What Leaders Can Learn from NASA and the Space Race

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New Wharton research looks at how thousands of NASA employees with vastly different roles were able to rally around the common goal of a lunar landing in the 1960s. More: http://knlg.net/2kTkqfT 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. today we're talking with Wharton professor drew carton about his new research titled I'm not mopping the
  2. floors I'm putting a man on the moon how NASA leaders enhanced the meaningfulness
  3. of work by changing the meaning of work thanks for joining us drew thanks for having me so what led you to study
  4. meaningfulness of work so I had a long-standing interest in a problem related to how leaders tend to
  5. communicate about the organization's ultimate goals it's been well subscribed at this point that that one of the most
  6. inexpensive and effective ways that leaders can motivate employees is by articulating a compelling depiction of
  7. where the organization's ultimately trying to go yet the empirical evidence on that particular tactic is actually
  8. surprisingly mixed on some occasions it's worked quite well it's yielded the expected effects it's motivated
  9. employees led them to transcendent achievements that they wouldn't otherwise be able to attain but in other
  10. contexts it hasn't had that intended effect and in fact sometimes it's actually backfired because employees
  11. oftentimes will hear lofty rhetoric that's used by leaders and will think to themselves that you know the work I'm
  12. doing right now doesn't actually seem to be very aligned or connected to these grant conquests that you are reporting
  13. it to serve and so actually ends up leading to a form of cynicism and pessimism and actually can end up
  14. demotivating them so so I became interested in and what was going on with that the this this tactic that was
  15. rhetorical tactic that we would expect to work effectively yet wasn't working effectively at least as consistently as
  16. we would so you think so I started to probe the literature in this area a bit more and it dawned on me
  17. that it could relate to a fairly interesting paradox that ties to cognitive psychology or so cognitive
  18. psychological findings specifically if you think about the type of work that you're doing every day most people do
  19. every day it tends to be fairly circumscribed and clearly defined concrete small and scale and usually is
  20. is very time constraint and time delimited so you might have something to do by 5:00 p.m. or by
  21. 11 p.m. a deadline or something by the end of the week and it also tends to be it also tends to be done in small groups
  22. or people working alone yet the types of purposes the types of organizational missions that people find most inspiring
  23. tend to be quite grand in scale so they tend to be timeless or if not send a set
  24. on an indefinite time scale it tend to be quite abstract in the sense that they they focus on the essential central
  25. merits of what the organization is trying to achieve rather than any specific concrete situation that an
  26. employee might find him or herself in so for example one company has has the vision of becoming a world's most
  27. customer centric company another company health care company has a vision of of spreading care compassion and well-being
  28. across the world so these these these visions are very grand in scale and they're they're lofty and they're
  29. timeless but they don't have a clear connection to the type of work that I do every day and so I think what what
  30. really struck me was this paradox that as as a purpose and as a mission becomes inherently in and of itself more
  31. meaningful it actually starts to feel more disconnected from the kind of work that I do every day as an employee in a
  32. given organization and so that's when I decided to delve into this case at NASA which was a period of time where there
  33. were many reports of employees who said that that that period in their lives was
  34. included were involved more meaningful work than I had ever experienced before and whatever experience again regardless
  35. of what they were doing yeah it's interesting because even even people who were quite far removed from the the you
  36. know the the famous goal of landing a man on the moon people who are far removed from that for example electrical
  37. engineers and then of course this very famous legend that that is in the title of the paper of a custodian mopping the
  38. floors even they felt reported feeling an incredible connection to this ultimate goal and would often actually
  39. define their work everyday in terms of that ultimate goal rather than talking about unfixing electrical wiring or
  40. I'm stitching spacesuits or I'm mopping the floors they would actually identify their work as I'm putting a man on the
  41. moon and so it was it was a strikingly unique period of time where many people is a 400,000 person organization many
  42. people across the entire organization had these kinds of perceptions and it was also a period where there was a lot
  43. of very rich information that was available in terms of leader communication tactics and and then how
  44. employees were experiencing their work a lot of internal memos and documents that
  45. allowed me to dive into to get a really rich sense of what was going on at that point in time so it's an inductive study
  46. yeah so it was an inductive study in the sense that most most research that we do
  47. here at Wharton it and that I do involves crafting a set of hypotheses and then collecting data to test them
  48. this was diving into a rich very detailed analysis of a single case and then and then trying to induce or get a
  49. sense of what some key relationships are between how leaders communicate about the organization's ultimate purpose and
  50. how employees perceived their work it's a little bit of a little bit of a departure from the norm at least from
  51. type of research that's that's done around here but it allows you to get a rich sense of the the process and how
  52. employees perceptions shift across time so when you're dough into all this information what did you find so I'd say
  53. the core takeaway that I found most striking and unites a lot of the core findings is that and this is a also a
  54. bit of a departure from conventional wisdom so the conventional wisdom around what how leaders should orient
  55. themselves when communicating about the organization's ultimate goals is that they should be visionaries so they
  56. should paint a grand picture of what it is that we're all trying to achieve this
  57. this destination that we're all trying to strive to reach and what I found is that's absolutely essential it's
  58. critical that leaders do to picked a compelling picture of where ultimately we want to go but just as important and
  59. also more time-consuming and requiring even more investment is that they communicate about how each employee and
  60. the organization can get a sense of how their work connects organization's mission or vision in that
  61. connection that process of connection building took more steps and was more time-intensive and more complex than the
  62. process of just selling somebody about the importance and the and the beauty of this ultimate goal that we're trying to
  63. achieve together in some senses that was the easy part the hard part is helping people see a connection between their
  64. work and the organization's mission so what surprised you the most when you dug into all of this yeah I think there were
  65. a few surprises and they mostly revolved around the specific communication tactics that leaders used to help
  66. employees see that connection one that I found quite remarkable was was you know
  67. it's it's pretty well known at this point that that articulating a common goal or a common purpose has powerful
  68. implications especially for groups collectives and organizations because it galvanizes collective energy it gives
  69. people a sense of a rallying point a common cause that they can all rally around that the coalesce is their energy
  70. and effort and in some senses can build what are called social contagion effects
  71. where people one person's excitement spreads to another person and also is a boon for coordination because it gives
  72. us a sense of what we're trying to achieve as an organization but what I found it was also interesting was
  73. Kennedy's ability to articulate a common purpose was highly useful for individuals working alone because it
  74. allowed them to get a better sense of how their work connected to the organization's ultimate aims and the
  75. reason is again drawing from cognitive psychology is actually fairly straightforward when you think about it
  76. you know the kind of work that we're doing every day a lot of times we might look down the hall at what our
  77. colleagues are doing or maybe working with somebody across the country on the same project and what we'll often do is
  78. we'll look to see what other people are doing and we'll piece together what they're doing visa vie what I'm doing
  79. and when it turns out that that without exception every time I look to what my coworkers doing
  80. I recognize that they're channeling their effort toward the same end goal that I am then it leads this process of
  81. mental dissemble II and assembly where I get a sense that there's this broader pause
  82. and we're all working on a critical piece of that puzzle so I'm working on a small piece but an irreplaceable and
  83. essential piece of that puzzle and I can see how it fits in within this broader organizational system and because of
  84. that I can see how my work connects to the organization's aims if you have just two or more purposes even if you just
  85. have two organizational purposes this starts to break down because oftentimes we'll look to what our coworkers are
  86. doing our colleagues are doing and we won't do that process of disentangling what we're doing relative to them and
  87. then and then putting it back together seeing this this puzzle in this puzzle metaphor actually was used by some NASA
  88. employees to as an illustration of how they made sense of their work so the surprise here is that articulating a
  89. common goal was not just effective for a galvanizing collective energy but also for helping individuals see how they
  90. were connected to the organization's Ames and Kennedy did this by initially NASA had three overarching missions to
  91. to establish superior technology in space to attest to establish preeminence in space relative to the Soviet Union and
  92. to advance science by exploring a solar system and he decided on his own once he
  93. became president NASA was founded in 1958 but he came present in the early 60s he decided on his own to restrict
  94. all of NASA's attention just to that third ultimate aspiration of advancing science by exploring the solar system
  95. and then of course we all know what he did after that where he made an announcement to Congress in one of the
  96. most famous speeches to date in which he he talked about how we're gonna actually
  97. refocus our energy on a specific incarnation of that broader goal which is to land a man on the moon before the
  98. decade is out and return him safely to earth so if you had to distill this down just a list of or some key takeaways for
  99. leaders what would you say sure so well one is the as I just mentioned the criticality of
  100. articulating a common goal not just to galvanize collective energy but also to help people build a connection between
  101. their work in the organization's highest names another critical piece of the puzzle again always keeping in mind the
  102. the importance of not only selling a grand vision but helping people see a connection between their work in that
  103. vision the usage of sub-goals so Kennedy had a very unique way of using sub-goals that
  104. was pretty surprising so usually sub-goals are thought of as ways to break down a broader goal that could be
  105. daunting or intimidating and on a scale that is not it's not tractable to try to
  106. pursue this goal in and of itself it's it's to break that goal down into smaller bite-sized pieces what Karl
  107. Weick would call small wins and to focus on each increment one at a time in piecemeal fashion and what Kennedy did
  108. is he actually took a completely different approach rather than thinking about having sub goals be a way to
  109. divert your attention away from this broader goal just focus on one bit at a time
  110. he thought of sub goals as a way to actually let people focus even more of their attention and effort on the
  111. ultimate goal in this case the the goal of landing on the moon and he did this by by appending conventional wisdom at
  112. that time and even to date most people tend to set and tend to think of sub goals as better as they increase in
  113. numbers so a greater number of sub goals is good because it allows us to monitor
  114. progress more effectively it makes the the problems that were tackling more manageable Kennedy took the opposite
  115. approach he articulated at first just three sub goals to put a person into orbit to perform rendezvous and docking
  116. missions in space and then to ultimately reach lunar orbit prior to landing on the moon and these these sub goals ended
  117. up being the objectives of the three space programs first the Gemini program in the early 60s then the sorry the
  118. mercury program in the early 60s then the Gemini program in the mid-60s then the Apollo program in the late 60s and
  119. what happened was employees would they saw a plausible path to the goal to the goal of landing on a moon at first they
  120. thought it was impossible even Neil Armstrong the first person to walk on the moon in the early 60s said that he
  121. thought this was an impossible goal and they would never achieve it so it helped
  122. them realize or at least think that the goal was plausibly achievable but it was
  123. simple enough of a pathway that they didn't get completely diverted away from the goal landing on the moon and so it
  124. remained in the forefront of their minds and it retained its motivational power people didn't lose sight of what they
  125. were ultimately trying to achieve and so they continued to be invigorated by it and so this is an
  126. example of how to think about a conventional idea setting sub goals we all do it we do at work we do it
  127. oftentimes in our own lives for example let's say I'm trying to run a marathon I'm going to set a series of incremental
  128. goals number of miles I'll run each week and so we all make use of sub goals but
  129. this is a very different way of thinking about the uses of sub goals it's to pave
  130. the path to focus our attention on the end goal rather than to divert our attention away from it great it seems
  131. like a vast area to study are you working on anything that's related to this yeah so right now I have a
  132. concurrent line of research that that speaks to a a an exercise that Kennedy engaged in that was also quite effective
  133. which is translating the the abstract mission of advancing science by exploring the solar system to this
  134. concrete goal this time delimited goal of landing a man on the moon before the decade is out that that kind of twist
  135. where leaders focus on redirect their attention and redirect everyone's attention from an abstract overarching
  136. mission to a more concrete instantiation of the mission is extraordinarily difficult in my research I found that
  137. that vast majority of leaders actually don't do that they tend to communicate abstractly and this was very useful
  138. because what it does is it is it makes people feel as if the goal that they're striving to achieve is closer it's more
  139. proximal it literally is it's it's more proximal in time because it's going to elapse at some point and it's also in
  140. this case of the moon it was a tangible palpable goal it's a concrete goal you walk outside of your door at night and
  141. look in the night sky and see the moon and as deke Slayton said you know it was hard not to stay motivated when every
  142. time you looked up in the sky you had a reminder of what it is that you're striving to achieve so so this kind of
  143. transformation of an abstract principle into a concrete manifestation in reality
  144. is extraordinarily difficult and so I have a line of research that that can help identify a what we call a nudge
  145. which is just a way of tweaking the way that we tend to think about the goals that were articulating and so that we
  146. can think about a slightly too anyway so that our our first instinct is to articulate a concrete organizational
  147. objective that we can all rally around rather than an abstract general principle one caveat though and this was
  148. something else that Kennedy did remarkably well is that he he focused everybody's attention on a concrete goal
  149. but it was a concrete goal that that retained a sense of gravity and challenge and ambition that could then
  150. allow people to cast it as a symbol that embodied the organization's ultimate grand abstract ideals and so in this
  151. sense and people didn't think that they were just striving to land on the moon they also felt like just just by landing
  152. on the moon that they actually were were realizing these abstract ideals and Kennedy very carefully crafted his
  153. rhetoric to make people feel this way so he would he would actually talk about abstract principles as if they existed
  154. in the physical world so for example he would say he would say we want to go to the moon because knowledge and peace are
  155. there and if you think about the literal phrasing of it's pretty fascinating knowledge and peace are on the moon it's
  156. something that of course is impossible an abstract idea existing in a physical location but what it did when he and
  157. other NASA leaders continually reinforced the the idea that these two concepts were inextricably linked the
  158. physical and the abstract it allowed them to cast the the moon as a symbol of what they were trying to achieve in the
  159. abstract sense rather than just an impressive physical feat of Engineering and so in think about one of the most
  160. famous one-liners of all time Neil Armstrong talking about you know it's just not just one small step for a man
  161. it's one giant leap for mankind right there he's actually connecting one very in some senses trivial human action
  162. of just taking one step to this broader idea of advancing science one giant leap
  163. for mankind so so that's the twist is is getting leaders to to articulate more concrete objectives yet without those
  164. objectives living the losing the gravitas that allows them to be Rican Street gang the organization's ultimate
  165. aspiration great well thanks so much for joining us today yeah thanks so much for having me
  166. thank you you [Music]

Brief Summary

Drew Carton discusses how NASA leaders made work meaningful by connecting daily tasks to grand goals like landing on the moon.

Key points

  • NASA's Unique Approach. Drew discusses how NASA employees felt connected to the moon landing mission, regardless of their roles.
  • The Meaningfulness of Work. Drew Carton explores how leaders can enhance employee motivation through meaningful communication.
  • The Power of Sub-Goals. Kennedy's approach to setting sub-goals helped maintain focus on the ultimate goal of landing on the moon.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes