The Obesity Bias

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

If you’re significantly overweight, warmth may be your most powerful weapon against discrimination, says Wharton’s Maurice Schweitzer. More: http://knlg.net/1DUtm5n 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. my work looks at obesity within the united states in the last 50 years obesity has tripled currently 68
  2. of americans are overweight and a full 30 of those people are obese now a lot of the work has
  3. looked at the health and economic consequences for our health care system what happens when people are really
  4. obese and overweight what has received much less attention are the interpersonal and social costs
  5. and my research looks at how people who are obese are discriminated against and perceived differently within a
  6. workplace setting people are discriminating a way that we see obese people as less competent
  7. than non-obese people one of the things we find is that this is a bias that is we can separate actual
  8. competence from perceived competence and we see that people judge obese people unfairly
  9. the second thing we find is that these social perceptions are really labile they can be changed as
  10. a function of things like how warm somebody is so whether or not somebody evokes
  11. sympathy or disgust is a function of how warm they're perceived to be there are a couple things that surprised
  12. us uh first we find this bias it works for both men and for women who are heavy second we found that even heavy people
  13. are biased against other people who are heavy uh and third we were surprised at how
  14. how important this idea of warmth is that it's this idea about expressing your close relationships with
  15. your family your friends your pets that is when people express warmth they're judged to be much more
  16. sympathetic they're liked much better and that in fact this expression of warmth could be even more
  17. important than actually losing weight in changing the way we're perceived by others
  18. the two different implications of this work uh i think apply to people who are doing
  19. the judging like managers who are hiring and promoting people and for targets themselves but first i
  20. think about the managers that is as a manager we want to think about ways in which we can judge other people
  21. in a way that's unbiased and that might mean changing the the way we interview or promote people
  22. and specifically here i'm thinking about trying to make things as objective as possible
  23. so really judging people on the objective merits rather than some other holistic judgment that might
  24. be subject to bias the second set of implications where i think about are for people themselves as targets
  25. when we're concerned about how we're being judged by others demonstrating warmth emerges as a really
  26. important thing that is when we convey our warmth for our family our friends our co-workers
  27. that really matters and it turns out what we find is it matters in particular for people who are
  28. obese and might be targets of discrimination otherwise in our research what we looked at were
  29. people in basically two categories we we focused our contrasts on people who are sort of a normal
  30. size and an obese size and by normal what we did is we looked at meeting statistics
  31. within the united states and for example we looked at women who were five four uh and either 132 pounds or
  32. 220 pounds and for men we looked at people who are five foot nine inches who are either 168 pounds or 243 pounds
  33. and those heavier weights are classified as obese what's interesting is we found that
  34. these effects they held for photos which might be more intuitive but they also held even if we just
  35. presented people with text so we showed people resume information and all they could see were just
  36. numbers they still had these visceral and emotional reactions to obesity what's interesting is the the biases we
  37. have against overweight people are different than the biases we have against other categories for example we know
  38. that there's discrimination based upon race ethnicity religion sexual orientation
  39. the bias against overweight people i think is particularly pernicious because it's judged to be acceptable
  40. that is people perceive it's as if people think you chose to be overweight you violated
  41. this protestant ethic against gluttony and that was your choice and so the sanctions we have against
  42. people who are obese tend to be more overt and more acceptable societally than than other
  43. discrimination that we might see well i think the first thing is to be aware that this is a potential bias
  44. and to recognize that as we judge other people we may judge obese people more harshly what we
  45. find in our research is a very consistent bias perceiving obese people to be less
  46. competent now what's interesting is that even when we disentangle actual competence
  47. from perceived competence we see the gap in judgment it's a bias and i think the first thing
  48. we can do is recognize that it is a potential bias when we're judging other people
  49. and again if we're if we're a manager for recruiting if we're promoting we want to think
  50. about relying on the objective criteria as much as possible and the way we've moved
  51. for example to try to make things more gender neutral as we do as we do recruiting and
  52. promotion we want to think about the same kinds of procedures for judging people based upon their their
  53. size and weight the second part is for people themselves for those of us that are a little bit
  54. heavier to think about not just the health benefits but now also the career and interpersonal benefits of
  55. losing weight and the importance of demonstrating warmth that is when we perceive
  56. when other people perceive us they're going to perceive us differently if we're warm we have close relationships
  57. we've demonstrated concern and care for other people you know i think the the most obvious
  58. story in the news or the one that certainly hits me first uh are stories about chris christie when
  59. he wanted to run for president there was a lot of news regarding his weight and in fact i have a quote here from
  60. michael kinsley this is on bloomsburg where he says look i'm sorry but new jersey
  61. governor chris christie cannot be president he is just too fat uh and it goes on but i think the idea
  62. that we're we accept this kind of bias in a way that we wouldn't if it was a racial ethnic
  63. uh or other type of discrimination but we see this to be far more acceptable when it has to do with weight
  64. we root our work in a bias content model where we look at perceptions of other people based upon two dimensions
  65. warmth and competence and here what we're looking at are people who are perceived to be low
  66. competence and so obesity what we find is one trigger that signals perceptions of low competence
  67. but there are others for example there are stereotypical groups like the elderly who are also perceived to be
  68. low incompetence now we find is that people who perceive to be low competence could be discriminated against but that
  69. social perception is really a labile changeable construct and when those people let's say the elderly demonstrate warmth
  70. they're perceived much more sympathetically than when they're perceived to be cold
  71. our research is the first to embed social perceptions of obesity within a broader theoretical
  72. framework and what this framework allows us to do is explore how perceptions can change
  73. and we develop testable predictions and test those to show that things like warmth for
  74. example can shift in a predictable way the reactions that we get both the perceptions and the behavior
  75. consequences that follow those perceptions i'm very interested in how the appearance
  76. of somebody influences their interpersonal perception and how it influences our social
  77. interactions i focus on obesity because it's such a growing and important problem in the united
  78. states and abroad but i'm also interested in how other aspects of appearance like physical
  79. attractiveness influence our social perceptions with obesity in particular i'm also
  80. interested in what happens for example after we lose weight you can imagine somebody that loses
  81. weight both through a surgical operation or by diet and exercise we might perceive people differently as
  82. a function of how they lost weight and if they lost weight so i think there are a lot of questions going forward
  83. that we could fruitfully explore you

Brief Summary

Obesity bias affects workplace perceptions; warmth can change judgments.

Key points

  • Obesity in America. Obesity has tripled in the last 50 years, affecting 68% of Americans.
  • Perceptions of Competence. Research shows that obese individuals are often perceived as less competent.
  • The Importance of Warmth. Demonstrating warmth can significantly alter perceptions of obese individuals.
  • Pernicious Bias. The bias against overweight individuals is particularly harmful and socially accepted.
  • Acceptable Bias. Bias against obesity is often seen as more acceptable than other forms of discrimination.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes