The Health Care Landscape: Changes and Challenges Ahead
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Bruce Broussard, president and CEO of Humana, acknowledges that the health care industry has been in a state of flux as the details of the Affordable Care Act continue to be ironed out. In an interview with Knowledge@Wharton, he offers his take on Obamacare and the challenges -- and opportunities -- it presents. 📂 Leadership;Health Care Management
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] hello I'm hog Levens from knowledge at Wharton and today we're here with Bruce
- brussard who is the CEO and president of human the fourth largest Healthcare Insurance Group Bruce welcome to
- knowledge at Wharton well thank you I'm so glad to be here Bruce uh on the web this morning I see that your your
- comments in Louisville and earlier in Texas uh raised something of a buzz uh there uh you said that uh were there are
- a lot of bumps in a road coming with the implementation of the Affordable Care Act and also very interesting uh you
- indicated that the price of insurance wasn't likely to be going down anytime soon and this has to do with the
- 3:1 ratio and the way that's will be tightened up can you uh uh tell us a little bit more about that yeah hog I I
- we first I want to say that we are very very positive on the fact that healthc care reform is going to expand coverage
- so we're we're glad about that but it is going to raise the cost of care and what
- we see is is that the 3 to1 ban that we're talking about is really going to uh cause the younger population and the
- healthier population to pay more um to help with the older population because that band is going to restrict your
- pricing of the difference between the lowest and the highest and so young people who are very healthy will be
- paying more than they expect to pay in order to fund old people who will be using more than certainly than the young
- people fundamentally that's a good way to say it and you know there's a there's a lot of work going on right now in the
- details of healthcare reform so it's not completely finalized but the way it looks today and what the experts are
- telling us is I think the public is going to see an increase in healthcare Insurance in
- 2014 and overall looking down the road at the implementation of the Affordable Care Act you're the Press coverage of
- your remarks seem to be saying that uh you were still concerned about the fragmented kind of uh uh somewhat
- chaotic nature of where everything was going could you give us an idea of uh you indicated there were bumps in the
- road what are some of the largest bumps that concern you on the insurance side and on the care delivery side well one
- of the challenges we have is CMS has a lot of work going on right now and so we have not seen all the details around the
- healthcare reform so we sit here now in February and the implementation is going
- to be at the end of the year in fact people will start buying in the coming um probably in the fourth quarter or so
- and so we're asking the question of just some more details in that aspect of that
- so first it's just trying to provide the details the second aspect it is so complicated it is such a complicated
- Bill and there's so many interrelated details that I don't think anyone knows all the various different parts of this
- um aspect of it and the concern is is what we don't know in terms of uh the health insurance exchanges which are a
- large part of all this um we're looking down the road it's a matter of months now before things have to start
- happening uh we know some states are doing some things some states are refusing to do things some states are
- setting up their own some are going Federal uh what are your actual expectations of what will be there uh
- you know on this upcoming deadline do you think we'll make the deadline do you think it's realistic to expect Health a
- year from now health exchanges will be up and running and actually be in use in 50 states I don't know if it'll be in 50
- states I mean I think there are going to be Decisions by some some states that will probably decide not to do that um I
- actually today is the final deadline of what states have to decide if it's going
- to be a federal program or a state program in that regard I um I do think that when we talk about
- bumps in the road I think the The Hope and I think everyone's intention is to get it um off the ground and I think
- they I don't see any reason different differently from that but I do think that there will be a lot of details that
- have to be worked out over the coming months that that could prevent it but I I think the intentions are fully to have
- it up and on the cost issue of the young versus the old do you think the public fully appreciates what's coming do you
- think think the Press has gotten this right or do you think this is a subject that has or has not been uh talked about
- enough in public I don't think it's been talked about enough in public C I think
- the the plan has really been talked about around the expansion and and the communication of the reform has been
- around that but I do not see there's been a real large um conversation around the what the impact is to the the public
- uh and in terms of and in terms of the Health Insurance Exchange is the latest reports out of human uh are that you
- hope to open them uh you hope to be part of them in 10 states uh can you tell us the 10 states
- or uh we're really not telling the 10 states but there are there are states that today we um have a significant
- presence in in states where we feel that we can offer the the best plan for members that participate in the exchange
- so it's really our our bigger states that we we're focusing on and I'm guessing that some of those States will
- be St established exchanges and some of them are likely to be Federal established exchanges do you have any
- sense of which will be better in terms of business model for you I don't know if we have one that's uh better from a
- um a point of view of financial or for that matter ease of use uh but we do think that uh a federal funded is is
- easier for us because we're able to deal with one exchange and the rules of one exchange as opposed to dealing with
- multiple rules of of each state next issue uh we're really interested in is uh the whole issue of retail medicine
- and by that we mean over the last several years there been an explosion of the creation of walk-in clinics mostly
- staffed by uh uh nurse practitioners in drugstores in mallfront stores um in other consumer venues and
- in parallel there's been uh uh uh ambulatory uh facilities popping up everywhere that are essentially a
- cheaper alternative to emergency med Med um and I'm just wondering in terms I know that that human is becoming
- involved in some of that and in the big picture uh is this whole retail medicine
- thing a good thing or a bad thing for big insurance companies and or big Health delivery companies I think for
- the consumer it's a it's a good thing I think it's um cost effective I think it's also brings convenience and what we
- see in our relationship with our customers is that they are asking for that they're asking for something that
- is cost effective and convenient that um and there's a lot of conditions today that can be um appropriately treated in
- those settings uh so we're we're actually excited about that we have a organization called Concentra that
- actually has a lot of those clinics and we also have guidance centers um in a lot of our markets that um help in that
- ability to provide that convenience and costeffective Care does Concentra function as as kind of a feeder Network
- for any of your other products or it's just a standalone thing it does it um at um if it's an episodic treatment so if
- someone comes down with a cold and needs a needs some help there then um if it is
- a longer standing condition we'll refer them back to their primary care physician or to um whatever provider
- that they that they have a relationship with uh so irrelevant if it's a human uh
- physician or a physician a non-human we still refer them back to that that physician
- some of the observers have uh raised concerns about uh patients who go to Minute Clinics and and other kind these
- sorts of drugstore clinics uh and I think the numbers I forget the percentage is a high percentage of all
- who go next time also go there rather than their primary care physician there's a concern that these clinics
- have the ability to disconnect patients from the continuity of of primary care and and all the the health implications
- of that what are your thoughts on that well two two sides of that you bring up two very interesting points one is the
- from the standpoint that they are voting with their feet they're voting with the
- price and the convenience side so if they're going back it's an enjoyable experience that is an experience that is
- that is U uh something that they desire the second aspect I think you're pointing out to is a a a fundamental
- challenge in the healthcare delivery system and that is around connectivity of information and the healthc care has
- been divided among itself within silos and that connectivity of information has been lacking we are optimistic in the
- future that that particular issue will be taken care of and so that if they do go to an episodic kind of um u u service
- such as a Urgent Care Center or a primary care that when they do decide to go back into their Continuing Care um
- delivery system that they're able to get their information but I still believe that uh you will see a continued growth
- in the retail side because of that convenience and price and I think the real key for us as leaders in healthcare
- is how do you connect that to the more traditional side where there is more uh chronic conditions and more acute care
- needed and some strategic speculation if you look down the road 10 years and tell
- me uh the the uh the networks not necessarily human but the networks of these clinics and these Ambulatory Care
- Centers and the traditional hospitals and other care Delivery Systems where do you see the relationship going are we
- likely to see them most of them become aligned feeder systems are we likely to see parallel competition where do where
- do you think it's going in the big big picture I think the primary care model will continue to grow to be a very
- influential part into the referral system of Health Care um whether it's a primary care model in the uh setting
- that you're referring to a a retail setting or a primary care in a traditional setting around a f Family
- Practice delivery model but we we are big Believers that that model will continue to be a very important part of
- healthcare because Health Care needs somebody to help navigate through the Journey of care and the primary care um
- Family Practice oriented Physicians are really at the Key of that and the issue the one point you raised which is
- chronic care and these clinics and Ambulatory Care Centers there's a great deal of concern among primary care
- physicians we've talked to and and hospitals and others that chronic care particularly conditions like like
- diabetes account for a lot of the care that's given and a lot of the revenues that are generated and if the clinic
- systems begin to uh pull in uh you know diabetic patients on a big scale it has Revenue implications for everyone do you
- see uh again looking down five or 10 years do you see that that the The Chronic care delivery will become a
- normal part of what these Clinic networks and even Ambulatory Care networks do I think um with staffed with
- primary care physicians they very well could do that I think um I believe that as we see the future that healthc care
- will continue to be more segmented and and uh patients like diabetes uh diabetics will actually be have a
- holistic view of Health Care I mean treatment so they will not only have a primary care aspect they'll have a
- nutritionist there I think they'll have foot specialists in there and there will
- be able to be taken care of it from a holistic point of view from from an individual and to me that's where a
- whether you're a family practice or a Urgent Care Center is how you can compete it's looking at the person in a
- much more holistic fashion as opposed to a particular treatment um and I think the the the patients will go to that
- particular model as opposed to just convenience because you're delivering much more
- value okay Bruce another big Trend out there in in healthcare land today uh is this movement uh in keeping with the
- Affordable Care Act towards team care bundled care uh a completely different sort of integrated approach to healthc
- care I know that human has been involved in this longer than most other uh companies tell us a little about where
- this is all going and what this is going to mean to healthc care reform in the very near future yeah we have a and we
- have a big belief that um integrated care is an important part of the delivery model both in being able to
- reward for cost and quality and being able to oversee the the Journey of Health for individuals in fact we saw
- that in recent president's um speech around talking about pay for performance that was a I think a very highlighted
- the need for that at himana we believe in the integrated delivery system through what we refer to as the
- integrated model and that really has three components to it one component is on the delivery system where we create
- relationships with primary care physicians and providers in general around aligned incentives on quality and
- cost the member experience is another area that we Orient to and really encouraging people to be actively
- involved in their health care and uh we have a just as an example we have a particular company called Vitality that
- they actually encourage people around membership and reward on health so if you take 10,000 steps a day you get 15
- points and what that we've found is between understanding your health through health risk assessment and
- participating in these programs you become actively engaged in your uh health and and really have an impact on
- that and then the last is data and analytics and I think for us to um to really make advancements in care uh we
- need to have the data in analytics and that includes integration of systems along with clinical analytics and then
- also consumers and how far away are we from that it part that's a huge concern yeah
- um there seems to be hundreds of silos of different systems uh looking down the road how soon do you think there will be
- some sort of rudimentary Universal system of medical information exchange between all of us I think uh we're
- making progress there slow the first step was to to Really wire the offices which was the electronic medical record
- now everyone has separate medical electronic medical records the next step is bringing those together uh healthc
- care exchanges will probably be the first step in that aspect of that and actually human has taken that step by
- acquiring a company just recently called certify and it is a company that connects one EMR to another EMR so that
- we and our providers can see not only what's going on at the particular Primary Care office for example or a
- hospital we can see across the um Health Care delivery system and and what has that individual seen and both recently
- and also historically okay and I think that brings us almost to the end let me ask you one final question which is
- again looking forward uh to the implementation uh of of the Affordable Care Act what do you think will be what
- is the biggest unappreciated challenge that insurers and Care delivery companies will face going down the road
- into that the the challenge that the general public least understands well we've talked about pricing I mean
- obviously that's the case I I think um I honestly think that's probably the largest issue is the pricing aspect of
- that there's a lot of details to work out the problem is we don't know those details um and that's why I say it'll be
- a bumpy road until we know those details and are able to work that out I think it'll be um it'll be just some some
- bumps on the road I do think and I have very large um um a very big belief that the future of Health Care is is is on a
- good road I think we are in some troubled times right now relative to the implementation this but I look to the
- Future and I see technology Information Systems I see the ability to bring all this together and have an impact on the
- cost and Care long term great thank you very much for being at knowledge at Wharton well thank you very much enjoyed
- it [Music]
Brief Summary
Bruce Brussard discusses the Affordable Care Act's impact on insurance costs and the rise of retail medicine.
Key points
- Healthcare Reform Challenges. Bruce discusses the bumps in the road for implementing the Affordable Care Act.
- Retail Medicine's Impact. Bruce shares insights on the rise of retail medicine and its implications for insurance.
- The Future of Healthcare. Bruce discusses the future of healthcare and the integration of care delivery systems.
Episode highlights
- Healthcare Reform ChallengesBruce discusses the bumps in the road for implementing the Affordable Care Act.“There are a lot of bumps in the road coming with the implementation of the Affordable Care Act.”0:45Mar 27, 2013
- Retail Medicine's ImpactBruce shares insights on the rise of retail medicine and its implications for insurance.“For the consumer, retail medicine is a good thing; it's cost-effective and convenient.”6:49Mar 27, 2013
- The Future of HealthcareBruce discusses the future of healthcare and the integration of care delivery systems.“I see technology and information systems having an impact on cost and care long term.”16:20Mar 27, 2013
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





