Will AI Take Your Job? Experts Say Maybe Not

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton's Peter Cappelli joins Dan Loney to discuss how AI is reshaping the workplace, the risks of overhyped forecasts, and why company leaders may be making premature decisions under investor pressure. They explore which jobs are actually most vulnerable, how firms may backtrack on automation efforts, and what this all means for the next generation of workers.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#AIAdoption #FutureOfWork #JobAutomation #ArtificialIntelligence #WorkplaceTrends #AIAndJobs ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, as AI has become more of a growing part of our professional lives, the question has been asked about how much
  2. it might impact a thing like the workplace. And that question has seemingly been buried by many members of
  3. the seauite up until now. We're starting to hear leaders of companies have comments about just how many of their
  4. employees might no longer have a job in the years ahead. To more on that, we're joined by Peter Capelli, who is a
  5. management professor here at Wharton. He's also director of the Center on Human Resources. Peter, great to talk to
  6. you again. How are you, sir? >> Good. Thank you, Dan. >> I guess it's probably not a surprise
  7. that at some point we were going to have to see leaders of companies address this
  8. issue because it's just one that is seemingly on the forefront of a lot of people's minds.
  9. >> Yeah, it's a good thing that they're addressing it. I think as we'll see in a
  10. couple of minutes in the conversation, unfortunately they what they really should be telling people is a lot of we
  11. don't know yet. Uh and I think I'm not sure what they're telling them is the most useful thing yet. It's kind of
  12. scaring people. >> Right. Well, but the comments uh from people like Jim Farley, the Ford CEO,
  13. saying half of all white collar jobs will be gone. Uh is that an overestimate or is that to a degree somewhat on
  14. point? Well, uh, we've had those, uh, kind of forecasts for about 20 years now and
  15. they haven't worked out, right? So, I would say if you were a betting person, you would bet against that and nothing
  16. I'm seeing right now suggests that that's going to happen. Um, but, you know, the effects might be very
  17. different depending what kind of job you've got. >> Why do you think that is that maybe
  18. those some of those estimates are maybe a little bit high? What is it about, I guess, the structure of the company, the
  19. jobs themselves that that you see that is still going to require that human connection?
  20. >> Well, I think we really don't we know very little about how these tools can actually be used. So, the story has been
  21. driven largely by people who build them talking about what could be done. So we will all remember by 2019 driverless
  22. trucks would have taken over and you need to get rid of your truck drivers because there was you know they were
  23. going to be obsolete and there were companies that actually did that and then of course they got completely
  24. surprised when it hadn't happened at all. So, you know, the forecasts have been wildly wrong. And if you are a a
  25. person concerned about risk, I would not pay much attention to the forecasts because they have been wildly wrong.
  26. They've been driven largely by people who build the systems, thinking about what they could do rather than what's
  27. cost effective to do and what is sort of reasonable to do. Right? So, we're only
  28. getting a sense of that now. Is there some of this that we may see companies make some of these moves and then have
  29. to do a 180, a U-turn to bring people back in as they learn what they can and can't use?
  30. >> Yeah, I I understand there's already been a little bit of that in various places, but yes, I think there we
  31. probably will see that. And I I think there's a a reason for it that u we may have talked about before and that is you
  32. know in the finance world there is a real preference for companies to squeeze down headcount. Part of the reason for
  33. that is companies are assessed on profit per employee profit you know cost per employee everything per employee. So if
  34. you can get your headcount down that's really a nice thing. And employers don't think very much about the costs of
  35. losing people. And some of that is because human capital has no accounting value. Uh and so you know if you lay
  36. people off usually the investors if they do anything they just cheer. Nobody's thinking about what has to happen if in
  37. fact you fall short of talent. What happens then? You know we know what the answers are and they're not pretty but
  38. in the investment world we're not seeing them. So I would imagine that you probably could bet on some of that
  39. happening. Yes. >> And there are probably and it's and this may be a question where you know it's
  40. going to depend on the firm or the sector but there probably are jobs that as you go along and you look at these
  41. different companies different sectors that there will be jobs that would be more susceptible than others within the
  42. firm to potentially get cut. >> Sure. I think that's right. Now, what we're learning is those jobs appear to
  43. be the exact opposite of what people said they would be. So, you know, up until just a little while ago, people
  44. thought the simple jobs would be the ones most easily replaced. And that is not turning out to be the case. One of
  45. the reasons why is in simple jobs like sorting and coding, right? Or moving data from one pile to another, one set
  46. of documents to another. The problem with that is it has to be absolutely right. And to make sure it's absolutely
  47. right, you have to build the algorithms, train them on real data to make sure that it can tell what is in pile A and
  48. what should be in pile B. And it takes a long time to get that right and it's really expensive to do. On the other
  49. hand, things which are you can do right now with no training is ask the internet
  50. to provide a summary of what we know about the tire industry in China, right? Uh those answers are probably not going
  51. to be that great right now. They won't be as good as some expert would give you, but they're cheap and they're free
  52. and they're quick, right? So, it turns out that if you're doing some knowledge work, um maybe those jobs are pretty
  53. susceptible. But even there, the reality is nowhere near the hype. Let me give you an example. If you look at computer
  54. programmers, which is one of those where people are saying they're just going to
  55. be obsolete, right? Well, there have been for a long time tools that would help you automate programming. They'll
  56. suggest code that other people have already written on this topic you're trying to do with this question. So,
  57. that stuff's been around for a while. AI, generative AI, arguably better than that. But when you look at what
  58. programmers actually do on their job, it appears they only spend about 30% of their time actually coding,
  59. >> right? >> So what are they spending the rest of the time on? Negotiating a budget,
  60. talking to their clients and users to see what is it you actually need. Negotiating between the budget and the
  61. clients. Here's what we think we can do. That's where they're spending their time. So if AI took over completely the
  62. programming task, you still got 70% of the work that so far it looks like people do.
  63. >> So what does this potentially mean then as we look down the road for the next
  64. generation? Because obviously we're learning about a lot of this right now. that next generation coming into the
  65. workforce, they have to I guess if you know if you're in high school now and you're going to college now, you have to
  66. have the expectation that AI is going to be part of the mix. But you know, how much could it potentially develop? And I
  67. guess to a degree this there's a lot of still unknowns that haven't been answered yet.
  68. >> Yeah. And I think that is the point. Uh what is a mistake is making a guess and
  69. investing a lot of money in that guess. So saying for example, you know, they can never automate art. Uh so I'm going
  70. into art and then it turns out they can automate art pretty well. You know, it's
  71. just hard to know. So don't place a single bet and say this is the field I'm going into because, you know, we can't
  72. automate it. And some of the ones that, you know, it we thought they were going to automate pretty easily, it turns out
  73. it's hard to do. So I guess I would just not worry about it all that much trying
  74. to guess where the technology will go. I think the problem companies have right now and I think you hear it from the
  75. CEOs is that they're under pressure to respond to the hype and the hype is AI is the way to cut headcount. So get busy
  76. and do it. Right. Right. So there was an interesting survey uh of top executives
  77. saying 74% of them said that they felt their job was on the line if they couldn't deliver these cuts basically
  78. and they can't. They also said about a third of what they're doing with AI is performative. It's not actually doing
  79. what they say it's doing and they're kind of pretending. That doesn't mean they're necessarily lying but they're
  80. counting a lot of stuff as AI which is not even AI at all. Right? So the problem is we don't know. The CEOs are
  81. under pressure because the boards in particular think we do know and so they're responding in ways which are
  82. probably going to be dysfunctional. >> Peter, great to talk to you and get your insight as always. Thank you, sir.
  83. >> Thank you, Dan. >> Peter Capelli, management professor here at the Wharton School and director for
  84. the Center on Human Resources.

Brief Summary

Peter Capelli discusses AI's uncertain impact on jobs and workplace dynamics, emphasizing the need for caution in predictions and decisions.

Key points

  • The Uncertain Future of Jobs. Peter Capelli discusses the potential impact of AI on the workforce and the uncertainty surrounding it.
  • AI's Job Predictions. Capelli reflects on past job loss forecasts and their inaccuracies.
  • Navigating AI in Careers. Capelli advises against making definitive career choices based on AI predictions.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes