billion dollar investment we're going to work through that same project valuation cash
  54. flow model the one that's already on the books the one that they already use in the investment committee meetings we're
  55. not going to create a green light red light smiley face frowny face that goes on top of the ROI we're going to use
  56. that same calculation and we're going to augment it by bringing in the way stakeholders can affect it great you
  57. note in the book that perceptions matter more than facts yes it's interesting statement what do you mean by that V too
  58. often I think when we're confronted with an allegation of a a human rights abuse
  59. an environmental spill a unfair treatment of workers we respond with the facts we respond with no here are are
  60. policies no here's what the scientists tell us here's what really happened but nobody makes a political or social
  61. judgment about whether you're behaving a appropriately or how they feel about you
  62. based on the facts they do it based on emotion based on gut uh based you know if you think about how you go into The
  63. Ballot Box when we go in and we decide who we're going to vote for we're not pulling the lever based on a net
  64. presentent value calculation of our future lifetime earnings under a Republican or Democrat or socialist or
  65. conservative we're doing something more subtle uh we're thinking about who we trust who we have more confidence in and
  66. I'm arguing that stakeholders are doing the same thing and so if we're going to shape the way they feel about us we
  67. can't just stop at are you better off or are you worse off uh what are the facts
  68. about what really happened we have to assess how they trust us whether they trust us and we have to try to build
  69. that trust does that relate to a social license to operate is that exactly social license to operate is a broader
  70. construct than just are you better off or worse off is looking at a more holistic perspective of how we perceive
  71. a company uh the social license to operate is the the general is the perception by a stakeholder that you're
  72. behaving in an appropriate manner uh that you're acting in a way they perceive as fair or just and what you're
  73. trying to do is build up not just whether they perceive you're helping them or hurting them financially or
  74. materially but are you behaving appropriately do you deserve their trust and that takes more than just thinking
  75. about the facts it takes more than just thinking about the financial benefits it
  76. requires thinking about the relationship how do you know when you have it and who
  77. gives it to you well each stakeholder gives it to you so the stake social licensed operate is granted by each
  78. stakeholder at a moment in time and it can be with drawn by any stakeholder in a moment in time so this really focuses
  79. the attention on an ongoing process it's not just the design and the implementation of the entry strategy
  80. it's everything you do every day who you hire who you partner who you contract with where you build how you build all
  81. those things on a day in day out basis affect each stakeholder's degree of social license or the degree to which
  82. they Grant you the social license you have to monitor that in real time you have to watch it in real time you have
  83. to adapt to change in real time uh and so so it's something that's an ongoing management function not just something
  84. at the time of Entry not just something at the time of Crisis something that Senior Management should be focused on
  85. on an ongoing basis corporate diplomacy sounds very complex uh lots of stakeholders to manage lots of issues
  86. perhaps different in every country in which you operate absolutely are there tools that can help you sort all of this
  87. out well there are tools and and the book covers quite a few of them uh stakeholder mapping tools so how do you
  88. V visualize the stakeholder landscape you know if you think about what oil gas and mining companies do in terms of do
  89. IG on geology how much do they do in terms of due diligence on the political space so there there a number of tools
  90. regarding how we take all the complex information on who the stakeholders are what they want how they're connected and
  91. create visuals that can actually guide strategy uh we also talk about scenario analysis for financial valuation so how
  92. do we actually calculate the npv or the ROI of stakeholder engagement and then we talk through tools about how we build
  93. up trust and Frameworks that help think about trust and and Trust building tools
  94. that relate to Communications uh and tools that relate to creating an organizational culture an organizational
  95. mindset that support stakeholder engagement as well as uh learning tools that create a more uh supportive
  96. learning environment or adaptive environment so there's six tool sets of tools or Frameworks uh which together
  97. build up this framework of corporate diplomacy and you go into these six set of sets of tools in detail in your book
  98. corporate diplomacy I do we provide examples of each um both uh tools examples of the use of the tools firms
  99. that have used them the other thing I try to draw is parallels from different sectors I draw lessons from the front
  100. lines of corporate diplomacy uh the front lines of the mining and oil and gas companies that I've referred to also
  101. providers of infrastructure services like Wireless Communications Transportation infrastructure uh also
  102. sustainable tourism uh another industry that's ironically on the front lines uh in very touchy environmental spaces or
  103. political spaces but also the military counterinsurgency campaigns lessons from the development agencies so a diverse
  104. set of sectors who have struggled with corporate diplomacy challenges and I look at how common uh use of these tools
  105. uh is across these six sectors and then say well this is these are tools that managers can use who are going into
  106. these sectors for the first time it sounds comprehensive uh let me ask you what are the critical takeaways that you
  107. would suggest to managers who are either corporate diplomats or should be corporate diplomats well one of the
  108. lessons I draw from looking at the front lines and looking at the experience of best practices is many of the firms I
  109. survey in the book have written off aund million or a billion dollars of losses because they've mismanaged their
  110. relationships with external stakeholders and as a result they've reflected they've built new tools new capacities
  111. they've tried to become better corporate diplomats so they've learned from their
  112. mistakes I guess one of the takeaways from the book is that it's possible to learn from someone else's mistakes you
  113. don't have to wait until you write off a100 million or a billion dollars to invest in this capacity you can learn
  114. from the firms that were there first that were on the front lines that lost and learned so why not learn from
  115. someone else's mistakes learn from best practice and that's what I try to pull together in the book great and again the
  116. book is Corporate diplomacy yes corporate diplomacy building reputations and relationships with external
  117. stakeholders thank you V thanks Steve [Music]

Brief Summary

Corporate diplomacy is crucial for managing diverse stakeholder relationships and enhancing shareholder value in emerging markets.

Key points

  • Corporate Diplomacy Explained. Corporate diplomacy is the ability to build and maintain relationships with stakeholders.
  • The Importance of Stakeholder Relationships. Firms must engage with diverse stakeholders to succeed in emerging markets.
  • Learning from Mistakes. Companies can avoid costly errors by learning from the experiences of others.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes