Are Europe’s Conservation Policies Actually Working?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Arthur van Benthem, Wharton Professor of Business, Economics and Public Policy, breaks down a key question: Are Europe’s conservation policies actually working? While the European Union is on track to meet ambitious land protection targets, new research suggests these policies may not be delivering meaningful improvements in biodiversity or ecosystem restoration. In this episode, we explore what’s driving that gap and what it means for environmental policy going forward.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The European Union has protected lands of more than 26% as of 2023. They are doing this so that they can have a variety of different elements impacted,
  2. like restoring vegetation cover and also improving biodiversity. But how do those policies work?
  3. Are they as effective as they can be? Pleasure to be joined by Arthur Van Benthem, who is a Professor at the Wharton
  4. School of Business Ethics and Public Policy. He and a group of his colleagues have been working on
  5. focusing on these policies and he joins us right now. Arthur, great to catch up with you. How are you, sir?
  6. I'm doing fine. Thank you for having me. Thank you. So I guess let's start with the research itself and why it's
  7. important to truly understand the impact of these policies. Yeah, I think nature is in a pretty dire state in many continents.
  8. So there is this push globally to protect 30% of the Earth's lands and waters in an
  9. effort to fight back against biodiversity degradation. So from that perspective, it's truly important
  10. to see our countries reaching those targets. And if they're reaching them, are they actually effective at restoring nature?
  11. How do you gauge then the effectiveness of these policies? How does that occur? Well, we focus specifically on the European Union, which is the continent
  12. that is closest to reaching that 30% target by 2030. They're actually getting there, 27 percent at the moment.
  13. And the way to do this is using satellite data. So Europe is adding more and more protected areas in the various countries every year.
  14. And what we track as researchers is the greenest of those lands. Of course, you don't expect a lush forest the year after you protect a piece of
  15. grassland, but slowly over time, you expect to see forest regrowth and maybe people moving out in the areas that are protected.
  16. So we use a lot of satellite data, nightlights, greenness, those kinds of measures.
  17. And I noticed that in the paper you talk about, there are some areas that seemingly
  18. have done a very good job in terms of recovery, and other areas that have not. How then are you able to better understand what's going on in these different areas
  19. and maybe what has gone right and what has not? Yeah, that's, of course, the key question in our research, right?
  20. So actually the reason we started studying Europe is we read a couple of years ago,
  21. me and my co-authors, that Europe is a fair bit greener today than it was a century ago.
  22. So it's sort of across the continent. There's more forests, for example. We've also seen that more land has become protected.
  23. But what we tend to see in a lot of areas in Europe is, you know, the comparison we
  24. need to make is, is it really the protection that led to that increase in vegetation cover?
  25. Or is that something that would have happened anyway, perhaps as urbanization happens and agricultural imports are increasing and less is grown in Europe itself?
  26. There could be other explanations. What we find is that there's a lot of areas in Europe that are getting greener.
  27. It just doesn't seem to be the protection that triggers it. So that suggests that a lot of protection is happening in areas that were already on
  28. a path of greening. So then what is happening that is leading to this higher level of protection if it's
  29. not the policy that's kind of having the impact? Yeah, so that's a question that there's lots of speculation and thoughts about.
  30. I haven't seen the definitive answer to that. I will add, this is for parts of Europe.
  31. So about half of it is seeing these improvements. Nature is also under tremendous pressure in other parts of Europe.
  32. But the question why in the Baltics and, for example, in northern Europe and southeast Europe, that that greening trend is happening in general,
  33. people have attributed to various things, including sort of a change in the economy
  34. over the last several decades away from agriculture and industry towards services.
  35. People have thought about climate change even as explanations, but I don't think
  36. the answer to that has been proven in any definitive way. And if I read it correctly, I believe you mentioned in the paper that you also have
  37. to take into effect what the, for lack of a better term, the federal government in
  38. each of these countries is doing from a policy perspective to in some cases what
  39. local governments are doing on this topic as well. Yes, I need to explain to you a little bit about— so, what does protection mean?
  40. So protection can mean lots of different things. Like you may think about the Grand Canyon, which is very strictly protected,
  41. and there's some of that in Europe. But there's lots of different categories. Anything from a big national park to a local county park is in my data set. Okay.
  42. Now, the EU federally dictates to the member states that they should reach that 30% slowly over time.
  43. Then think of, say, a country like France is going to outsource a lot of that to its
  44. local government, and they are the ones that then have to have the stakeholder meetings to get people together about, can they protect some new area?
  45. And what tends to happen in a lot of European countries is that's a fairly consultative process, right?
  46. You need the local communities, the farmers, the scientists, the water management bodies, everyone to agree.
  47. And the more people that need to agree on something, in practice, the weaker, of course, the consensus or the agreement becomes.
  48. So we tend to see a lot of protection on paper, but then those tend to be fairly
  49. minimally protected areas, say agricultural areas where there's some restriction on economic activity.
  50. But this is far from a pristine nature that's regrowing or protected. So you bring up something I wanted to ask you anyway, is that, how then do these
  51. countries go about kind of marking off what are going to be those protected lands
  52. in comparison to areas that they may want to develop for business, for the economy of their country as well?
  53. Yeah, you're getting at the reason why this is a complicated statistical problem, right?
  54. There's a lot of selection. It's not random which areas are protected. So countries would prefer, if they can, to protect areas where the economic cost
  55. of reaching that 30% target is relatively minor. So what can you do? Well, you can do two things.
  56. Either you look at far away, remote areas that are, say, forested or natural, and you say— you put a stamp on it, right?
  57. And say, like, "Oh, this is now strictly protected." There's a lot of that has been happening in Northern Europe, for example,
  58. in Scandinavia, which is, you know, useful on paper, but not particularly changing the course of nature in those countries.
  59. Or you say, I'm protecting lots of land near cities, but then I am going to assign
  60. it a fairly weak protection status that doesn't interfere too much with my other development plans.
  61. And I think, in a nutshell, that is really sort of the reason why we across four
  62. decades, across all European countries, do not detect a very impactful policy. Can you start then to better understand, having done this research, the level of
  63. quality of work being done by the European Union in terms of protecting these lands?
  64. Well, let me put out first that we point out that this particular policy that the
  65. European Union has been pushing, which is really laser focused on achieving that quantity target, that 30%, that that might have been a bit counterproductive.
  66. I guess the EU has been focused too much, and we need to reach the 30% without asking perhaps the question, is that 30% having a large effect?
  67. Is it changing what would have happened otherwise? That said, I think the EU has been very, very thoughtful in its environmental
  68. policy in general, including its policies to protect nature. There's a different policy called the Nature Restoration Law, which isn't
  69. focused as much on protecting new lands, but to improve the quality, the deteriorating quality of the existing protected areas.
  70. And that might be much more impactful. And that's, in fact, another angle I'd want to go into in future research.
  71. So I applaud the EU for being thoughtful in general, but we're hoping to point out
  72. that just a percentage alone is not enough to have real impact. Right, exactly. And then the other question, from my knowledge, is when we're talking about a
  73. 30% piece of territory within, are we talking within each country, or are we talking about the European Union as a whole?
  74. Like, you know, the levels may vary from country to country, but it's 30% on scope.
  75. Yeah, the EU passes down to 30% to each individual country. It is, of course, much easier to meet that for a country like Sweden that has lots of
  76. areas with low population density and lots of forest, than for my home country, the Netherlands.
  77. So when you look at the map, it's kind of interesting. You see these large connected contiguous areas in some countries.
  78. And then in a densely populated country like mine, you will see a patchwork of tiny areas because they're really scrambling to find the 30%.
  79. What then does this research, and does it, kind of open the door to understand how
  80. the United States is looking at having protected lands? Right. So our paper at Europe has studied a policy that— it's
  81. the flagship policy for protection, or one of those two. And then we're showing, unfortunately, that it hasn't worked too well.
  82. So that has somewhat of a limitation that it hasn't proven that a policy that we
  83. could import here into the United States. I do think that what's happening here in the US is very different.
  84. The current federal administration is actively taking away nature protections. Think about the waters of the US, the Endangered Species Act.
  85. And I think in general, we see both in the US and in Europe, a pretty alarming speed
  86. of deterioration of our natural ecosystems. And I think that this approach to trade a quick economic gain here in the US by
  87. weakening those standards is unbelievably short-sighted. And I really hope that everyone can agree, whether you're Republican, Democrat,
  88. or Independent, that we all benefit from the beauty and the economic value of our natural land.
  89. So I think it's more— in the US, it's about, you know, let's at least stop weakening those standards.
  90. And I hope we can get to a point where we can discuss about how do we tighten them in a more effective way?
  91. Arthur, great to catch up with you again. All the best on this research and the follow-up research to come. Thank you.
  92. Thank you so much for having me. Thank you. Arthur van Bentham, who's a Professor of Business
  93. Economics and Public Policy here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Arthur Van Benthem discusses the EU's land protection policies and their effectiveness in restoring nature.

Key points

  • EU's Land Protection Efforts. The European Union aims to protect 30% of its lands by 2030, but is it effective?
  • The Importance of Effective Policies. Arthur Van Benthem highlights the need to evaluate the effectiveness of land protection policies.
  • Nature Restoration Law. The EU's Nature Restoration Law focuses on improving existing protected areas rather than just quantity.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes