Nike FuelBand: The Band, the Brand Strike a Goal

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Read the transcript: http://knlg.net/1el4fMu

Nike's FuelBand is one of its hottest sellers ever. Three Wharton professors explain why. 📂 Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so product Focus marketing is what happens if you think of a market as between a seller and a buyer and you
  2. think of one extreme there's a sellers Market in The Other Extreme there's a buyer's market in a sellers Market if
  3. you want the product you have to go to them so that gives them a lot of power in that exchange and under those
  4. circumstances people tend to do what's called product focused marketing and what that basically is since you're
  5. going to come to me if I want the product I work on developing a good product I I work on reducing costs and
  6. I'm very much um concerned with selling my product when Nike fuel band first came out this is a Nike fuel band I had
  7. one of the early ones and this is one of the first generation ones um since there
  8. was no not much else in the marketplace then they could really focus on the unique features I didn't really consider
  9. anything else I bought a Nike fuel band because I want wanted something that monitored my calories my steps my energy
  10. Etc and there really wasn't very much choice so that's product Focus marketing what happens is again we're
  11. thinking about the exchange between the buyers and sellers as more competition comes in as there are other substitutes
  12. then buyers have more choice and in that case when the when the marketer wants you to buy from them rather than from
  13. the competition they have to start focusing on what you want and so then it becomes a customer focused Market well
  14. this is the second generation I don't have it yet but the second generation of the Nike fuel band really focus on the
  15. way the customers were using the product Less on the way Nike thought it should be used so actually one of the things
  16. that's different first of all there's color in it so they come out with different colors well vault is the new
  17. yellow color so it's kind of sexy color the other thing I think is really interesting is a lot of people were
  18. using this Fuel band you you don't want to have that many things lining up on your wrist and so one of the things that
  19. Fuel band did almost as an afterthought was to tell the time well it turns out because people didn't want to have so
  20. many things lining up on their wrist they were using the F fuel brand as time but in order to get the time in the
  21. original version you got to like psych oh I passed my goal you got to uh cycle through all the different things look
  22. how long it's taking me and now I can tell you the time the new version you just double click it and the time comes
  23. out right away that's more C customer focus it's giving the customers what they want and giving them a reason to
  24. buy this over the competition so if you're looking through these trends of marketing product focus
  25. when there isn't a lot of competition Market gets more competitive and then you start being customer focused what's
  26. happened in the last say 10 years is we've got a connected Community now and there's social media there's the
  27. internet there's well what's interesting about this product is every day you can
  28. upload your data to the internet and you can keep track of it that way because it
  29. doesn't hold that much data on each thing so you can keep a long record I've had my record now for about six months
  30. what I've done in addition I can interact with my friends who also have Nike fuel ban or I can interact with
  31. them on Facebook and we can share data and I can tell my friend when she's being really lazy move it you're too
  32. slow you know and she can tell me when I'm doing well so we have this whole connected community and I think over
  33. time the power for Nike behind the fuel band is going to be the data and once they can get that connected to your
  34. Facebook activity connected to other things that they can tell about it they can start really marketing different
  35. kinds of products to you um and increased customer share and share of wallet well once you know like how I use
  36. the product you might be able to Market shoes to me on that you know Market certain kinds of clothing if you can
  37. upload my data with my Facebook data you'll know like well I'm using this in New York or I'm using it in San
  38. Francisco or something like that or you can see who my friends are and can connect my friend then you can mark it
  39. to my friends and things like that so once you have that data if you figure I now have your internet data I have your
  40. offline data I now have they know how many calories I'm burning they know when I'm doing these kinds of things you link
  41. all those data together and you have a really pretty big picture of your consumer um and it seems like there's a
  42. lot of opportunity to try to add customer value by understanding exactly what you want and where you
  43. are these activity trackers or electronic Fitness bands or whatever you want to call them are actually a great example
  44. or great opportunity for customer centricity and action part of it is the data which which we can talk about
  45. separately but part of it is it gives a a a company a chance to really surround its valuable customers with a variety of
  46. product services and information and to use that information to figure out which
  47. kinds of products and services to deliver up to the right kinds of customer so it recognizes that customers
  48. are all different from each other it recognizes that what they're doing how they're moving around can interplay with
  49. uh what other uh uh behaviors they have what they eat what kinds of exercises they do where they live what their
  50. lifestyle is so so it gives the company a chance to really better understand a customer not necessarily the the
  51. specific details of their heart rate and so on but just a a better picture that they couldn't get any other way it's
  52. it's hard to say how much of this data is actually being stored and used by the companies because the data is going
  53. someplace where it can be seen not only by the user but by other people so for instance in the case of of the Nike fuel
  54. band uh that it becomes social fund that I could see my friends activities and compared to mine so the data is
  55. definitely being stored somewhere but of course the user has a lot of control over it one of the other great
  56. opportunities with these electronic gadgets is that it lets companies that Beyond those that are already in this
  57. space it gives them an Entre point to deal with customers in a new and different way so for instance I can see
  58. a big pharmaceutical firm giving these bands out giving them to people giving them a service as a way to understand
  59. what they're doing and not necessarily to try to push pills on them but uh all the Pharma firms are talking about
  60. customer centricity they recognize that they need to understand their customers more than just developing new drugs and
  61. hoping that people are going to buy them so it does create new kinds of business
  62. opportunities and I can see lots of different kinds of firms besides Pharma getting into the space as
  63. well all the data that's being collected by these electronic Fitness bands it's a
  64. blessing and a curse on one hand it adds to the whole idea of Big Data it gives us all kinds of of of columns in a
  65. database all kinds of observations that we didn't have before in fact we couldn't have even dreamed of a few
  66. years ago so on one hand all of the challenges and opportunities associated with with Big Data uh are associated
  67. with with these new kinds of data structures but there are opportunities there as well and if we can triangulate
  68. someone's purchasing habits with their media consumption with their exercise activities with their sleep habits and
  69. so on we can get a more complete picture about who does what I'm not saying that
  70. this kind of information will transform our understanding of customer behavior I'm not saying that it will contribute
  71. significantly to our estimates of customer life time value but it can't hurt and it's so new and it's so
  72. different it's hard to say just how much incremental contribution it will have so
  73. it'll be great to see that we understand what kinds of statistical methods we'd want to use but the results the impact
  74. of this these new data sources is something that the the future Generations will tell
  75. us we're just barely getting started with with these uh new electronic Fitness bands uh I think there's a lot
  76. of people today who are are messing around with them they're trying them out sometimes
  77. unsuccessfully uh it's not clear what they're doing with the data or how they're sharing it what uh what what
  78. companies are doing with the data but I see this as more of a generational kind of issue uh I imagine that the Next
  79. Generation we start putting these these Fitness bands on our children when they're not even a year old it'll just
  80. be uh something that we want to monitor all the time obviously for different reasons when they're infants or toddlers
  81. than when they're adults but people are going to be used to wearing these things
  82. they're going to be used to using the data the the whole idea of the Quantified Self a concept that a lot of
  83. people are talking about today it tends to apply more to grown-ups can I look at
  84. myself and my exercise and my nutrition and all kinds of habits but when the Quantified Self Works its way down to
  85. one and two year olds and when they're accustomed to doing it when they start tying in their exercise activities with
  86. their social media usage and and and their their schoolwork and so on we're going to get just a much more complete
  87. picture about individuals now on one hand that can be a bit creepy it can be a bit intrusive it might be a bit too
  88. much A lot of that data might be useless but it's going to be a new era and the idea of people managing their own data
  89. figuring out what the value of that data is to themselves and maybe economically
  90. a lot of folks are talking about that a lot of companies are developing new business models around that idea but I
  91. think that these gadgets these armbands that people are wearing is going to be the major breakthrough to let people
  92. understand the value of their data uh and uh and I think these business models will take off as a result of these these
  93. gadgets moving their way down to Children Well I think the really interesting thing about the Nike fuel
  94. band is it potentially appeals to a very very wide range of users everybody from
  95. kind of the serious athlete who's interested really monitoring what's going on with their body to the
  96. so-called uh weekend warrior maybe people like you and Ice Steve who like to play a bit of tennis a bit of
  97. basketball this and that here and there so it's potentially a very very wide group I think it also cuts across all of
  98. the traditional segmentation variables like gender it's both for men and for women uh cuts across various age groups
  99. various socioeconomic brackets so this is a product I think if marketed effectively uh potentially has a very
  100. very wide Target group and a number of segments within that so as we've been discussing Steve in our
  101. other sessions pricing is a very very difficult thing to get right because the price has to be something obviously that
  102. makes sufficient margin for the firm uh the price also has to be uh fair and relevant relative to the competition or
  103. whatever those other points of comparison and products are and it also has to be something that the customer uh
  104. feels comfortable with so I think 149 is a price that's sufficiently high that I
  105. don't just feel that like this is a cheap piece of plastic around my wrist it's something that really has Tech
  106. technology uh embedded in it that's a a good product and an interesting product um it's not so high that it's going to
  107. be completely inaccessible but the point of comparison is very very interesting is this like a $50 monitor uh that would
  108. monitor my heart clearly it does a little bit more than that so I don't want that point of comparison is it a
  109. new sort of piece of technology like an iPod or an iPad or an iPhone something that we're all used to sort of carrying
  110. around but it's kind of related to those because it has a USB connection where I
  111. get the data feed so I think it's really um interesting from a pricing point of view of how you use all of those things
  112. that we discussed to communicate this value of course it ends in a nine so it's sort of Cheaper Than 150 in some
  113. sense but it doesn't overly cheapen the product so those are all the various elements that presumably Nike thought
  114. about when they set the price you know here's the cost here's the willingness to pay what's the right comparison in
  115. terms of the competition and then also the other things that affect fairness in the channel and so of course you want to
  116. take into account what the various competitors are doing and what the early products like the Fitbit and so on in
  117. this category were and also what might be coming next so how could one then as has been done with other products in in
  118. this General class um add to the product line through different colors different
  119. Technologies maybe different levels of service in terms of data feed so this is also a product where we might start to
  120. see that kind of differentiation coming through too so I think this is a really interesting question so again when we
  121. discussed in the ear course era segment about um the way one communicates and the way one designs a message and the 7M
  122. of uh marketing communication one of the key issues around the message is should
  123. the message have a rational appeal or should it have an emotional appeal and of course it depends on the kind of
  124. product now emotion's important here because Nike has this notion you know that anyone who has a body really is an
  125. athlete we're all athletes in some sense and so we should be doing the best that
  126. we can with our bodies all the way from we think of the early campaigns of Nike you know just do it be like Mike it's
  127. very very aspirational it kind of gets you to think about the power of getting in better shape the way you're going to
  128. feel the way others are going to perceive you so it's much much more important I think uh to have that kind
  129. of messaging to really resonate with the customers than a messaging that's you know count the number of steps that
  130. you're doing this is the technology this is how we feed it so I think this is a classic case of a product where the
  131. product itself is based on really interesting technology but the way that you Market it and you communicate it is
  132. actually through things that that appeal to the heartstrings that really kind of
  133. tug at you in terms of the emotion and of course that's going to be a much more successful barrier to Future entrance in
  134. this category than if it were just purely a play based on technology because then when the next player comes
  135. in with a better technology uh the point of comparison may be eroded but it's probably going to be difficult to come
  136. up with a better messaging than you know anyone who has a body as an athlete I think that's that's what's really key
  137. here

Brief Summary

The episode covers product-focused and customer-focused marketing using the Nike Fuel Band as a case study.

Key points

  • The Shift to Customer Focus. As competition increases, marketers must prioritize customer needs over product features.
  • The Power of Data. Nike's Fuel Band connects users and tracks data, enhancing customer engagement.
  • Pricing Strategy Insights. Nike's pricing strategy balances perceived value and market competition.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes