The Quest for Respect in Sports

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Claims of racism, domestic abuse, bullying, ethical breaches: Are we seeing a new low in sports owners’ and players’ behavior? More: http://knlg.net/1Eoh9WO 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi everybody I'm da Loney host of knowledge of Wharton on siriusxm 111 we are here today talking about the new
  2. book coming out sport matters with its author and Wharton professor Ken Shropshire ken great to have you thanks
  3. dad good beer this is an interesting topic to bring up because there are certainly have been a rash of incidents
  4. involving all of the sports industry where we have seen a quote unquote loss of respect and that's something that you
  5. talk a lot about in this book was it's incredible I'm even at this this week just now Little League has has
  6. encountered further problems with this whole issue of integrity respect all the important issues that we think about
  7. outside of sport and we really think sports should project most positively so this has been a pretty dramatic year
  8. what has it been that has really changed within the fabric of sports booth at the
  9. professional level at the college level and even as you mentioned at the little league level that has really seen this
  10. this grand change in how people respect the games or do not respect the games well you know what's curious i mean the
  11. short answer might be might be money and kind of a more that's available if you are successful so that kind of striving
  12. for success but i think you know more deeply probably what what has brought this to our attention is how easy it is
  13. to get information now I mean it's more the if you think the incidents the the Donald sterling and you think the the
  14. owner of the Atlanta Hawks you think about Ray Rice I mean all this has been exposed in a way that we never saw
  15. before so historically you know Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig may have been up to a lot of things but we didn't know about
  16. it so it's it's really that but has revealed some of this huge respect or lack of respect issue that occurs in so
  17. many levels in sports one of the cases that you discuss in the book involves the miami dolphins and their hazing case
  18. which is interesting because i know you spent time with the dolphins in terms of
  19. talking with them about what happened and maybe how they can affect change within their organization well i'm still
  20. working with steve ross and and not some about the organization but I think what
  21. he's done is really tried to capture that moment and a lot of ways the same way that I think about the book you know
  22. how can you positively take the things that happen in sport and improve society how can you deliver the messages and his
  23. focus really at the youngest age two kids and say if you're going to participate in sport here's some other
  24. lessons you need to learn as well and you need to carry forward into life so you know the the drama other thing to
  25. think about one of the things is I've worked with him we've struggled with is it's it's not too difficult to think
  26. about how to work with kids and get them to understand all these important lessons about you know diversity
  27. inclusion respect equality kind of those those big themes but how do you do it with with adults how do you do it in in
  28. the locker room perfect with professional athletes with with people who in many ways have been pampered
  29. throughout their life and haven't had to deal with these real-life issues who in
  30. many ways or have been in this sanctuary my motherly the right word in these locker rooms that are private spaces for
  31. so long but but again just like in the other incidents we mentioned have been exposed in a way that the people have
  32. never seen before so we know what goes on there in a way that we didn't know the interesting part is that you have
  33. the contrast between what mr. Ross is trying to do down in Miami and of course what we saw with the Los Angeles
  34. Clippers with Donald sterling which I think it it shook a lot of people to their core the fact that I don't know if
  35. anybody believes that we are a true a true society where racism is not part of everything we think but it is still a
  36. scary prospect that a man that owned a professional sports franchise that had obviously a great deal of power a great
  37. deal of wealth had these views about people that in some respects people that were working for him well and look we
  38. don't know again if he's alone and it's his thoughts or how many other people have said such negative things in the
  39. privacy in the space that he was in with with his alleged girlfriend then and and
  40. again she records in a way that historically we weren't able to do so he what he really did was with shed light
  41. on this issue for for those who may have thought we are in some kind of post-racial era and the Obamas in the
  42. White House and things are rosy all around that here's somebody in a business that's people predominantly by
  43. african-americans and he expresses such negative views of them and it really displays this this whole but in the book
  44. I talk about this kind of continuum of this idea of Tolerance versus respect and then the full place we'd like to all
  45. get to his acceptance and he merely apparently tolerated these African Americans and didn't want maybe one of
  46. the most prominent sports figures in the World Magic Johnson to to attend his games because of his race so that really
  47. shed a light on on where we are but but I think that that you know not not so important that that this this one man
  48. did what he did but just that the fact that this still exist and exist in the most powerful position in sport at the
  49. ownership level it's interesting because when you look at ownership of professional sports teams these days you
  50. have some owners that are doing some unbelievable work for their communities for their organizations but you do have
  51. owners that I don't know if it's it's a case where the bottom line still ends up
  52. being the most powerful thing but you have a case like the Washington Redskins where that name has obviously drawn a
  53. lot of attention from the American Indian community they are not happy with it for the most part yet Daniel Snyder
  54. the owner of the Redskins is sticking to his guns in some respects and saying he
  55. will not change the name of that's what that name of that team and look you know
  56. successful men become successful because they have the type of stamina and drive
  57. that Dan Snyder has and he's displaying on this issue but but what this realist rates further I mean again we're talking
  58. about owners and the different kinds of issues that are there is the need for not just diversity in these big settings
  59. but also inclusion that that it's never clear to me who it is that he's getting this advice
  60. from that that drives him to stick so adamantly behind his decision to stick with the name that is one of the most
  61. racist names characterizing a group of people in existence and and you know the fact that you can you can find some
  62. people that say and if I'm some Native Americans that say it's okay that you can pull fans and majority of fans say
  63. that it's okay well well there is a substantial group of people that say it is a porn it is one of the most racist
  64. names that exist in any and if you kind of take the the casual step looking Webster's dictionary that's the kind of
  65. definition you'll get it at phrasing so so it's not that difficult i mean sport we've seen name change take place quite
  66. a bit i mean we've seen teams take this movement and do it positively and when you saw this this past season with the
  67. the charlotte bobcats that's back to the Charlotte Hornets and it was a tremendous marketing opportunity they
  68. increase their sales so there are ways to do this positively it really is again if we think the character of many of the
  69. people that own these teams and who think that there are certainly the positives but but here's a negative
  70. moment that it also allowed this guy to be very successful in what he does character obviously played a big part in
  71. the aftermath of the Ray Rice case which was a case where there was very shocking
  72. video of rice and his fiancee at the time in an incident in a casino in Atlantic City but I think as horrified
  73. as a lot of people were of the incident itself they were also disillusion in some respects by how it was handled by
  74. the quote-unquote leaders that were involved in that case whether it be Roger Goodell leading the case for the
  75. NFL whether that be Steve bisciotti for the Baltimore Ravens they did take the ACT to action to release ray rice from
  76. his contract but still there were some some people that were very disillusioned by what happened through that whole
  77. little situation yeah one of the great things about that terrible incident is it
  78. it was a very vivid visual of again the need for greater inclusion these decision-making processes I mean to have
  79. somebody in the room that understands about domestic violence does have somebody in the room you know unlike
  80. myself when I saw the the second video when Ray Rice structures then fiancé as a man would hit a hit a man I'd never
  81. seen that in real life and I've seen the kind of you know comical version but never unfortunately I'd never seen it in
  82. real life so so when that occurs you know if you don't have the inclusive atmosphere in your leadership setting do
  83. you really know how to react and and and part of the lesson that we get from that
  84. is to understand that when something new something you're not familiar with occurs if you don't have a domestic
  85. violence specialist if you don't have a Native American or you don't have an african-american your leadership space
  86. or wherever you may be then then this is the time where you should go out and seek that additional advice and guidance
  87. before you take a step that can later later be severely criticized and proven to be wrong is it tougher at times when
  88. you have an organization in comparison to what the NFL went through with the Ray Rice case is it tougher sometimes
  89. when you have an organization like the NCAA much different situation but we're talking about an organization that has
  90. been very much under fire for a lot of topics a lot of issues over the last several years the situation now at the
  91. University of Miami with the investigation into their potential impropriety the situation at Penn State
  92. with Jerry Sandusky and how they handled that it's it does require a different type of leadership in some respects now
  93. it really does and then you think about the NFL Major League Baseball NBA you've
  94. got 30 or so owners that work closely with a commissioner and their motivation is profit I mean it's so it's a it's a
  95. lot different there's a lot a lot of issues about protecting the business and NFL they're talking about protecting the
  96. shield the NCAA you had a thousand plus member institutions you've got an administrative body in DNA
  97. apolis is the interest in making as much money as possible where is it in educating student athletes and when you
  98. have these additional issues that that come into these these institutions individual schools and maybe they don't
  99. happen all the schools how do you get everybody united behind the kinds of issues that have to be dealt with so
  100. it's a lot different it's a lot different when you think about an educational institution trying to deal
  101. with issues as opposed to a professional sports organization any which which is a
  102. a small not a small business but it's a relatively small business to IBM or others that has to make business
  103. decisions that aren't related to now we're going to get this kid to graduate and to get a degree and to think about
  104. being a donor later on yeah those sorts of things the interesting part about that the NCAA is the fact that even
  105. though they are tied to educational institutions realistically the NCAA is a quote-unquote money-making operation
  106. when you think about the contracts that they are dealing with to promote the college basketball to promote college
  107. football and in some respects people I think believe that that's at the detriment to the organization that they
  108. have so much influence over money-making entities that maybe do they lose sight of what the grander picture is at times
  109. right and partly the NCAA's problem is is it the I think much of the world doesn't understand what the NCAA does
  110. and what it doesn't do and part of the world doesn't really focus on NCAA they run a great basketball tournament that's
  111. that's probably the biggest moneymaker for the enterprise but in terms of the football games the football
  112. championships and all those that's outside of the NCAA's purview for the most part except for the eligibility of
  113. the athletes and the dollars that are coming in the new dollars that are really coming in that's up to the
  114. individual conferences so that's the pac-12 the SEC and all those other other entities and so maybe greater scrutiny
  115. about what they're doing and whether or not those dollars are being used to further the educational missions of the
  116. individual institutions I mean that that's really where I think the focus should be you know we can beat up the
  117. NCAA all day but let's follow the money and see where it's gone and the positive
  118. things that can be done and for me that's that's well beyond thinking about paying athletes it's
  119. about thinking about how do you help the young men and young women find their way
  120. in life in the end the early realization the sports thing is not going to last forever you got to forget our way to
  121. survive in the world that goes beyond balls and bats and rackets the book is sports matters can what would you like
  122. people to really be left with what vision would you like them to be left with after they read this book well you
  123. know part of the drama that I went through and thinking about this book was was to move away from thinking about
  124. although it is in my mind the dominant respect issue out there move away from just the the race issue and which I
  125. wrote about some years ago on another book and really just understand that that a lot of the issues they're out
  126. there in this space and I think beyond our about respect and if we can just figure out how do we treat people her
  127. respectful manner and sports provides provides a prison for us to think about that then we can all be a lot better off
  128. thank you very much for joining us today thanks you

Brief Summary

Ken Shropshire discusses respect and integrity issues in sports, highlighting recent controversies and the need for positive change.

Key points

  • The Loss of Respect in Sports. Ken Shropshire discusses the troubling trend of declining respect in sports at all levels.
  • The Miami Dolphins Hazing Case. Shropshire reflects on the hazing incident with the Miami Dolphins and its implications.
  • Racism in Sports Ownership. The conversation touches on the racism exhibited by sports owners, highlighting Donald Sterling's case.
  • The NCAA's Money-Making Operation. Shropshire critiques the NCAA's focus on profit over educational missions.
  • Life Beyond Sports. The discussion emphasizes the importance of preparing athletes for life after sports.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes