How AI Is Changing the Skills Employers Look For

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Eric Bradlow, Vice Dean of AI and Analytics at Wharton, breaks down the accelerating shift toward a skills-based economy. He explores the growing skills gap in today’s labor market and what it means for students and upcoming graduates as they prepare to enter an AI-driven workforce, based on insights from the Wharton-Accenture Skills Index, made in partnership with Accenture.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#AIandJobs #SkillsGap #WorkforceAnalytics #TalentStrategy #labormarket ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. One of the concerns in the labor market right now is a perceived mismatch in skills, what companies are looking for and
  2. what might be actually available in the labor market. Part of the reason why is a very quick reorganization going on at the
  3. moment, and to no surprise, AI is playing a role in all of this. But how do we best judge the skills gap? Recently,
  4. Wharton and Accenture came together to try and tackle that issue. Pleasure to be joined by Eric Bradlow, who's Vice Dean of
  5. AI and Analytics at Wharton, as well as Professor and Chair of the Wharton School of Management— excuse me, Marketing Department.
  6. Eric, great to see you again. How are you? It's great to be on the show, Dan. Thank you. All right. I've heard the
  7. conversation about skills gap for at least a couple of years now. How significant of an issue is it?
  8. Well, the best way I can describe that it's really significant is, as you can imagine, given my role at AI and
  9. Analytics at the school, I talk to alumni. Go travel the world, talk to our current students. The minute I'm done talking, the
  10. number one question asked of me is, what— let's say it's for undergraduates. What should my high schooler be studying? What
  11. jobs are going to be left over? It's the same question asked for— by undergrads, MBAs, at all levels. I think it's the most
  12. significant question from our side, from the academic side, because what should we be training students to do? And the
  13. only way to understand that— and remember, we're Wharton, which means we're the empirical school where and we're going to
  14. talk about this, we're not just going to opine on the skills gap, we're going to actually measure the skills gap.
  15. And so that's part of the reason why this partnership between Wharton and Accenture came about, to kind of better understand
  16. what's happening and how to address it. I think, let me— it's a good question. The Wharton partnership
  17. with Accenture— and I should say, it is the flagship partnership. We call it the affiliates program. Accenture is the number
  18. one affiliate of Wharton AI and analytics. We're doing a little branding here today for that. This is one piece of a much
  19. larger partnership, which also involves developing content around AI and analytics, events around AI and analytics, thought
  20. pieces around AI and analytics. But absolutely, you know, Accenture is, of course, their— one of their big parts of their
  21. business model is providing support to companies in areas where there are those gaps. And so it's not just to enlighten
  22. us, but it's for their structure and their reorganization that they want to understand what the skills gap is as well.
  23. And the term skills-based economy seems to be growing in importance right now from the business side.
  24. I think you've said the correct word, in my view, at least four times since this interview started. Which is, it's not a
  25. jobs gap. And that's the crucial part. People ask, you know, go back 30 years. What job should I go into? That's not the
  26. right question anymore. It's what skills do I need to have? And as a matter of fact, what you're seeing on more and more
  27. resumes— because I get— I see resumes all the time, not just from students, but as you know, I have a company. All the time, I
  28. see people applying. I do the following, Dan. Obviously, people tend to list their experience. That's great. They
  29. list their education, that's great. I go directly to the bottom of people's resumes, which is typically where they
  30. list their skills. That's what everyone's hiring against today. Everyone's hiring for people with skills. And while this is
  31. not part of the report, as you know, for 20 years, one of the things we've been doing at Wharton AI and analytics is,
  32. while people are students here and to our alumni worldwide, providing people skills-based opportunity to take what they've
  33. learned in the classroom and apply those skills to actual, real world projects. Because that's what companies are
  34. looking for today. I saw something in the report that also talked about the fact that skills, in many instances, are becoming more
  35. important than the actual job titles that companies are looking to fill. Oh, I could not agree with you more. In other words, what
  36. you're— let's see. The other thing that's going to happen besides my agreement with that statement, what you're going to
  37. see is assessments that firms do. Look, I'll give you an example with my middle son. He was taking a skills-based job
  38. recently at a private equity firm. He literally went through, and this is no exaggeration, Dan, 13 rounds of skills-based
  39. interviews to come up with, does he know this? Does he know that? Does he know this? And so I think what you're also going to
  40. see, it's going to back up just from, do I hire Dan Loney? Do I hire Eric Bradlow? You're going to see the evaluation of what
  41. skills you have increase. And actually, the nice— another thing about artificial intelligence, by the
  42. way, is you can ask it to construct those skills-based assessments. And not only will it say, "Eric Bradlow has this
  43. skill," or not, but if I don't have that skill, it will provide me the education I need to develop that skill.
  44. What does that mean, then, in terms of the needs, the necessities that the individual will need, or the student coming
  45. out of college, or the student coming out of high school going into the workforce, that they will need to have, or at least
  46. start to develop while they are still going through their education process? Yeah, so you talk about two things. Three— actually,
  47. there's three answers to your question. The first is, is that Eric Bradlow and Dan Loney could be sitting in the same classes,
  48. taking the same curriculum, but because of artificial intelligence and the degree and the ability of personalization,
  49. Dan will get— even if we have the same grades, Dan will get, "Your skills are deficient in this area." "Eric, your skills are
  50. deficient in this area." The second thing is, Dan will get, "Here's your individualized lesson plan to build your skills
  51. in this area." "Eric Bradlow, here are yours. Here's your lesson plan to get skills in this area." The third thing is— and this, Dan,
  52. is going to take a little bit longer, because we in education tend to not be the most innovative and fast moving. How
  53. does the curriculum change from course labels to skill-based labels? And that's what— by the way, that's what students know.
  54. Because students, by the way— students typically lead us faculty. Students know the skills they need, and they're
  55. going to be looking for courses, whether it's whether we try to tell it in the title of the course or in the description,
  56. trust me, students— here's what I know students are doing, Dan. You'll like this. They're ingesting syllabi from faculty
  57. about courses and seeing whether it matches the skills they want to acquire. Are, then, the changes that we will see occur in the
  58. education side, are they more subtle in terms of the development off of what is already being taught, or are we
  59. talking about a complete 180? Yeah, it's a great question. So there'll be differing of opinions on this, but since I'm
  60. here, I get to give my opinion on this. - Right. Right. I think everything has to change. I'll just give you an example of
  61. myself, and I know I speak not just for myself. One of my colleagues who works with us at Wharton AI and Analytics started
  62. what's called the Wharton Generative AI Lab, which is Ethan Mollick, who's extremely well known now, is well-read
  63. and well-posted on these topics. He and I both believe that pretty much everything has to change. Let me give you an
  64. example. So I teach— I'm about to start, literally two weeks from today or two weeks from yesterday. I teach our MBA Core
  65. here at the Wharton School. And it's, of course, not surprisingly, Dan, in data- driven marketing, which brings
  66. together my love of data science and marketing. Up until two years ago, this was a course where I would have students
  67. ingest data, analyze data using R or Python, come out with analyzes, interpret those analyzes and say what it means
  68. to the firm. Well, now, of course, the generation of data can be done using generative AI, whether it's from real data or
  69. simulated data. The analysis is now about prompt engineering. It's not about teaching them R or Python, because you can code
  70. that directly in large language models. So literally, every aspect of my course, from evaluation— I have Dan Loney
  71. read a case. Let's be honest. Dan Loney is taking that case, ingesting into a large language model, and is going to ask it for
  72. the answer. A matter of fact, if Dan Loney is a smart man, Dan Loney is doing that. And by the way, that's the skills that jobs want
  73. you to have. They're not going to drop 50 PDFs on your thing and say, "Print them out and read them." They know you're not going
  74. to do that. So I'm a believer that we need to totally rethink the way we educate people around skills. And I know we're going
  75. to talk in a second about which skills I think tend to be over versus undervalued.
  76. Well, that was going to be my next question, because from a business perspective, they have to look at this from the bottom
  77. line, which means the financial side of this. So there is a value when you're talking about what skills are most valuable
  78. and what skills are not. And can you can you already see certain skills that are kind of universally more valuable, kind
  79. of across the business, no matter who it is? So there's two answers to your question. First, we have to
  80. talk about the skills that are valued, and then we have to talk about supply and demand. There could be a skill that's
  81. extremely valued, but there's too much of it in the market. So let me give you an example. This is why we work with Accenture
  82. on this skills gap. So let me just be clear on what we did, to every— to all of our listeners here. There's a company called
  83. Light Start. What we did is that we scraped data from both job postings and from resumes. That makes a lot
  84. of sense. Job postings list— forget just the titles— the skills they— and experience they want people to have. Resumes are
  85. people highlighting the skills and experience they have. Let's see if there's a gap between the two. That was the intent of the
  86. project, to have an empirically- driven measure that we could do every year. Wharton, partnered with Accenture, on the skills
  87. gap. Now the next natural question— remember also, jobs come with salaries, which means— or ranges, which means you can
  88. now say which skills tend to be paid more, right? You can do that. You can also say which resumes and which skills
  89. in those resumes tend to get accepted for higher paying jobs. You can start doing that. So all the things that you might want
  90. to answer, you can do through this data. So let me tell you the two— the two big highlights that came out for me. So one of
  91. the things I hear all the time, Dan, I'm sure you've heard this, is that five years ago, every child, man, woman, etc, was told,
  92. "You got to study computer science, because Big Data science is the future." Now, all I hear is, "Should my kids take
  93. any coding classes whatsoever? Because isn't computer science going to be entirely democratized?" So one of the
  94. skills we found is that there's a oversupply of people with claimed computer science skills. Now I'm not saying people don't
  95. need those skills, but they— it's— there's an oversupply of it. The part on the other side, though, the two things that never go
  96. away— and I'm not sure AI is going to replace those skills. Maybe they will— are what I would call communication and selling.
  97. Because what happens is, if AI can do the technical parts of jobs, or parts of the technical parts, you still need to be able
  98. to sell the ideas. You still need to be able to sell your company services. So that part, there's an under— let me say, be
  99. clear— there's a claimed undersupply, which means maybe people aren't highlighting the right skills in their resumes.
  100. The second thing that came about was— you know, I hate to say this, but too many people claim, "I've got leadership
  101. skills." Well, the problem— I'm not saying leadership skills aren't important. All I'm saying is, when we look at the supply
  102. and the demand of leadership skills, there are too many people that say they have leadership skills compared to
  103. jobs that are hiring people that say, "We need someone with leadership skills." What do you think, then, this means for the labor market as we
  104. go into the future? Well, let me— that's good. Great question. These are great questions. That's why I love talking to you, Dan.
  105. Thank you, Eric. No, no, no. This is why we've been together for— we've been partnering for 15-plus years on this. - Oh my god, yeah.
  106. It's been— and then sometimes it's around sports, sometimes it's around <i>This Week in Business</i>, it's all kinds of things. - Yep.
  107. I would say two things. Here's what's going to happen in the short term. I think, obviously, in my view, the Wharton School,
  108. Accenture, we're going to push this report out. Big launch tomorrow. Big, big PR launch about this. First, if I were a
  109. rational person looking for a job in the short term, maybe I can't do skill acquisition, but I'll put on my marketing hat. I
  110. can reposition the skills I have around the skills that companies are demanding. So rather than emphasizing my leadership
  111. skills, which I'm not saying you don't need to have, but maybe you should emphasize the things that we're finding.
  112. Communication, your technical skills, because those are the skills that there seem to be an undersupply for. So I think this
  113. is literally marketing. What you're going to see is a short term repositioning of people in the way they describe their
  114. skills. Now in the medium term, this is where, whether it's academic institutions with full time jobs or, what it is, it's
  115. other institutions that are actually coming up with short term courses. That's what we're going to see. We're actually
  116. going to see people saying, "I see there's a shortage of digital marketing skills. There's a shortage of web
  117. development skills." They're going to come in and create that content. Eric, always great to get your thoughts and your insight.
  118. Thanks again. Look forward to talking again down the road. It's great to talk to you, Dan, and I really believe this
  119. Wharton Accenture Skills Gap Report will be something we hope that is tracked as much as anything over time.
  120. Eric Bradlow, Vice Dean of AI and Analytics here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Eric Bradlow discusses the skills gap in the labor market and the need for education to focus on skills over job titles.

Key points

  • Wharton and Accenture Partnership. A collaboration to measure and address the skills gap in the workforce.
  • The Skills Gap Challenge. Eric Bradlow discusses the significant skills gap in the labor market and its implications.
  • The Shift to Skills-Based Education. Eric argues for a complete overhaul of educational approaches to focus on skills rather than job titles.
  • Valuable Skills for the Future. Discussion on which skills are becoming more valuable in the job market, like communication and selling.
  • Short-Term Job Market Strategies. Advice on how job seekers can reposition their skills to meet market demands.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes