Why Your Best Customers Can Be Your Best Marketers

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE The people who already love a brand can be more effective than a traditional influencer campaign.

Lindsey Carter, Founder and CEO of SET Active, explains how the activewear brand identifies passionate customers and turns them into authentic advocates through its SET Insider program. She shares why social media should be a place for connection, how product drops can create a sense of belonging, and what marketers can learn from building a community customers want to be part of.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Marketing Matters is hosted by Wharton marketing professors Barbara Kahn and Americus Reed. Each week they discuss marketing and advertising trends, consumer behavior, data and analytics, the latest in retail marketing, brand-building, and much more with their expert guests. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Yesterday, we were in a line meeting and I said to my team, I was like, you know, I'm not excited about this graphic.
  2. And we've sat in meetings and it's been approved and it's been finalized. And I was staring and I was like,
  3. we got to change it. Something doesn't feel right. And I think that is something that you
  4. also have to naturally trust. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Manners on the Wharton
  5. Podcast Network. This is our weekly podcast where we analyze the latest in advertising, marketing, consumer behavior, new
  6. product launches, retailing, branding, everything marketing. I'm Barbara Kahn, the Patty and J.H.
  7. Baker Professor of Marketing. And I'm joined by my co-host, Americus Reid, the Whitney M.
  8. Young, Jr. Professor of Marketing and the identity theorist and the winner of a big award
  9. or his big award. He's been honored at our at our annual marketing and consumer behavior research for like the
  10. best dissertation advisor, basically. Yeah. Yeah. Very exciting. So great week. I start to a great week and I'm
  11. pretty excited. Really, really exciting. Congratulations. Thank you. Appreciate it, Barbara.
  12. And joining us and joining us today is Lindsay Carter, who's the founder and CEO of
  13. Set Active, which is an active wear and lifestyle apparel brand. And you launched it in 2018 and it's
  14. grown pretty fast and in a very competitive industry. So it's quite interesting to hear what your
  15. strategy is. And we're interested in how you view social media and influence marketing to really build a
  16. brand in this competitive active wear kind of industry. So welcome, Lindsay. Thank you so much.
  17. Thanks for having me. I'm very happy to be here. So let's start with that idea that this
  18. is a really crowded category and a lot of the really big brands like Lululemon and
  19. even Nike are faltering. You know, I mean, it's not an easy industry to win in. So what compelled you to go into this
  20. industry and what gap did you think that you were going to be fulfilling? You know, at the time when I started
  21. Set, no one was really making active wear for or athleisure for the everyday girl, like
  22. whether without the pressure of if you were going to a workout. I personally felt like I didn't fit into
  23. any of the buckets that was being marketed to me. I didn't really feel a desire to need
  24. technical active wear. I wasn't someone who was hiking all the time or doing recreational things.
  25. I also wasn't someone who was doing weightlifting or working out in a gym or needing
  26. performance wear. And, you know, eight and a half years ago, no one was really making just like
  27. simple everyday active wear. And that's sort of like when the idea popped into my head.
  28. At the time, I specifically remember it was before the Aloe store opened in Beverly Hills
  29. on Canon. And I remember being like, oh, like an active wear store. Like, I'm so excited.
  30. Maybe this will be like the one for me. And then it was all their marketing collateral
  31. was yoga poses and headstands. And I was like, oh, I actually don't relate to this.
  32. And it wasn't something that was really aligning with me. And I at the time, I had a
  33. background in marketing and social media. And I was like, what would it look like if if I did it?
  34. And that's like kind of the day that I went into just like understanding that getting
  35. dressed should require less decision making, not more. And if I made it easy for women,
  36. then it would take one less decision out of their day. And that's why I decided to call it
  37. Set Active and, you know, make it really easy to understand from the name. And it's matching sets.
  38. And you can just kind of grab your set and go. That's interesting. So that was part of it.
  39. You don't have to have two decisions. That's interesting. Question for you, Lindsay, just real quick.
  40. Barbara and I talk about this all the time. And it's been sort of characterized as the
  41. entrepreneur's paradox. And it's the idea that I feel like I have a problem. And now the next step is to make
  42. sure I'm not the only one with that problem. So talk to us about what you what were the signals in the marketplace?
  43. What was the data, data, you know, lowercase d, big case d that you looked at that says, hey, you know what?
  44. This is a pretty ubiquitous problem here. And I need to build this because I'm not the only one who's experiencing this this
  45. problem to solve. Well, I have a background in trend forecasting, and I would sit at coffee shops when
  46. I had my other business in marketing and social media, and I would just watch. Like I would sit there for hours.
  47. I didn't have kids at this point. I was in the middle of building my other social media agency.
  48. And I would just sit and I would watch and I would observe and I would see what women are wearing when they walk
  49. into the coffee shop. I figured that coffee was a neutral place to, you know, have people come and go
  50. that were probably on their way to doing something, arriving, leaving. And I was watching what they were wearing.
  51. And that was like my personal data. To be perfectly honest and transparent, I'm not
  52. a data person. I never. Big d or little d. Well, observations is data. I mean, your point's a good point, Lizzie.
  53. Yeah, absolutely. It's done a lot in retail. Yes, yes. But like I've always been, you know, if
  54. I'm if I'm being really transparent here, I was a you know, C's get degrees type
  55. of girl in school. I was never a super academic. I never really understood. I never fit the mold of the education
  56. system. And I always thought something was wrong with me. And it wasn't until I was able to
  57. start set that I realized all of my superpowers. And obviously have now built a close to
  58. 100 million dollar brand with no investors. So congratulations. And one of the things I did a
  59. little that kind of little d data myself and talk to a bunch of people about this brand just to try to get word
  60. of mouth on it. And they do talk about the brilliant social media and influencer strategy.
  61. So it's interesting to hear that that is actually your background and you were building on
  62. that expertise. Maybe that's in some ways, ironically, what really differentiates your approach, because I don't know if
  63. the other big brands were doing so much of that. So what intuitions? I think it's interesting you say your other
  64. business, whatever that, you know, that other business. How did you take those skills and put
  65. it into this business and get that insight? Because I think that does explain some of
  66. your explosive growth. Is that true or do you agree with what I'm saying? Yeah, I mean, I think I think when
  67. people want to try to understand like their passion or how to turn their passion into
  68. their career, you kind of have to like take a step back. And the word social media sounds fun.
  69. Oh, I get to play on my phone all day or I get to just scroll on Instagram and TikTok.
  70. But really, there's so much more to social media. And for me, what social media meant to
  71. me that I don't think I realized back then, but looking back, I realize now was just the art of connection.
  72. And that's really where I think my passion lies. I remember when I used to nanny before
  73. while I was in college and I was taking a little girl to dance class and I was waiting for her dance class to
  74. be over. And I'm sitting in the lobby and there is a new mom there and she's like,
  75. I'm not from here. Like, where should I go eat? What should I do? And I just remember talking to her.
  76. And it was like an hour went by and I like had this whole list and I was like telling her what to do,
  77. where to eat, where to shop, all of these things. And I was like, wow, I feel like
  78. invigorated by that. Like that was so fun. What a great conversation. And I was like, I think there's an
  79. art of connection that just fills my cup. And I kind of, you know, put that to the side, put that to the back
  80. burner. And when I was, my first job out of college was at NBC Universal. I was a department production assistant.
  81. And I remember Instagram was, you know, just becoming a thing outside of Facebook.
  82. And I was learning about these two sisters, they're the Carlson sisters. They started Wallflower Cases and I'm like, wow,
  83. like there's got to be like, I'm sure people want to know their story. Like they're blowing up.
  84. They have this phone case business. But do people actually know who the girls are?
  85. And I ended up pitching a show called Growing Up Wildflower to the head of production.
  86. And we did a sizzle reel on it. And I was like, wait, there's something here about telling stories.
  87. And I realized that that still fit under the umbrella of the art of connection. And so really what I, when I think
  88. of social media, that's the underlying passion that I have, which is how I was able
  89. to start Set, which I know is a very long winded answer, but I feel like that background is necessary.
  90. No, no, it makes sense. Yeah. That makes total sense. It's interesting. Lindsay, could you comment a little bit on
  91. the challenge of organic, you know, building a brand in social and also the fact that
  92. it seems, and I could be wrong here, but it seems that long form story narrative
  93. storytelling is not that easy to do when people are swiping so quickly and they're not
  94. spending a ton of time on each piece of content. So could you speak to that? Because this is something that Nike faced pretty,
  95. pretty, you know, as a big challenge is like when they went D to C, it's like literally now they're two dimensions and the
  96. brand is just not experienced the same way, you know, when it's sort of a quick little micro consumption moment.
  97. So talk a little bit about how do you, how do you maintain the integrity and the discipline of the storytelling part, but also
  98. living in this very fast constrained social media world? I honestly think it comes down to just
  99. knowing your audience on a, like at a true level. I think that, you know, Set has been
  100. around for eight and a half years. I've seen the highs and I've seen the lows and when you're at the low, you're
  101. able to kind of, excuse my language, but as shitty as it is, identify what the problems are.
  102. And I think when Set was at our low, we were able to identify that we just lost touch with the customer.
  103. Like we don't know what they want. Like we started operating on trying to, you know, be different and color outside the lines
  104. and it's okay to do that, but you still have to do that with, but riding the same track as your customer.
  105. And so you have to make sure that you really understand who they are, where are they shopping?
  106. What are they talking about? You have to kind of break down your marketing into like, who's your get girl?
  107. Who's the customer that you want to acquire? What are they talking about? What are they doing?
  108. And how do you check that box? Who is your current girl? What's that discourse that they're discussing on their
  109. social media or what the trends are without it being a fast trend? So there's fast trend, long trend, and you
  110. just have to kind of also trust your gut in a way. Like we'll sit in a line meeting and
  111. a line plan meeting and I'll look at it and I'll stare at it and my team will literally be like, what are you
  112. doing? And I'm like, I'm seeing where my gut starts to raise a flag and they'll be
  113. like, what does that mean? And I'm like, well, it feels like when I look at something, does it excite me
  114. or does it not excite me? And why doesn't it excite me? And then you kind of like go through
  115. this task of like asking yourself all these different questions and it kind of makes the
  116. decision clear. And then yesterday we were in a line meeting and I said to my team, I
  117. was like, you know, I'm not excited about this graphic. And we've seen this graphic so many times
  118. and we've sat in meetings and it's been approved and it's been finalized. And I was staring and I was like,
  119. we got to change it. Something doesn't feel right. And I think gut is something that you
  120. also have to naturally trust. We try to view our social channels as if Seth was a person rather than a
  121. brand. And if Seth was a person, how would we talk to her friends? What kind of content would we share with
  122. our friends after we got back from vacation in the group chat? And it's less of a marketing channel and
  123. more of a connection point with our customers. Interesting. So if we get into like specifics about
  124. like, I am really interested in how you're differentiating your brand. Like I said, in this category, like you
  125. mentioned Aloe and some of these others, you know, seemingly they're similar products, but there is
  126. a different brand voice to what you're doing. And I am curious, like what you do
  127. in your line. If you had to, you said already Seth, the coordinated pieces is one piece.
  128. What maybe you do with color and material compression? Like if you have some kind of differentiation
  129. on that, that makes the product different. And then what your social voices, your story
  130. is. Like if you use influencers or celebrities or something like that, like really getting in the
  131. specifics. Because I think in the end, that is what's been differentiating your brand.
  132. Some of those decisions, what your gut is telling us about those types of decisions.
  133. Yeah, totally. I mean, loaded question that has a lot of different answers. I think something that we implemented this year
  134. that definitely has pioneered the industry is our Set Insider program. That's where we treat our, you know, our
  135. customers that are naturally talking about the brand as sort of set detectives or set insiders.
  136. And what we'll do is, and I'm now spilling the beans on here, is we will identify a group of people who are already
  137. naturally fans of the brand, loyal, already talking about it on social media, who love to
  138. kind of be the detective, whether they're finding Easter eggs and day in the life videos.
  139. And we'll take them and we'll say, hey, we're going to, throughout the rollout, drop a
  140. lot of behind the scenes pictures to you. We just want you to talk about it. We have no guidelines or anything that you
  141. have to follow. Talk about it in whatever way it feels right to you. We will send you PR from that drop
  142. as long as you are posting the content and talking about our brand. And it's now taken off.
  143. We call it our Set Insider program, but brands left and right are starting to adopt
  144. this. And I think the uniform, which is our drop that drops tomorrow, it's the first drop
  145. where I think we sent solely to customers first and no influencers. But these customers have almost become their own
  146. influencer. We have one customer, her name is Jessie. She's now hit 10,000 followers on TikTok,
  147. and it's just from talking about the brand she loves and the Easter eggs she finds.
  148. And so it's kind of become another funnel of marketing for brands. So that's sort of one way.
  149. I think also something that differentiates us is our world building. We create these worlds that you get to
  150. step inside and feel like you're a part of for a brief amount of time. And I think that with Set, you know,
  151. we're not just trying to make another legging and convince you that it's the best legging
  152. on the market and you're going to run a faster mile because you have set leggings
  153. on. That's not what we're trying to do. We're selling product, yes, but we're also selling
  154. a feeling. When we did our state fair in Austin, it wasn't just like a collection of colors.
  155. It had this Americana universe around it. And we got to activate in real life and bring customers into that world, not just
  156. digitally, but physically as well. Yeah, Lindsay, let's talk a little. This is really interesting.
  157. And Barbara, I want to at some point unpack the world building because that that word
  158. had there's a lot there. But before you do that, talk a little bit about this notion of and I love
  159. this idea of the advocates. The advocates are not the same as influencers, necessarily.
  160. Advocates love you and they want to tell your story. You just have to open up the channel
  161. so that they can do that. However, talk a little bit about your point of view, Lindsay, about allowing people to and
  162. obviously this is a selection issue. You pick really good people. It's less of a risk.
  163. But there is a risk when you're out there and advocates are like brand co stewards
  164. with you because they can do lots of things in social media that may not comport
  165. with the brand. You know what I mean? So it's like when you open up the aperture to say we're going to invite advocates
  166. in to also do a lot of our marketing, one person marketing department for free kind
  167. of a thing. It's not without risk. So how do you how do you think about risk in that sense of like someone
  168. goes off and they do something with your brand or they post something and then, you
  169. know, that could be potentially a problem? I mean, look, at the end of the day, like if they're not if there's people
  170. talking about my brand, not an insider program, there's nothing I can do about that.
  171. I've never really thought about our insider program in relation to risk. And maybe that's just me, you know, being
  172. ignoring that side of it. But, you know, our set insiders there. Maybe there's no risk.
  173. Maybe there's no risk. Yeah, they they they're our friends. They're our champions.
  174. They're champions of the brand. And we have guidelines, you know, when you're when if you want free product from us
  175. that they would probably pay for outside of the set insider program, there's guidelines you have
  176. to adhere to. And we make those guidelines very clear. Like, hey, we're happy to show they also
  177. feel they feel selected. They feel special. We're showing them stuff that's stepping up.
  178. You're giving them an identity. Yeah. That's very cool. Yeah. How many set insiders are there at, let's
  179. say, steady state equilibrium? How many typically are in the in the wild at any given time?
  180. Right now, we have we have about 20 insiders with a goal to, you know, reach 50 by end of year.
  181. But these insiders videos like they go they go pretty viral because they they've trained their
  182. audience to know that they're that stop for the latest and greatest of whatever brand that
  183. they're talking about. And we don't it's really about. Quality, not quantity, we want to make sure
  184. that we're vetting the right person, that they're actual champions of the brand.
  185. And that we trust them to speak about the brand in a positive way. And it's not about accelerating that program, but
  186. really finding the champions of the brand to help talk about. What we're doing, what's exciting, what's coming and
  187. any feedback that people might have. So one of the things in your with your strategy and creating a community and creating
  188. a point of view to be really effective, I think part of it is who you're going after, what your market is, you know,
  189. girls like you or whatever you were talking about when you first had the vision.
  190. But it also is who you're not going after. So do you have a sense of this is us and this is not us?
  191. It's a great question. And have you identified what's not you, where you stay away, you know, some avenues you
  192. may not want to go to? Yeah, I think, you know, it's it's clear that our hero product is active, like tenfold.
  193. When we have drops and we have other categories, people want active from us. I think that we've tried, you know, coloring
  194. outside the lines and trying different categories. In 2023, we even tried tapping into denim
  195. and it just, oh, wow, that seems so different. It was. But that's what I meant. Like I thought that when I was, you
  196. know, you learn so much as you build. And I think that you're never like not learning.
  197. And the biggest takeaway I had from 2023 is like I thought because I was listening
  198. to podcasts and reading these entrepreneur books, like throw spaghetti at the wall and see what
  199. sticks. And 2023 was our version of throwing a lot of different types of spaghetti at the
  200. wall and seeing what stuck and what didn't. And, you know, I think when it came down to it, after just identifying all the
  201. things that went wrong that year was that our customer is someone who honestly just wants
  202. to feel put together without overthinking it. You know, she lives a very real life
  203. work, errands, coffee, travel, dinners, or she's just at home and she wants clothes that can
  204. move with her. And I feel like our customer cares about style and cultural relevance.
  205. I think that you have to find ways to keep up with what the social narratives are online with still staying true to who
  206. your brand is. And I think that also like our customer wants newness. And because we have such like this is
  207. where my big D comes into play. We have a very high customer return rate and they're probably going to want new with
  208. every drop since so much of them are coming back to shop with us. And so understanding that data with a capital
  209. D, you know, that tells us that she wants the newness. And it's why the drop model works for
  210. us. She's not coming to set because she wants another legging. She wants to see what we're doing next.
  211. Yeah. And so you're going after a young, what is your demographic? I mean, first of all, you're 100 percent
  212. women, right? Is that right? Yes. You haven't got. OK. And then what what's your age?
  213. I'm curious because like that was one of the things I remember when we talked about
  214. Lulu. It was one of the few activewear brands where mother and daughter wore it.
  215. Typically, not your father's Oldsmobile is the thing like you don't want to wear what your
  216. mom's wearing to the gym. And I would think that you have a pretty sharp demographic here.
  217. And I have two questions about that. One, is that true? And if so, what is it? And two, that demographic is going to age
  218. at some point. And do you have an idea like is your demographic the current age of that segment
  219. or are you going to stay with that segment as they age? Do you see what I'm asking?
  220. Yes. I mean, right now it's half millennial, half Gen Z. It's around 18 to 36 ish.
  221. But I think it's it's interesting because like I have I'm 30, I'm 35. So I'm at the like older end of
  222. our demographic, but I'm so tapped into what our customers are talking about that I sometimes
  223. feel like I'm living a double life between my mom friends and my online presence because
  224. I have to be so tapped in with what people are talking about. And I think it's just understanding the online
  225. social conversation. I think that we want to grow with our customer, but we also want to keep
  226. earning the next generation. And right now, what does that look like? That's a freaking line to navigate.
  227. You know, like you get up, you get 45, you know, they're going to get older, those customers.
  228. And you do tend to see an old, young kind of clash. And you're going to I mean, a lot
  229. of the brands that went after a particular female segment like Talbot or even Ann Taylor,
  230. as they stayed loyal to their aging consumer. But it was hard to bring in young people.
  231. And it's kind of a it's a especially in as a trendy a category as you're in and you're telling us you're chasing after
  232. new styles and new trends. You do kind of have that. Do you see what I'm saying?
  233. That clash in and even your demographic band is pretty high. It's pretty big, you know, from Gen Z
  234. to there's famous stories about how the millennials like a side part and the Gen Z
  235. or a Gen Alpha like a center part or whatever. You know what I'm talking about? So there's things where they where they push
  236. again. And in a business that's as trendy as you yours is, how do you grapple with
  237. all of that? I think you have to understand, one, the demographic and what their entry point is.
  238. And so that's why I think having all these different drops makes it really easy to
  239. create an entry point for different demographics. You know, for the uniform, which is our
  240. drop tomorrow, it was definitely a big risk for us to take because it leaned very
  241. sporty. It wasn't girly and, you know, frilly and what the younger demographic wanted.
  242. But it also, you know, it piqued interest of my my mom friends and, you know, older friends of mine.
  243. They're like, oh, my God, this feels so nostalgic to me. And this reminds me of 90s and 2000s
  244. active wear. And I need this and I want every piece. And I think this is the perfect sort
  245. of drop that kind of is now we're telling the younger generation that we've already acquired
  246. from a different entry point of a more girlier drop. Now they're following along.
  247. They're interested in the brand. And now they see this rollout of another drop that doesn't really feel like something that
  248. they necessarily would have bought. But now they're like, wait a second, do I need that?
  249. And so we've acquired that other entry point into this other drop that is now touching
  250. a different entry point for someone else, if that makes sense. So I think that's where storytelling and world
  251. building really helps identify, OK, who are we trying to acquire with this drop?
  252. What is the goal of this drop? Is it brand awareness? Is it customer acquisition?
  253. Is it to bring the returning customer something new? And that's sort of how we we go
  254. into planning out the year and like understanding the yearly calendar is what are the different
  255. entry points for the different demographics and how do we speak to everybody? Yeah, it does sound it does make sense,
  256. but it also sounds to me, to America's earlier point, somewhat risky because, you know, you're
  257. really hoping and you said this is a risky drop. You know, you really have to call it.
  258. You've got to be on the pulse. You're a very you're a very trend driven, you know, brand, as you're saying.
  259. And so when you bring out the new, it's got to take, you know, and it's a fun, exciting business, but it does seem
  260. to have some risk to it. I think at some point and just like in any business is you just have to
  261. be willing to take a big swing. And the safest version is usually the least differentiated from what other people are doing.
  262. And we've really, you know, I've really built SET by making conviction led bets on product
  263. drops, creative, retail, and not all of them are going to be guaranteed to work.
  264. But I think the upside of getting it right is much bigger than the downside of playing it safe.
  265. Yeah, I mean, I think that is the bottom line. Well, Lindsey, we are out of time.
  266. We've been talking to Lindsey Carter, who's the founder and CEO of SET Active. Thank you so much for joining us today.
  267. And where can our listeners go to find out about this drop and all the other stuff?
  268. They can follow SET on Instagram at SET Active or they can follow me. I build in public.
  269. I talk about what it is that we're doing at Lindsey Carter. And I would say those are the two
  270. main places to see what we're up to. Well, that's great. Thank you very much. That's all we have time for today.
  271. Thank you all for listening. And we'll be back soon. Till then, this has been Marketing Matters on
  272. the Wharton Podcast Network. And I'm here. I'm Barbara Kahn here with America's Read.

Brief Summary

Lindsay Carter explains how Set Active uses customer advocates, product drops, and lifestyle storytelling to stand out in activewear.

Key points

  • Activewear for the everyday girl. Lindsay Carter saw that activewear marketing centered on workouts and performance, leaving everyday customers like her out. Set Active began with a simple promise: make getting dressed easier with matching sets.
  • Coffee shops as a research lab. Without relying on formal data, Carter watched what women wore as they came and went from coffee shops. Those observations helped her recognize a need for everyday activewear.
  • Connection is the real social strategy. Carter traces her approach to social media back to a love of connecting people and telling stories. That instinct shaped both her earlier work and the way she built Set Active.
  • Trust the gut—and stay close to customers. After losing touch with customers during a low point, Set Active refocused on understanding what they want. Carter also trusts her instincts when a product or graphic doesn’t feel right, even after approval.
  • Customers become Set Insiders. Set Active invites loyal customers to share behind-the-scenes content in their own voice, with clear guidelines when free product is involved. One customer’s brand videos helped her reach 10,000 TikTok followers.
  • Selling a feeling, not just leggings. Set Active builds immersive worlds around product drops, bringing customers into the experience online and in person. The goal is more than convincing someone to buy another pair of leggings.

Episode highlights

Tension

24/ 100Calm

Related episodes