Understanding the Future of Work, Labor Trends, and Organizational Change

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Dean Erika James sat down with George W. Taylor Professor of Management Peter Cappelli to explore his path into higher education, his perspective on workforce transformation, and the evolution of labor economics. They discuss the decline of unions, the impact of remote work, management underinvestment, global workforce trends, and higher education's current challenges. Drawing on 40 years at Wharton, Cappelli reflects on organizational behavior, employee relations, and leadership strategy in uncertain times.

This talk is part of the series “What I’ve Learned,” which puts the spotlight on Wharton faculty who have made a lasting impact on their fields.

#FutureOfWork #RemoteWork #Management #OrganizationalBehavior #WorkplaceCulture #LaborEconomics ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dean James: Peter, thanks for joining us. Peter: Thank you for have me. - Glad that you're here.
  2. I'd like to start with an origin story of sorts. So if you were to think back across the span of your
  3. life, what are two or three instances or moments or experiences that really propelled you for
  4. a career in higher education and a career in labor economics, more specifically?
  5. Getting to college was a transformative time for most everybody. I have pretty big case of attention deficit
  6. disorder, which was not treated. Of course, they didn't even know what it was, right? But when I got to college, I realized if I
  7. could lock myself in the library and study, then I could focus and get things done. And I went from being a not particularly
  8. distinguished high school student to a distinguished college student. So that was certainly one of them. I would
  9. say, as with many of our colleagues here, we didn't necessarily set out to be faculty members, you know. And a
  10. large number of us intended to be lawyers. At least when I was in college, if you were good in science, you wanted to be a
  11. doctor, if you were good and everything else, you want to be a lawyer. And my father was a lawyer. And so that sort of made
  12. sense. But my father died when I was in college, so that kind of derailed that ambition a little bit. So maybe that was the other
  13. one. But even then, I was in graduate school, I went to Oxford, with the idea of just goofing around for a while
  14. and coming back here, and I discovered you couldn't do that. You had to enter a degree program. So I did that, and I
  15. was not quite done. So I got a postdoc at MIT, and then I kind of woke up, and I was a professor. You know, was already
  16. down the pike a little bit, without so much a conscious choice early on, saying this is what I was going to do. You
  17. know, I didn't know an awful lot about careers, right? I didn't know what business careers were like. I didn't know what
  18. consulting jobs were like, nor did anybody else. At Oxford, I went to see the careers people at one point, and they said, "You
  19. have the rest of your life to worry about your career. Don't worry about it now." So very different advice, right, than
  20. when we got here. Very different advice. So how did you come to learn about the field that you chose to study and pursue?
  21. Well, as an undergraduate, I was around a lot of these topics. I was interested in the issue of how we regulate economic forces.
  22. So I was interested in a lot of the legislative efforts to try to constrain, guide, harness economic forces, and
  23. particularly not crush people in the process. So I was interested in those general questions. And then that takes you, you know,
  24. into these topics. And also in England, labor economics looked a little different. It wasn't dominated by large data sets
  25. and, you know, econometrics, it was much more go get data and look at it. So it looks more like what we do here, maybe,
  26. than what you would see in an economics department. So you were in graduate school in the late '70s. It was the time
  27. period where labor unions were starting to be a bit on the decline, and there was an emergence in the management
  28. literature on different theories of management. So how did that, or did that shift in how we thought about labor and the
  29. workforce influence your own work? Yeah. Well, career changes, right? Because I wrote my thesis
  30. about inflation. And as soon as I finished it, inflation kind of disappeared. So that topic was gone. And then, you know, when I
  31. came to the Wharton School, there were still seven people here who studied unions, right? And it used to be that, if you
  32. looked in corporations, the executive vice president was industrial relations. Human resources reported to the
  33. industrial relations people. And part of my early career, when I came back to the US, was studying what caused these
  34. unions to collapse. And it wasn't just economic, global economic pressures, it was a sort of concerted effort by
  35. employers who had sort of decided that the old bargain that you just should accept unions and strikes and, you
  36. know, not try to fight them— they didn't buy that any longer. So it was a shift in values, I think, that led companies to take
  37. off the gloves, as it were, and started to take the unions apart, you know. So that started in 1981, which was— with the
  38. recession. That was, you know, at the time, the worst recession since the Great Depression. And that was part of it, was
  39. dismantling unions. Part of what happened then is, "Okay. What do we got now?" Well, because part of dismantling unions was also
  40. inside the great corporations restructuring themselves down to shrink. And a lot of it was the belief that they were bloated,
  41. and they probably were, having grown up in a period of regulation, stable markets, lots of planning. And that all
  42. kind of went out the window. So that was probably me talking about that issue of what happens when we got rid of lifetime
  43. employment. That was my work in the 1990s, trying to think about that. And at the time, you know, a lot of people didn't believe
  44. it had changed, because we had had that for 45 years or so, 50 years, that stable model of big corporations. And just hard
  45. to believe that it disappeared that quickly. But in fact, it did. So speaking of change, and in some cases, transformational
  46. change pretty rapidly, is the way in which the workforce has changed as a result of, for example, the pandemic. Remote
  47. work, which wasn't something we were talking about 10 years ago, we are now trying to actively navigate. So as you think about
  48. some of these big contextual variables that are now influencing the workplace, what is your advice to organizations
  49. and to leaders about how we should be thinking about and preparing— advice to a Dean or faculty— how we should be
  50. preparing the workforce of the future, given the shifts that we're seeing? - Well,
  51. you know— and you see this, I'm sure, in practice. But also in university. We have a really hard time with uncertainty, and
  52. we would love, love, love to be able to plan. And to plan, you really need certainty of some kind, you know. And I think the
  53. advice is, we have to get more comfortable with uncertainty. And that planning when you have uncertainty is dangerous, right?
  54. You— assuming you're going in this direction, you start making investments in that direction, and then you discover that, if
  55. you're wrong, you would have been better off just waiting right? And I think with with AI in particular, we're absolutely
  56. in that right now. The assumptions we made about what was going to happen have been proving wrong, wrong and wrong.
  57. Like driverless trucks, right? So by 2019, they were supposed to take over. Every consulting firm had made that story. They've all
  58. taken those reports down off their websites now. They just bury them someplace. But they all believed it, right? And I
  59. think it happens because we really, really want to know what the answer is. And people are willing to tell you, but
  60. they don't know, right? So I think the problem for us, we see this in executive and some of our colleagues here have been
  61. trying to persuade employers to think about this for maybe 10 years or so. How do you deal with uncertainty? You don't have
  62. to ignore it, but you don't have to just make a guess either, right? So I think that's our problem, right?
  63. And would you say it's the same kind of perspective when you think about remote work and how we should be thinking about the
  64. management of a workforce, whether it's in person, whether it's in a hybrid environment, and the way in which technology
  65. has influenced how people can engage with the workplace? Yeah. I think employers are— you know, are really in the driver's
  66. seat on this, right? There's no country in the developed world where employers have more ability to control things in the
  67. US, right? And they're making the calls. I think what concerns me is they're not making sensible calls on this. They're
  68. not thinking through what will work for us as an employer. And I think the problem is in lots of places, they're just assuming
  69. that having people work remotely will be just like if they were in the office, right? And it's not. I think one of the
  70. things that we didn't understand before the pandemic, and before remote work, is how things actually got done in offices,
  71. and how much of it was relational based. Right? That you need something done, you call this person that you know over
  72. here. And some of the research that we did, and some of the studies of hybrid workplaces, discovered that, you know,
  73. that's still what they try to do. If we need something from that team over there, we say, who in our team knows anybody
  74. over there? But the problem is with remote work continuing in some places, average job tenure is four years. We have cohorts
  75. of employees in these companies who really don't know anybody there, because they were never face to face. And so we're kind
  76. of running down the stock of relational capital we've got. And, you know, employers have to think about,
  77. how do we rebuild this so that people will figure out how to get things done? You could do it. Some of the companies like
  78. GitHub, you know, and the virtual companies, all virtual, they figured out ways to do it. But they've got rule books that are
  79. like this thick, you know, telling you, "Here's how you have to describe what you're doing and keep a record of it so
  80. everybody can see it on a common document." And I don't think most employers are willing to go to that much effort. So the choice
  81. is, you know, work is not getting done as well as it could be, and there's now a fair amount of sophisticated research
  82. showing problems with this. Productivity, innovation problems. And the question is, okay, employers, you're in
  83. charge. What are you going to do? Right now? You've been just assuming it's all working. It's not.
  84. So you've had the opportunity to work around the world both as a scholar, as a consultant, as an author. What— have you
  85. identified— are there any sort of universal truths or themes that you have found either about companies and organizations or
  86. about employees, regardless of region or geographical— Yeah. Well, I think, you know, human needs don't differ all
  87. that much around the world. And we like to think they do. We, you know, like to think these national differences and culture
  88. are overwhelming. But, you know, human needs don't differ all that much. I'd say what's really different is how employers deal
  89. with them or don't deal with them. And that stems from how much power the workers have. A lot of that is political power,
  90. right? So if you're in a country that has a Labor Party and the labor has a strong political role, then employers take labor
  91. issues and managing people much more seriously, right? And if you don't, they don't think to go in that direction, you know.
  92. And despite, for example, in the US, the sort of 30-year run of research all saying this, showing that this really matters
  93. and pays off, it doesn't always align with people's guts who are in power. And so they go with their gut, you know. So I'd say
  94. that's the big difference, is people's motivations, needs and things don't differ that much. What does differ across
  95. countries is how seriously the employers are willing to deal with those as a way of trying to be more effective.
  96. So as you think about a lifespan of work and investigation into organizations and employees, is there one thing that you have
  97. seen time and time again that companies just get wrong? Yeah, I think in US companies anyway, I think now, anyway— so in
  98. the last 15 years— they are just underinvesting. You know, not just in employees and training and development, but they're
  99. underinvesting in management. And we're seeing this right now almost, as we speak, companies trying to take layers
  100. of management out. Sounds like a reasonable thing, except what you're doing then is you're really expanding the spans of
  101. control. So one supervisor has 20 people, right? And you just don't— can't keep track of what's going on with those
  102. people, even in their work. You know, how are they doing in their jobs? And we're trying to make the supervisors individual
  103. contributors as well as supervising all these people, right? So I think we are systematically, particularly in
  104. public companies, under- investing. Training is largely disappearing, you know. So a third of US managers say they
  105. never had any training in management before becoming a manager. So I think that's the big thing, which we're seeing
  106. systematically in the US. You know, a lot of ideas from the US translate around the world, maybe through multinational
  107. companies. But you're starting to see some other countries— UK, the Commonwealth countries, especially— following the US
  108. path on some of these things, which is not always great. But not all countries are. Like India, for example, never copy
  109. the US. They were closer to copying Japan than the US. And it's a country that takes managing people very seriously.
  110. And they've got enormous challenges, right? They don't have education systems that are near at the scale that they
  111. need. They have diversity issues that absolutely swamp what we see here. Religion, caste, you know, nationality, language. And
  112. so they have to take them seriously. So I'm curious about this notion of management and the under-
  113. investment of management. So Wharton, obviously, is a premier business school where we teach management. Are we teaching it
  114. the right way? Are there things that we should be including in our syllabi and in the curricula that we are not including, or
  115. things that are outdated that we're doing? What would your advice be? Yeah. So funny story about this. We have a case that we
  116. teach on purpose every year. We've been teaching it for a long time. And it's a case about an investment bank and about the
  117. associates. Junior people in investment banks, you know. And they're often in bullpens in the middle of the— you know, the
  118. building, and the managers are around the outside with window suites. And the people in the middle get these tasks sort of
  119. dropped on them at the last minute. They don't know what's going on. They're working crazy hours.
  120. And then we ask people in the room, you know, "Does this look like what you've been doing?" And they say,
  121. "Yeah, yeah, yeah." And then we tell them the case was written in 1973. Right? So we've had generations of managers go
  122. through, right, and they go off to Wall Street. They know this is crazy, and yet, for some reason, it persists. And I think part of
  123. the problem, which we don't quite understand, I think sometimes, is how much our students, when they come to us,
  124. have already got very strong ideas about things. And there are things they pay attention to and things that they don't. And
  125. they pick those up from what's going on in the business community around them by the time they— when they get here,
  126. right? And it's hard to get them off of those things, right? So that's— I don't think we're teaching the wrong things. I
  127. don't think that's right. Getting their attention is another problem. Well, increasingly now with— I mean, we are officially in the
  128. age of having a digital native generation entering the workforce. And the ability to maintain focus and attention
  129. is a whole other— whole other issue. So you have spent a number of years also focused on women and women's issues in the
  130. workplace. What can you share with us about what drove that interest for you? Well, I think I wrote about a lot of groups that were sort of
  131. disadvantaged in the workplace a little bit. Maybe before we get to the women, one that I think I really had some influence —
  132. it turned out, in a small way that's really mattered was the world of people with disabilities. And with the Office of Disability
  133. Employment in the Department of Labor. And they were persuaded that the problem they had with employers was not being able to
  134. show the ROI on hiring disabled workers. And I pointed out to the people, you know, in the department and elsewhere, you
  135. know, think about the struggles that women had getting into the workforce and then getting up into leadership positions. Do
  136. you think any of that had to do with ROI problems? You think the problem was they couldn't show an ROI as to why you should hire
  137. minorities? "No, no, it wasn't any of that." Well, so why do you think that's what's going on here? The problem with
  138. disability is that people are uncomfortable around those who have disabilities, because they feel if this happened to me, I
  139. would feel terrible, if I lost a limb. And they assume the people they're talking to who have disabilities feel like that. And
  140. they don't, right? Somebody who's lost a limb lost it 20 years ago, right? They're over it. They're dealing with it. They're
  141. fine, right? So don't assume that, you know, they're miserable, right, because of that. That that's the problem.
  142. It wasn't— nothing to do with ROI, right? I think with respect to women, I think, you know, it's similar kinds of
  143. issues. Had nothing to do with ROI, right? It just had to do with discrimination in various kinds of forms. One of the
  144. things that we were showing, actually was about some of the progress that women have made in the managerial and
  145. executive ranks, right? And there were at least some moments where employers were giving women a push to try to advance
  146. them faster than you might otherwise expect, right? So that was kind of encouraging, and it does show that you could make it
  147. happen faster if you wanted, right? Wasn't really pipeline problems or other things, right?
  148. So I want to ask a more personal question, because I think your previous answer surfaced this. Early in your career, you were
  149. diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome. So I don't know if that's considered a disability of sorts, but it's certainly
  150. something that you needed to navigate as a professional, and I'm wondering how you did that, and what influence that
  151. may have had in your thinking about some of the research that you've pursued in this regard.
  152. Yeah, you know, it's a quirky illness, and some people get over it reasonably quickly. For me, it was 20 years, which was
  153. not fun. You know, Somerset Maugham, the novelist, began his career as a doctor. And he said, observing patients, that
  154. there was really no benefit to being sick, you didn't get stronger. Suffering didn't make you better. You know, it was
  155. really nothing useful to it. I think, in terms of what I learned was things that everybody who's successful
  156. knows, you know. And that is, if you actually take time off to get better, you will pay a price for that, right? You'll
  157. pay a price in opportunities that you're going to be passed over because of that. And—
  158. Are you saying that as a perception or as a reality? No that's the reality, I think, right?
  159. And so I can think about my own experience here, for example, when I sort of first had this,
  160. and I had the opportunity to work for the Secretary of Labor, because she was a WEMBA student, Ann McLaughlin, then. And then
  161. that's gonna be in addition to all your other work. You're gonna do that or not? Well, I did it, and because I did that,
  162. then I got this opportunity to run a research center for the Department of Education, which we did with my colleague Bob
  163. Zemsky here for 10 years. And because I did that, I got the opportunity to be the senior advisor to the Crown Prince of
  164. Bahrain. And, you know, these things all— if you miss them at the beginning of your career, you know, they don't necessarily
  165. come back. I think it probably cost me a lot in terms of how long it took to get over this thing, you know. So you pay,
  166. unfortunately, you do pay a price for these things, right? But it is, unfortunately, a really difficult Faustian
  167. choice, you know, to make. I think I was fortunate in many ways. I didn't pay a career price much for this, really. But
  168. you know, you learn how to fake it, right? You learn how to cut out of the reception part of programs. You learn to come in
  169. the night before so you can get more sleep. You know, you learn to go lay down between classes. And, you know, you find ways to
  170. fake it, which are their own skill. And I think that is kind of how I got through it. I don't know that it had a profound
  171. effect on thinking about, you know, these other research topics. I think I am more motivated, maybe, by— than many
  172. people— by things that irritate me. You know, many people say they're motivated by things they love, but there are many things
  173. that I've written really because I found them irritating. You know, like a book about older workers was, you know, there's
  174. enormous discrimination against older workers based on assumptions about them, all of which are wrong. You know, like
  175. their job performance is worse. It's actually better. Absenteeism is actually better, turnover is actually lower.
  176. There's all kinds of myths, right? So I think I've been motivated more by those things that, you know, I just think
  177. were wrong and irritating. And I wanted to say it. You know. I don't know if you give this advice to people too, but I tell
  178. them, if they're interested in an academic career, do you feel that there's something you want to say and do you feel better once
  179. you have said it? If you think that the goal here is to say it, and then people— your phone will ring and stuff, you know?
  180. Doesn't happen. - Very, very, very— Very rarely. So it ought to feel good to you
  181. to say it. And if it doesn't, you're probably in the wrong line of work. So let's talk about your time at Wharton. - Okay.
  182. You've been here for how long? 40 years. - 40 years. I told that to my undergraduate class, and
  183. they just started applauding. Like, you know, "Look, he's still standing. Isn't that cute? He can move and everything," you
  184. know. Yeah. So. Yeah, 40 years. So you have seen a lot of things at this institution and just in
  185. in the world. How have our students changed over those 40 years? I mean, mainly, I would say, in good ways. Their academic
  186. abilities are better. One of the things that was quite clear is their writing got better. Their ability to write was much
  187. better. I think there was kind of a— you know, the thing about students is that they are on the crest of whatever wave is
  188. happening in society, particularly with employers, right? So employers want to change direction. Easiest to do
  189. it by who you hire, right? And the job market is tight. You notice it most if you're at the entry level. The job market goes
  190. soft, you notice it most if you're trying to leave. So they get yanked around by the market and society more than people who
  191. are in their midlife, right? So I think in terms of the students, they haven't changed that much. The 1980s, the
  192. students were a little difficult, because it was the peak of the finance wave, and it was just heady, you know? They
  193. were able to make so much money so quickly. And— unprecedented, right? And that just completely captured them. And they were not
  194. happy to be doing anything that wasn't showing them how to make money right now, and I'd like to get out of here, you know, and
  195. start cashing in, right? But I'd say after that, they haven't changed that much. But the world around them changes,
  196. and as a result, you know, whenever the labor market gets tight, we hear employers complaining that our students,
  197. you know, are difficult and they have unrealistic expectations, you know. And it happens, you know, every 10 years or so.
  198. They don't change. I want to bring this to a close shortly, but I have two more questions, one of which is, higher education is going
  199. through a very tumultuous period right now. And so as an organizational scholar, as someone who understands labor
  200. and labor markets and employee dynamics and all of those issues, how should we be thinking about the management of
  201. change through this period of tumult? And what advice, what counsel would you have for leaders of
  202. higher education institutions? Yeah. So, I think three points. One is just to remember that
  203. higher education in the US is largely a public university story, right? 80, 85% of students go to school in public
  204. universities. And the big thing that has changed there is that it used to be— so, I began my career at University of Illinois.
  205. Wasn't there long, but a couple years. And Illinois largely loved the University of Illinois, and the view among people there was,
  206. if your kid got in there, your career was set. And I think what has happened in the last two generations or so is, we've so
  207. expanded higher education, and when you add an extra college graduate, you don't add an extra college job, right? And we've
  208. tended to add more capacity, frankly, at the lower end of the distribution, in the sense of schools that have fewer
  209. resources, students who are not able to have residential experiences. It's just a different experience. And
  210. families discovered that their kids were graduating and could not get a college job, the kind that was going to give you a
  211. career. And that led to considerable dissatisfaction with the whole college experience, right, and the whole
  212. concern about whether it will pay off for people or not. So I think that's the big political change. I think the second issue
  213. is about management, something that you obviously see. So we used to run an executive ed program here for higher
  214. education. We had 100 colleges and universities go through it. And early on, they didn't understand that there were
  215. markets they were competing in with each other, but they got that pretty soon. The second thing they didn't understand was
  216. strategy. That you can't all, as a university, be Harvard or Penn. You can't all, as a college, be Amherst or Swarthmore, right?
  217. There were niches. You had to figure out your strategies. They kind of got that. What they never quite got their hands
  218. around was that management mattered. You know? That understanding how to manage change mattered, understanding
  219. how to deal with uncertainty really matters. And we're still struggling with that, right? And if you look at— as one of my
  220. colleagues in education said, if you really want to be a university president, be a classicist and take one course
  221. in accounting. The path is set for you, right? But they're suspicious— the rest of higher ed is suspicious of business schools
  222. and management, right? So it doesn't get up there. I think the third point, where we're in this year, in the last year or
  223. so, is that, you know, we have to recognize that we have groups that really don't like us for reasons which might not be good.
  224. And traditionally, we have laid back, you know, and just let things pass. But if you let your opponents define you, then you
  225. really have a problem. And I think that's what's happening now. We were visiting a company, a colleague and I here, we were
  226. doing some research at. And one of the guys there, who was a very conservative guy, at the end of our program, said, you know,
  227. "Gee, you guys really surprised me. You're not weird." And I said, "What do you mean?" "You know, all politically correct
  228. and all this sort of stuff." So, "What do you think goes on at universities? You know, like our campus, 3000 faculty, half of
  229. them are in medical school. What do you think they're studying there? They're trying to save your life, you know." And I think
  230. we've allowed them to define us. And we can't do that, you know. We have to define ourselves to this broader community. We can't
  231. take it for granted anymore. Thank you for sharing that. Last question. Given all that you've
  232. learned in your career, what would be your biggest piece of advice for someone entering the workforce today?
  233. I think it ties back to things we were talking about earlier, and that is, you can tell pretty quickly from an employer whether
  234. they think that their employees are an asset or a liability, right? And you probably are not going to have a
  235. good time for long in a place where they see employees as a liability, right? So you know, if you pass through those
  236. places, that's fine. You're probably not going to stay long and be happy, but you could figure that out pretty easily
  237. these days as to how they're going to manage and treat you, right? And you want to be in a place where they
  238. think you matter. So assessing culture and the fit of the culture with your own values.
  239. Yeah. And you can see that by how they treat people and what their priorities are. Pretty easy to tell.
  240. Peter, thank you so much. Well, thank you. This was fun. - Likewise.

Brief Summary

Peter discusses his career journey, labor economics, and the impact of remote work on organizational management.

Key points

  • Transformative College Experience. Peter shares how college helped him focus and excel academically.
  • The Shift in Labor Economics. Peter discusses the decline of labor unions and its impact on his work.
  • Navigating Workforce Uncertainty. Advice on preparing for the future workforce amidst uncertainty.
  • Underinvestment in Management. Peter highlights the critical issue of underinvestment in management training.
  • Chronic Fatigue and Career Choices. Peter reflects on how chronic fatigue syndrome influenced his career decisions.
  • Motivation by Irritation. The speaker reveals that irritation often drives their research motivation.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes