The Value of Schmoozing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research confirms that the use of enterprise social media may improve firms' bottom lines, but it also -- surprisingly -- may help workers avoid being laid off. More: http://knlg.net/1nwQeRw πŸ“‚ Human Resources;Technology 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so what i study is to understand how enterprise social media affect various type of work outcomes
  2. the way the reason i'm studying enterprise social media is that there's actually been uptick in adoption
  3. in recent years i think in 2009 mckinsey report came out only 28 percent of firms
  4. has used some type of social networking tools but by 2012 that has gone up to 53 percent so we are
  5. familiar with consumer-facing social media such as twitter facebook there are lots of
  6. studies lots of startups or industry activities around this consumer-facing social media
  7. but how enterprise social media affects performance affect firms affected employees effect collaborations
  8. hasn't been examined and that's what i'm trying to do to understand how enterprise social media
  9. enables network formation enables information acquisition and how these intermediate benefits
  10. ultimately affect various work outcomes such as your billable revenue or your probability being laid off next
  11. cycle so information diversity and social communication are two factors i'm looking at in this research
  12. and i found that both have an impact on your work outcomes just affect them differently for example
  13. information diversity measures how much information or how or how diverse your information is and i'm measuring
  14. this through in machine learning techniques looking at your email chats and calendar
  15. events basically all your electronic communications and we found that information diversity
  16. is strongly correlated with your billable revenue and the more information you have the
  17. more likely you're you're you're able to build it makes sense in a sense like the more
  18. influence you have you're a better worker and you're better able to solve your client's problem
  19. interestingly we found that a particular topic called social communication does not have a direct impact on your
  20. billable revenue but has a tremendous impact on whether you get whether you got laid off
  21. in the 2009 recession when you have social commission have the words such as coffee lunch dinner football baseball
  22. these social words the more words you have in your communication the less likely
  23. they are to be laid off and in fact that's the most significant predictor above and beyond your objective
  24. performance measures in predicting whether you're laid off i think the social communication one is
  25. surprising because i thought i i deliberately picked industry where you can measure
  26. your value to the firm very clearly like in the end you know how much you bring how much money you bring to the firm
  27. should be the ultimate value i would thought all the other stuff should have maybe have a bit of
  28. predictive power but in fact that what i found is that social communication has bigger power than your objective
  29. performance in predicting what they got laid off in the 2009 recession i think that's that was really
  30. surprising to me but i'm not saying that people should necessarily just stop working and show
  31. their community should communicate all the time but i'm surprised i'm thinking that
  32. there's a perhaps there's some kind of intention intended value that people should
  33. communicate can provide that we don't see perhaps this person is a really good team player i just really
  34. enjoy working with this person maybe that makes him maybe he did not build directly
  35. but he enabled his co-workers or his colleagues to do better job perhaps that's one reason or you can
  36. think of the traditional and old boys club where you know people who are tend to
  37. schmooze a lot get better but you know i don't know which one's which but uh you know but that's really
  38. surprising to me i guess importantly well obviously you want to do a good job you know getting lots of information on
  39. time is very important and your social network plays a really key role in helping you get the
  40. information and the stuff by social networks also helps you to you know i guess smooth the relationship around
  41. you perhaps you shouldn't just you know be the dilbert in the office always just work and code and do what do
  42. we need to do it actually pays perhaps to you know get to know your co-workers to understand
  43. what's going on at workforce and those kind of intangible benefits through social
  44. communication can be very valuable to workers and for managers you know again maybe you maybe as i think whether
  45. social communication is a positive negative in your workforce i think manager has a
  46. particularly uh better ins a particular better insight than anyone else maybe social communication is really a
  47. lubricant makes the team collaboration better then you should you should foster that but if social communication really
  48. is about political backstabbing or boys club maybe you should you know try to stem that from
  49. happening i think it's becoming aware that social media in particular enterprise social media
  50. can have productivity effect is very important and in particular what was important as firms started
  51. adopting enterprise social media at that workplace i think before you before anyone is
  52. starting to do that i think it's really important to understand potential implications
  53. for our workforce what is the mechanisms going on what enables your workers or employees to do
  54. better job and before knowing that's what's happening you may actually experience
  55. some unexpected consequences of adopting center by social media so although i'm studying consultants but
  56. i think this type of work can generally applicable to all kinds of information workers
  57. including lawyers consultants scientists any kind of information related worker would be you know
  58. we find this research very valuable but i think as enterprise social media is becoming more prominent
  59. any firms are trying to adopt this type of technology will find this very interesting as well
  60. i think the closest one perhaps marissa meyer's decision to ask all the workers to show up instead
  61. of working remotely i think a lot of people there's a lot of backlash against that particular
  62. policy especially for working moms i'm actually i'm working on myself and but i actually
  63. think there's some merits in that as well but for the workers if you think social
  64. communication is really going to be such an important predictor in your career outcomes or
  65. career trajectories perhaps it pays to show up and to lubricate this social communication around you and to
  66. understand each other to understand your colleagues who know what's going on because a lot of
  67. information or especially intangible information are passed down through water cooler conversations and
  68. with that but if you're working at home all the time without having that access perhaps you actually you're actually
  69. doing your own you know you're actually worse off as a result if you're kept doing that so i think marissa has a
  70. point but whether we should enforce 100 percent i think it depends on the setting depends on the
  71. firm was it was what was needed and uh perhaps marisa made it the right decision i don't know it means actually
  72. yahoo well i guess it depends on the person again right this perception again depends on
  73. who you're talking to perhaps for a consultant this may be may not be as surprising i don't know
  74. but for someone you know for like me or anybody who's in the in the industry at least in america we
  75. think of meritocracy right we think that meritocracy is ultimately what gets us you know promoted we got we were
  76. rewarded for you know for doing our job well but the fact that we the fact this is
  77. this research i've shown that social communication matters it's interesting takeaway in the sense that not only
  78. should you do your job well but you also have you also should worry about some other
  79. intangible communication or other stuff you have to do at work it makes us more likely that you will be do
  80. you'll be you know keeping your job getting promoted or improve your career outcomes
  81. i think enterprise social media in general hasn't been studied much we see a lot of again facebook and
  82. twitter social media that's consumer facing and what's unique about this research is
  83. that i have the real social network of employees because if you think about your
  84. communication electronic communication channels including your calendar events that capture some of the
  85. meetings facebook facebook basically encounters these are all real communication that your real network at
  86. work and to capture that precisely to understand the intermediate outcome that networks can produce is something
  87. that hasn't been done before so i'm actually in the process of finishing another project related to
  88. this and where we found a emergence of a network biased technical change in instance as a social media is being
  89. adopted at work we actually see a you know digital divide among workers so you think that perhaps social media
  90. enable people to find each other more easily and may therefore we raise some of the barriers that we
  91. have in connecting to other people at work and perhaps the dilbert of the world would
  92. be better off because now he has to use social media to find the people he needs to find
  93. but in fact what i found is actually a little disco disconcerting the sense that
  94. dilbert are becoming worse off as social media becomes more available if you think about it if you were making
  95. connection you need to find a person you wanted to connect but you also need to persuade that person to become connected
  96. to you so as a search cost have become erased because of social media this conversion
  97. cost of you know making the person become your friends is even becoming more prominent
  98. as a result if you have a lot of political i mean social capital before you are even better off because you have
  99. the power to make that person be connected to you whereas if you don't have that power even you found the
  100. person you defined they may not choose to connect with you and then you're actually worse off
  101. so in a sense we actually do see a rich get richer and poorer get poorer phenomenon with enterprise social media
  102. and i think that's again some unexpected consequences that firms should should try to
  103. understand before they adopt these type of technologies you

Brief Summary

Enterprise social media impacts work outcomes, with social communication influencing job security more than performance metrics during layoffs.

Key points

  • Impact of Social Communication. Social communication significantly predicts whether employees are laid off, more than performance metrics.
  • The Importance of Networking. Understanding social networks can enhance career outcomes and job security.
  • Unexpected Consequences of Social Media. Adopting enterprise social media can lead to a digital divide among workers.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes