Why Merit Pay Raises Are Causing Problems at Work

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Should top performers always receive bigger raises? Peter Cappelli, Wharton Management Professor, explores the growing debate over merit pay and the return of so-called “peanut butter raises,” where pay increases are distributed more evenly across employees. As companies face inflation, budget constraints, and shifting labor market conditions, leaders must balance rewarding high performers with maintaining fairness and morale across their workforce.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Management #Leadership #Compensation #Workplace #BusinessNews ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. You know, growing up, I think many people liked peanut butter. Obviously, those that are allergic to it, that's
  2. one thing. But now peanut butter is being used as a term connected with the business world and
  3. with pay raises. Interesting combination, to say the least. We talk about it more with Peter Capelli,
  4. who's a professor of management here at the Wharton School. Peter, I loved peanut butter growing up, but
  5. I think in the case of many people, they're not liking how peanut butter, the term
  6. is being used right now. Yeah. And just to be clear, we're probably talking about smooth rather than crunchy peanut butter.
  7. Yes. All right. So take us into this. The term peanut butter raise is kind of in the vernacular of companies right now in
  8. terms of the type of pay raise that they're giving. Explain this. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think it's not actually not a
  9. new term. As I recall, this may be 20 years ago, you heard this term before. And the idea is, if you have merit
  10. pay money to distribute, so our annual pay increases, the budget is 3% or 2%. It's been like that for a very long
  11. time. Do we spread it equally around to everybody? So everybody gets a 2% increase or
  12. do we make it crunchy? So some people get zero and some people get 6%, right? That's the question.
  13. And the peanut butter spread approach means we're going to basically give it to everybody equally
  14. or more or less equally. So are these types of pay raises then considered to be fair when you're giving them
  15. to everybody and maybe somebody who has done more for the company is not getting as
  16. much or getting anything at all? Yeah, I think it is the right question. And it is complicated by the fact that
  17. these increases are so modest, right? So they are this year going to be the average below the rate of inflation, right?
  18. So that means that if everybody got just the merit pay increase, they're all losing slightly
  19. to inflation. And so the question, one way to think of it is, as you describe it, you
  20. often hear executives say this, the best performers should get more. But how about those employees who are doing
  21. just what you're telling them to do? You got an office job, you don't have a lot of discretion over what you do.
  22. Do you give them a zero? In which case they're taking a 3% real income cut, right?
  23. Because inflation is at least 3% or so. So one fairness idea is to say, look, people who are doing fine at their job,
  24. they're doing okay, they're doing what you want them to do. They shouldn't get punished because they don't even
  25. have the opportunity to do more. But the other side is, as you say, we have some people in some jobs who
  26. are doing really well. Shouldn't they get more than inflation? But there's the rub.
  27. We don't have very much money to spend. All right. So let's look at this from the company's
  28. perspective for a second. Is there some dynamic within the company, whether it be philosophy, whether it be the bottom
  29. line during a quarter or during a fiscal year, where a company would trend to go
  30. one way or the other? Well, I think at the moment in the U.S., because we're so concerned about inflation,
  31. the idea of really squeezing your employees and that is giving some of them 0% increases in the other folks so you can
  32. have more to distribute elsewhere is likely to really get up the nose of employees.
  33. And so what you're thinking is, if we differentiate a lot, is it really going to
  34. motivate our best performers to do a lot more? So we're going to give some people 0%,
  35. some people 6%. And the answer might be maybe, but these increases are so modest, you know, that it
  36. probably might not do an awful lot for them. And then on the other hand, you're thinking
  37. about the people who'd be irritated by taking a pay cut and they haven't done anything
  38. wrong. So I think the reason that this term has come up a lot now is the inclination, I think, for organizations to try to
  39. do more peanut butter spreading. But the folks at the top really don't like to do that.
  40. But the people at the bottom are telling them, hey, you know, you've got a lot of irritated employees if you don't.
  41. Does the type of labor market that we have right now factor into these decisions being
  42. made in this direction? Yeah, I mean, if we think the labor market is really soft, and I think it
  43. probably still is, although new data today came in coming out showing a big jump in
  44. job openings, so maybe it will change quickly. But, you know, you can squeeze your employees
  45. more in a down market. They can't quit. More important, they probably feel better about just
  46. having a job. Right. And, you know, you start to feel worse if you think there are lots more options
  47. around you. So you probably could squeeze them more if you wanted. But then again, the question is squeezing them
  48. for what? And if it's to be able to demonstrate to your high performers that we really are
  49. paying attention to you and looking after you, you know, maybe that is what they want.
  50. I don't know if there's research about this, but, you know, I guess then the potential
  51. reaction of having this peanut butter spreading of pay raises is whether or not the people
  52. at the higher end who have been more successful potentially look to go someplace else over
  53. the next 6 to 12 months because they feel like they have been undervalued to a degree.
  54. Yeah, I think that's right. I think on the other hand, if we're thinking about this is the time you could
  55. squeeze your employees, that's also true for your high potential employees, right?
  56. They don't have a lot of places to go right now, so you probably could squeeze them.
  57. But I think the complication is, you know, who are you going to squeeze here, right?
  58. I mean, the problem is companies are allocating very little money to employees. And maybe a better way to do this
  59. is to try to rely more on bonuses as a way to increase people's motivation. Yeah.
  60. Going back to somewhat at the beginning of the conversation, you said this has been around
  61. for a little while now. Is this realistically a style that has been in play constantly through the last couple of
  62. decades, or is this kind of hit and miss depending on some of the dynamics in the economy?
  63. Well, you know, I guess we should say first, I'm not exactly sure what on average
  64. companies are doing right now. You know, the stories about peanut butter raises were kind of pejorative, right?
  65. I mean, they weren't saying, oh, this is a great thing, we should all do it. So I think, you know, the debate has
  66. been around forever. I think you would have seen a decade or two, two decades or so ago, much
  67. more concerned about trying to treat everybody kind of fairly. And, you know, since in the last generation
  68. or so, much more concerned about trying to differentiate employment broadly and rewards in particular.
  69. But then we come back to this issue of, you know, if your jobs aren't allowing you to do very much that's creative, and
  70. we're just asking you to do regular office work, why shouldn't you get at least the
  71. average pay? Right. Exactly. You haven't done anything. Yeah. Peter, thanks very much for your time today.
  72. Wish you all the best. And thanks again for spending a few moments. Peter Capelli, Management Professor here at the Wharton
  73. School.

Brief Summary

Peter Capelli discusses "peanut butter raises" and their implications for fairness and employee motivation in the workplace.

Key points

  • The Peanut Butter Raise. Companies are using the term 'peanut butter raise' to describe equal pay increases for all employees, regardless of performance. This raises questions about fairness and motivation.
  • Inflation and Pay Raises. This year's pay raises are below the rate of inflation, leading to real income cuts for many employees. The fairness of equal raises is called into question.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes