Radical Innovation: Unleashing Creativity

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I want to welcome Kim Wagner to knowledge at Wharton today she's a partner and a managing director at
  2. Boston Consulting Group also BCG and Kim is an expert in corporate Innovation which is a topic near and dear to almost
  3. every company's heart these days and she's also the author of a piece of BCG research titled managing the
  4. unmanageable radical Innovation so radical Innovation for corporations that's quite something so
  5. tell me about why radical Innovation is important sure so first thanks for having me um why is radical Innovation
  6. important first let's define it so radical or breakthrough Innovation is where you're creating a new market or a
  7. new category of of products so it's when the iPod was first introduced it's when
  8. the cell phone was first introduced um it's remember when the wman was first introduced which now we think of as
  9. something archaic but at the time it was pretty revolutionary and so that's the category
  10. of of new products that we're talking about if you are a startup company um you start in typically the garage um the
  11. person who has the idea has the technology has the vision maybe in it may be in one brain it may be in Two
  12. Brains it's not in 5,000 brains so it's very easy to manage all the cross functional pieces you need to get a
  13. product to Market because it's in a limited number of people's minds or in their in their concept when you move to
  14. Corporate America the idea that you're going to do something breakthrough radical you know really different is
  15. really hard to do because you have a huge company with lots of processes and a history to protect and and numbers to
  16. hit and when you start to bring the idea of something really breakthrough and a lot of rules together it starts to get
  17. very difficult nevertheless it's important and great if you can do it if you can produce the
  18. next iPod so companies do want to do this they definitely want to do it interestingly our research shows that
  19. there's two kinds if you think about strong Innovative companies there's two kinds there's ones that say radical or
  20. breakthrough Innovation is an important part of my portfolio of products so I'm going to spend a certain amount of my
  21. time doing continuous Improvement on products that I have and then I'm going to spend another
  22. portion of my resources on things that are truly new to the world and apple kind of epitomizes that if you think
  23. about every Apple product there's always the next version the next version the next version but at the same time
  24. everybody's waiting for what's that hot new thing what's the Breakthrough thing and when you don't deliver that
  25. breakthrough thing there's huge disappointment there are other companies um and oftentimes it's it's you know
  26. your standard consumer goods companies but not always who do more incremental Innovation and they do a very good job
  27. of it they're extraordinarily successful they return well to their shareholders but they've focused their Innovation on
  28. incrementally adjusting either things that other people produce so fast follower or their own products
  29. creativity and Innovation are abstract ideas and people immediately seize on the on the idea that you you can't sort
  30. of legislate creativity or innovation and so it's hard to take processes and so forth and get them you know put put
  31. inputs in and have them go through a process and come out with creativity and Innovation um how do you view this yeah
  32. it's it's true you can't um but you sure as heck can take whatever creativity exists in an organization and kill it
  33. very quickly and so if you think about think about the evolution of of where you know kind of in the early 90s um
  34. Innovation and new product development was um that was the time that big Enterprise software packages were
  35. getting introduced into Corporate America there was a a desire to control things people were worried about waste
  36. they were starting to think am I investing too much in research am I getting out what I was supposed to get
  37. out and so a lot of um management science started to get applied to the Innovation process there started to be
  38. more metrics more forms more gates more if you want Capital you will need to jump through these hoops and so all of
  39. these processes serve to take the creativ that existed in any organization and make it
  40. very straight path so think of yourself as moving from side streets to Super highways it basically said we want to
  41. move on super highways and so all of a sudden um that shift makes the idea that you would like get off on an exit and go
  42. to a local diner for dinner it just doesn't happen CU you're on the Super Highway and you're trying to get to the
  43. next toll road so that process very very much took creativity out of organizations sounds like it would yeah
  44. yeah and now if you go talk to companies if you talk to the very senior folks often times they'll say we don't have
  45. the ideas we don't have the creative ideas if you talk three or four layers into the organization at the rockface
  46. what you hear is we have a lot of creative ideas we just can't fill in the form to get permission to be part of the
  47. portfolio anymore and so that starts to get it things like typically the quote form to enter the portfolio requires you
  48. to have some sense of what the forward Revenue stream would look like not only how much is it going to be what's the
  49. cost of goods going to be and when can we expect it is this three years out or five years out and and often for a
  50. breakthrough Innovation you can't even comprehend that yet you're still at the stage of I need resources to test if
  51. this is even possible as opposed to I'm ready to tell you how much money you're going to
  52. make you have an interesting example on your paper I think Corning for example and it's people may not realize they
  53. used to make cookware right they still do and and and Industrial things too but then suddenly uh with the world of of
  54. the internet Digital World fiber optics and so forth the the products that they made were uh lent themselves incredibly
  55. well to to that industry but but they made all these things and somewhere inside a coring was a division that was
  56. working on that how did they I mean how did they break through and get management to to pay attention or was it
  57. just so obvious that hey we've got the right technology here to do this this is a no-brainer it wasn't a no-brainer was
  58. it it wasn't a no-brainer but remember it came out you know this is all stuff that happened in the 50s 60s early 7s so
  59. it was the same time as Bell labs and IBM labs and lots of labs and so a lot of industrial companies had these almost
  60. pure research institutes associated with them and that was great and and there was a lot of great Innovation that came
  61. out of it there was a prior work that was done by many other scientists both in academic
  62. labs and other commercial Labs that showed that you could pass light through fibers in a way that you didn't have to
  63. add a lot of repeaters so basically the the technology was if you could imagine sending a signal down a copper wire the
  64. signal could only go so far before it faded out and you had it to reamplify it with a light path you could go much much
  65. further and so the the there was a lot of technology and and proof of concept around we could make a fiber and and it
  66. started off as just I want to make a optic fiber like I would a copper fiber and so it wasn't for the why there was
  67. already some uh evidence that showed that you could send a signal down it you could send an audio track down it you
  68. could send an image down it that was all academic work but you know what I mean by down it is not like miles and miles
  69. away it was like from a point B really close in a lab so they started that in the 70s they
  70. proved that they could make that cable so to speak they then in the late 70s formed a a joint venture with another
  71. company to start thinking about how do I commercialize it the research that they
  72. started with happened in the 60s so you're going from the 60s to the late 70s before you're even thinking about
  73. commercialization and then there were many kind of mistakes along the way or you could call them learning
  74. opportunities like in the' 70s we weren't quite ready for a video phone yet you know it was technically possible
  75. but the idea that the infrastructure would be out there and people would start buying them was really not there
  76. yet except at Disney world except possibly at Disney World or in other proof of concept type situations and so
  77. um you know there were opportunities for Corning to learn as they go and and go down some paths and decide maybe it
  78. wasn't time yet back out and go down other paths uh there's also an idea that you
  79. can't follow every idea this was a great idea and it worked out most of them are
  80. dead ends how do you know how far do you follow them and uh how do you figure out
  81. which ideas give you the best odds for Success yeah this is where you have to remember that Innovation is part science
  82. and part art and actually if you think back to what we did in the 90s when we tried to really industrialize Innovation
  83. is we tried to take all the art out of it almost push the button and hope that innovation comes out and actually that
  84. works very well if all you want to do is change the flavor of something change the packaging of something so
  85. refinements yeah refinements and incremental Innovation if you want to actually go to the the step of something
  86. new to the world um there you have to bring back the art and often times when you know is when you reach the end of a
  87. of an investment period and you sit back and you say what do I know and based on
  88. everything that I know now can I get a product I think or not and what are the critical risks to
  89. getting a product and then that's what you test next so you take an incremental learning approach and if each time
  90. you're getting closer and closer to a product you keep going if all of a sudden something happens and you realize
  91. that the risks are too high the technolog is not in play you either shove it you sell the IP or or you stop
  92. another point that you make in this paper which I think is maybe not surprising but really important is that
  93. old ways old processes just looking at kpis uh and that kind of thing the way companies typically go about things can
  94. actually not just not Foster Innovation they can actually kill it or hurt it slow it down so how are companies
  95. supposed to think about that on the one hand these tools are good for certain things but you have to be careful how
  96. how you use them right and and you don't want to completely abandon them because
  97. you know this radical Innovation project this breakthrough innovation has to exist within the confines of the
  98. corporation where you're doing incremental innovation in parallel so it's mostly about thinking how do you
  99. learn with a program and so um often times uh companies will have a stag gate process where in order to get say a
  100. release of capital funds you need to check off certain boxes around future Revenue future cost of goods uh proof of
  101. concept you design criteria and the like um rather than thinking about checklist
  102. and stages and that you think about learning and you think about how what are my unknowns and what do I need to
  103. learn to go to the next level and if you keep this rigorous learning process going then you can quickly decide do I
  104. have something there or do I not have something there but none of this is going to be a metric of what's the
  105. future Revenue yet eventually you'll get there I mean eventually you have to get
  106. to the point where you manufacture whatever you're going to manufacture and it has to fit into your manufacturing
  107. plants just like every other product so it's not that you abandoned it it's just
  108. that early on you need to protect it from the metrics killing it because if you do a pure rack and stack on things
  109. like probability of success this is going to have a low probability of success but a high potential return in
  110. the event of a success and that you know just drawing a line on a rack doesn't doesn't help so it says balancing
  111. between creativity and Serendipity even and having some some hardcore process to
  112. kind of monitor what's going on and measure and make some judgments along the way right right you need to govern
  113. it you just can't overover it so and successful companies rarely follow traditional management practices they
  114. have some quirky way or some different way of doing things can you talk about what right can you generaliz can you
  115. generalize about creativity so so what's interesting is if you if you talk to companies that have very rigorous
  116. processes in place which so first thing um what we've learned is that to be a good breakthrough innovator you have to
  117. start by being a strong innovator so there's a certain base of you need to know how to do innovation in a corporate
  118. setting in order to be a breakthrough innovator in a corporate setting so if you want to go to kind of plan B and and
  119. break a piece of your portfolio off into in into breakthrough you need to start um by saying what do I need to Shield
  120. this from there are some companies that have a thoughtful process they maybe call it
  121. a swim lane or a breakthrough path or something that allows it to exist in its own type of governance for a period of
  122. time until it has to intersect with the regular process um companies that are not as proactively thoughtful but still
  123. successful it turns out that they had a skunk ORS they had somebody who was very
  124. senior who thought that this product had to go forward it had to be protected they found a way to make it happen they
  125. kind of broke the rules on the side they had their little team and then when it was ready for prime time it got
  126. introduced into the portfolio so um that latter one's harder to replicate right that's it's much harder to replicate an
  127. entrepreneur in your midst and and someone somehow they got to a position of power where they could just let it
  128. run right but what you often find so if you go into a company and they say we really want to get good at this you
  129. start by asking them what were the Breakthrough products that they've launched over their history and then you
  130. start to understand how that got through how did you manage that and then you start interviewing people and you you
  131. talk to the older folks that were there then or were actually Junior then so they're senior managers now but they
  132. were on the working team back then and you often find the examples of the Skunk Works thing worked so how do we now make
  133. that a normal part of business how do we accept the fact that this is a piece of
  134. radical Innovation and and now how do we control it in an appropriate way it's already in the culture so try to harness
  135. that in some way or it used to be in the culture and don't be afraid of it right
  136. okay because you may have squashed it out of the culture so um do you have a a kind of sounds crazy
  137. to talk about Blueprints and creativity Innovation but we're talking really about balancing the two with some kind
  138. of processes so do you have a u a list of processes that companies can follow to help them as they allow the
  139. creativity to run wild in their companies well you don't want it to run wild so so they don't run wild so so
  140. typically um you know what we find again being a strong innovator is important so
  141. you need Senior Management um support for this and you often need more Senior Management visibility and support to do
  142. radical well than just merely being a strong innovator um there's typically a focus on intellectual property um
  143. interestingly radical innovators not only worry about intellectual property from the perspective of can I protect my
  144. product and do I have the permission to operate in this space they also think about it in can I create a business
  145. around this IP on top of it so they often have a side business around monetizing intellectual property that
  146. they create um they have strong portfolio management processes they have strong project management and new
  147. product development and governance processes um and they have a customer focus they're very focused on what their
  148. customers need um and not necessarily what their customer customers tell them they need but what they intuitively know
  149. is an unmet need of a customer so focus on customers but not overly reliant on focused groups yeah because you I mean
  150. if I asked you 15 years ago do you want an iPad you would say why would I need such a thing because 15 years ago you
  151. were just getting used to lugging around a laptop so you know if you think about
  152. it in those terms you just you kind of have to have the vision always something new Under the Sun right all right well
  153. thank you thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Kim Wagner discusses radical innovation in corporations and the challenges of fostering creativity within structured processes.

Key points

  • The Importance of Radical Innovation. Kim Wagner discusses why radical innovation is crucial for companies today.
  • Challenges in Corporate Innovation. Wagner highlights the difficulties large companies face in fostering breakthrough innovations.
  • Balancing Creativity and Process. Wagner emphasizes the need to balance creativity with structured processes for innovation.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes