Health Care Reform: The Supreme Court Debate

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The U.S. Supreme Court recently heard arguments both for and against President Obama's health care reform initiative, known as the Affordable Care Act. The provision at the center of the legal debate, known as the "individual mandate," requires all adults to buy health insurance, either through their employers or by buying it themselves. Knowledge@Wharton talked with Wharton professor Arnold Rosoff about the possible outcomes of the court case; the potential implications for businesses and consumers, and ongoing questions about how to improve the country's health care system.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] as we all know the US Supreme Court has recently heard arguments both for and
  2. against President Obama's healthcare reform initiative known as the Affordable Care Act um one of the key
  3. Provisions at the of the court case is what's known as the individual mandate so could you talk to us a little bit
  4. about I mean what are your views on the individual mandate in its current form would you say you're for it or against
  5. it I think the individual mandate was as good a solution politically to getting the law passed as they could have come
  6. up with if it was possible to start with a clean sheet of paper I wouldn't have used the individual mandate but the
  7. individual mandate and I know you've talked to Professor Paulie about this was a republican idea uh and as part of
  8. President Obama's and his um the proponents of the laws compromise they reached across the aisle took a
  9. republican idea came from the Heritage Foundation initially was endorsed early on by n Gingrich was adopted in
  10. Massachusetts and in Romney care um I think they thought that was a big step towards the compromise that had to be
  11. necessary to get a universal healthc care law passed um so given the political realities I think the Mandate
  12. was a decently good way to go about it uh it turns out now that doing it that way exposes the law to some very
  13. significant constitutional challenge uh which seems everybody underestimated while the law was being
  14. considered when it was first being passed after it was first passed uh I don't think anybody felt that the legal
  15. challenges were going to be taken as seriously as they are um but the Mandate may bring the whole
  16. law down may very well bring the whole law down like I said if I started from a clean sheet of paper I would do it
  17. differently I would do it as a tax which probably makes it clearly constitutional
  18. Beyond challenge uh and a voucher system everybody in the country would have to um have money deducted from their
  19. paycheck just like they do for Social Security just like they do for Medicare and in return for that you get a voucher
  20. that would enable you to go out and buy healthc care um maybe you could buy it from a governmental entity like Medicare
  21. but I think this being America you'd be able to buy it from private vendors and if it was structured that way I don't
  22. think there'd been any constitutional infirmity to it now I mean this is a very complicated multi-part law overall
  23. so can you talk to me a little bit about I mean overall I mean what are your views on the different provisions of the
  24. Affordable Care Act our Health Care system in this country is so complex and is so distorted in the way it's set up that
  25. it requires reform from top to bottom me more people who go into medicine go into
  26. a high-priced um surgical Subs Specialties and other subs Specialties than primary care that needs to be
  27. changed uh the health insurance Provisions where people with pre-existing conditions aren't allowed
  28. to buy insurance or where your rates go up astronomically uh if you use Health Care um these are these are very bad
  29. things so it requires a toz reform and the law got to be 2700 pages in Bill form they they keep talking about the
  30. law being over 2,000 Pages the law I think actually only comes out to 975 pages but the bill was 2700 pages and if
  31. you look at that bill there's only a few paragraphs that deal with the Mandate notwithstanding that the Mandate
  32. is the centerpiece of legislation uh and there are many other things particularly all of the health insurance
  33. reforms that are um one could well argue inextricably intertwined with it uh on the insurance industry side what the
  34. health insurers gave up was the right to exclude people who look like they' need
  35. too much health care or the right to kick people out of their policies if they use too much health care uh the
  36. insurance companies accepted Community rating so that they couldn't charge you an exorbitant premium if you needed more
  37. Health Care um those are all difficult pills for the insurance industry to swallow and what they insisted on in
  38. return was an individual mandate or some kind of mandate so that everybody would
  39. get into the game otherwise they said they'd be eaten alive by adverse selection people who considered
  40. themselves healthy would stay out until they needed health care and then they would come in and they would be able to
  41. insist because of the provisions of the law that they'd be insured at that point
  42. it would be like a homeowner coming running into a homeowner's insurance company saying
  43. sign me up quick my house is on fire um and so the Mandate was put in as the quid pro quo the negotiated
  44. um deal to get those other patient protections so I mean if the court strikes down the individual mandate or
  45. even the whole Affordable Care Act I mean what does this mean for healthcare going
  46. forward well before I answer that question let me deal with the first part of what you said if the court strikes
  47. down the Mandate which I sat in on the arguments I listened to the judges questions and I've read a lot of
  48. analyses since then I think there's a pretty good chance they'll strike down the Mandate the other question then that
  49. becomes very important is well they strike down the whole law um there is a long-standing constitutional
  50. principle in favor of constitutionality presumption of constitutionality the court has to show
  51. allegiance to the Constitution so if Congress puts something in a law that's unconstitutional the court has no CH
  52. choice but to take that out but everything else in the law that's constitutional they should leave in as a
  53. part of the separation of powers the respect of a democratic majority I don't mean Democrat versus Republican I mean
  54. representative of democracy um so there's so much else in the law that they could keep in place but they would
  55. have to be able to decide what stays and what goes and in the one and a half hours of oral argument over separability
  56. um the justi has made it clear that they didn't have much of a clue where to begin and deciding what stays and what
  57. goes uh justice Scalia and this is a little bit of a mischaracterization but other justices U I guess it was
  58. Justice Kagan uh equipped that it would be too difficult for justice scalia's law clerks to have
  59. to go through the whole 2700 pages of the bill and figure out what stays and what goes they probably throw it all out
  60. well if the court is supposed to keep as much of the law as it can and they throw
  61. it all out that would throw it back to Congress to say if you want all these other Provisions let me tell you what
  62. some of the other Provisions are things that have nothing to do with the Mandate
  63. like nutritional label you go into McDonald's it tells you how much a Big Mac U has by way of calories um other
  64. things loan forgiveness for people's medical school loans if they go into primary care or go to work in an
  65. underserved area has nothing to do with the individual mandate funding for black
  66. lung disease for Research into cancer and things of that nature those things don't have to go just because the
  67. Mandate goes but for the Supreme Court to sit down there and try to figure out provision by provision with hundreds of
  68. Provisions what is tied and what isn't tied what Congress would have intended to have if it didn't have the Mandate
  69. that's pretty much a legislative function and so the court can say we don't want to Wade too far into the
  70. congress's legislative function which is which is respecting Congress more uh to
  71. say we're going to leave as much of your work intact we're going to take it all out or on the other side saying we the
  72. court are going to try to decide what you wanted to leave in and what you wanted to take out both of them are an
  73. encroachment upon Congressional legislative domain and which is the greater one of the justices asked that
  74. question now but do you feel like I mean can without the individual mandate I mean can what would have to H if that's
  75. if that is thrown out I mean what would have to happen in order to sort of keep some of the intents of the law intact I
  76. mean do you think the majority of it can move forward or are there certain things
  77. that the Administration or Congress would have to go back and do and if so what what would they have to do or what
  78. would you advise they do let's imagine another an alternative Universe where the Congress is bipartisan or
  79. nonpartisan and functional um and the court took out an important piece of their legislation and there were many
  80. other pieces that were unconnected the day after the court did that Congress could meet in session and say let's put
  81. back these 200 Provisions or 300 provisions and so forth the concept that our Congress at this
  82. point in time given how fractious and divided they are would do that is ridiculous so at one point in the in the
  83. argument in the Supreme Court one of the attorneys for the government was talking
  84. about the Court's um job being to ascertain the will of Congress what would Congress want us to do in terms of
  85. keeping the rest of the law intact and Justice Kennedy who's really going to be the decider here because you got the
  86. four liberal justi and the four conservative justices and CED swing Justice I predict what happens with the
  87. Mandate by the way will happen with a 5 to four vote very dangerous to make a prediction I shouldn't do it but I do it
  88. anyway what Kennedy said was um is that the real Congress or a hypothetical Congress because a a hypothetical
  89. Congress the day after the court struck down the whole law would meet and they'd
  90. put back in all the parts that weren't controversial but every part's controversial now
  91. because politics makes everything controversial that's a very very long-winded way of saying I can't answer
  92. your question yeah that that is actually very helpful I mean so that I mean given
  93. that environment and I think most people would agree that you were correct in characterizing that environment I mean
  94. what would you say is sort of one thing that should be done to help tackle all the problems with the American Health
  95. Care system I mean is there one I mean can you I know there's probably a lot of things but can you think of one thing
  96. that if in the Hy in that hypothetical Cong or if there was a hypothetically could get done right away that would
  97. make a big help what would you say it would be replace all the congressman Congress
  98. people excuse me I don't I don't know um I don't think it's likely to happen at this point in time I'm not sure it'll
  99. happen in my lifetime but one of the things that could happen is that the American public realizing the need for
  100. Universal Health Care and realizing that we've gone down a a dysfunctional Road in relying to the extent that we have on
  101. for-profit Healthcare uh will'll say okay let's just wipe it all out start with a clean sheet of paper and come up
  102. with something like governmental health care like France has or like Italy has or like Britain has thing is that none
  103. of those countries are just sailing along happily now uh with aging populations advancing technology sagging
  104. economies all of the countries that have universal healthcare in Europe and elsewhere are struggling to maintain
  105. that National commitment I think it's I think it's a a shame an embarrassment that our country is the only major
  106. Nation on the face of the planet that hasn't made a national commitment to Universal Health Care and there are a
  107. lot of reasons why we haven't I don't think it's because Americans are inherently selfish or greedy or whatever
  108. but we've kind of let the system evolve piece by piece by peace over generations
  109. and we've essentially painted ourselves into a corner and when you ask me what should we
  110. have I'm not sure how we can get from where we are to where we need to be when this law was being debated in Congress
  111. you may remember a lot of people who were against the law made a big point out of the fact that it was over 2,000
  112. pages and why should it be that long um why should it be so long that most of the Congress people say we haven't read
  113. it our staffs have read it peac meal the thing is that we've got a very complex system or non-system some would say and
  114. almost every piece of it has to be changed in some way um you can't do that with a 50-page law or 100 page law and
  115. whether we can get there from where we are now it's anybody's guess [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode discusses the Affordable Care Act's individual mandate, its political origins, and potential impacts of Supreme Court rulings.

Key points

  • The Individual Mandate Debate. The individual mandate was a politically viable solution but now faces significant constitutional challenges.
  • Universal Health Care in America. The speaker argues for a national commitment to Universal Health Care, citing the struggles of other countries.

Tension

55/ 100Some tension

Related episodes