How Stress Influences Decision-Making

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Research by Wharton’s Gideon Nave takes a closer look at how hormones impact the choices we make. More: http://knlg.net/2d7fY9L 📂 Human Resources;Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton marketing Professor giddy n to talk about some of his latest research giddy thanks for
  2. being here hi Rachel nice being here too and so first of all could you just give
  3. us a brief overview of your research what you were trying to what question you were trying to ask yeah well I came
  4. to work on from a neuroscience department and uh my work is mostly focused on the biological basis of how
  5. people make decisions uh we all know that the way we make decisions is influenced by our biological state
  6. things like hunger sleep deprivation and stress influence the process of decision- making and I'm trying to study
  7. this in a rigorous way using lab experiments and uh some biological data and what have been some of the key
  8. takeaways from your research well one of the things I study is hormones and how hormones influence decision- making we
  9. all know that there are many situations in which different hormones fluctuate in
  10. our body H stress is a good example uh we all have a very uh clearly measurable biological stress response that uh
  11. consists of elevation of several hormones in our body like neur adrenaline and cortisol H one of the things that I am
  12. studying is how cortisol specifically affect decision making and we do it by pharmacologically administering this
  13. hormone to people under a double blind and Placebo controlled protocol H what's interesting is that giving cortisol to
  14. people is not stressing them out cortisol is actually a TR response it's something that make people more relaxed
  15. H but the interesting thing that we find is that even though people are not even
  16. aware at the fact that they received cortisol we see very clear behavioral effects of this drug on how people make
  17. decisions one thing specifically that we take a look at is the tradeoff between people's accuracy and speed when making
  18. the decisions uh we have this uh Paradigm called the cognitive reflection test I don't know if you heard about it
  19. but I can Give an example using one question that'd be great you're going to try to answer it but okay I can do that
  20. all right so there is a bet and a ball like a baseball bet and a ball and together they cost
  21. A110 so far we're good y yeah now the BET costs a dollar more than the bow right and again together they're
  22. $110 now what's the price of the bow 10 cents okay so you just gave me your intuitive answer which is the in
  23. answer of most people so if the ball is 10 cents and the bet is $1 more that means that the bet is a do and 10 cents
  24. so together there will be a120 so the correct answer that you will have to check yourself and get into some
  25. more I'd say deliberate calculations is $5 five cents and a do5 what we see is that when you give
  26. cortisol to people they're more likely to do what you just did and say 10 cents and not deliberate and think it's
  27. through even even though they have some incentives to really think it through and they get paid for being correct
  28. they're just giving their gut answer faster as if they're in kind of time pressure they're more likely to rely on
  29. this incorrect but uh simple euristic in the decision making process so I'm using
  30. this task uh many times uh I find it quite interesting to study we have other studies where I give testosterone to
  31. people testosterone again is a hormone that is involved in instinctive behaviors in animals such as intale
  32. aggression and mating behaviors again it typically rises in context where it's better to act fast and we see again that
  33. men that receive testosterone are more likely to fail in questions like the BET and the ball ones uh so this is
  34. one topic that uh I'm currently studying H yeah so other than my questionable Mas
  35. skills what can we what what can businesses take away from this I mean I can can imagine there's lots of
  36. different applications from this from I mean Human Resources departments dealing
  37. with their employees to businesses dealing with their customers I mean it would really want the gamut I would
  38. think yes so for start failing in this question is not necessarily bad if you have a good intuitive response you will
  39. answer it faster after when you're stressed or uh having high level of testosterone but there are some
  40. situations where deliberation is needed and there are some situations and some people that are more vulnerable to make
  41. fatal m takes in these situations and I think it's important that we pay attention to these situations and make
  42. sure that these won't happen for example once you're stressed if you're put in environment that you know well perhaps
  43. you'll respond good but if I put you in in a completely novel environment and give you some easy to fail uh questions
  44. you may be worse off traumatically because of being stressed so I think it's important that we're know when and
  45. where to expect these uh fatal mistakes and it also seems to me like it would also for I mean for the point of like a
  46. retailer for example like the idea of if you can try to figure out what state the
  47. customers are when they come in your door that you can try to sort of adjust your environment accordingly to either
  48. you know to make them less stressed or to sort of Point them towards the decision you might want them to make
  49. that's true one would say that maybe you can manipulate people easily more um when they're stressed on when they this
  50. boost of testosterone on the other hand I don't know if that's what you want to do because overall we want customers to
  51. be satisfied and if they're more likely to make mistakes they more likely to regret their purchase and let enjoy it
  52. and not come back so I think that again it depends on the situation but uh on my
  53. side I think it's better to know and also for me as a customer it's better to know for example that when I'm stressed
  54. I'm not going to go to the supermarket or hungry or hungry right I mean hunger is sort of a stressful
  55. situation true and so what's next for you what's next for This research well we we're living now in a time when we
  56. can measure and we can manipulate a lot of factors that we couldn't in history and it's not only hormones I'm talking
  57. about brain activity we can look at the where you're looking at eye tracking data we can look at the brain images uh
  58. meaning the anatomical structure of the brain we can look at gin all of these things are measurable nowadays and uh we
  59. can learn a lot from about individual differences between people from these measures and I think it's a very
  60. exciting time now uh to be working on this intersection between biological science and Behavioral Science and
  61. obviously the best type of Behavioral data we can get is now coming from marketing and from online Behavior great
  62. thank you so much for being here thank you Rachel [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Giddy N discusses how hormones affect decision-making and the implications for businesses.

Key points

  • The Impact of Hormones on Decisions. Research shows hormones like cortisol can influence decision-making processes, often leading to quicker, less accurate responses.
  • Stress and Decision-Making. Understanding how stress affects decision-making can help businesses improve customer interactions and outcomes.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes