Ripple Effects of Environmental Policy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I think it helps to give a little bit of a sense of my own personal background to
  2. explain where my research comes from before coming to Wharton I spent 10 years as a um Federal prosecutor in New
  3. York I was an assistant United States Attorney for the southern district of New York and in that capacity I um
  4. participated in kind of traditional law enforcement particularly with respect to
  5. environmental laws and so the traditional model of environmental law is that Congress passes a law and and
  6. the government enforces it against business firms which are the polluters right so that's kind of the traditional
  7. understanding of what environmental law is in my research what I try to do is I kind of flip that around so I ask what
  8. if the government is not the regulator but instead private firms are regulators and what if the government is not the
  9. regulator but instead is a polluter so my research kind of falls into two categories right now the first is
  10. exploring the role of the government as a polluter and the second is exploring the role of business firms as sources of
  11. environmental standards on the side of my research that focuses on the government as
  12. polluter I think one of the key takeaways is that the military does not always stand opposed to the idea of
  13. Environmental Protection there are kind of two narratives about the role that the military plays in society with
  14. respect to the environment one is that the environment and National Security stand opposed to one another and that
  15. the environment needs to bend if National Security is issue but what I suggest in my research in a paper called
  16. the military environmental complex is that right now because the military is the nation's largest consumer of fossil
  17. fuels and because many thousands of soldiers have died guarding fuel convoys in recent conflicts in Iraq and
  18. Afghanistan um the military has um this tremendous internal incentive to reduce its fossil fuel use and replace it with
  19. Renewables and so is investing heavily in that right now and so that sort of turns the traditional narrative on its
  20. head and suggest that the military actually has a very important role to play in supporting the development of
  21. clean and renewable energy technology so on the other side of my research which focuses on the idea that
  22. business firms can be a source of environmental standards um I think that fact in and of itself is surprising um
  23. when you study environmental law in a traditional law school environment the focus tends to be on the laws that
  24. congress passes um and on business firms as polluters and the targets of government regulation but what you see
  25. in this environment here in a business school um and I think that is of great interest is that business firms can
  26. themselves be sources of environmental standards so for example if Walmart imposes requirements on its supply chain
  27. that suppliers need to disclose their greenhouse gas emissions in order to have contracts with Walmart that in and
  28. of itself is an environmental standard um similarly nonprofit organizations like the Marine Stewardship Council or
  29. the forest Stewardship Council create certification programs whereby you can certify fishery or fish catching um or
  30. Forest um Timber practices as sustainable and in order to Warrant the label the certification the business
  31. needs to comply with certain rules which are then audited by Third parties those
  32. are themselves Environmental governance though maybe not in the most traditional
  33. sense and so I think it can be eye openening for people to understand that certain forms of corporate enironmental
  34. social responsibility are actually um that they have broader implications than just for the firms
  35. themselves so I think the most surprising conclusion has come in connection with some empirical work that
  36. I've been doing uh with colleagues here at Wharton to test a hypothesis that I put out in an article called valuing
  37. National Security security so in the article called the military environmental complex I suggest that the
  38. military um is playing an important role in stimulating innovation in technological advancement in the Clean
  39. Energy Arena in valuing National Security I suggest that the military um by focusing on renewable energy
  40. development and reducing its fossil fuel use actually has the potential to um affect policy debate and individual
  41. behavior in the kind of climate change Arena um the the mere fact that the Department of Defense is using solar
  42. panels has the potential to drive individuals to want to use solar panels at least that's the hypothesis so I've
  43. been working with colleagues here at Wharton to test this hypothesis empirically and just a few days ago we
  44. received some preliminary test results um we suspected that um the difference would be among conservative um survey
  45. participants people who generally don't tend to favor Environmental Protection but do tend to Value the role of the
  46. military in society what we found was um actually that people who self-identify as liberal were more likely to want to
  47. purchase renewable energy um from their utility when they learned that the Department of Defense was actively using
  48. renewable energy technology the sample size wasn't large enough for conservative so we don't know yet um
  49. what the result is on that front but we plan to follow up with additional testing
  50. there are really three practical implications of my research at this point the first is that I think we need
  51. to be thinking much more broadly Scholars and Regulators need to be thinking much more broadly about what
  52. constitutes environmental law and environmental governance it is not simply laws passed by Congress or
  53. regulations passed by EPA it includes private environmental governance that is actions by firms and non-governmental
  54. organizations to set environmental standards so I think that's really the first implication
  55. the second implication relates to the work that I'm doing on valuing National Security that is I think it's extremely
  56. important to recognize that if we want to change individual behaviors in the climate change context that we need to
  57. think broadly about how to frame climate change we shouldn't Simply Be framing climate change as an environmental issue
  58. it needs to be framed as a national security issue as well the third implication is very specific um one of
  59. the reasons why the military has been able to um leverage its purchasing power to stimulate the development of
  60. renewable energy Technologies is because Congress gave it a particular statutory
  61. Authority that statutory Authority allows it to enter into what are called Power purchase agreements whereby the
  62. military purchases power from an an energy generating entity and so the military is able to enter into Power
  63. purchase agreements for 30 years which is necessary in order to um allow the entity that that builds the generating
  64. facility on Military land to recoup its initial investment you can't do Renewables on a very short time frame
  65. because The Upfront costs tend to be high other government agencies are limited to 10-year power purchasing
  66. agreements so I make a very specific recommendation in the military environmental complex that Congress
  67. should consider lengthening the term um for other government agencies as well such that they could enter into these
  68. long-term 30-year power purchase agreements because I think that that would allow them to stimulate the
  69. development of renewable energy technology as well so obviously my research focuses on
  70. environmental governance um but the point is broader and I think it's important to recognize that the idea
  71. that private governance is not limited just to the environmental Arena private governance exists in um firms where
  72. they're setting labor standards for their suppliers in in their supply chains um there are also Private
  73. Financial standards recently two candidates for higher office entered into a contract whereby they agreed to
  74. um certain campaign Finance rules so rather than relying on Congress to set campaign Finance rules two candidates
  75. privately agreed that they would not accept certain money or not spend more than C C amounts so the the phenomenon
  76. of private governance actually extends quite broadly and I think it's important to recognize
  77. that the news is full of stories recently about the impact of climate change the intergovernmental panel on
  78. climate change has been releasing various working group reports which demonstrate that climate change is
  79. happening that climate change is anthropogenic and that the consequences of climate change may be dire for
  80. society um in addition a group of 16 retired generals um from the military recently last month I believe put out a
  81. report um saying that climate change is is posing a national security threat and
  82. that climate change acts as a threat multiplier that destabilizes um countries that has the
  83. potential to increase conflict to create climate refugees and other situations in
  84. which the US military is going to be called upon to um address these conflicts so I think
  85. the idea that climate change is a national security issue is certainly in the news what sets my research apart in part
  86. comes from where I'm situated and what my background is um most lawyers who decide to become professors go on to
  87. teach in law schools um but I chose to come to a business school obviously my my research is very um
  88. uh connected to the idea of the role that business plays in society so I think what sets my research apart in
  89. part is the fact that I'm kind of bridging these two worlds and trying to have a conversation not only with other
  90. legal Scholars but also with business and management Scholars I'm following up on this
  91. research in a number of different ways with respect to valuing National Security I am currently working with
  92. colleagues here at Wharton to empirically test the hypothesis so we are going to be following up with
  93. additional studies in which we frame climate change as a national security issue or demonstrate military leadership
  94. with respect to renewable energy use to see what impact that has on individual um behaviors and beliefs and attitudes
  95. toward climate policy and reducing fossil fuel use um I'm also working with um some colleagues here at Wharton on an
  96. empirical study to understand how business firms talk about climate change in their Securities and Exchange
  97. Commission disclosures do they talk about it as an issue of strategic Advantage do they talk about it as an
  98. issue of Environmental Protection and morality do they talk about it as an issue of National Security um and in
  99. particular for major military contractors how do they talk about climate change and to the extent that
  100. the ways in which they've talked about climate change um over time uh have changed what can account for the change
  101. so those are some empirical projects that I'm work working on with colleagues here at Wharton I'm also continuing to
  102. do my own uh work on uh more kind of normative theories of private environmental governance to try to argue
  103. about how it fits into larger views of what constitutes environmental [Music] law
  104. [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode discusses the military's role in renewable energy and how businesses can set environmental standards, challenging traditional views on environmental law.

Key points

  • The Military Environmental Complex. Research suggests the military could drive renewable energy innovation.
  • Business as Environmental Regulators. Exploring how companies like Walmart set environmental standards.
  • Climate Change as a National Security Issue. Recent reports indicate climate change is a growing national security threat.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes