Obama's Top Economist Tackles Climate Change, Wage Stagnation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The benefits of the Obama Administration's climate change policies far outweigh the costs, says Jason Furman chairman of the President's Council of Economic Advisors. More: http://knlg.net/1yK6B5y 📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the chairman of the president's Council of economic advisors Jason Ferman joins us today to talk about climate change
  2. and the administration's policies for addressing it thank you for being here with us thanks for having me uh about a
  3. year ago a little more than a year ago June 2013 uh President Obama announced his
  4. plans for addressing climate change over the second half of his administration um what's been happening
  5. in the ensuing 15 months and um is he is the administration on track with what they hope to accomplish um we've been
  6. working really hard since the president first announced that climate action plan
  7. and that plan has three parts which involve almost all the agencies in the federal government the first is to
  8. reduce the amount of carbon we emit the second is to be able to better deal with
  9. the changes that climate change will bring because we can slow it but we can't stop it and third is to better
  10. enlist the World in that effort and if you look at just the last week um you see things in a lot of those different
  11. areas last week we had a number of companies at the White House talking about how they could phase out their use
  12. of hydrocarbons increase their use of solar and this week the discussion at the United Nations will help advance that
  13. third prong of the climate action plan engaging with the rest of the world recently 12 States mostly coal producing
  14. states have sued the EPA uh claiming that the rules which I believe the administration would like to uh impose
  15. on uh air emissions greenhouse gas emissions uh would affect the coal fired plants in these states uh drastically
  16. causing some of them to close there's been protests among uh by coal miners uh for example um and
  17. so these are these are charges which U sort of the mirror image of that are the states that are feeling that this the
  18. either pollution or Andor greenhouse gases are sort of wafting over state lines into their territory and are
  19. trying to put a a stop to that so where where does this all stand I mean this is really
  20. about jobs and climate change and uh tradeoffs and that kind of thing I'm an economist not a lawyer so let me give
  21. you an economic perspective although I should say that the lawyers I talk to think this is clearly in the statute the
  22. Supreme Court um basically has said that in the past but um it's very much sound
  23. economic policy and it's consistent with what we always try to do in environmental regulation which is look
  24. at the costs and look at the benefits electricity is responsible for 32% of our greenhouse gas emissions that's
  25. larger than any other source of greenhouse gas emissions most of those emissions are coming from coal fired
  26. power plants when we look at that we think there's a number of things you can do to improve you could have more
  27. efficient Coal fire power plants you could shift to a transition fuel like natural gas you could instead build um
  28. capacity in Renewables or you could use um less electricity and the combination of those four tools means that we could
  29. bring our emissions down and we could bring them down in a very coste effective way the benefits of bringing
  30. them down are many multip of the cost both direct health benefits like reductions in asthma and premature death
  31. and then longer term benefits from mitigating some of the potentially worst impacts of climate change okay um so the
  32. standard argument oftentimes when you discuss environmental issues is that there has to be some kind of a trade-off
  33. between uh the the good effects that might come from from these kinds of things uh and the
  34. the negative economic effects so it's not to say there aren't economic effects you're saying that the that the the good
  35. that is produced outweighs it but how do you think about trading these things off
  36. because there would be some jobs lost or maybe there's jobs created somewhere else um but you know obviously U there
  37. are some winners and losers even if as you argue the winners might be outweighing the losers MH right so first
  38. of all I'd look at the costs and the benefits and here the benefits are in the range of 50 to 90 billion dollar per
  39. year and the costs are in the range of eight or9 billion dollar per year so it's many multiple benefit um to cost
  40. ratio I would then um you know note that there's a lot of ways in which this will
  41. help the economy and create jobs whether that's in natural gas or Renewables and
  42. you see jobs booming in those sectors of the economy I certainly think that preventing asthma premature death
  43. respiratory illness all of that actually can can help make people more productive
  44. and help the economy the IMF has a recent study that has um documented that and finally most importantly there's the
  45. economic costs of inaction those are really large and they're the more we delay the more they are we wait extra
  46. decade the costs go up about 40% we wait extra decade and don't do as much so the temperature goes up an extra
  47. degree Centigrade the costs go up by the equivalent of 100 50 billion for the United States so there's a lot of cost
  48. um you know to inaction when uh projections are made for the growth of alternative energies a
  49. lot of times you see kind of simple straightforward projections um solar energy will likely increase by a certain
  50. amount you sort of see these straight line projections and it it strikes me a lot of times that that that doesn't take
  51. into consideration unexpected breakthroughs although there's maybe likely to be some
  52. breakthroughs even if we don't know what they're going to be by definition and also that you can reach a Tipping Point
  53. so some are arguing that that's what's that's the point that we're at now so solar energy costs per dollars per watt
  54. of electricity generator have been dropping something like 5 to 7% per year for 30 years almost in a predictable way
  55. um to the point now that it's getting very close to parity in in terms of cost with fossil fuels uh what's your view on
  56. on this is are we likely to see a sudden and dramatic increase uh in in reductions in cost that would cause
  57. people to want to use these alternate sources more uh and what is your growth projection for uh alternative energy use
  58. over the next couple of decades right so in the last few years we've seen wind um
  59. power produced by wind grow three-fold and solar grow um tenfold and I expect they're going to continue to grow
  60. rapidly um I'm not the best person to predict just how rapidly but what I can tell you
  61. is if we have the right public policies in place that would help and those public policies are appropriate because
  62. you have an externality here which is other forms of um Power produce carbon which creates a worldwide harm um
  63. Renewables don't and in the face of that externality policies like the production
  64. tax credit we have in the tax code the investment tax credit that the those two benefit wind and solar and the clean um
  65. Power plan for existing power plants lot of states are going to figure out how they want to adopt that rule and
  66. implement it and I think many of them will create incentives for Renewables so I think all of this will help provide an
  67. impetus to um accelerate the work on Renewables okay I would be remiss if I had the chairman of the president's
  68. Council of economic advisors here and didn't ask him what you see coming ahead for the economy so in terms of GDP
  69. growth over the next two three four quarters what what do you think is going to happen uh we've seen growth uh speed
  70. up in the second quarter the indications are good for the third quarter I'd never
  71. want to venture a quarter by quarter forecast but one of the things I think we have going for us and it's one that I
  72. hope we don't interrupt um and mess up is we've had a somewhat more predictable fiscal environment with less of the type
  73. of uncertainty that hurt the economy in the past and a more neutral fiscal policy without the types of large fiscal
  74. contractions that were helping to go against our growth before I think if we can continue that then there's every
  75. reason to believe the private sector can continue to make um you know its contributions to Growing our economy and
  76. bringing the unemployment rate down and on a percentage basis for GDP what kind of I don't have a particular forecast
  77. for you but we're still um in the phase of growth where we get extra growth by bringing our
  78. unemployment rate down putting more people to work and adding to our growth rate um after we're fully
  79. recovered then growth will only come from expanding the economy's potential which depends more on the types of
  80. Technologies we have at our disposal the the quality of the capital Investments we're making but still right now um
  81. we're we're you know in the final stages of the cyclical recovery and that will be boosting growth in the term there's
  82. been an interesting release of studies recently from the oecd organization of Economic Development World Bank the ILO
  83. International labor organization they're all looking at this question of wage stagnation which has been a problem in
  84. the US uh but also around the world so in a nutshell the idea is that a lot of companies or economies are having
  85. relatively decent productivity gains but those gains are not flowing much down to
  86. workers whose wages haven't increased much if at all uh for a very long time and that uh has not only an effect on
  87. the workers but it also has the effect of dragging down uh the potential of the economy if if uh people don't have
  88. enough money to spend so what's what's your view of that particularly in in the US what are some of the causes what
  89. could some of the solutions be for that well I'd love to spend an hour with you on that topic I think if you look at
  90. Family incomes um there have been three important things that have happened first um productivity growth matters a
  91. lot and it isn't as fast as it was in the 50s and 60s it's a lot faster than the 70s and 80s but it still hasn't uh
  92. you know it still could be faster the second is the big increase in inequality that we've seen since the late
  93. 1970s and the fact that a lot of the gains in the economy are going either to higher earners or to um the business
  94. side of The Ledger and the labor share of income has been falling since about 2000 and then the final issue is one
  95. that I don't think is fully appreciated but even against those two forces family
  96. incomes continued to rise in the 70s 80s and 90s and that's because there was pressure on wages but a lot more
  97. households had two earners rather than one as women um came into the workforce and droves now that that which was
  98. helping to compensate and offset some of these other ch es has stopped and women's labor force participation has
  99. basically flattened out and started to fall that means that we're feeling the productivity growth and the inequality
  100. you know even more than the ways in which it was masked in the 70s 80s and 90s um which is creating I think a very
  101. serious challenge for the typical fam's income and one that I think needs to be the central focus of Economic Policy um
  102. not one that has a onep part agenda or even a three-part agenda it's more like uh as many parts of an agenda as you can
  103. you can throw at the issue because it's a big one what what are just some of the
  104. potential tools that could be used uh to address this problem in your view I think we need to expand our growth rate
  105. we can do that with immigration reform business tax reform investing in infrastructure improving education
  106. expanding trade then I think we need to make sure that more of the benefits of those growth are shared across the board
  107. um the minimum wage is one particularly powerful tool we have to do that another
  108. one is expanding the earned income tax credit for workers um without children or non uh custodial parents and um you
  109. know but I think we just need to keep working on you know every aspect and you know I'm not one the person who says um
  110. let's just focus on distribution let's focus on growth I think we need to focus on both I think a lot of the instruments
  111. we have um working on both of them uh simultaneously thanks very much for joining us thanks for having
  112. me and

Brief Summary

Jason Furman discusses climate change policies, economic impacts, and the growth of renewable energy under the Obama administration.

Key points

  • Climate Change Action Plan. The administration's plan focuses on reducing carbon emissions, adapting to climate change, and global cooperation.
  • Economic Impact of Climate Policies. The discussion highlights the economic benefits of climate action versus the costs of inaction.
  • Wage Stagnation Issues. Exploration of wage stagnation and its impact on the economy and families.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes