Could A 4-Day Work Week Succeed in the U.S.? Wharton Management Professor Iwan Barankay
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW A four-day work week in the United States is appealing to employees seeking work-life balance, but Wharton’s Iwan Barankay thinks it’s a problematic idea that won’t take hold. This episode is part of a series on “Hybrid Work.”
Topics and questions covered: 0:00 - Introductions 0:49 - The impact of the 4-Day Work Week 2:00 - Past 4-Day Work Week strategies 6:07 - Reflecting on workplace dynamics 8:37 - Employee expectations vs. employers 10:35 - Can the 4-Day Work Week structure work in any environment? 12:44 - 4-Day Work Week's impact on sub-contractors 16:41 - Predicting the long-term impact
PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.
Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- you know when we switch to a four day work week the productivity was the same or even better and when they looked more
- closely they found that or perhaps people spend less time on less efficient and less effective workplace practices
- in particular they highlighted that all the meetings were not so productive anyway and they actually spend less time
- in meetings welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the
- minds of Wharton faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind
- the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring
- how their findings resonate with the world today and great to be joined by Yvonne Baron Kay who's associate
- professor of management here at the Wharton School Yvonne pleasure to talk to you again Dan so nice to see you
- thank you and so the the idea of the four day work week I guess after everything we've gone through during the
- pandemic and the kind of the success that people have had in terms of working remotely and all the different changes
- should we be surprised that we're starting to see more and more ideas like this come into the mix in terms of when
- we think about what work is going to look like no I think it's uh very interesting that
- um because employees have gained a little bit more bargaining power because the labor market was very favorable for
- employees employers had a often a hard time finding and retaining their employees
- because they were switching jobs so that gave them a bit more leverage and that perhaps has brought up a couple more
- ideas on how to accommodate the needs of employees in terms of work-life balance
- in terms of other obligations that they have and you know we will see ideas like this
- coming up up all the time and yeah the third day work week is an interesting one although it is it is something that
- has been around a little bit actually yeah yeah that's the unique thing is that this is not a New Concept
- historically there is a history there but it's realistically it's new in terms of what we think about work here in the
- United States yeah just just to provide a bit of historical context I mean the four day work week actually was tried at
- a large scale in Germany by Volkswagen after reunification and that was really in the cotton text of large
- restructurings of the economy because with reunification people discovered that most of the industry most of the
- capital in East Germany was not competitive so that led to massive restructuring and many of the western
- companies bought their counterparts in East Germany and then they faced the situation that they had to really
- rebuild how they are doing everything and in the past you might just say oh let's just fire people and then when we
- want to hire them again we can bring them back on board but that transition is is very very costly you know firing
- and then fining and training them again is very expensive so there they found uh
- the situation where they say well uh currently we don't have as much work so we cut the work back to four days
- um and in the German context it was almost at the same uh pay so it was uh it was that their pay did not shrink by
- 20 it shrank by a little bit but but but but not by 20 percent and but Volkswagen then went back to to
- the full week uh at some point yeah but the the idea of the four day work week now yeah is obviously it's a little bit
- different because the expectations are probably different for what would be what you would get from an employee yeah
- uh in part in part I think already if I may just put give one more historical uh
- experience from that um because um you know the workplace um is a funny is it funny it's the funny
- space because there's work that has to be done and companies uh think about what work they need to do and how many
- people they have that they need for that um but people who are in the workplace they of course are thinking about their
- career and careers are essentially tournaments and uh the way you get a promotion is to
- be good but also to be better than your peers and that led to a dynamic in the experience of the four day work week how
- many people actually took work home because they not only just wanted to get their work done but they wanted to excel
- they they were like contractually obligated to leave because these are you these were union jobs in the Volkswagen
- place and they did then they continued to work at home so that they you know could win in this tournament and that
- was something that led them to pressure among their peers to do the same so it was not just you Dan because you're well
- known overachiever you can't stop working right but then you know your peers at other
- um you know Executive Education or business school or radio stations will do the same so this then led to like a
- contagion effect across the the place and that led to a a view by many employees that this was actually quite
- more stressful because um The Experience the expectations of performance uh remain the same but they
- were not really adjusted to the fact that they had 20 percent less time to work and that put actually more pressure
- and more stress onto the employees so that was just like one historical experience I think is is relevant to
- bear in mind I think there have been now some new uh forests into this and there
- were like a couple of researchers who partnered with some companies and um they looked at the data and they seem to
- report that you know when we switched to a four day work week the productivity was the same or even better and when
- they looked more closely they found that or perhaps people spend less time on on
- less efficient and less effective um workplace practices and particularly they highlighted that oh the meetings
- were not so productive anyway and they actually spend less time in meetings now here I think it's worthwhile to
- reflect a little bit about what the modern workplace is like because it's not that you know you hire people to to
- uh to just like plug things together right and there's on an assembly line um because these jobs especially with
- GPT or perhaps those who will be replaced by by programs or by machines anyway so most of the jobs that require
- a human input and where value added is created are what we would call complex jobs or non-routine jobs
- and one particular type of job and here's a bit of a jargon here from computer science is called irreducible
- complexity so this is jobs these that are complicated and whenever there was there's a change in the circumstances
- you really have to think again about how to optimally spend your time so think about this for instance for you every
- day you have to think about how much time you want to spend on emails how much time you want to spend on meetings
- and talking to other people and how much time do you want to spend on in the studio right and in the end you want to
- figure out you know what makes you happiest and most productive but when I say there's a shock in the
- economy and because this time allocation job is a complex one whenever there's a
- change in circumstances this actually asks you to rethink how you spend your entire week and this is very very
- laborious to do that and this is why people in organizations on the outside they look it might look like it is not
- productive what they're doing when they're sitting around talking to each other but what happens in those
- circumstances is that they reflect on their work with their colleagues they learn from each other they learn uh from
- from them what they tried and what worked better in the current situation where they actually update their
- algorithm on how to spend their time and how hard to work on certain tasks so my
- concern here is that this is a bit of a simplified view of what the workplace really looks like when we say oh just be
- effective and you know just get your crank your workout and you know get it done and then you can go home and then
- you can spend time with your children learn another language and start a charity or whatever people are doing in
- this spare time I don't think that's really the the correct view of what a value creation job looks like so that's
- that's the balance that I'm thinking here it and as you were saying that one of the other things that came to my mind
- as well is the perception of what the employee has for what they think is the right mix in terms of duties and
- responsibilities in comparison to what the middle manager or the c-suite believes is the proper level and how
- those two may very well could could Clash at times absolutely absolutely and uh you know
- when I thought about this this this new interest and the four day work week and what it does to the workplace and you
- know spending your time more efficiently I I have to think about uh my marriage or everybody's marriage where you know
- there's one thing where you agree on what to do and then you you do it you know um I don't know my wife works on on the
- on our taxes and I perhaps fix dinner and what not and this is this is very good separation of tasks but on the
- other hand there are also these moments where we just like casually sit together
- and think about what we want to do and how we want to spend our time on and this is where we actually come to an
- understanding and this is really essential if you take away this time where people can reflect and discuss
- what are the important routines and where people can express their different Visions about what the work needs to be
- done when we take this away this just leads to a Schism in the workplace where there's just like uh the employers who
- pass on orders to their employees to execute them which in the end takes away a lot of the meaning and just job
- satisfaction and where people are just disgruntled and don't want to work in the workplace and that is not good for
- productivity are not good for Innovation so I think we have to be really careful
- that um we we have to create a space where people can continuously improve and realign their Visions in the workplace
- and when we squeeze them for time like this um I I fear that this might be at a loss
- both for the employees but also for the companies then what is the do you have kind of a
- formula then do you think of what it would take to make a four day week work on all of
- these different fronts because I think that's the challenge that you know to to get the best of both sides here yes yes
- so I think uh what we should not do and what I try to convey is we should not take away the time and space where
- people can hang out where people can exchange ideas and learn from each other in the workplace and align their Vision
- with the different layers in the hierarchy that is important I think moving to four day workweed should not
- mean that we take away meaning time a meeting time and where people are just there and implement the work I think
- that is the that is the concern I I have here so I think what we need to Simply do if people say I can or only want to
- work four days a week and the companies are happy with that then basically we need to shrink all components of this
- um I have a worry that you know if we do this then this might lead some companies
- to um actually do away with all these people who want to work four days a week so here again going back to Germany
- afterwards um there was a a very senior politician who actually took over one of
- the few competitive companies in East Germany which is size econ you know the lenses and Optical measurement
- instruments which was like very competitive then and then we when he thought when people asked him about the
- four day work week he said that you know I don't know maybe the Futures that people are just working on Tuesdays
- right is that is that what we're going forward obviously not so my concern is that when people are shrinking down the
- jobs in a compartmentalized way that can be done four-day work week they might just as well subcontract them
- because people who only show up for part of the week they're much less integrated
- in the workplace much harder to manage um and you know much harder to supervise if they're not there a lot so this is a
- slippery slope and I think not what companies and employees actually want well and and playing off of something
- you said a moment ago we're also at a time right now coming out of the pandemic where uh work from home remote
- work is it has grown for a lot of people you also have more and more focus on things like benefits and while those are
- great for a lot of the employees kind of off of what you said the potential is that it could have a negative impact
- because you have the options of chat GPT and other words to be able to get rid of
- employees and not have them working a four day week where some of these would be benefits for them
- yeah I think this is the the big discussion now I mean we want to create a workplace where benefits are better
- this is really having better benefits is very very instrumental for large sections of the of the population
- especially those who uh you know have a weaker social environment you know think
- for instance of single mothers they they really heavily depend on these benefits
- to actually be able to participant labor force so it's it's very proactive to have these benefits around and there are
- lots of studies that show that these benefits are conducive in the long run for better productivity
- um so but on the other hand when companies see this they might say SSA just we don't hire them and then we just
- subcontract them but again the My worry is that if you subcontract something it is not the same
- as having an employee because these persons are not really integrated in the routines and the culture of the
- workplace and uh they they don't have a say of shaping the workplace in a most effective way and employees are at the
- Forefront of the work they know what uh what are the challenges at the at the front lines so this this feedback loop
- leads to better productivity and by with a subcontractor you don't have that at all so I I think people need to
- think about carefully what uh what they miss out on or what they lose where they
- move to a four day work week or when they are moving to subcontracting and I think you know before they work week is
- a intermediate step to just Outsourcing and subcontracting and not for uh better
- uh workplace environment and when we're talking about this realistically we're not talking about all jobs here we're
- talking about even within companies there are probably certain jobs that maybe would would fit in that category
- yeah and other jobs that would not and you could probably say that by business and by sector as well that there are
- some companies that could probably do it other companies that would not be able to do it
- yeah um I mean if you think about it when you say oh let's what are the jobs that wow
- would really work well uh for a four day work week you might say oh these are people jobs that are pretty routine uh
- where okay you and you just do the job but it's well defined what the tasks are it's well defined what the what has to
- be done um but it turns out I think many people who actually push for the four day work
- week are not those people these are the people who push for the further they work with are those who actually are
- quite competitive in the labor market they say oh you know I want to perhaps do other things perhaps they want to do
- another job on this side uh or or another career development on the side and those are people who actually have
- many of these non-routine tasks and they are not all that great to be translated
- to a four-day work week think about this if you are running a team and you have a big project with
- many team members and in addition to the complexity of the team you of the task you also have to keep track on who's
- there when you know when is the day five when they're away because it's not that
- it's Friday where they all go home it will be all over the place so this comes with a lot of coordination logistical
- problems for companies when they actually have to do these non-routine complicated tasks so this is the
- interesting thing where the people who push for it are actually not the ones who uh who would be the most uh most
- amidable to have these kinds of tasks and these kinds of job designs what do you think then is the potential
- like Downstream impact of this idea of the four-day work week kind of being implemented here potentially in the
- United States um you know I think it's first of all I think it's great that companies and organizations
- always explore new uh new ideas as I said we had experience in the past they were from a very very different context
- and sometimes ideas that were used in a different scenario can generate a very unintended benefits in a new scenario so
- I think it's fantastic to see this in the workplace in the US that companies are always exploring new ideas and I'm I
- look forward to see you know what what else we are going to learn and what we have learned so far makes me
- a little bit worried as I say you know what we've learned so far is that people are just cutting out unproductive
- meeting time uh that sounds of course very entertaining and resonates with a lot of people but that leads me to say
- well then perhaps you need to make the meetings better and on the other hand meetings are really important for Value
- creation and reorganization that have have to happen continuously so I think I look forward to what else
- we will learn as companies are exploring this uh among the magnet portfolios or other ideas that they have but if they
- are if it's the same as in Germany in 1993 I think it will be a transitory idea it is a reflection of companies
- trying out things perhaps employees pushing for it but after a while they realize that this is just too
- complicated to coordinate keeping track of who is in the office when and people as well perhaps want the Simplicity of a
- nine-to-five job that they can depend on and there's something to be said about how we are kind of become entrenched in
- our in our patterns and our history here in the United States yeah and it's and it's quite a bit harder to be able to
- break from those patterns oh absolutely yeah and there you have like the binary situation where either people stay in a
- certain pattern or companies just immediately jump over to subcontracting and that is kind of the slippery slower
- I'm worried about both for the employees and the organizations to to move more into subcontracting Yvonne great to talk
- to you as always thanks very much for your Insight yeah this was very interesting thank you have a great time
- you too Yvonne Baron K associate professor of management here at the Wharton School
- thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to
- subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the warden School
Brief Summary
Yvonne Baron K discusses the implications of a four-day work week on productivity and employee satisfaction post-pandemic.
Key points
- Historical Context of Work Weeks. The four-day work week has historical precedents, notably in Germany post-reunification.
- Four-Day Work Week Benefits. Studies show productivity remains the same or improves with a four-day work week.
- Workplace Dynamics. The balance between employee expectations and management directives is crucial for job satisfaction.
- Impact of Remote Work. The pandemic has shifted focus towards remote work and employee benefits, raising new challenges.
- Concerns Over Subcontracting. Subcontracting may lead to a loss of integration and workplace culture.
Episode highlights
- Historical Context of Work WeeksThe four-day work week has historical precedents, notably in Germany post-reunification.“The four day work week actually was tried at large scale in Germany by Volkswagen.”2:16Sep 19, 2023
- Four-Day Work Week BenefitsStudies show productivity remains the same or improves with a four-day work week.“When we switched to a four day work week, productivity was the same or even better.”5:46Sep 19, 2023
- Workplace DynamicsThe balance between employee expectations and management directives is crucial for job satisfaction.“There’s a clash between what employees think is right and what management believes.”8:54Sep 19, 2023
- Impact of Remote WorkThe pandemic has shifted focus towards remote work and employee benefits, raising new challenges.“We’re also at a time right now coming out of the pandemic where remote work has grown.”12:47Sep 19, 2023
- Concerns Over SubcontractingSubcontracting may lead to a loss of integration and workplace culture.“If you subcontract something, it is not the same as having an employee.”14:01Sep 19, 2023





