How AI Is Reshaping Jobs, Skills, and Education in Real Time

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Professor Manav Raj talks about how AI is changing the way people work, how tasks are shifting within jobs, and how companies are still figuring out how to reorganize work around these new technologies. He discusses the uncertainty students face in the job market, the evolving value of degrees and master's programs, and how education is adapting to focus on skills less susceptible to automation. He also explains how using AI tools directly is essential for understanding their impact, both for individuals and for researchers.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#AI #FutureOfWork #JobMarket #WorkplaceTrends #TaskAutomation #AIImpact ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, it seems that we may be hitting somewhat of a unique and potentially concerning part of the job
  2. marketplace. We are seeing layoffs as companies somewhat right size their operations. And at the same time, you are seeing
  3. recent college graduates find it harder to get that first job. So what does this all mean for them, and especially, what does
  4. it mean for the importance and the value of a degree, or even going for your masters? Pleasure to be joined right now
  5. by Manav Raj, who's an Assistant Professor of Management here at the Wharton School. Manav, how are you? Great to talk to you again.
  6. I'm doing well, Dan. Thanks for having me. And so you're right in the middle of this, probably seeing
  7. and hearing from some of your students, as— you know, some of the issues that they are dealing with right now.
  8. Yes, that's correct. I mean, I see this on both sides of things. My research studies technology change, and has
  9. focused a lot on AI. So, obviously thinking about the job market effects of that technology. And certainly in the last few years,
  10. teaching tech strategy and interacting both with undergraduates and with the MBA students here, there's a lot of
  11. conversation and concern and thought about, you know, what the job market might look like and how students should be
  12. preparing themselves best for the future. So let's start with the AI component, because it's
  13. obviously one of the biggest questions out there right now, and a lot of discussion as to just how much AI is going to
  14. impact the workforce in the years ahead. Let me ask you this then, from two perspectives. One, what are you seeing right
  15. now? And two, what is your expectation 10 or 20 years out in terms of how AI will be impacting the marketplace?
  16. Yeah. I mean, I'll start actually, with the second question. You know, 10 to 15 years out, I think I expect it
  17. to have large impacts. As many of us know, especially those of us who are using these kinds of technologies, you know, the
  18. capabilities are fairly impressive, given, you know, how rapid the progress has been, and our ability to do things have
  19. changed, right? Like I use it day to day in my work as well. We— it's altered, kind of, the ways that I carry out many of my
  20. tasks. And I'm sure that's the case in many white collar occupations, even at the early stage of the technology is
  21. relative to where it'll be in 15 years. You know, when we think about the job market impacts right now, it's something that
  22. me and my colleagues, you know, are very curious about, because there's just a lot of uncertainty. I mean, we have
  23. uncertainty in the macro environment generally right now, I think, but especially with this technology. You know, we—
  24. the tools are developing rapidly. There is a big learning curve in figuring out how best we can deploy them. And, you
  25. know, even as we know that they improve our individual productivity, there's a organizational component of how
  26. do firms and organizations actually reallocate tasks and move things around in a way that the firm is able to also
  27. increase the productivity of the aggregate. Is that— at least in the short term, the important
  28. question right now is just how much it can have an impact. How does it change somebody's job on a week to week, month to month
  29. basis, in terms of, you know, obviously the help they can get from things like ChatGPT, but how it may change some of the
  30. dynamics of what their job actually becomes? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we think about jobs, in my field,
  31. oftentimes, as like a bundle of tasks or skills, right? And what we have is this new technology coming in, and you're changing
  32. the value or in changing how we do some of these different tasks, right? So if, for example, you're a copywriter,
  33. right, perhaps some of the— the tasks you've done previously about actually writing some of these lines becomes automated,
  34. and you have to reallocate your tasks and your time in a different way, right? And so some of those are done at the
  35. individual level. Right? Again, when I'm playing around with these tools and trying to figure out how I can best use them for
  36. my research, I'm reallocating on my end. And then again, you know, when we're thinking about the job market, a big question
  37. mark right now is, how do firms move things around? And how are they understanding where they want to be reallocating their
  38. workers and changing their hiring. What does this mean, then, for the students moving forward? And I
  39. kind of open it by saying, you know, what is this going to mean for the type of degree that they're going to want to get?
  40. Are they going to want to pursue a master's degree, if there is— I mean, it's kind of that balance between— and maybe we
  41. don't know yet, how much of this is still going to be human and how much is going to be technology?
  42. Absolutely. I mean, I think there is a lot of uncertainty here. Obviously, as a business school professor, you
  43. know, I want to be bullish on master's education in general, and I am. But I think it's— you know, it's a challenge for us as
  44. educators to think about how we can retain the value in the degree. You know, just as with other technology changes in
  45. the past, you know, the kind of work will shift. I know when I talk to my colleagues, we may care a little bit less about the
  46. case write-ups that the students are doing right now. Because, you know maybe it's pretty trivial to come up with a
  47. reasonably high-quality case write up with ChatGPT. But, you know, I want to understand how the students are thinking
  48. creatively. I want them to work on their communication skills. The kinds of things that I think are a little bit more protected,
  49. I guess, at this point, from these technologies. Whereas there may be other skills that are a little bit more exposed.
  50. Is this, then, the beginning of a path where we will see change continuing to occur? And it always does. But when you think
  51. about how AI is going to factor in. And then, you know, there are probably, you know, a variety of jobs where quantum
  52. computing, you know, in the next several years, is going to be impacting those jobs as well. And it feels like we're starting
  53. to get into a pattern where technology is going to play a larger role in everything we do.
  54. I think that seems to be the case. I mean, when we think about previous generations of technology change that may have
  55. led to automation, we oftentimes think of things like manufacturing, right? And I think what's different here,
  56. perhaps, is that, you know, this is affecting a lot of what we think of as high skill work. You know, white collar occupations
  57. where cognitive skills and communications come into play. And that obviously opens up, you know, a much larger swath
  58. of the economy, in the labor market, to be thinking about these effects manifesting in.
  59. Are you seeing sectors right now that maybe aren't as affected by AI as others right now, and whether or not they're just playing catch
  60. up at the moment? Or maybe they are going to be a little bit devoid of having that serious AI impact moving forward?
  61. Yeah. As of right now, you know, I think one of the things that people have talked about a lot with these new technologies is
  62. that they seem to be general purpose technologies in the sense that they can have impacts in many sectors and many
  63. settings. And I suspect over the long run, we'll see that. In the short run, you know, definitely there are some industries and
  64. sectors paying more attention to this, and that have just figured out how to use these tools better. Or perhaps, maybe
  65. another way to put it is, the tools are better suited for the task, right? And so programming is, like, a really easy one to
  66. think about, right? Both in terms of people who are in these technology industries are very aware of what's happening here,
  67. and these tools are very good at many of these coding kinds of tasks. So I think we could— you know, if we're imagining where
  68. we might start seeing some of these effects pop up first, I wouldn't be surprised if we see them, you know, start showing up
  69. in kind of coding and programming jobs, and then kind of slowly diffusing out into other areas. But again, even
  70. there, I think there's this— there is this question of, like, trying to figure out the organizational implications. And
  71. one example I'll just toss out is that, you know, there's— there's some research that has been done, or evidence that can
  72. suggest that, you know, many of these AI tools can carry out tasks that can be done by entry level consultants or things like
  73. that. But the problem is, if you automate those tasks, you're not helping your entry level consultants develop the skills
  74. that they need to kind of move up in the organization and do things that the AI can't do, right? And so I think these are
  75. the kinds of questions that firms are thinking through. And you know, I suspect we're going to see a little bit of a— some
  76. time before we have good answers to them. I'll finish up on this. What do you think, then, is the longer
  77. term message that needs to be sent to people heading into the workforce, whether you're a college graduate or you're— you
  78. know, looking for a blue collar job, whatever it is. And on top of that, how, then, potentially, does that impact how you and
  79. your colleagues are thinking about the type of research that you're going to conduct?
  80. Yeah. I mean, so the advice that I give my students, and maybe this feels like a very basic piece of advice, is, you know,
  81. if you're worried about the concerns of AI, just use these tools a lot, first. And I think that's— that's kind of the
  82. first order condition to understanding how to respond to them, is just understanding them. What are they good at? You know,
  83. where can they help me? Where are they going to make my skills redundant? And then try and, you know, push towards the things
  84. that you think you can actually bring value on. For our research, you know, it's certainly something that I think people in
  85. my field are also interested in and concerned about. There was an interesting presentation I saw recently where, you know,
  86. they were analyzing working papers, research in progress. And they're saying, you know, a large majority of papers now, or
  87. there's a big increase in influx of research that may use these tools too. And obviously there are questions around quality
  88. and, you know, kind of the provenance of what comes out of this. So I'm trying to follow the same advice I'm giving my
  89. students. I'm using these a lot. I'm trying to figure out, you know, where can I be effective on using these tools to
  90. improve the quality of the product and improve my productivity? But it's still a work in progress, certainly on our end too.
  91. Manav, appreciate your time and your insight. All the best. Appreciate it. Thanks, Dan.
  92. Thank you. Manav Raj, Assistant Professor of Management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

AI is reshaping the job market, impacting degrees and skills needed for future employment.

Key points

  • The Impact of AI on Jobs. Manav Raj discusses how AI is changing the job market and the skills needed for future employment.
  • Preparing for the Future Workforce. Manav Raj emphasizes the importance of creativity and adaptability in education amidst technological changes.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes