How to Cut Down on Visits to the ER

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management;Health Care Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. there's dissatisfaction and even frustration among patients and physicians with the state of primary
  2. care in the US when we're thinking about the physicians they're facing low managed care fees they're facing
  3. increasing costs of running a practice and that's inevitably leading them to spend less time with patients see a lot
  4. of patients during the day have patient wait very long times for appointments and that obviously has the potential to
  5. deteriorate the level of care heard the quality and lead to inadequate care patients have the same issue they don't
  6. spend enough time with the physicians very little face time leads the physician to rely very heavily on
  7. referrals to specialists and of course waiting a long time for an appointment has its own problems your condition may
  8. deteriorate you're delaying very necessary care and at the end of the day you actually might resort to going to
  9. the emergency room or or suffer some other consequences this is not going to get better because this issues with
  10. inadequate access to care and the fact that there's mismanagement of health condition is only going to get worse
  11. with aging population with increasing chronic condition prevalence and with insurance expansions so with the
  12. shortened shortage of primary care physicians we currently have in the US we see regulators we see policy makers
  13. we see employers and and we see health plans looking for innovative ways to change the landscape of primary care one
  14. of those innovation is probably the most notable one is the patient-centered medical home which we study in this in
  15. this particular research and we're trying to see if the adoption of the patient-centered medical home model
  16. leads to a reduction in the reliance on emergency room services patient-centered medical home can be
  17. best described as a model of primary care centered on the patient it's a team-oriented it relies on accessibility
  18. to care care coordination and the use of IT to provide better care and better outcome for for patients most of the
  19. patient-centered medical homes in the US are recognized by the National Committee
  20. for Quality Assurance or short is NCQA unsecure is a non-profit committed to improving quality in primary care in
  21. order to be NCQA recognized the practices have to put in processes for scheduling appointments with patients
  22. for communicating with patients for organizing documenting and measuring clinical outcomes for implementing
  23. evidence-based guidelines in their practices and for organizing and tracking referrals and there's a whole
  24. long list of other things that they need to put in place to receive this recognition every one of those standards
  25. elements and factors that are being reviewed is getting scored and when you aggregate this the score there is a
  26. determination whether this patient whether this clinic becomes a patient-centered medical home or not and
  27. not only that it also determines whether the recognition receive a low level or high level so there's different levels
  28. of recognitions if you're a patient-centered medical home recognized by the NCQA you have access to financial
  29. incentives that are provided by health plans by employers and in kind of in the early days of patient-centered medical
  30. homes which we study also state and federal sponsored pilot programs we find that practices that went through
  31. this transition and became a patient-centered medical home yeah the practice itself becomes the home for the
  32. patient they're not going anywhere there's a team-based approach that provides a home for every need that the
  33. patient has the practices that went through this transition have reduced the number of emergency room admissions for
  34. their patients by five to eight percent if the patient had a chronic illness if the patient did not have a chronic
  35. illness there was absolutely no reduction this is the primary finding and then when we drill down and look at
  36. the different chronic conditions we see that a lot of those benefits and the biggest reductions that we see happens
  37. for patients that have either hypertension or diabetes in addition to that a very interesting thing that we've
  38. looked at is what's the mechanism that leads to this reduction in ed admission and one of the finding we see is that
  39. the reduction in the admission is not very sensitive to the timing of the visit and what does that mean is that
  40. the reductions in ED admissions are not coming necessarily from the fact that the the patient-centered medical home is
  41. open for longer hours or that it has more accessibility but actually from better management of chronic conditions
  42. that basically means that even if you seek care in the emergency department on weekends when most of those primary care
  43. clinics are closed you would still have the same reduction the same benefit and that tells me that your chronic
  44. condition is under control and it's better managed I believe what sets our researcher part
  45. is its scale we look at four hundred and sixty thousand patients over four years
  46. in 280 patient-centered medical homes and this this was never done before nothing on this particular scale 115,000
  47. of those patients we see them each and every year in our sample and that allows us to do things that again we're never
  48. done in the literature so it's not just that we can see what happened to the patient population when a practice
  49. decides to switch to a patient-centered medical home but we can see what happened to an individual patient when
  50. their practice switches to a patient-centered medical home and follow the patient and see if there is a
  51. different experience for that particular patient doing that that particular transition
  52. previous research is very mixed on this issue of the benefits of patient-centered medical homes so we we
  53. didn't really know what to expect I I see our findings as somewhat comforting because we see the effect where we
  54. expect to see it and we don't see it where we expect not to see it let me give you an example patients that don't
  55. have a chronic condition we don't expect the patient-centered medical homes to have a big impact on on ed admissions
  56. the main reason why a person ends up in the emergency room whether they don't have a onic illness is things like
  57. trauma a motor vehicle crash there's nothing in the patients that are come centered medical home that makes you a
  58. better driver that they're not claiming to do that on the other hand if you have
  59. a chronic condition a better management of that condition using all the processes that ncqa puts in place in the
  60. practice can have an impact and it's very comforting to see that five to eight percent of admissions to the
  61. emergency room are being avoided now we have a lot of research that documents that many of the visits to the emergency
  62. room can be prevented it's either that the visit is legitimate somebody has a problem but if they had better
  63. management that visit could have been avoidable and we still have a lot of visits to the emergency room where the
  64. setting is wrong you could have went to your primary care physicians or to another setting and received care you
  65. didn't have to go to this high level of acuity a type care if the patient-centered medical home
  66. model is the poster child for innovation in primary care the stepchild would be at least judging from the lack of
  67. interest among researchers would be a variety of retainer based medicine models also known as concierge medicine
  68. models where the heart of those models there is a monetary transfer from patients to their physician in the form
  69. of retainer fee which averages about one hundred and fifty dollars per month in return the physician is able to reduce
  70. the size of their panel from what we said before about 3,000 patients to no more than 600 this allows the physician
  71. to spend more time with the patient have extended visits about half an hour visits you know make sure that patients
  72. can come in on the same day so enhance accessibility to care and then patient can call their physician they can email
  73. their physicians so the service aspects and the convenience aspects are enhanced
  74. the retainer base models stem from the same dissatisfaction of frustration that the patient-centered medical homes
  75. models stem from but retainer base models have not received much attention not in the literature and and you know
  76. to some extent in the media but not all that favorable attention and you might ask yourself why well there's two main
  77. reasons why one people view this as medicine for the reach this a little bit ignore is the fact that most people who
  78. receive services nowadays in in those concierge practices and retainer based medicine models our middle class and and
  79. and one hundred and fifty dollars a month we can debate that but for a lot of people this is considered to be
  80. affordable the second and probably the biggest criticism of retainer based models is its sustainability we have a
  81. fixed supply of physicians if every physician downsize your practice we're just going to exacerbate the shore
  82. stage of primary care physicians this is a valid criticism but it ignores a couple of things one many physicians
  83. especially at a certain age in their life contemplate retiring contemplate maybe changing direction professionally
  84. working for a pharmaceutical company or something like that instead if they can go into this retainer base models it
  85. buys them a couple of more years where they can work in this field in a different pace the second issue is that
  86. retainer based models tend to make primary care more attractive to young doctors who are choosing which field of
  87. medicine they want to go into and if we want to solve the shortage of primary care in the long run we have to make
  88. primary care more attractive and and when we see that happening on the ground and the last point is that there's many
  89. models of retainer based medicine that do not rely on major reductions in the panel size those models typically called
  90. hybrid models have a huge potential because they're both scalable and also because they tend to segment patients
  91. into those who value access to their physicians from those who see their physicians you just for routine checkups
  92. and very basic here I think in spirit Obamacare fits very well with this trend of innovation in
  93. primary care this innovation when we look at patient-centered medical homes places the patients in the center and in
  94. in a way it transitioned us from a world in which physicians were paid based on volume to a world in which we're trying
  95. to shift and pay physician based on value that they create for their patients that's very much in the spirit
  96. what else is in the spirit is the reliance on information technology on cost containment on finding ways to have
  97. other non physicians in the clinic part of this medical home that will work at the top of their license will engage in
  98. population management will reach out to patients with chronic conditions and will follow up and will try to improve
  99. care to reduce the burden of kind of downstream utilization that can happen when those are breaks in continua t of
  100. characters there's a couple of research projects already underway the first stream deals
  101. with this heavily understudied returner base medicine models this is coming through a partnership with one of the
  102. leading companies in the industry to study the real effects of patients who stay within a retainer based framework
  103. and those who find themselves outside of that framework what happens when you spend half an hour the physician instead
  104. of 8 or 12 minutes what happens to referrals what happens to outcomes what happens to your health and what happens
  105. on the financial side in terms of health costs on the other venue the patient-centered medical homes our
  106. partners at independence Blue Cross and I have received a very unique data from NCQA allowing us to look at all the
  107. individual scores on all standards elements and factors for those practices that we've studied in the research I've
  108. described today this will allow us to look under the hood well at the very granular level of what is driving change
  109. and innovation in primary care and allow us for the first time to understand the
  110. elements that are driving this the various improvements in care both in terms of outcomes and costs
  111. you

Brief Summary

Primary care faces challenges; patient-centered homes reduce ER visits for chronic patients.

Key points

  • Deteriorating Primary Care Access. Patients and physicians face increasing frustration with primary care in the US.
  • Impact of Patient-Centered Medical Homes. Research shows a reduction in emergency room admissions for chronic illness patients.
  • Concierge Medicine Critique. Retainer-based models face criticism for being exclusive and unsustainable.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes