Health Care Reform: Lessons from Massachusetts
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The U.S. Supreme Court recently heard arguments both for and against President Obama's health care reform initiative, known as the Affordable Care Act. The provision at the center of the legal debate, known as the "individual mandate," requires all adults to buy health insurance, either through their employers or by buying it themselves. Knowledge@Wharton talked with Wharton professor Jonathan Kolstad about the possible outcomes of the court case; the potential implications for businesses and consumers, and ongoing questions about how to improve the country's health care system.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I'm gonna talk a little bit about the u.s. supreme with the Affordable Care Act and as the US Supreme Court
- deliberates about what it where it is going to come down in terms of the constitutionality of it but what I'd
- like to talk to you about is a lot of a lot of the debate on this issue has centered around the so called individual
- mandate the provision that requires all adults to buy health insurance either through their employers are buying it
- themselves can you talk a little bit about sort of your views on this provision and sort of
- your feelings on it absolutely I mean I think this is ultimately one of the key features of this approach to health
- reform which is in the Accountable Care Act and nationally and then was in Massachusetts previously in some ways
- it's what makes it a kind of middle of the middle of the road type of policy approach you know it's not at the
- extreme of just having say single-payer system and it's not at the extreme of just saying well everyone's in it for
- themselves because ultimately it recognizes the relationship between my decision to purchase health insurance or
- my decision not to purchase health insurance and then go to the hospital if I get sick and the implications for
- others it's basically the individual mandate ultimately is it's very similar to attacks in many ways but basically
- the simple idea is that if at the end of the day you don't have health insurance
- you pay a penalty and it basically is you can think of it I think in some ways it's kind of a nudge towards getting
- health insurance right so at the end of the day under you know depending what the Supreme Court does if I don't have
- health insurance that's still my choice but I will pay a penalty potentially and
- arguably commensurate with sort of some cost I'm imposing on on others and but ultimately I don't have to do it it's
- not a mandate in the sense of kind of everyone will be you know forced to do this and in Massachusetts a very similar
- thing occurred and in fact you did see a big effect on amongst the people who were uninsured about half of the newly
- insured we're gaining coverage through their actually through their employer and so one argument there is that what
- the individual mandate was doing was really just augmenting some underlying value for health insurance maybe you
- know people valued it a fair amount just not quite enough to to take it up so say
- I said well every dollar of health insurance I get you know ninety cents of it is worth it to me
- that's not enough to make that make that trade-off but then you add on the individual mandate and it kind of puts
- you over the over the hump as it were so I think it's it's a new policy tool broadly and in the health reform and
- health insurance debate but it's been tried in Massachusetts and it's obviously a fairly critical Keystone to
- the national reform the other big piece on the insurance side are the substantial subsidies which exists both
- expansions in traditional Medicaid for people under 133 percent of the poverty line but then subsidies for insurance
- gained through the various state health insurance exchanges and that will go up to 400 percent of the poverty line so
- lots of people will have potentially access to some form of subsidies so those are the kind of two pillars that
- that really are intended to augment the expansion and health insurance now I mean if the court strikes down the
- individual mandate or even the whole Act I mean what did that mean for what would
- that mean for health care going forward can I mean can the bill can other aspects of the Act stand without the
- individual mandate or if the entire Act is struck down I mean what does that mean for businesses for consumers or
- even for Congress and the Obama administration I think absolutely this is a critical question and obviously one
- of the fundamental questions leaked from a legal perspective the Supreme Court is
- facing is is can the rest of the statute stand without without the individual mandate in it and at a very simple level
- the individual mandate is very important for facilitating basically pooling in the insurance market and the problem
- occurs if one of the other key pieces of the ACA is the fact that basically the prohibition on on pricing based on
- pre-existing conditions or not offering coverage and that of course is a very popular and potentially very valuable
- tool it effectively prevents people from facing the risk of becoming reclassified
- so right now it may be that if I get very sick I can still get health insurance but if my premiums go up and
- in a you know substantially then I would like to even insure against that and so
- if you basically pool everyone you've improved welfare by overcoming that problem the issue the issue is that if
- you if you don't have any way to actually get everyone into the pool and and you can't price based on
- pre-existing conditions or by price based on health risk then in fact only the sickest people will decide to decide
- to come into the insurance market and that can potentially lead to rising premiums and even in the extreme kind of
- the individual insurance market unraveling now there is some evidence for that at different state levels and
- you have seen for example in Massachusetts when they implemented the individual mandate you did get healthier
- people into the pool and in fact they had at baseline they had basically guaranteed-issue and community-rating
- which ostensibly looked like the other pieces of the ACA without the mandate and they did see some reductions in the
- newly insured worse were significantly healthier than the previously insured so there's some evidence that the insurance
- market would be or that the difficult there would be difficulties in operating the insurance market in the absence of
- the individual mandate but with the existing provisions that limit the ability of insurers to price an
- underlying risk the other important piece that I did bring up is the subsidies you know it might well be that
- with very substantial subsidies you are able to expand insurance coverage substantially and potentially these
- issues with adverse selection will not be as problematic if you are able to facilitate you know for example a
- subsidy gets in relatively healthy folks into the into the pools and into the markets and it also depends on how
- insurance exchanges are set up so that's one key feature which is is in the ACA but each state is setting up their own
- health insurance exchange and how that functions and how that works is going to be really critical to what insurance is
- available who signs up who enrolls even conditional on kind of the overarching structure which is going which is in the
- ACA now and will be determined to some degree by the Supreme Court's decision so on the insurance side I think it is
- very fundamental though arguably there's lots those other provisions can stand in
- the absence of it there are also key features that are I think not the not the focus of the
- but things like the accountable care organizations and changes to the payments until for delivery of care that
- arguably are very critical going forward in thinking about new models to address
- the cost of care the appropriateness of care the effectiveness of care that potentially are largely unrelated or
- certainly are almost largely unrelated to the expansions in coverage which are the keystone of this reform and I think
- they arguably should be you know in the u.s. we have roughly 50 million uninsured that's kind of a first order
- issue of deal you know to deal with that but ultimately we all know that the growth trajectory of cost relative of
- health care cost relative to GDP is a big issue and one argument has been to change the incentives to try to deal
- with that and there are a number of provisions and demonstration projects and new approaches in the ACA that I
- think would be important to try and it would be I think a setback to our understanding of the policy options to
- deal with healthcare cost if everything was thrown out and we weren't able to implement things like accountable care
- organizations or other forms of bundled payment that might might potentially incentivize higher quality lower or
- lower cost or both by physicians so I mean given that almost everybody agrees that health care in the country is too
- expensive and getting more so every year plus it doesn't cover as you said I mean
- I think it was 50 million people I mean what would be one thing that we could do
- to tackle rising healthcare costs I mean is there something is particularly maybe
- something that's not in the act they you could see that would probably make a big
- different a big difference or impact well I mean I think there are there are features of very important issues in the
- Act it you know there is an important thing to remember is that we get a lot for what we spend so we live longer and
- healthier lives today than we did in the 60s and we spend more on health care and
- and on average we may be very willing to have made that trade-off now that doesn't mean that health care cost is
- not eating up a larger and larger share of GDP and in fact we can observe there are very wasteful things so the question
- of course is can we sort of have our cake and eat it too that is can we cut back the wasteful stuff without really
- undermining those incentives that ultimately I think we all value for ourselves for
- that you can go into the hospital and get treated effectively for things that you couldn't have been treated for even
- ten years ago now and and you know most of what's driving cost growth is those are those new technologies are those new
- treatments and one important feature there is potentially aligning the incentives of providers to provide
- high-quality low-cost care and not to be rewarded for providing just the most intensive care but arguably the care
- that provides gains in health while not incentivizing additional technologies or
- additional intensive procedures and there are features in the in the ACA that are intended to at least address
- this and some degree within Medicare which is kind of thinking about bundling payment or accountable care
- organizations which I think are at least steps in the right direction and that is
- to say if you are giving physicians basically strong incentives to reduce cost but the key feature that I think is
- unique and potentially positions us well is that today as opposed to say when managed care was was first really on the
- rise say in the early 90s is that we have substantial extensions and healthcare information technology and
- the ability to actually measure quality and quality of care and a lot a lot of different conditions not all conditions
- it can be very challenging much more effectively than we have been able to in the past and so if you combined you know
- potentially strong incentives to lower cost with very strong incentives to provide high quality care the confluence
- of those two things is potentially a powerful mechanism to really kind of align incentives to approximate kind of
- what we would think the market would would offer you know if I go and buy something at the store say I go buy
- breakfast cereal we're not concerned about you know me making the wrong decisions or my decisions not reflecting
- sort of some optimum whereas in healthcare the information problems you know the namely that I don't know what I
- need and I'm relying on a physician to both inform me as well as sell me those goods and services it is is a
- problematic and then they're being paid by an outside you know a third party there is an argument that with
- information technology and with new incentive models we might be able to actually at least begin to approximate
- the appropriate incentives and try to cut out those sort of marginal services which
- are of low value while leaving intact the fact that we do like I think in general you know the hospital University
- University of Pennsylvania is right there I like the fact that I can go to hop if I get very sick and I think most
- Americans do on average so trying to align those incentives well while keeping intact what we have that's
- functioning quite well I think those mechanisms and the combination of IT and incentives might be able to to
- accomplish that now I mean you've done I'm studied extensively healthcare reform in Massachusetts I mean can you
- say I mean is there anything initiative there any lesson learned there even other places that you think could be
- really impactful for at the federal level for us to consider absolutely I mean I think there's a number of
- interesting lessons in Massachusetts and some of them are ongoing so in many ways
- Massachusetts was focused on kind of the former piece we were talking about which
- is Massachusetts was largely about insurance and the ACA is largely about insurance Massachusetts is now beginning
- to think about some ways to potentially tackle the cost growth and the fact that
- messages has had cost growth and in fact has had cost growth that has exceeded other states before their reform and
- after their reforms so I think there's there will be interesting lessons coming out of Massachusetts there but certainly
- from the perspective of the individual mandate the employer mandate and subsidized care where the the mechanisms
- in Massachusetts mimic very closely that's a sort of key structures of the ACA depending on what the Supreme Court
- does and I think you know there's a couple important lessons first is there is a fair amount of evidence from
- Massachusetts that basically the provision of insurance to the new put you know basically six percentage points
- new people you know of the population gained health insurance as a result of the reform and there was evidence that
- basically they were using the emergency room less both for outpatient visits and
- visits that eventually resulted in the impatient and in an inpatient admission there was also some evidence that they
- were basically getting access to outpatient care that could prevent hospitalizations that's a little more
- mixed but certainly some initial evidence for that and so I think there are some some early signs that that
- given our system providing access to insurance can actually make a more efficient delivery of health
- care and potentially maybe lower-cost but certainly improved health which is of great value so that's that's I think
- an optimistic lesson from Massachusetts the other big lesson relates to the in function of the insurance market and as
- I was saying earlier we know we've done some work and there is some evidence that when you implemented the individual
- mandate on top of an insurance market which had Community Rating and guaranteed-issue you did find that the
- new enrollees were differentially healthier at least on Hospital cost than the prior enrollees and that is
- suggestive of some degree of adverse selection in the advert in the absence of an individual mandate and it does
- suggest that's an important aspect now of course Massachusetts overall insurance market was functioning
- reasonably well but their individual market was very very expensive prior to the individual mandate and was not
- functioning very effectively so I think the individual mandate could be quite key if you really think we're gonna rely
- on exchanges an acquisition of individual health insurance to facilitate expansions in coverage now
- the other lesson from Massachusetts is in fact that when you when they did implement the reform of about half of
- the newly insured gained coverage through their employer and so that is I think not as consistent with a lot of
- the kind of projections for national reform but I think that that some of those projections are missing this
- underlying feature which I was talking about earlier which is people value health insurance you know even if you
- don't take it up you don't think of it as something that's totally worthless and so when you implement an individual
- mandate in some ways that just augments the underlying valuation and if in fact your employer it can be you know is
- providing you a benefit that you see as as something that you is well matched to
- you and something you value then the combination of your value for health insurance and the individual mandate can
- actually be a powerful incentive to get people to take up their existing employer sponsored health insurance and
- that seems to have happened in Massachusetts so in some recent work we've done we found that the newly
- insured in Massachusetts were willing to accept wage reductions on the on an average of six thousand dollars per year
- to gain employer sponsored health insurance and that Kordes almost exactly with the cost to their employer of
- providing that insurance so implicitly that Bay basically suggests that they the
- combination of their underlying value and and the individual mandate that doose's evaluation led them to basically
- value the health insurance benefits they received almost fully and that made it an incredibly efficient mechanism to
- expand health insurance because effectively they were able to to piggyback on the existing infrastructure
- expand coverage to that additional population and distort the labor market very very very minimally and so I think
- there are some lessons that suggest that this can be a very efficient tool and so
- I think you know there's obviously legal questions which are critical and in determining of the Supreme Court is
- focused on but from an economic perspective and a policy perspective I think it would be a major setback if we
- lose this tool as a mechanism for it for public policy as well as kind of undermine what is you know a big step
- forward in terms of health policy we've been trying for a hundred years to have some sort of comprehensive form of
- coverage and I think we are relatively close at this point and there is some evidence from Massachusetts that this
- could be an effective middle-of-the-road way to do it you
Brief Summary
The episode examines the Affordable Care Act's individual mandate and its critical role in U.S. healthcare reform amid Supreme Court deliberations.
Key points
- The Individual Mandate Explained. The individual mandate nudges people towards health insurance by imposing penalties for non-compliance.
- Healthcare Costs and Quality. Aligning incentives for providers could help manage healthcare costs while maintaining quality care.
- Lessons from Massachusetts. Massachusetts' healthcare reform offers critical insights for national policy, especially regarding insurance mandates.
Episode highlights
- The Individual Mandate ExplainedThe individual mandate nudges people towards health insurance by imposing penalties for non-compliance.“If at the end of the day you don’t have health insurance, you pay a penalty.”1:33Apr 11, 2012
- Healthcare Costs and QualityAligning incentives for providers could help manage healthcare costs while maintaining quality care.“Can we cut back the wasteful stuff without really undermining those incentives?”9:01Apr 11, 2012
- Lessons from MassachusettsMassachusetts' healthcare reform offers critical insights for national policy, especially regarding insurance mandates.“The provision of insurance led to a significant increase in the insured population.”13:02Apr 11, 2012
Tension
50/ 100Some tension





