Neighborhood Social Capital
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
According to a recent research paper and a new book by Wharton marketing professor David R. Bell, “location, location, location” is as relevant in the world of e-commerce as it is in the physical world. Read more: http://knlg.net/1l8ka1E 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- This research is called neighborhood social capital and social learning for experience attributes of products so
- right there in the title are some of the key ingredients that we want to think about the first is neighborhood Social
- Capital meaning the extent to which people trust and know each other and interact with each other offline uh
- social learning means that information is transferred from an existing customer to a potential customer and then
- experience attributes of products are products for which it's very hard to know what they're going to be like until
- you try the product on we're thinking about fashion apparel eyewear those kinds of things where you'd really like
- to have a visceral experience so what this research is really about is about how to figure out where those customers
- live who are most likely to talk about the product and therefore generate new sales particularly for products where
- some explanation is required so there are two really important takeaways here for anyone
- who's in the online World selling things through the internet the first is that it's very very critical to understand
- what the offline environment looks like why is it that you have some customers in one location and no customers in
- another what is it about the physical world that's affecting what's going on in the virtual world that's the first
- thing the second thing that this research really emphasizes is that existing customers are often the most
- powerful source of new customers for a firm the extent to which they Advocate to which the product they're using is
- socially visible and the extent to which they talk about it with friends and family and local others that they come
- into contact with so with any piece of research it's always nice to find something that's a
- little bit surprising or counterintuitive and there were really three things here the first thing was
- that this social and learning effect was really quite large up to half of the new
- customers that came into the firm that we studied bonobos.com got there because information was shared from One customer
- to another in an offline environment that was the first thing the second thing was that this effect became more
- important over time so people who were the first customers into the firm maybe they're going off their own information
- or their own feel or they're fairly risk um seeking people people who come later
- on tend to require a little bit more handholding from others and then the third thing that was very very
- interesting is that this notion of social capital or the extent to which people trust and interact with each
- other in a local neighborhood doesn't generate sales per se what it does is it makes information transfer more
- efficient so bad information is being spread this company's no good it's going to slow down sales in this case
- fortunately for bonobos what was being transmitted was positive and therefore sales sped
- up so the first thing that's really important for an e-commerce business to understand is that the offline
- environment is going to explain a lot about the success of online sales so the firm really needs to think about what
- kind of locations are going to be most fruitful and why and then go into those locations and try and seed customers
- secondly if the firm wants to make the product socially visible some products are naturally socially visible if I'm
- wearing glasses or I'm wearing a pair of pants people might ask me about them or
- I might be able to generate a conversation if a product's not socially visible then maybe there's a way to make
- it socially visible by having it shipped to the home sorry the office rather than
- the home for example so let's give a practical example that really ties all of this together so the firm that we
- looked at bonobos.com is a men's fashion retailer and what we found was and where
- customers were more apt to talk to each other and trust each other there was a greater sales diffusion online so the
- Target customer in this case is a male aged 25 to 45 who's somewhat fashion Ford and it just so turns out that a
- good proxy uh for where those males are congregating is the number of bars and liquor stores per capita in a location
- so we had some sociological theory that told us about interaction and then we were able to go to public data and find
- a variable that was actually a pretty good proxy so it's tying those things together thinking about the theory and
- then trying to find a proxy with real data so one strategy that an e-commerce firm can pursue which is really just an
- outcrop of what they're already doing is to append the ZIP code data that they collect naturally through the sales
- process with other data about what's going on in that zip code this can be coming from the US Census or for other
- third-party suppliers so for example if I'm bonobos I'd like to know how many fashion apparel stores that were in a
- location I'd like to know what the population density was what the age distribution was the presence or absence
- of a college campus those things will tell me quite a lot about why I might have high sales in one location and low
- sales in another so it's really just app pending to what is already being done that's the first thing that an
- e-commerce company should be thinking about this is really a very very general conclusion that even though there are a
- number of companies out there now selling things on online through the virtual world if you will um all of
- those companies are selling to customers who still live in the real world so understanding the real world
- circumstance of your customer what other offline options they have who they live
- next to how they interact with a local environment is a really critical ingredient perhaps the most critical
- ingredient for understanding whether or not they're going to shop online or offline how they're going to search and
- also with whom they're going to interact and spread the good news about your product
- so one thing that's getting a lot of press in the news right now in fact a great buzzword and being in marketing we
- love buzzwords uh is this notion of omni Channel online offline being integrated
- seamlessly and I think what we've seen um is there are firms who came out very strongly early on perhaps even bonobos
- who was the subject in this study in 2007 uh when they first started saying why would anyone ever bother to operate
- offline when you can sell through this wondrous thing called the internet but I think what everybody is realizing now
- whether you Rent the Runway or Birchbox or even Amazon in addition to WBY Parker
- bonobos and many others is that you really need to operate both online and offline there are certain things that an
- online environment does for you makes fulfillment easy and makes it easy to scale but there are other critical
- things that offline does for you as well it makes it much easier to relay information to other people it also
- makes it much easier to build credibility about your brand if you really have a physical world presence so
- I think we're seeing more and more of this discussion now of what it means to be omn Channel not just present in one
- world but present in both so this study really dispels a couple of misconceptions uh the first
- misconception that I've talked about already a little bit is the fact that the online world is somehow disconnected
- from the offline so the first misconception is really that the offline world uh is explaining a lot of what's
- going on in the online world and also the offline world's actually pretty easy to understand there's been a whole
- history of very very rich data being being collected about who's living where what are they doing what's the level of
- commercial activity and so on so that's really the first thing that it dispels the second thing and we we hear this for
- years and years in Commerce is that location is very very important but we tend to think about the location of the
- firm where do we put the store where do we operate the factory which country should we be in but here what we're
- finding is it's still about location but this time it's about the location of the
- customer where is that customer and to whom does that customer also live that's what's really important in the world of
- e-commerce so I think one really novel aspect of This research is it's really combining ideas from two different
- fields and data in fact from two different fields so in this case we're talking about some ideas that come from
- sociology why it is that people trust each other and interact with each other and also some ideas from marketing about
- how information gets communicated and how people relay ideas from one person to the next uh in addition it's also
- combining data from two disparate sources that are not often used uh the first source of data is the Social
- Capital Community Benchmark survey I know that's a mouthful uh that's coming from the Kenedy School uh collected by
- Robert putam who was involved in writing the book bowling alone about the collapse and Revival of social capital
- in America and then secondly data coming from the firm itself bonobos.com founded
- by Andy dun so what we were able to do was sort of merge theories from sociology and marketing and also merge
- data uh collected for another purpose with real data coming from a prominent e-commerce
- firm so this is a very very rich area this whole online offline Omni Channel interaction so the next thing I'd like
- to look at is how customers who are exposed to the firm in one world let's say the offline world might continue to
- interact with the firm through the online world so A lot's being written right now about popup stores WBY Parker
- has a bus uh running around the us and so on and so uh I want to actually give a shout out to Lawrence laham one of our
- alums who runs first Mark capital in New York came and spoke in my class and he gave a very very interesting analogy he
- said that for example when I interact with somebody let's call him Joe and it's over email it's a very low um
- energy interaction we don't know each other and then Joe and I get on the phone and Joe hears my accent I hear his
- Long Island accent our energy level goes up and then we go out and we have a couple of beers and we have dinner we
- really get to know each other so then the next time an email comes out the energy level has now been elevated to
- here and so it is in some sense with online and offline so we're going to look at the customers that were acquired
- by WBY Parker for eyewear bonobos for fashion clothing if the first experience was offline and it was a good experience
- are we able then to subsequently serve these customers online and there's great operational advantages from doing so
- because it's much much cheaper to fulfill that customer out of a warehouse than to always having them come into a
- retail store so that's really where I want to go next again uh research being inspired by some of our Alum and and
- colleagues from the warten school [Music]
Brief Summary
Neighborhood social capital boosts e-commerce sales through offline interactions and customer advocacy, especially for fashion products.
Key points
- The Importance of Neighborhood Trust. Neighborhood social capital significantly influences online sales through trust and interaction.
- Social Learning's Impact on Sales. Existing customers drive new sales through offline information sharing.
- Omni-Channel Marketing Insights. Successful e-commerce requires understanding both online and offline customer interactions.
- Combining Data for Better Insights. Merging sociology and marketing data reveals critical customer behavior patterns.
Episode highlights
- Social Learning's Impact on SalesExisting customers drive new sales through offline information sharing.“Up to half of new customers came from offline information sharing.”1:47Jul 31, 2014
- Omni-Channel Marketing InsightsSuccessful e-commerce requires understanding both online and offline customer interactions.“The offline environment explains a lot about online sales success.”2:49Jul 31, 2014
- Combining Data for Better InsightsMerging sociology and marketing data reveals critical customer behavior patterns.“This research combines ideas from sociology and marketing.”7:39Jul 31, 2014
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





