Beyond the Affordable Care Act
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Wharton health care management professor Ezekiel J. Emanuel, one of the architects of the Affordable Care Act, has published a new book that offers an inside look at health care reform, as well as a critique of how the act has been implemented.
Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1qsTMGa 📂 Health Care Management;Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- hello i'm hogue levins and we're here at the wharton school video studio and today
- our guest is dr ezekiel emanuel who's a vice provost of the university of pennsylvania
- and formerly he was an advisor to the white house and he is one of the architects of the affordable care act
- dr emmanuel thanks for being with us it's great pleasure and today we're here to talk about your
- brand new book correct and let me start at the beginning the very cover and the title
- of this is reinventing american health care and the subtitle is how the affordable care act will
- improve our terribly complex blatantly unjust outrageously expensive grossly inefficient error-prone system
- and my question is were you at all concerned that that that subtitle is somewhat
- confrontational uh it's somewhat absolute were you concerned at all that it might turn off
- some of the readers that you would otherwise be able to influence well i do think that the description
- there the complexity the inefficiency the expensive error-prone system are well accepted we did
- before the affordable care act have that kind of system that was terribly expensive and
- inefficient had a lot of people uninsured i do think that the affordable care act is going to make a big dent in
- each one of those and i make that argument uh in the book although i should say the book is not
- just an argument about the affordable care act it's sort of tries to educate people about
- the health care system how various parties get paid how insurance came about in the united
- states all the efforts over hundreds of uh 100 years of trying to reform it how the affordable care act got passed
- what's in the affordable care act and then i do make predictions about the future so it's not just about the aca
- okay and in the book you take the congressional budget office to test you talk about the tyranny of
- the cbo and you say that although the congressional budget office scores are objective and nonpartisan
- they are frequently wrong and you talk about the bias and how it can create real harm by placing roadblocks for
- important and worthy legislation and you cite instances of from three decades of wrong
- cbo estimates so my question is how did the cbo scoring impede the aca uh and if there had not been cba scoring
- how would the aca be different so first of all i also say that we need an umpire
- i i recognize that the role the cbo the congressional budget office plays is absolutely essential
- you have to have someone who's going to objectively assess a bill but i also indicate as you point out
- that they have an institutional bias they're always willing to say discount savings
- and assess higher costs than you might because if they're wrong things don't cost as much
- or they save more than they anticipated they think there's no harm done to the system and part of what i wanted to
- point out is there is harm done to the system because good ideas that might have saved they say no it's
- really not going to save or it's only going to save a little or it might even cost
- they may be wrong on that and inhibit a lot of good ideas from coming forward and i do cite the
- over three decades from the 80s the 90s and the 2000s cases of major healthcare legislation where
- they simply have underestimated the savings uh that could be achieved the part d
- the uh medicare drug benefit is an excellent example their their cost estimate was 40
- too high that makes a very big difference in setting policy especially when every uh
- politician is constantly asking how does it score which means does it save money and
- there are a lot of programs that we wanted to put in to uh the affordable care act that didn't
- score or didn't score as much as the cbo would say and that means that you know when you're bargaining you
- don't retain them as uh uh for the bargain because you know it's not that expendable or you can't
- get as much savings from them and then there are you know i think i point out in the book lots of things
- where there's no precedent so they just guess and i'm not again i didn't want to fault
- them i did want to just indicate how it creates a certain kind of mindset everyone thinks they have this model
- which really does predict the future well they have a model that doesn't predict the future terribly well
- and uh to constantly be trying to guess what they're going to score it i think inhibits a lot more creative
- policy thinking than we might otherwise get of the elements uh for the potential
- elements for the ac that didn't score you know which one was the most important one you thought should be in
- and you regret it wasn't uh in general and this is separate from scoring in general the thing i'm most frustrated by
- is that we didn't have more payment reform in the bill because i do think that's a very important
- element to get us off the fee for service system which encourages using more services and of particular
- types that are highly paid to a system that doesn't encourage people just using services but
- actually keeping patients healthy keeping them out of the hospital i think that's a very important switch
- and again this is a case where i think the cbo scoring was less favorable to those changes the other
- thing i would say is that the cbo scoring tends to evaluate each individual change
- as opposed to putting them all together and for i think many changes a complete change uh that involves you know i.t
- uh disease management uh identifying high-risk people uh putting in place interventions uh
- those haven't been regularly and rigorously tested and so the cbo doesn't really have an idea about or doesn't
- think it can actually estimate with reliability savings but a lot of places have seen
- those changes give you a sort of directional savings and a a pretty good savings and
- but you know it doesn't meet cbo standards for including in their model and i think that kind of sort of
- experimentation doesn't get highly ranked nonetheless i recognize the important role of the cbo i don't
- we can't work without it in washington but i do think we all we and including the cbo ought to
- recognize the biases and flaws and try to figure out ways to counteract them okay in your in your frequent tv
- appearances and your interviews in other media at least the ones i've watched and the ones
- i've read uh over the last couple of years you've been uh you've been perceived to be a
- staunch supporter of the obama administration obviously and the aca parts of this book which are
- pretty critical seem uh to have a totally different tone is this a dramatic departure for you to be
- so critical of of internal white house management procedures now as opposed to the stance you took
- publicly in the past well i think a lot of people have tried to pigeonhole me in point of fact when the
- exchange went bad i had a pretty detailed critique in the new york times pretty public about what i think they needed to
- do to solve the problem uh including appoint a ceo they haven't done that you know and so i do think i've tried to
- be balanced in what has gone wrong and what has gone right you know i've actually been pretty out in the
- open i think it gets drowned out by the fact that i do think in general this the aca has been a big step in the right
- direction and is catalyzing positive change but there are plenty of things uh especially around the execution that
- i think could have gone uh better i i am disappointed we still don't have menu labeling
- uh regulations i have been disappointed about uh pcori the patient-centered outcome
- research institute not being aggressive enough and i think i've been actually pretty
- upfront about that but you know not everyone notices all the nuances of an academic
- and i think that's uh you know i am generally quite positive i think the bill did address
- many of the problems we had in the system and i've often said it's not a perfect bill in a democracy you can't
- expect a perfect a plus bill you're going to get compromises and that policy makers would
- prefer not to be there but politics dictates that they are you mention uh the ceo issue and in the
- part of the book that's a post-mortem inside the white house of what went wrong managerially
- it's sort of inside baseball but you can can explain a little bit about why a different kind of ceo might have
- made a difference in the way that healthcare.gov uh went bad so um i think you need to
- view the exchanges and the federal exchanges as a e-commerce site we should not view it as
- a program in the government like the va benefits it is much more analogous to say
- amazon or other e-commerce sites and in that regard it needs to be run like an e-commerce site not like a
- government program issuing regulations and that typically will require a ceo it'll require us
- a highly talented staff it'll require constant tweaking of the exchanges the rules how you want
- to show people what their options are and educate them and i've been pretty upfront about that i was upfront about
- that beginning in 2010 that i thought this was necessary for proper execution and i think if you look at the
- successful state exchanges like connecticut like california they've had that structure where they've
- had someone typically with insurance uh company experience or running an exchange uh being able to
- collect the right team and basically every morning get up thinking about how are we gonna make
- this better how are we gonna work with our suppliers the insurance companies how are we going to work with our
- customers to make sure they're having the right experience or that we can adjust what we're doing
- to make it better for them i think that's the proper way to run this thing again on the idea that this
- is more an e-commerce site than this is a government program back then did anyone actually say to
- nancy ann deparla we should have a ceo of this type and why did she elect to go first of all
- i don't think it was her decision i think this was a a decision inside uh the white house um and i can't tell you
- why they uh didn't go that route i mean i have as i mentioned in the book there was you know political
- considerations they had the administration uh we had been criticized about having too many
- czars of this and czars of that and they were worried about uh additional criticism but i think as
- has become clear over time uh getting the exchanges right was critical politically and even if you
- took short-term uh criticism for appointing a ceo and creating this structure that would run it like a
- business i think in the long term it was clearly not optimal to fail to do that in the book uh on
- that point uh you write though in a very positive way there is no reason to despair or give up on health
- care reform itself as many high technologies have shown it is possible to bounce back from flawed
- website rollouts but this is only possible if relentless focus on execution becomes a reality so the question is
- today has the white house changed and is it relentlessly executing this correctly
- well uh clearly when they appointed uh jeff science to uh uh i guess the word the correct word
- is rescue the uh exchange in websites uh he was uh focused uh the recent steve bill article
- does show that they really work 24 7 they got a really top flight team uh and i think that
- lesson uh should not be lost on them that that's really what you need uh when you launch and you know let's
- remember twitter was not a flawless launch lots of other companies have had problems with launching their website
- that have come back to be very successful and i certainly hope that the white house is paying attention to that okay
- back to a subject you mentioned payment reform and in the book you have a section on that
- and the whole issue of switching from a you know a four fee payment service to a more episodic
- one i've gone to any number of seminars and conferences this is a constant subject
- subject but i haven't been to any where anyone actually presents a plan to achieve that and there seems to be a
- great deal of confusion inertia no one knows what to do how do you take a four billion dollar a year urban health
- care network and completely unbuild its revenue systems at the same time you build
- something else that's not exactly defined how well first of all i do think in i believe it's chapter 12 of my book
- i do talk about healthcare health reform 2.0 and i do have a chapter about or a section there about uh getting more
- uh alternative payment models to fee for service and i do have a very uh plan actually
- so i do think that there is a plan uh i would suggest that there are three or four steps that would be very important
- to this and as you point out you're not going to get for example the university of
- pennsylvania overnight to be able to go from feast for service to alternative payment
- models but the approach therefore is well let's give it a guide pla path but all agree
- that at the end of some predefined time period i say a decade so 2022 is my time point by 2022
- 75 or 80 pick a number is off fee for service and that gives everyone sufficient
- planning time and ability to shift then you pick particular areas where you think
- you can move off the fee-for-service system quickly and allow the hospitals and health
- systems to experiment so as i say in the book step one is we have had a recent medicare experience called the
- ace demonstration the acute care episodes which pays bundled payment for cardiac procedures and orthopedic
- procedures stents cardiac catheterizations cabbages coronary bypasses pacemaker placement hips and knees you
- give the institutions and surgeons a bundle payment that has shown to save some money and
- improve quality of care that's a place to start very defined i as i point out in the book the bundle
- used by medicare in the demonstration wasn't perfect and we'd like to try an experiment to expand it to include
- shared decision making at the start so every patient undergoing these procedures
- is given an information sheet or a video to see whether they want in or out and then it includes rehabilitation
- after the procedure as well as a guarantee for up to six months that anything that
- goes wrong say with the hip replacement is going to be covered free of charge that
- you can phase in pretty quickly because we have evidence it works then you take another area like cancer
- and i think cancer is a very good area because we have a lot of guidelines we have a lot of agreement
- on how patients should be treated and begin to identify very high volume high cost cancers that
- can be bundled and this i think provides you a a path way forward to move off the fee for
- service system into a system where people are not paid to do more but to do higher
- quality care efficiently and that i think is a plan that can take us to 2022 and shifting a
- lot of payments off the fee for service system and i think that's a great plan in theory and i guess the question
- is within the aca how do you actually get hospital systems to begin to do this well first of all first of
- all the aca one of the i do think one of the smart provisions we put in was the secretary of health and human services
- has the authority without getting additional legislation to nationalize to take a a experiment a
- demonstration project that has shown to either save money and or improve quality and nationalize
- it across medicare she doesn't need to go to the hospital she can say all right in two years we're going to
- start paying this way and give them two years to figure out how they're going to do it
- let's remember we have a lot of really smart people running these health systems including the university of
- pennsylvania you tell them what the rules are they will adapt to those rules i have no
- doubt about it and they just want those rules i mean one of the things that's true
- as i go around the country is they feel like a lot of doctors and health systems feel
- like they're caught in two boats at the same time which is they're paid fee for service and everyone is telling
- them oh you've got to improve the quality of your care you've got to become more
- efficient and yet they're not being paid to do those things and they would i think
- in general prefer to be paid to do that so they wouldn't lose money while trying to improve the quality of
- their system okay and in the payment section you also get into graduate medical education
- 10 billion dollars from medicare every year and i can't remember whether your word was
- useless but essentially uh it's not being tracked or assessed assessed well how it's being used right
- you indicate that the students coming out are simply not prepared for modern day
- digitally based team-oriented care right what's the answer to that how do you change that you say it must be
- changed what are the changes do you think that well again in the book i i think we make
- pretty clear during medical school first we ought to shorten medical school second we ought to have some focus on
- training people in team-based care training people in digital medicine as you point out how do you work with
- various wireless monitors at home or wireless compliance devices at home that people need to be trained for that
- we also need to train them in the outpatient setting right now if you're uh in medical school
- and interned resident the vast majority of your time 90 plus percent of your time is spent
- treating patients in a hospital whereas in the new system much less time much fewer patients are
- going to be in the hospital doctors are going to spend much less time treating patients in the hospital and
- yet that's how we train them so we need to emphasize you now have to provide half the training outside of a
- hospital that's complicated i recognize it and again this isn't a change that can
- happen overnight but you have to give deadlines otherwise no one's going to have an
- incentive to change their system and i think those kind of changes in addition i think i mentioned in the book
- that we need to train doctors much more in management change management how do you actually
- manage change negotiations because they're constantly negotiating whether with their
- colleagues or their patients or payers we need to train them in strategic planning
- how to use data how to implement changes so i think there's a lot uh that needs to be done
- to change the medical education we've had i mean one of the ironies is medical education
- really took the structure it has today 100 years ago with the flexner report medical system has changed a lot the
- kinds of treatments we're giving to patients have changed a lot you would think medical education should
- change more than it has okay uh one of the in in your book you go through various trends as you look
- forward and bravely make predictions about what's going to happen and you say this is a brave
- you know brave test i recognize the stupidity of making tradition predictions mostly because phil tetlock
- is a professor here at the wharton school uh and at the university of pennsylvania
- and he's written a whole book about how dangerous it is for experts to make opinion
- make predictions so i recognize it's it's difficult but i also recognize it's essential all
- of us are making predictions about the future whether you're running a hospital whether you're a doctor or an investor
- you're making predictions about how the future is going to evolve and i thought well i've got a lot of
- experience knowledge i'll make some predictions and again i've learned from phil tetlock
- that you've got to be very specific what exactly quantitatively is the prediction if there's a quantitative
- prediction and give a specific date so i try to be as rigorous as possible and i know that i might be
- held up to laughter and insult if my predictions turn out to be wrong one of those predictions is that in the
- next six years at least a thousand hospitals across the country will close and within that you you suggest that the
- community either that part of the community that works at those hospitals or the patients who use
- those hospitals that they should not fight this can you explain that more why why would we want to see a thousand
- hospitals close and just sort of just let it happen uh first of all uh the hospital occupancy rate
- uh in the united states is now under 70 that means uh there are lots of beds that are not being occupied
- and a lot of the hot there are a number of hospitals under 50 percent and they are not necessarily shouldn't
- necessarily be there take vermont for a population 400 000 people they have 11 hospitals that's
- just unnecessary second a lot of these hospitals uh as i mentioned we're one of the
- reasons we're going to see hospitals close is because a lot of care that hitherto had been delivered in
- hospitals can be more effectively and at less cost delivered at home or in other settings
- there's no reason to go into a hospital for example for a colonoscopy you can do it in outpatient setting at a
- cheaper rate and with the same kind of quality many patients who we used to admit to
- the hospital for example for exacerbations of of emphysema or congestive heart failure
- can be treated just as well at home so we'll see that shift well if you treat people at home
- the nurses as i think i make clear in the book who were once working the halls are now going to be
- visiting patients at home they're not going to be unemployed if the main worry about closing a hospital is
- employment you know will lose important high-paying jobs we're going to shift those jobs to other
- services in the health care industry while i'm a cost control hawk you might say when it comes to health
- care i am also a realist we are not taking a system that now is spending 2.9 trillion dollars on health care and
- going to reduce that to 2.6 trillion the only question is how fast or slow does it go up from 2.9
- trillion to 3.2 3.3 trillion and to the extent that it's on the upward slope that means
- more people are going to be employed in the healthcare system more services are going to be delivered
- and therefore i think when we close hospitals we shouldn't look as if all of that's going away it's going to
- be redeployed in other areas people who were coming into this hospital aren't suddenly not going to
- need health care services they're going to need them in a different way in different facilities
- or maybe at home and that's going to be i think if you're worried about the employment part
- going to employ plenty of people and i think again is going to be better for patients and
- we should remember the main goal of a health care system is not employment the main goal of a health
- care system is keeping the population healthy okay and one uh one of the last questions we're talking about
- updating the law and in in the book you're talking about the aca is an enormous thing it'll make
- significant changes uh eve even as it will need further modifications and revisions
- and uh just the other day um we had andrew dreyfus from massachusetts come and he and
- others talked about how in massachusetts since the law was passed in 2006. it's been significantly amended six
- different times and they anticipate an ongoing endless amendments because of corrections because of
- unintended consequences etc the aca is is one it never made it through conference
- now it's like a non-dynamic law what do you see happening as this non-changeable law
- pushes forward and can't be corrected is that sufficient to the aca or where is that going to go
- uh it seems in the poison atmosphere of washington it's unlikely that it will be amended is
- that so i think i think what andrew dreifus says is right healthcare i think the opening line of
- my disclaimer is healthcare is dynamic and we similarly need policies and laws and regulations relative to healthcare
- to be dynamic and to respond as the system evolves as flaws are found and ironically if you talk to people in
- washington who when they're not engaged in the partisan battle there's a lot of agreement about the
- kinds of changes they want to be put into place but we're locked into this uh what seems to be an endless uh battle
- over the soul of the aca i actually believe that's unfortunate i think almost everyone no matter whether
- you're republican or democrat believes it's unfortunate and i think that we're probably going to
- fight two more elections on the aca the 2014 election and maybe the 2016 presidential election and then hopefully
- uh my hope is that we'll be able to get all right it's the law of the land uh let's
- deal with uh the problems and let's see if we can improve things i will say my uh best hope on that
- regard is before i went on to on tv last night with bill o'reilly uh he said to me
- look i don't want to talk about the aca it is the law of the land it's coming into being i want to talk about
- responses to it and for in for example how doctors are responding or not responding and don't want to participate
- in the aca and i uh took that as uh wow that's uh revealing and you know i wish you would say it on the air
- because that i think would change the discussion and allow us to move forward but i can tell you i've talked to a
- number of staffers of republican senators and congressmen and they recognize and actually have a lot of
- agreement with the things i want to propose i think you know when i talk to conservative
- uh health policy experts there's a lot of overlaps 60 70 percent overlap between my views and their views
- and i think we could actually make a lot of progress if we put the ideology behind us and try to
- improve the health care system in this country and you know again i was involved in passage in enacting the aca
- and helping to design various provisions um i recognize it's flawed it's not a perfect bill as i said before it's it's
- not enable you're not going to get perfection in a democracy and it needs to be constantly healthcare
- system needs to be constantly tweaked the idea that we do it once and for all that is just false and looking down the
- same road in the book you talk about how the aca has been a great achievement for
- president obama at the same time it has wounded him politically really badly and you also say that you think down the
- road that history will actually look back at him and smile tell us how and why i not not many people are are
- students of american history but let's take a pause and a little diversion to answer your question
- harry truman when he was actually president was not very popular some people don't uh don't fully
- remember but the 1948 in that year he was more or less written off everyone was sure he was not going
- to be re-elected even the chicago tribune on election day published you know dewey defeats truman
- uh so here's a guy who is not very popular and a lot of the things he did integrate the army drop the bombs on
- hiroshima the marshall plan nato the cold war were at the time you know he wasn't popular for integrating the
- army the marshall plan barely passed the senate he had to call the marshall plan instead
- of the truman plan to get it to pass uh very you know not very popular president
- now we lionize harry truman and we think he's like the greatest you know he's a near great president
- behind uh washington lincoln and rose franklin roosevelt he stands with people like teddy roosevelt
- uh and others as a near great president well i think that the affordable care act is
- going to play the same way once it plays out once it begins to transform the system if
- in fact you know even half my predictions are true it gets healthcare inflation down to gdp
- uh it transforms the delivery so we're really taking care of the chronically ill and the mentally ill
- you will see people say wow this really did make a very positive move in the system
- it was a very important change it's going to take a decade to see those effects i believe again because we're dealing
- with such a big part of the economy such a complex part of the economy i would also say i think i
- say this very clearly in the book the wounds that politically have been suffered
- because of the aca are a result of bad communications about the aca what's in it what it means for
- the average person and the bad implementation of the exchanges neither of which were inherent or
- necessary both were in as i say in the book somewhat self-inflicted we didn't the obama administration didn't do a
- particularly stand-up job either of communicating around it or executing and i think there's nothing
- inherent or necessary in the aca being viewed as negatively as it is today it could have been different a
- perfect ending dr emmanuel thanks for being with us and good luck with your book
- thank you very much you
Brief Summary
Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel discusses his book on the ACA's impact and future healthcare reforms.
Key points
- Reinventing American Healthcare. Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel discusses his new book and the Affordable Care Act's impact.
- CBO Scoring and ACA. Emanuel critiques the Congressional Budget Office's impact on healthcare legislation.
- Payment Reform Challenges. Emanuel outlines the need for payment reform in healthcare and presents a plan.
- The Future of Medical Education. Medical education has not evolved as much as the medical system itself. 'You would think medical education should change more than it has.'
- Predictions About Hospital Closures. A bold prediction states that at least a thousand hospitals will close in the next six years. 'One of those predictions is that in the next six years at least a thousand hospitals across the country will close.'
- The ACA's Political Wounds. The Affordable Care Act has caused significant political backlash, but its long-term impact may be positive. 'The wounds that politically have been suffered because of the ACA are a result of bad communications.'
Episode highlights
- Reinventing American HealthcareDr. Ezekiel Emanuel discusses his new book and the Affordable Care Act's impact.“The Affordable Care Act is going to make a big dent in the system.”1:18Mar 11, 2014
- CBO Scoring and ACAEmanuel critiques the Congressional Budget Office's impact on healthcare legislation.“CBO scoring inhibits a lot of good ideas from coming forward.”2:20Mar 11, 2014
- Payment Reform ChallengesEmanuel outlines the need for payment reform in healthcare and presents a plan.“We need to shift off the fee-for-service system.”12:30Mar 11, 2014
- The Future of Medical EducationMedical education has not evolved as much as the medical system itself. 'You would think medical education should change more than it has.'19:47Mar 11, 2014
- Predictions About Hospital ClosuresA bold prediction states that at least a thousand hospitals will close in the next six years. 'One of those predictions is that in the next six years at least a thousand hospitals across the country will close.'20:58Mar 11, 2014
- The ACA's Political WoundsThe Affordable Care Act has caused significant political backlash, but its long-term impact may be positive. 'The wounds that politically have been suffered because of the ACA are a result of bad communications.'29:31Mar 11, 2014
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





