Net Neutrality: What's the Real Threat?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The FCC's proposed new rules regarding net neutrality are most likely benign, says Wharton's Kevin Werbach. Instead, a much bigger threat to the Internet in the U.S. is a lack of competition in broadband.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1rBYqiG πŸ“‚ Public Policy;Technology 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to welcome Kevin warbach to knowledge at Wharton Kevin is a professor at Wharton of legal studies
  2. and business ethics and we're going to talk about the controversial issue suddenly of net neutrality and the new
  3. proposed Federal Communications commission's uh proposals to uh that could affect net neutrality and Kevin I
  4. think the best thing to do welcome to knowledge thank you but the best thing is probably to start out with a thumb
  5. sketch of what net neutrality is for viewers absolutely no it's funny you say suddenly in in some ways this has been a
  6. sudden controversy after the FCC proposals um leaked a few days ago but uh in some ways this has been a
  7. controversy that's been going on for the past decade um so Network neutrality is
  8. basically the principle that internet access providers which is the company you use to get your broadband service in
  9. the US that would be companies like Verizon and AT&T and Comcast it's the idea that they shouldn't
  10. discriminate in how they handle traffic on the internet so whoever you are if you want to plug into internet and offer
  11. information on the internet you get the same speed as everyone else well exactly
  12. what it means is is difficult and controversial but the general notion is anyone can connect to the internet if I
  13. have a startup I may have very little Capital um but I can get on the internet provide my service uh and reach
  14. customers uh and I don't have to get permission from some company I don't have to pay them uh some special fee
  15. just to get online it's on the internet and and customers of those Broadband providers can get access to anything
  16. that's there okay so the FCC is proposing some changes uh there's a lot of hue and cry uh some calling it The
  17. Death nail for net neutrality uh and others saying well I think you have a slightly different point of view why
  18. don't you uh describe for us what everyone's worried about and whether or not they should be worried the the first
  19. point that's important to understand is where we are today so at this moment in the United States there are virtually no
  20. network neutrality rules that are legally enforcable there's some rules that apply to Comcast uniquely because
  21. of some conditions it agreed to for a prior merger and there's one FCC rule that says that Broadband providers have
  22. to be transparent in their Network management practices all the other rules were thrown out in court a few months
  23. ago uh and that was after the fcc's prior attempt to impose Network neutrality was also thrown out in court
  24. um but fortunately the court in the most recent decision gave the FCC validation
  25. on the basic legal Theory they use the the big question up until then was does the FCC even have jurisdiction to
  26. address these issues because the FCC regulates telephone service television and so forth and so there was an
  27. argument that they couldn't uh impose rules on Internet services the court for the first time said yes they do Under
  28. the kind of legal Theory they were using they just couldn't adopt the rules that
  29. they proposed so fast forward to today the uh FCC chairman Tom wheeler has circulated to the commission a set of
  30. proposals to adopt Network neutrality rules to to ban blocking of traffic uh to ban certain kinds of discrimination
  31. of traffic um the rules aren't public yet they're going to be circulated among the Commissioners if they're adopted by
  32. the commission it'll be a proposal that goes out for public comment um but the concern has been uh from some ERS um
  33. that the proposal doesn't go far enough in uh restricting a certain kind of practice which is called paid
  34. prioritization so the idea is uh there's the basic internet Lane that anyone can
  35. use uh but Broadband providers might have more leeway to offer uh faster or better service for an additional fee so
  36. as soon as someone hears that there might be a two-speed service there's certain conclusions that are reached and
  37. uh and and they worry that I guess the uh the two-p speed service well in the beginning it may be a premium service
  38. that you can pay extra to get the faster speed but in the end that the the main Lane would be degraded in some way and
  39. so I guess they worry about protections that's one point the other point I think
  40. is interesting that is that up until now industry and all all the stakeholders here have been sort of agreeing to
  41. certain conventions where net neutrality has been respected and so far that's worked but I guess there's you know this
  42. is bringing up the idea a that that could change absolutely it's important to point out that we're talking here
  43. about connections on the the network side so you as an end user customer as individual or a business of course you
  44. have options of different speeds you can go to your Broadband provider and say I
  45. want 5 megabit service 10 megabit service what they offer we're not talking about Fast Lanes and slow lanes
  46. that way the issue is for content and service providers so if a company like Netflix uh wants to provide service to
  47. customers of Verizon or Comcast whether uh they can be offered an enhanced delivery service and it's even
  48. more limited than that um because it's only an enhanced delivery service um that is differentiating traffic on the
  49. Broadband provids Network um the FCC has said that this doesn't address what's called peering uh which is how the
  50. traffic actually comes into the network over the Internet so you're absolutely right there are some very serious and
  51. and reasonable concerns that people have expressed um the fact is though we haven't actually seen the C proposal and
  52. what chairman wheeler has suggested in a blog post uh is that there going to be some substantial restrictions on how
  53. those paid prioritization Arrangements can be adopted I I think absolutely if there's too much room for the Broadband
  54. providers to degrade the basic internet pipe um that will violate uh the spirit and the reality of network neutrality um
  55. but but my take on this is that's not necessarily going to be the case if there's sufficient conditions put into
  56. into place so why the misunderstanding why is it this proposal which will then have months of comment and so forth in
  57. debate why is it seen as such a threat by so many people it's a combination of just how partisan things have gotten in
  58. Washington I mean the reason that this is at the FCC is Congress has refused to act and in fact Congress has uh whenever
  59. the FCC has tried to act different factions in Congress have threatened to basically grind the FCC to a standstill
  60. if they don't do what those members of Congress want um so it's a very difficult and charge situation again the
  61. FCC has tried two times before um and uh has proposed rules that generally uh haven't uh provided what network net
  62. neutrality Advocates really fully wanted um which is what's called reclassification um they've been
  63. advocating that the FCC uh change the uh regulatory category that Broadband is under in the United States uh to be in
  64. the category called title that applies to telephone service um now what people Miss is actually under title 2 under
  65. that uh telephone regulation category you can do paid prioritization uh if it's if it's offered on the same terms
  66. to everyone um but there's a perception that that's the only solution that will protect Network neutrality and the fact
  67. that the FCC has now said we're not going to do that um and we're going to step back somewhat from what the
  68. previous FCC rules had said before they were overturned I think that's gotten a lot of the net neutrality The Advocates
  69. upset because they they see that President Obama um and other officials have have long claimed that they support
  70. an open internet and yet when they see that there's going to be again two prices two speeds um they see it as I
  71. guess the campell's nose edging Under the Tent and I guess what you're saying is we don't really know that for sure
  72. but that the concern seems a bit overblown at the moment yeah it's it's uh always unsatisfying when uh someone
  73. who is an AC mic or a policy wonk says it's complicated um but it's complicated um because it's complicated in several
  74. ways technically it's very complicated what exactly these prioritization deals are how they work uh the engineering how
  75. they compare to all the other options that those companies have um is a very complex subject it's not that uh there's
  76. just one way you get from here to there on the internet a company like Netflix has a whole variety of different
  77. providers it uses it uses caching systems called content delivery Network works it Engineers where its traffic
  78. goes and and it's paying for all those services so it's not that there's this free internet pipe and now for the first
  79. time there's a paid pipe um there's a lot more complexity on that side and then on the FCC side there's a lot of
  80. complexity um again what are the practices that go into effect how does the FCC respond what are the enforcement
  81. practices and again that's always going to be the issue uh even if the FCC adopted this title 2 regulation they
  82. would still have to make distinctions and still have to engage in enforce so what do you think is the bottom line
  83. for people that are looking at this issue from the outside they they they they see this might be a threat to Net
  84. Neutrality the the issues are complicated what does it mean for example for consumers uh will it affect
  85. what they're paying uh and other stakeholders sure so two points one is net neutrality is this this this vague
  86. concept it's it's a buzzword it's a slogan um but we need to walk back and and break down what what it actually
  87. means what should people be concerned about um people should be concerned uh on the one hand if new uh Innovative
  88. Services can't get off the ground can't reach their customers um or you know see
  89. that their service is being degraded um so people should be concerned about that
  90. and if we have evidence of that then that's something that should be taken to the FCC and to Congress and so forth to
  91. say this isn't working um secondly people should be concerned on the enduser side if they find for example
  92. that Broadband providers are um creating discriminatory cap saying you you know you get 50 megabit service but you have
  93. this limit on your bandwidth uh and only certain services are subject to the limits hours aren't and the limits are
  94. far more uh restrictive than what's necessary for Network management um then that's something and and frankly those
  95. conditions aren't covered under Network neutrality um but they're the kinds of things that might make these harms that
  96. people are worry about come about um and then the big thing that that people should think about is the reason this is
  97. such a concern is we don't have enough competition for Broadband in the United States we do have uh in many places
  98. multiple providers uh but typically very few and and in much of the United States
  99. there aren't multiple providers for truly high-speed service um so we need to do in the FCC and Congress need to do
  100. everything possible to promote more competition and frankly the FCC and and chairman wheeler has a lot of that on
  101. its agenda um and the question is can it get to that agenda um or is net neutrality going to be such a
  102. controversy um that that's the only thing the FCC focuses on for the rest of the Obama Administration could you give
  103. a couple quick bullet points on how we would get more providers and increase that competition level absolutely um so
  104. uh the United States made a choice and I think frankly a wrong choice about 10 or
  105. 15 years ago which is different than just about every other country in the world I did a benchmarking study on on
  106. fixed Broadband for the oecd which is about 40 countries around the world the developed countries in the world and the
  107. United States was one of the only ones that didn't require a form of what's called Open Access that didn't require
  108. the high-speed Broadband providers to share their networks so we didn't go down that path and at this point
  109. politically it's very unlikely we will um so we need to think about alternate physical platforms one of them is
  110. municipalities um cities or organizations going in and getting access to City capacity polls and
  111. conduits and so forth in municipalities to provide their own Broadband Network it's a huge source of Broadband
  112. competition uh in certain parts of the world especially Scandinavia here in the US we have laws that prohibit that in
  113. many uh states and cities um the second one the big one is Wireless uh right now
  114. wireless service isn't a one-o-one competitor for high-speed Broadband uh but as technology advances uh in
  115. particular for what's called unlicensed uh shared access to wireless there's the
  116. potential at least for for a chunk of the Broadband Market that wireless could provide a viable uh competitor so one
  117. big hot spot one big or many big hot spots um and that requires the FCC to make Spectrum available it requires the
  118. FCC to promote unlicensed technology um and it requires ability of all those networks to interconnect with the
  119. existing Broadband infrastructure and again the FCC is looking at doing all those things uh and I think we should
  120. push it to continue um is it reasonable for people to be skeptical about this sort of like
  121. postdecision enforcement that happens so if if we see uh a squelching of competition uh as you
  122. mentioned or if we see some degradation then we go back to Congress or we go to the FCC and and yet people have a sense
  123. that that a lot of times uh that's really you're you're up against the brick wall you know once once certain
  124. practices get underway it's very difficult to go back and change them there's a there's a lot of power and
  125. money on one side that would like to prevent rent change uh when it comes to that so are people right to be skeptical
  126. we can say we're going to do this and if it doesn't work we'll we'll fix it but can we fix it really yeah so I'm I'm
  127. more optimistic um first of all there's a lot of power and money on both sides uh Microsoft Apple Google Facebook these
  128. are not tiny little companies uh the companies in the internet economy frankly are much bigger and certainly
  129. much more profitable and aggregate than the access providers the point is once you uh uh go to a certain customer you
  130. have to go through that access provider um but um if you look at the history here um every time there has been a
  131. major example of a network neutrality violation um for example there was a company called Madison river that
  132. blocked Voiceover IP service the FCC intervened uh told them to stop doing it they changed the practice Comcast a few
  133. years ago was degrading bit torrent traffic uh the FCC um imposed rules even though the rules were overturned in
  134. court Comcast retreated and agreed not to engage in the practice once once they had gone through that that complaint
  135. process and the public scrutiny they didn't want to have it happen again um so it's it's right to say uh hold the
  136. fcc's feet to the fire U but something important to remember is that that third that that additional requirement in net
  137. neutrality that I alluded to earlier the transparency requirement which the FCC apparently is going to beef up um if uh
  138. the light of day Shines on the practices of broadband providers um then there's opportunities for pressure and we've
  139. seen the effects of this so um it's not net neutrality but uh Netflix uh has a chart that shows Broadband performance
  140. from their streams from all providers um and they've made a lot of hay by showing
  141. companies like Comcast that are out there all the time advertising how fast our service is and how great it is
  142. they're way below a lot of providers or they were way below a lot of providers that that have supposedly higher speeds
  143. um I think that has an impact uh on companies uh like Comcast uh and if there's more disclosure that will help
  144. with enforcement you mentioned Comcast uh could this announcement well this blog I guess um and those kinds of
  145. proposals have an effect on say the proposed Comcast uh Time Warner merger yeah it's an interesting question so so
  146. legally they're separate issues the merger gets reviewed by the justice department and it gets reviewed by the
  147. FCC um as I said Comcast is already subject to Net Neutrality rules and they've already said sure we'll we'll
  148. put Time Warner Cable under those two um but in the court of public opinion um people are concerned that the big
  149. Broadband providers are getting bigger and that a company like Comcast if it acquires time order will have will have
  150. even more leverage in this market um and frankly um if the FCC puts into place net neutrality rules that are less than
  151. what uh Advocates want that's only going to redouble the pressure to say well if
  152. you're not going to do that then the least you can do is kill this merger um so I think there is some risk for
  153. Comcast but but as a formal matter um two separate issues uh you referred to possible Municipal competition do you
  154. think that the government will ever view Broadband as a public utility um so it's hard to know what
  155. that means um so at some level um it should and I I wrote a paper a few years ago called the networking utility um
  156. talking about how um internet access essentially is is a utility but it's a different kind of utility the the
  157. problem when people use the term public utility is they're either talking about the title to regulation I describ and
  158. and that itself is not so problematic um but people need to understand that's not
  159. a Panacea people think well once it's a public utility then all of a sudden those companies have to change all their
  160. business practices um no not necessarily it's just a different category of Regulation and and the reality is it's
  161. probably not going to get adopted in the US um when you think about public utility people think about the kind of
  162. pervasive regulation of either governmental or very um slow highly regulated Industries like the old AT&T
  163. telephone Network and um energy utilities and while there's some benefits of that um I don't think most
  164. people feel like those were Dynamic Innovative companies um so if we want Broadband providers to invest in new
  165. technology to give us higher speeds and more capabilities um then I think it's fair to say these are private companies
  166. they should have the incentives of the free market we shouldn't just say well let's let's essentially make this a
  167. government run Monopoly which is what we're we're moving away from in every other sector of the economy um I I don't
  168. think that's the solution uh but I think we need to understand that they're they're so important to the economy to
  169. daily life to free expression um that it is appropriate to have different requirements for them than for other
  170. companies what are the next steps for this whole procedure and argument uh the FCC proposal has been circulated to the
  171. five Commissioners three of them have to vote for it which is not a sure thing um
  172. because the Republican Commissioners have suggested they're not going to vote for any net neutrality rules and the
  173. other two Democrats want something stronger um so assuming the commission votes for it uh they have a meeting
  174. scheduled in miday it will go out for public comment typically for two to three months anyone can weigh in the
  175. fcc's already set up an email box for public comment but there will be an opportunity for anyone who wants to to
  176. go on the web and make a comment that goes in the formal docket um then the FCC will review all those comments uh
  177. and will uh issue an order which adopts final rules um that would probably happen sometime later this year um but
  178. again there's a number of ways that that could get blocked Congress could intervene um I think it's most likely
  179. that some version of this proposal will go into effect and then we'll be in the realm of potentially more legal
  180. challenges unfortunately uh and this question about all right what actually happens do these fears get realized more
  181. broadly what does the future of broadband look like in the US um again the fact that there is not more
  182. competition um is a drag on broadband in the US the United States is the uh World Center for internet
  183. Innovation internet uh economic value creation and and internet Freedom um but um that's been um weakened um in recent
  184. years um partly because of some of the revelations about government surveillance which have caused uh
  185. companies and governments to not no longer trust the US on that front uh but partly because uh we don't have the
  186. level of broadband connectivity by some measures that they do in other places so
  187. I think that will be a drag um and uh I think you know we talk to companies like
  188. Comcast and Verizon and so forth they say look we are investing we are providing these highspeed Services we
  189. we're putting fiber networks into the ground um which by some measures we have more widely than other countries um but
  190. I think if you look at the potential we haven't gone far enough so um I'm worried um that at some point even
  191. though silic Valley is here and even though Wall Street which which funds so much of this is here and even though we
  192. have this extraordinary Innovation culture the the the smartest and best entrepreneurs and technologist want to
  193. come here from around the world um that's not going away U but I I think there is some risk if we don't have a
  194. true National policy of promoting advances in broadband and more competition at every turn um that the US
  195. falls behind and also that we lose some of this potential that the internet has and that Broadband has um for catalyzing
  196. both economic benefit as well as all these great social benefits thanks very much for joining us thank thank you for
  197. having me [Music]

Brief Summary

Kevin Warbach discusses net neutrality, FCC proposals, and the implications for internet access and competition in the U.S.

Key points

  • Understanding Net Neutrality. Net neutrality ensures equal internet access for all users, preventing discrimination by providers.
  • FCC's Proposed Changes. The FCC is proposing new rules on net neutrality, sparking debate and concern.
  • Concerns Over Competition. The lack of competition in broadband services raises concerns about net neutrality enforcement.
  • FCC Proposal Vote Uncertain. Three Commissioners must vote for the FCC's net neutrality proposal, but it's not guaranteed.
  • Public Comment Period Ahead. The FCC will open a public comment period for two to three months after the vote.
  • Future of Broadband in Question. Concerns arise about the future of broadband and competition in the US.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes