The Net Gain of an Open Web

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

An “open internet,” free of entry bans, throttling or paid prioritization, won the day in a big FCC ruling Thursday. Wharton professor Kevin Werbach explains the business implications. More: http://knlg.net/1JUd57r 📂 Technology

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to welcome Kevin warbach to knowledge at Wharton thanks for being here with us again Kevin's a professor
  2. of legal studies and business ethics here at Wharton and we're going to talk about the recent uh Federal
  3. Communications Commission decision on net neutrality uh the idea of net neutrality was approved by a 3 to2
  4. margin on the five member board uh right along party lines and um what that decision means I think and you can
  5. provide more detail is that the big internet service providers like Comcast and Verizon um
  6. they'll be barred from providing high-speed services to companies who might be willing to pay an extra toll
  7. for those services so uh there's no FASTT tracking that's going to be allowed under this decision um and uh
  8. all companies will have equal access to to the Internet so there's a couple things about that so that means no
  9. blocking no throttling slowing down uh no paid prioritization and um this seems to protect the idea of open internet I I
  10. should point out that on the other side of the coin consumers can still pay extra for faster incoming service right
  11. this is about sort of pushing out rather than the service that comes in but uh my
  12. question is what are the big business implications for this decision well the first thing to keep in mind is the FCC
  13. adopted open internet rules and essentially as you said they prohibit certain kinds of business practices
  14. going forward um so it's not that your internet service will change dramatically tomorrow because of these
  15. FCC rules this is basically going to the possibility that Broadband access companies might discriminate um they
  16. might uh tell certain service providers um you can't uh reach customers or you have to pay extra to reach customers or
  17. they might throttle or slow them down um if that happens the FCC is in a position
  18. to act so from a business standpoint um this uh ensures that companies that want to provide services on the internet
  19. um small companies big companies content providers application developers and so
  20. forth will still have an unfettered opportunity to go online reach customers and potentially build a very big
  21. business um the other thing it does is it tells the Broadband access providers the companies as you said like Verizon
  22. and AT&T and Comcast that certain practice are off the table um there's been a lot
  23. of talk over the several years that this has been under discussion that somehow that will prevent them from investing or
  24. will destroy their businesses the reality is uh the day after the FCC chairman announced that he was planning
  25. to adopt these particular rules the stocks of the cable industry went up um and so while there's a lot of concern
  26. about government regulation and so forth now many of the companies cable vision and t- mobile and Sprint uh their
  27. Executives have come out and said you know what at the end of the day this really doesn't affect our business that
  28. much so if the stock went up um then does that mean that it's actually good for business or does it mean that a
  29. little bit of the previous uncertainty has been has been ended and so people feel more comfortable investing yeah I
  30. think the stock went up partly for other factors and and partly just because uh the negative had been to the extent that
  31. investors were concerned had already been priced into the stocks um and also it's it's really easy to get scared
  32. about the big bad government might do something um but what the FCC has made very clear is that they are not going to
  33. engage in direct price regulation they they've explicitly use what's called forbearance which is a legal tool they
  34. have under the communications act um to uh state that they are not going to enforce certain rules even if they're on
  35. the books um so uh ultimately an open internet is good for everyone um and ultimately frankly the the Broadband
  36. access providers want to see that as well um there are going to be business disputes there are going to be conflicts
  37. uh there are going to be issues uh but most of them actually go beyond the Discrimination issues that the net
  38. neutrality order is about um that's partly why this is actually important um because the reason I think that the
  39. Broadband access companies were so strongly opposed to This legal Theory the FCC used um which is basically to
  40. reclassify broadband access under the same Provisions that apply to telecommunication Services the reason
  41. they were opposed is that their long-term strategy is to transition as they should uh to being internet-based
  42. companies and ultimately that would get them totally out from under the FCC unless the FCC applied this set of rules
  43. so that does that make them regulated Monopoly or what what what under tile two what does that mean
  44. yeah a lot of words get thrown around people talk about whether this is regulating the Internet it's not people
  45. talk about this as turning the internet into utility that's not right um these companies aren't monopolies there is
  46. competition for Broadband um there's not enough competition for Broadband in the
  47. United States especially for high-speed Broadband it's a very concentrated market and there's opportunities for
  48. that to change at the margins one of the other things the FCC did in the same meeting was overturn some state laws
  49. that actually got in the way of cities competing where there wasn't sufficient Broadband competition building their own
  50. Municipal networks the FCC is now trying to break down barriers so there's more competition uh but for the moment the
  51. competition is limited um and even when there is some level of competition it's true I can choose between Verizon FiOS
  52. or comcast for my Broadband where I live even where that's the case they're big companies that have a lot of control uh
  53. and once I sign up for them any company whether it's uh Google or Netflix or Facebook or Etsy or any of these
  54. companies that want to reach me they have to go through that Broadband company so uh the communications act uh
  55. has regulation for these companies because they're in a a strong bottleneck position over a fundamental input for
  56. the information economy what about for consumers uh you explained for businesses what the
  57. implications may be and for consumers what are we looking at that might be different well again uh nothing is going
  58. to be fundamentally different because of these decisions um the question is what
  59. business models might get adopted um what kinds of pricing policies might get adopted um and what kinds of practices
  60. might happen in the future um and the argument against these rules is that Broadband companies won't invest to
  61. speed up their networks that only if companies can pay to get faster service will there be FAS service that hasn't
  62. been shown um and it stands the reason that uh if people want to get access to this content in these services and
  63. applications um that the companies will provide access to let that happen um people can still pay for faster
  64. broadband service none of this is saying that everything has to be exactly the same it just has to do with
  65. discrimination so at the end of the day um the issues that consumers I think are
  66. most concerned about the perception prices are too high um bad customer service there been lots
  67. of incidents with Comcast in particular these rules don't address that directly um but what they do is provide
  68. jurisdiction for the FCC so for example there's been discussion of what's called
  69. um zero rating different pricing practices that exempt certain services from um prices uh and from uh usage caps
  70. um the FCC will now have jurisdiction to address those practices if and when they
  71. are adopted but right now the way Broadband works today is the way broadband's going to work tomorrow this
  72. also affects mobile services um what are the implications of that or are there implications to that in the fcc's 2010
  73. rules which were the prior net neutrality rules that were overturned in court it basically cut a deal uh and it
  74. said other than the blocking rule which says you just can't completely block traffic the Discrimination rules don't
  75. apply to mobile um and there was really no good policy reason for that it was again it was a deal to get some support
  76. from the industry the FCC has now gone back and said look technically mobile and wired internet service are different
  77. there are more congestion issues for mobile um but the idea that you can't unreasonably discriminate that you can't
  78. uh throttle or slow something down just because uh you don't like the company or
  79. you want to prevent them from competing that doesn't make sense whatever the platform is so that's what the FCC has
  80. said they said that that mobile and fixed internet are now in the same basic bucket so we're acting as if this is
  81. settled law or rules but it isn't because there will be court cases um what are going to be the big challenges
  82. how long is this going to take be before it's actually settled uh the industry has already said it's going to sue there
  83. will be litigation um in all likelihood uh we're looking at 2 to three years before this gets through the uh first
  84. Court uh and then in all likelihood whoever loses the Supreme Court um so um this is not something that we will have
  85. certainty on for a while when we last spoke uh which was almost a year ago actually about this topic uh you talked
  86. about competition the fact that there isn't enough competition in this space you alluded to it earlier and at that
  87. time U what you also alluded to here was that there some competition could come from municipalities and from Wireless
  88. Services almost a year has gone by has there been any uh movement on that or is that still an interesting possibility
  89. that remains to mature uh well as I said the FCC finally has taken action on Municipal competition which for a long
  90. time was an issue that they didn't act on there are all sorts of state laws that have been passed that that really
  91. hamstring cities from competing um there's also something that the FCC chairman has said that he intends to
  92. pursue which is um making it easier for private companies that want to build say
  93. competing fiber optic networks like Google is starting to do in some areas and if few other companies are doing uh
  94. to make it easier for them to get access to telephone polls and conduits these sort of Nitty Gritty issues that
  95. actually have a huge amount to deal with the viability of competition um there's
  96. another set of issues that that would seem not to be related but it's the price of getting access to video so if
  97. you want to offer a competing fiber broadband service you have to offer a bundle you've got to offer the so-called
  98. Triple Play because that's what people expect but it actually is far more expensive for a new entrant to get
  99. access to the programming all the channels than it is for an established player so that's also something that um
  100. the agency hasn't acted on but I think they may act on um we've seen Google enter a number of new markets with fiber
  101. so I think in the last year we've seen movement in that direction but the reality is um there's no way anyone can
  102. wave a magic wand and say poof there's another high-speed Broadband provider across the entire United States um it's
  103. an incremental process City by City Wireless keeps getting better but it's never going to be exactly the same as
  104. Wireline service so um there certainly are ways we could have more competition um one thing the FCC has not done and
  105. has not given any indication that it wants to do is require the incumbent Network operators to share their
  106. networks that's how competition works almost everywhere else in the world not the direction we've gone here not the
  107. direction we're likely to go here so yeah the competition issue is going to be with us for a long time what haven't
  108. we talked about around this that's important for uh viewers to know um I think again you hear a lot of
  109. hyperbole on both sides of this and it really is important for people to calm down there's an important principle here
  110. which is that the internet has been an extraordinary vehicle for both economic activity as well as political activity
  111. and speech and Innovation because it's an open network um and when this debate started years ago um the Broadband
  112. companies would say look we built the pipes we control if we want to discriminate we should be able to
  113. discriminate now if you listen to Executives at companies like Comcast and variz and what they say is we don't
  114. agree with these rules we think they're too regulatory we're concerned what the FCC might do with price regulation but
  115. we agree the internet should be open we agree that discrimination unreasonable discrimination doesn't have a place we
  116. can debate about certain practices where company wants to pay for better service
  117. as opposed to service being reduced but the basic notion now is widely accepted um and so uh neither outcome here was
  118. going to dramatically change the internet um the other piece that's important for people to realize is um
  119. this was a pretty shocking reversal by the FCC from where they started a year ago um this idea of classifying
  120. Broadband as telecommunications under title two of the communications Act was something the FCC chairman was not
  121. inclined to do and I and others who are experts said not going to happen uh it did happen um and it happened partly
  122. because lots and lots of individuals as well as lots and lots of innovative companies wrote to the FCC went in and
  123. met with the FCC um and with the support of lots of very effective Advocates convinced the FCC to change its mind um
  124. so I think it's important people to realize that um public input does matter input from small companies and startups
  125. does matter I think there were 4 million comments well there were four million comments but it wasn't just the uh
  126. rubber comments of people clicking a button um there were VCS and startups and lots of companies that spent their
  127. time going to Washington or meeting with the FCC elsewhere um I was at the FCC now almost 20 years ago when we were
  128. first looking at the internet I would go fly out to Silicon Valley and get this reaction of like who are you stay away
  129. from us and I would say you know what you'd be much better off talking to us you'd be much better off telling us what
  130. you want telling us how we can avoid making mistakes than saying stay away from us we don't want to talk to you um
  131. so it's gratifying to see that starting to happen and I think it is important for people to realize that um government
  132. can work and can actually listen to people um but as I said the issue is not over um so um this is something that's
  133. going to be going on for some time thanks very much for joining us thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

Kevin Warbach discusses the FCC's net neutrality decision and its impact on businesses, consumers, and broadband competition.

Key points

  • Net Neutrality Decision Explained. The FCC's recent decision on net neutrality aims to ensure equal access to the internet for all.
  • Impact on Broadband Providers. Broadband access providers are now barred from discriminatory practices, affecting their business strategies.
  • Public Advocacy Matters. The FCC's reversal on net neutrality was influenced by public advocacy and input from startups.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes