How AI Is Reshaping Blue-Collar Work and Skills

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Lynn Wu, Associate Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions at the Wharton School, discusses how AI is driving a shift in blue-collar work, reshaping job responsibilities, and creating new opportunities for human judgment, adaptability, and problem-solving in an evolving workforce.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#FutureOfWork #BusinessNews #WorkforceTrends #BlueCollarJobs #AIandJobs #TechImpact ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. There's been a discussion for quite some time that artificial intelligence was going to have an impact, potentially negative, on the workforce.
  2. Especially when you're talking about jobs like blue-collar jobs. We could see robots replacing humans in many
  3. of the tasks that require some level of labor. But there is now more and more thought that there will be somewhat of a
  4. blue-collar transition or revolution in terms of the types of jobs that humans will still need to be called on for in this new AI world.
  5. Pleasure to be joined by Lynn Wu, who's an Associate Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School.
  6. Lynne, great to catch up again. How are you? I'm good, thank you for having me. Thank you. All right, so I'm one of those people.
  7. I've heard all of this conversation going on. There's obviously been a level of concern.
  8. Where should we believe this? Because seemingly this idea of a blue-collar revolution or readjustment or
  9. however you want to— is coming into play, isn't it? It is. I think it's an exciting time, because for the longest
  10. time we worry about blue-collar workers, and we still do. And now with the general rise of this type of super incredibly capable artificial
  11. intelligence tools, it can enable a lot of blue-collar work as well. What are the types of jobs then, if humans are going to be replaced by
  12. robots in some areas, what are the types of jobs that humans will still need to be counted on for?
  13. Absolutely, that's a great question. So let me just be clear. A lot of the digital AI tools we use today are in the virtual world.
  14. They're not co-existing, occupying the same space and time as we do. When that happens, when robots have the type of intelligence accelerating the way
  15. that digital tools in our computers, in our laptops, in our phones are doing, then there's a different story.
  16. For currently, there's a lag between the physical AI and the digital AI. So that means in short terms, medium terms, that physical manipulation in the
  17. unstructured environment. Like, you know, people who do the last mile of delivering your product to your door,
  18. delivery workers, or healthcare workers who lift you out of the bed, doing services for you when you're bedridden, right?
  19. These kinds of work are still going to be very much in demand. And furthermore, the type of job that we care
  20. about is people who can use AI really effectively. I mean, it's how do I use AI to solve really difficult problems?
  21. And problems with, you know— under certainty and easily verified, that, AI can do already.
  22. But problem solving under very high uncertainty and verification can take a long period of time.
  23. That requires human judgment and responsibility. And that's where humans can shine.
  24. And lastly, you know, interpersonal social intelligence is not something AI can ever replace.
  25. - Right. - At least yet. - Right. And do you expect that even with this shift you talk about in the medium term,
  26. are these changes that are going to be going on, are they going to be more long term or is there kind of a shelf life to them?
  27. There might be a shelf life to them just because of scaling law, in that the ability
  28. of artificial intelligence has been grown exponentially. Like in 2022, when ChatGPT first released, we didn't think
  29. it could do the coding kind of task that we're seeing today. So we generally tend to under— we generally do not understand exponential as
  30. a human brain because we are linear thinkers. We're not designed to think exponentially.
  31. So I would say in the long term, this could continue. And then robotics, physical AI, will be entering
  32. a scaling law just as we see with digital AI. And then all of this will be rethought again.
  33. Right. But right now, at least in the medium five, ten years, we're not seeing that yet because it is a difficult problem to solve.
  34. Now, you mentioned healthcare a moment ago. I would think there are certain sectors where there's almost
  35. kind of a platform to how much we can expect AI to contribute. Like in healthcare, I don't think there's much doubt that doctors and nurses,
  36. the physical need for those jobs is still going to be there for a long period of time.
  37. Absolutely. I think healthcare is a good example, and this applies to all jobs. We have to rethink about what jobs are actually encompassing.
  38. What is it encompassing? So the doctor's jobs have already changed. If you think about radiologists, right, they don't
  39. spend time reading, detecting cancers anymore. But they spend a lot of time communicating the findings to the primary care or
  40. whatever the cancer doctors, to formulate a diagnosis or treatment plan. And their jobs are shifting in the sense the job they did before may not be the job
  41. they're doing right now, but the radiology job will always be there, just like most of the jobs classes we see today
  42. will be there, just what we're doing within that job will be changed. Does this then change the thought process, and this is maybe a larger scale question
  43. about AI and the workforce moving forward, of how the younger generation may need to
  44. think about what their career might want to be 10, 20, 30 years down the road? I think it's never too early to think about what
  45. you want to do with life, and it's okay to change. And I think right now for young people, this is a really
  46. exciting time because the rule book was thrown out, right? And you got to redesign your own rule book.
  47. This generation of people gets to redesign it. They don't have to play the rules that we set up
  48. 50, 100 years ago since the Industrial Revolution. So it's a really exciting time for you to
  49. control what you want to do with your career. And how do you do that? You got to use AI.
  50. You got to use AI, daily life. Use it, how to do what you want to do more effectively
  51. and more efficiently. And that's where you're going to have the biggest edge. And I think it's interesting also, I saw a study the other day, but it seems
  52. like there's already a recognition by younger generations about some of this. Because the report said that you've got about 13 or 14% of undergrad students who
  53. are already rethinking their major because of artificial intelligence. So the younger generation we know is more
  54. tech savvy than some of us older individuals. But it truly is an understanding, it seems like already, that you need to
  55. really look at what you want to do because of the impact that AI is going to have.
  56. Exactly. So if I were a young 20-something, I absolutely would seize the opportunity.
  57. I will use AI and see whatever I can do with it. You know, redesign your rulebook.
  58. You get to redefine what's going on next 50-100 years. That's a really exciting time for this generation.
  59. Overall then, how do you think the workforce is going to be impacted as we move forward here?
  60. I think there will be a very strong short-term disturbance. I mean, a lot of traditional jobs will be changed dramatically,
  61. including my job as a research scientist, as a professor. Including you as a media content creator, right?
  62. So it doesn't mean that professor's job will be gone, research jobs will be gone,
  63. and media content creators' jobs will be gone. It's just, what we do within that job class will be very, very different.
  64. And you already see that with software engineering, right? So these days, most advanced coders, software engineers, they don't code.
  65. They use AI to code, right? What they do is they think about the higher-level artifacts.
  66. Like, how do I design this thing? What does architecture look like? What is client requirements?
  67. So they're doing a lot more higher-level jobs than maybe the project managers were traditionally doing.
  68. So it just means that software engineers will still play a very important role. It's just going to be very different, just like we are.
  69. Like, what I'm going to do is going to be different 10 years from now or five years from now than I would do now.
  70. And that could be exciting for some people, and that could be scary for some people.
  71. So it depends on how you look at it. So since you mentioned it, how is your job as a professor going to change?
  72. Do you see it? Oh, I think it's going to change dramatically for several ways. Number one, as a research scientist, like, how we research is going to change.
  73. Some of the stuff I do, like, you know, that would take months to do, Now I can use Claude Code, and it'll be done within a couple hours, in a week,
  74. in a day, right? So it brings a lot of thinking about, "Well, maybe, you know, this idea
  75. generation and verification is going to be fundamentally changed." So how do we think about hypotheses?
  76. Because now we can test hypotheses really quickly, potentially. So we've got to think about, like, this loop
  77. between creating a problem and solving a problem. - Right. - And that's exciting.
  78. And as a teacher, as a, you know, professor to undergrads and BA students, I think fundamentally how we teach is going to be changed quite a bit.
  79. Like, you know, why would I come to your class when I can have a ChatGPT to, you know, ask all the questions, right?
  80. So I think that has to be thought about. How do we manage the classroom experience
  81. so we can effectively use AI as opposed to just, you know, being replaced by AI.
  82. Lynn, always great to talk with you and get your insight. Thanks again for a few moments today.
  83. Thank you so much. Thank you. Lynn Wu, who's Associate Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Lynn Wu discusses AI's impact on blue-collar jobs and the evolving workforce dynamics.

Key points

  • The Blue-Collar Revolution. A shift in the workforce is anticipated as AI tools evolve, impacting blue-collar jobs.
  • The Future of Healthcare Jobs. Healthcare roles will evolve, but the need for human workers remains strong.
  • Rethinking Careers in AI. Young people are encouraged to redesign their career paths in light of AI's impact.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes