Health Care Reform: The Individual Mandate
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The U.S. Supreme Court recently heard arguments both for and against President Obama's health care reform initiative, known as the Affordable Care Act. The provision at the center of the legal debate, known as the "individual mandate," requires all adults to buy health insurance, either through their employers or by buying it themselves. Knowledge@Wharton talked with Wharton professor Mark Pauly about the possible outcomes of the court case; the potential implications for businesses and consumers, and ongoing questions about how to improve the country's health care system.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] as as we all know the US Supreme Court has recently heard arguments both for
- and against President Obama's healthcare reform initiative known as the Affordable Care Act um I guess one of
- the provisions of this that's sort of gotten a lot of the attention particularly in the in the court case is
- the individual mandate which requires all adults to buy health insurance either through their employers or by
- buying it themselves so can you talk to me about I mean what are your feelings about the provision as it stands in this
- act and I mean are you in favor of it and why or why not see yeah well first of all in the spirit of division of
- labor I need to say that the the primary Arguments for and against the individual
- mandate or lawyer arguments not Economist arguments so I'm going to speak about it as an economist but the
- key issues that I think were debated before The Supreme Court like does is it constitutional to affirmatively make a
- person buy something or is it how far does the interstate commerce clause extend um I'm not an expert on that uh
- there are though two reasons two good reasons to have uh the individual mandate in any kind of um Health reform
- legislation uh the one which has gotten the most discussion recently is um is kind of as a um uh an important um
- whether it's necessary or not we could debate but an important adjunct of a provision of the legislation which
- essentially says uh insures um have to charge everybody the same premium uh no matter what the risk level and uh the
- problem with that of course is that if you're an average person and the a this is not some kind of reverse Lake wagon
- where we're all sicker than average average person is reasonably healthy if the premium is high enough to cover the
- cost of the uh people with chronic conditions it'll look like a bad deal to a lot of um of those people and uh so
- you you need uh in a way some muscle uh to tell them you have to buy the insurance anyway even though it doesn't
- sound like such a good deal to you uh so that's one reason the other reason which
- was actually more important when we first considered this 20 years ago essentially
- arises because even if you were an average risk person and the premiums were tailored to your risk well I don't
- know about you or me but we know that somewhere between three and 4% of people just don't get the idea that they ought
- to have insurance uh and we know that when they're offered a really good deal as part of their job they only have to
- pay a few hundred dollars a month there was still will be um uh 3 or 4% of workers who will turn it down and not
- get insurance any where uh and that U why are they doing that well one reason probably is um unlike me they don't get
- up every morning and think about health insurance they think they're healthy and
- uh why buy insurance if you're healthy and there's ALS also the view that well if I get really sick no there nobody's
- going to leave me bleeding in the street and in fact Federal Law requires you to
- be treated uh at an emergency room and stabilized regardless of your ability to pay and so uh people will rely on in a
- way on the charity of others uh to compensate for the fact that they don't have insurance it's still I tell people
- it's still a terribly bad idea to run around without health insurance no matter what you are and no matter how
- much you count on charity but the one good feature of Charity is at least it's cheap if you're the object of Charity so
- we actually uh we originally called our proposal a proposal for responsible national health insurance because we
- thought that it was important to have a mandate in a way to deal with irresponsible behavior on the part I
- have to say of a small minority of the population uh surprisingly not necessarily the poorest people uh just
- the people who don't have the idea that they need insurance uh they the they uh the non-poor uninsured tend to be people
- who don't buy other kinds of insurance they don't have life insurance either they don't have insurance on their cars
- they live from paycheck to paycheck they're maxed down on their credit cards even if they have a pretty decent in
- income and so and uh since the challenge at that time was to come up with a plan
- to get universal health insurance coverage we thought that it was important to have a mandate to kind of
- round up the stragglers now there's so much I mean there's so many other Provisions to this law besides the
- individual mandate I mean can you tell me I mean what is your opinion of this act overall and what do you think the
- impact would be I mean if the Supreme Court strikes down the individual mandate or if it strikes down the whole
- law what what is the impact on I'm really worried actually that um the good there's some really good parts to the
- law and um in some ways um the the uh features that that that are around the individual
- mandate uh because they were put in there run the risk of Bringing Down the whole edifice so the part that at least
- in my opinion is very desirable is a part that's actually not been very much discussed the law is going to provide
- hundreds of billions of dollars worth of subsidies to not just to poor people but
- to lower middle- income people to help them afford health insurance and I guess my view is as a as a human being and as
- a moral person uh I think it's um just um socially undesirable and morally undesirable for people to go without
- highly beneficial care when it exists and um and and the most of the heavy lifting in the in the law to get people
- insured comes not from the individual mandate really but from the fact that if you can't afford insurance Insurance the
- government's going to step in and and really give you major help to afford it uh the the as I said the the Mandate
- mostly just kind of rounds up the uh the people who aren't persuaded Enough by an
- enormous subsidy that they ought to go ahead and get insurance so uh that part uh in a way uh what I call paying higher
- taxes in order to have a clean conscience is in my view the most important part of legislation and it
- would be a real tragedy I think if all the other things that were added on to it for various reasons kind of brought
- down the main uh objective and now I mean if the I mean if the court strikes down part of the law or all of the law I
- mean what is the impact on businesses what is the impact on consumers and I mean is there a way that you see that
- Congress and the administration could kind of come together and come up with something that might be able to stick
- that everybody could agree on oh I I think my view is but I think I'm not the only person that there are a lot if if
- we could just fix some things uh we could have something that would make sense uh uh there's of course a
- political Choice whether you think the best way to fix it is to throw the whole thing out and start over I hope still
- retaining uh generous subsidies to the people who need help to buy health insurance or whether you think you could
- somehow uh adjust a bunch of the other provisions of the law in order to make it possible to do that that's kind of a
- political Choice um I think uh you know the if if the centerpiece of the law is the subsidies I think it's certainly
- possible to design the other parts of it to um do two things one is just be much
- simpler uh the problem was uh as you can imagine it's after all it's our elected
- representatives in Congress they hung all sorts of things in on the legislation that have little to do with
- the uninsured and a lot to do with uh various Crusades that they might be engaging in and uh and that complication
- I think is just been U very harmful to the uh to generating support for the law it's just gotten so
- complicated and then there there is one thing in the law that's related to the Mandate that I think could have been
- done a lot better and that kind of gets back to the point I was making a few minutes ago the purpose of the Mandate
- is to force people who are relatively low risk uh to to pay more for their insurance uh why do we want to do that
- well there is a good social reason to do it for people who are unusually high risk especially if they're not very well
- off um they can't afford to pay an insurance premium that would reflect their risk so we want to cross subsidize
- them uh the problem I think with the way it's in the legislation is it's what I call the dumbest possible way to do a
- good thing we're trying to make a transfer to people who need some help to buy insurance because they're high risk
- and the way we the legislation does it is in effect by taxing people who are low risk and then the people who are low
- risk don't want to pay the tax and uh the alternative which actually exists in the legislation is to create a pool for
- high risks where if you are a high-risk person you have diabetes say or some serious chronic condition you can go
- there and buy insurance at reasonable premiums and the subsidy comes not from making Insurance expensive to low risk
- it comes from raising taxes the way we usually raise taxes on people based on their ability to pay or at least based
- on their willingness to pay uh for uh to help out others so yeah so so the so the
- main part I think that that has been harmful here is the um the way that the the lawyers who drafted the legislation
- thought uh that they would help out high risks was by punishing low risks and I think that was unnecessary now I mean
- what would you say I mean there's a lot of talk about who is sort of the main culprits with the problems facing the
- Health Care System whether it's the insurance companies the hospitals the doctors the government the consumers I
- mean what do you what do you think what do you think theid of the problem well insurance companies certainly were the
- designated enemies right uh and uh and this the the sort of populist version even of the requirement that insurers
- cover high risks at the same premiums is well they'll how will insurers do that well they'll do that just by taking the
- money out of their profit profits will just make them do it but of course you can't make insurers really do anything
- uh they'll turn around and charge the rest of us more uh which is um what probably will happen when um the um if
- if if and when Community rating uh and the whether or not it has the individual mandate um comes into play uh so so it's
- it's really hard to kind of Stick it to insurers because uh as long as they have
- the ability to vary the premiums they charge and law is not going to take that away although it does have some
- Provisions that they can't charge unreasonable premiums but essentially the reason they charge a lot is when
- they have to pay out a lot I mean most of the money that goes to insurers comes back to us in the form of uh healthc
- care claims so uh you know it's certainly uh commonplace to quote the horrible figures on the rate of growth
- and insurance premiums outrunning every other economic aggregate although lately
- they've been slowing down a lot and people haven't been breaking out champagne all that much maybe they
- should but the reason why insurance premiums rise rapidly for the most part is not because they're pocketing a lot
- more money than they used to it's because they're paying out a lot more in claims why are they paying out a lot
- more in claims well it's because you and I are going to the doctor not so much more but to get more done at a higher
- price sometimes uh and um so yeah the main culprit for high Healthcare cost in the US it's they're easy it's easy to
- find that person uh find a mirror and look in it and that'll be one of the reasons why healthcare costs are high
- and now I mean tell me I mean what would you say would be the one thing that we should do to tackle Rising Healthcare
- cost I mean can you point and can you point to The Economist party line here is to say that the most serious um
- impediment to uh an economically efficient Health Care system is of course connected with health insurance
- and the most serious impediment there is uh there is a substantial tax break that
- goes to that that's generated if you get your insurance through your job like all
- of us do or almost all of us do Al but about 6% of the privately insured get insurance to their job and the beauty
- part of it is uh from the point of view of a of of an individual is um well so pen pays uh uh uh or is able to uh make
- payments toward my health insurance in such a way I figure to Shield about $18,000 worth of income for me from
- taxes uh my wife says we should send a Christmas card to the treasury thanking them for that tax break but the
- consequence of it is in part uh uh that uh that I'm less parsimonious than I might otherwise be in choosing insurance
- and in choosing health care because in effect the treasury is sharing the cost and this this tax break of course it's a
- middle class tax break so people who are mostly middle class don't see what's wrong with it uh but it has the
- consequence of uh of providing um a pretty strong incentive for ordinary Americans not to be as careful
- about health care costs as they should be and now very quickly I mean are there any initiatives going on anywhere that
- you could see that would that are in progress that would work well I mean a model that well so a little bit of uh uh
- it actually surprised me and pleased me there is in the legislation a provision not to take effect until 2018 but a
- provision to try to um uh take away the subsidy to employment-based health insurance for high very high cost
- employment-based health insurance a so-called Cadillac tax uh now they didn't do it the right way what they
- should have done was said if you have a health plan that's um costing more than $22,000 a year uh at least some part of
- that out be treated as part of your taxable income and that will make you want to be more careful instead partly
- for appearance's sake they imposed a tax on insurance companies but of course the
- insurance companies won't pay that tax they'll shift it back to the employers and the employers will probably shift it
- back to us in the form of lower raises than we would otherwise get so that was a good thing although it's pretty pretty
- small and pretty long delayed so if I were to rewrite things I'd say give that a lot more muscle uh make it a lot more
- rational and move it up in time and that's essentially what the two uh deficit reduction
- committees uh the uh proposed uh to the Congress and to the president as well to
- change the tax treatment of employment based health insurance so that that would be my main thing uh uh certainly
- uh if you can make this is sort of a necessary condition I think for people to really care about the cost of healthc
- care personally as opposed to being outraged about it generally but if people did care more about their own
- personal cost of health care then I think other things like better information about where can I get a
- reasonably good deal on Health Care would be something people would pay a lot more attention to than they do now
- [Music]
Brief Summary
The episode analyzes the Affordable Care Act's individual mandate, its necessity, and the implications of potential Supreme Court decisions.
Key points
- The Affordable Care Act and the Individual Mandate. The individual mandate requires all adults to buy health insurance, sparking debate on its necessity and constitutionality.
- Impact of Striking Down the Mandate. Concerns arise about the potential fallout if the Supreme Court strikes down the individual mandate or the entire law.
- The Role of Subsidies in Healthcare. The law aims to provide substantial subsidies to help lower middle-income individuals afford health insurance.
Episode highlights
- The Affordable Care Act and the Individual MandateThe individual mandate requires all adults to buy health insurance, sparking debate on its necessity and constitutionality.“Is it constitutional to affirmatively make a person buy something?”1:08Apr 11, 2012
- Impact of Striking Down the MandateConcerns arise about the potential fallout if the Supreme Court strikes down the individual mandate or the entire law.“What is the impact if the Supreme Court strikes down the individual mandate?”4:55Apr 11, 2012
- The Role of Subsidies in HealthcareThe law aims to provide substantial subsidies to help lower middle-income individuals afford health insurance.“The law is going to provide hundreds of billions of dollars worth of subsidies.”5:24Apr 11, 2012
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





