Wharton Professor Peter Cappelli: How to Manage the Older Worker

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Professor Peter Cappelli talks about ways younger supervisors can manage older workers productively. 📂 Management;Human Resources

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so this challenge of getting younger supervisors to manage older workers is a big one it's only going to grow as the
  2. workforce begins to age it's going to be much more common to have somebody younger than you are supervise you and
  3. it probably helps before we get specific to just remind ourselves of what the problem is problem starts
  4. mainly with the supervisors who are younger and feel that they can't manage people who are older than they are
  5. because they don't know how those folks have more expertise they think of as their parents they they get intimidated
  6. sometimes and sometimes they don't give them feedback actually when they should so thinking about how to manage them
  7. begins with how to engage and hire them in the first place and that is what is attractive to older workers in this
  8. context and a lot of that has to do with more meaning to work right to actually create a context where they're working
  9. on tasks and problems where they can see connection to outcomes and particularly
  10. to social outcomes we know that empowers everybody we know it leads to better performance but especially for people
  11. who are at their end to their careers they're less interested in money they're more interested in social contact and
  12. the more I've been doing things that really matter so creating a description of the work and defining it in such a
  13. way that older workers maybe could specifically focus on those tasks that have greater social impact that that's a
  14. way to begin I think when it comes down to actually managing them the process of
  15. engaging older workers is one that we see may be best modeled in the military actually now and especially in the
  16. Marine Corps where they've got a formal model where young lieutenants who come in right out of a the red out of Officer
  17. Training are paired up with experienced sergeants who are often a generation older than they are and they're taught
  18. and told that they actually have to work together so the lieutenant manages the relationships with the brass above this
  19. the sergeant provides a lot of context and a lot of information they collaborate they make decisions jointly
  20. the lieutenant is actually in charge but the sergeant is a resource that you absolutely can't
  21. avoid and you have to work with and the sergeant actually kind of communicates what's going on so I'd say maybe with
  22. older workers not a bad idea to do this with all workers but with older workers the best thing to do is to sit down with
  23. them in advance of decisions important decisions that affect them and say here's the problem here's what I've been
  24. tasked to do here's what it looks like we need you to do let's talk about this let's talk about how to get it done so
  25. think about that arrangement between the lieutenant and the sergeant the same sort of thing applies I think
  26. in the workplace I think particularly older workers expect you to acknowledge their expertise so it doesn't hurt to
  27. just say a few times I know you've been doing this longer than I have and you probably have thoughts on how best to do
  28. it I think it's also important in addition to engaging them to think about giving them feedback sometimes we're
  29. reluctant to do that because we figure they must know what they're doing or they're older and jeez I don't want to
  30. give them feedback but it is important to give them feedback maybe the way is a little different it reflects more on
  31. what you see happening and maybe a little less judgmental that is you're not rushing as quickly to solutions as
  32. you might with somebody just beginning you might say you know well I saw this report come back from your I saw this
  33. engagement here and here's what it looked to me like what's going on or what happened what do you think what
  34. should we do about this so delay the process of offering solutions a bit and help you know give them an opportunity
  35. to explain what's going on and think about how to do things differently so I think both in the setting up of tasks
  36. and in the feedback about tasks is sort of performance review things have to be a little different even for the
  37. immediate supervisor but it is important to give feedback you're still in charge
  38. and it is important you know to engage them in the same sort of way you might try to engage everybody so examples of
  39. companies that do this stuff poorly are sort of Legion and I think the the poor way is basically just to not pay any
  40. attention to what your managers are doing at the lower levels they're hiring they're making supervisory decisions and
  41. they've often just loaded up their own in this process and so they do things poorly so it doesn't take much to do
  42. this badly basically it means just leave your managers alone and bad things will
  43. happen as a result of this so the companies that manage this process well first they manage it well on the
  44. recruiting side so the AARP for example has got a website with a job board job recruiting that certifies companies as
  45. being older worker friendly and that is companies that in their advertising make
  46. it clear that they're not discriminating that they're open to everybody older workers as well that they offer maybe
  47. some of the cafeteria style benefits that are more attractive to older workers like elder care in addition to
  48. childcare sorts of things and more advice on retirement issues around work scheduling more flexibility so older
  49. workers who often have more family responsibilities or at least more interest and demands outside of work can
  50. better accommodate them so somebody's on the recruiting side the companies that do this well in terms of accommodating
  51. the special needs or companies like Draper labs for example which is a company that accommodates his workers
  52. that are about to retire and basically says we'll give you more autonomy we're maybe not paying you quite as much to
  53. work on your own schedule Deloitte is a company that does something similar with
  54. its soon-to-be retired workers or people who would otherwise leave early and says
  55. look we'll let you pick some of the projects you want to work on because we figure at this point you have the
  56. judgment to know what is going to work for you there's a bunch of healthcare companies Bon Secour among among them
  57. that's been particularly good at benefits for employees trying to get nursers nurses to stay longer more
  58. tuition based reimbursement for people who would like to change their careers they get a little older or maybe upgrade
  59. their skills along the way so we see more of that sort of stuff in terms of benefits among more companies that are
  60. trying to engage in more experienced workers there are other companies that have gotten particularly good at
  61. finding ways to re-engage people who have already retired Procter & Gamble and Eli Lilly together put together a
  62. program for encore careers for employees who have retired to come back as consultants you can think of it sort of
  63. as like a big temp agency for special projects where they reengage and bring back some of their long-term employees
  64. for special project special assignments consulting like arrangements now Dow Chemical and other companies have done
  65. this as well have relied on some of their social networking software as a way to keep older employees engaged in
  66. with each other even sometimes retired employees some of this is information sharing so that younger employees can
  67. ask questions of the retired employees who perhaps have seen something or some client arrangement or something years
  68. ago and get the history on and get some of the backgrounds Edward Jones the brokerage company does something quite
  69. interesting with its retired employees and that is it brings them back to socialize the incoming employees so the
  70. very oldest and the retired employees teach the incoming employees what the company is like they tell stories about
  71. the history of the place what it meant to them how the culture of the company operates it's a way to maintain some
  72. consistency and culture as well why employers don't you be paying more attention to this issue is a really
  73. interesting problem because you know we seem reading the business press that they seem to be falling all over
  74. themselves to pay attention to Generation Y and Generation X and Z and all the you know the new categories that
  75. come up for each new cohort entering the workforce when in fact the older work worker group is a much bigger cohort and
  76. it's going to be here forever and their needs are you know pretty similar and pretty common so you don't have to keep
  77. adjusting for each little cohort so it's a thing so it makes perfect sense to do
  78. it why they're not is an interesting problem and I think a lot of it comes down to being stuck first in a model of
  79. careers which is already out of date but it's still in the back of people's minds
  80. and that's the idea that people will come you'll develop them they'll stay with you for a lifetime
  81. that hasn't been true for a while but a remarkable number of people particularly
  82. at the top of organizations still think that's the way things should be even though it's probably not even true for
  83. themselves if their own career that's the model they've sort of got in mind so they focused on the young people because
  84. of that and some of it is just the buzz you know there's been so much business discussion about young workers and I
  85. think there's a focus on that for a reason a lot of its just misunderstandings there's a sense that
  86. younger workers are cheaper and more effective no evidence for that in fact all the evidence is the opposite that
  87. actually older workers are more effective but a lot of it has to do simply with the fact that the problems
  88. we're talking about are rooted in the behavior and the attitudes of managers particularly those of middle aged and
  89. often the younger ones as well and this is much like the problems we saw a generation or so ago with discrimination
  90. with respect to gender and race and that is it's not company policies that discriminate or that make it difficult
  91. to engage in the past women and minorities it was the mental models in people's heads and the practices of
  92. individual supervisors there was never anything written down that said don't hire women or don't promote them it just
  93. happened and so unless companies actively do something to address these problems they're going to persist
  94. because they are fundamentally in the minds of the of the managers and particularly the first-line supervisors
  95. you

Brief Summary

Younger supervisors face challenges managing older workers; effective engagement and collaboration are essential for success.

Key points

  • Managing an Aging Workforce. As the workforce ages, younger supervisors face challenges managing older employees. It's crucial to engage and hire them effectively.
  • Feedback is Key. Providing feedback to older workers is essential for effective management, despite common hesitations.
  • Companies that Engage Older Workers. Companies like Deloitte and Procter & Gamble have innovative programs to re-engage older employees and retirees.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes