Designing Health Incentive Programs that Work

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Most U.S. employers now have incentive programs designed to nudge workers toward better health. But according to Wharton’s David Asch, those programs are too rational in how they deal with the human element. More: http://knlg.net/1TKCJuv 📂 Management;Health Care Management;Human Resources 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton and ped med professor david ash to talk about his research on behavioral economics and
  2. how they can help us develop better health incentive programs for employees David thanks for being here today well
  3. thanks for inviting me so can you give us a brief overview of your research sure well i mean i think the background
  4. is this that for so many american companies and American employers even if they're not in the healthcare business
  5. health is central to what they do because it keeps their workforce healthy and because frankly health care costs
  6. have an incredible impact on their bottom line everybody knows that health is determined so much by individual
  7. human behavior and we now have much better ways of motivating that behavior from principles of behavioral economics
  8. principles that frankly employers I think have been a little slow to adopt and so what are some of the key
  9. takeaways from a research in terms of how employers could use these principles to design better health and center for
  10. sure well I mean I think 11 comment would be to back up a little bit and say well what are they doing and I think so
  11. much of our approach to health actually whether it's from a doctor approaching health care or an employer an HR group
  12. thinking about wellness for their employees is based on the principle of education we should just educate
  13. employees that smoking is bad for them and that fitness is good for them and they should be adherent to their
  14. medications it's a very rational model that assumes that if our employees only knew what to do they would do that and
  15. and as soon as you say those words you realize how limited that approach really is because of course people do know that
  16. smoking is bad for them but it's very hard to quit or they they start up smoking in the first place they know
  17. they should take their medications so giving them education rarely is going to be enough to move the needle and yet so
  18. many programs that employers use are fundamentally based on that the next level that employers use actually is
  19. thinking about economic incentives why don't we give a reduction in a health insurance premium or some kind of pay
  20. for performance approach to get employees to move forward and there is some evidence that that works but the
  21. work that we do has been largely focused on different kinds of arrangements to help motivate either employees on the
  22. employer side or patients in the clinical setting because I'm a physician to try to get people to take better care
  23. of their health recognizing the psychological foibles and pitfalls that we all fall into so if I'm an employer
  24. I'm trying to design an effective health incentive program what are some conclusions from your research that
  25. might be of a surprise to me as I'm sitting down trying to design this plan yeah so a lot of the research results
  26. are surprising and they're surprising because they're sort of irrational in fact they take advantage of the fact
  27. that many of us don't think in rational ways so here's an example of a recent study that we did was led by a colleague
  28. mitesh patel also a colleague kevin volp and i we did this with a group of employees to try to get them to walk
  29. more and we we're aunt with a randomized control trial real science thinking how
  30. can we get employees to walk at least seven thousand steps a day one group got was a control and group they just were
  31. given feedback about how far they walked some groups were paid in this case we paid them up to a dollar we paid them a
  32. dollar forty a day for every day in which they walk seven thousand steps a third group got actually what we would
  33. call a loss framed incentive exactly the same amount of money a dollar forty a day is 42 dollars a month what we did is
  34. we gave them 42 dollars a month in a virtual account before it started and we took a dollar forty back for every day
  35. they didn't walk seven thousand steps now mathematically those two incentive arms are the same right a dollar forty
  36. gain if you walk or the failure to lose a dollar forty if you walk the same thing it turns out those who got the
  37. gain incentive that were promised a dollar forty four walking didn't walk anymore than the control group the group
  38. that got the same dollar forty framed as a loss incentive walked fifty percent more than the control group it's
  39. irrational it doesn't make any sense it's the truth real data that shows that and it's consistent with theories of
  40. behavioral economics but inconsistent with how a lot of employers or doctors think about the best way to take care of
  41. their patients so what are some of the underlying forces here in terms of like that's work here like if we're thinking
  42. about this like if I'm not necessarily doing walking but I'm doing any sort of incentive program or any sort of
  43. employee health program and I think about this using behavioral economics to kind of design something
  44. that will make people that will actually get the result that I want which is healthier employees like what are some
  45. of these irrational ways of thinking maybe that would help me out like how would I do the back what is the best way
  46. that you find to do incentives what is the best way to sort of make people do the things that we all know we should do
  47. but that doesn't mean we're going to do them yeah I mean I think it just phrased
  48. it perfectly how do we do the things we all know we should do but don't do it anyway and as soon as you say that you
  49. realize what strategies you have to use because it's not going to be the rational one because you just gave a
  50. very rational argument of course I should do this and the rational view is well then I do it but of course that's
  51. not what really happened so you have to move beyond the typical education i i'm not against education i'm a professor
  52. write this I'm in the business of education but it can be a bit of a decoy when when something more effective might
  53. be in reach and so I think the answer to your question the more direct answer to
  54. your question is to think well what are the pitfalls we normally fall into so one of them is that I just mentioned we
  55. see losses as more potent than gains so let's see how we can frame things as losses another pitfall is that objects
  56. right in front of us or goals right in front of us are so much more salient so much more meaningful than things far in
  57. the distance right this is what we don't save for retirement enough it's why we eat that piece of chocolate cake right
  58. in front of us even though we're on a diet it's why we don't take our blood pressure medicine even though we
  59. desperately want to avoid a stroke that might happen years later all of these things reflect errors in which we focus
  60. too much on the present and not enough on a future how do we fix that book can we accelerate the benefits can we create
  61. incentives today for taking my antihypertensive incentives today for not eating the chocolate cake incentives
  62. today for going to the gym not the incentive we would normally get which is a you know thinner healthier person 10
  63. years from now or several months from now and financial incentives our way to do that but there may be other
  64. incentives to social incentives right if I if I set up a system to go to the gym
  65. with a buddy right you don't we don't need research to tell us this people are more likely to go to the gym if they've
  66. made a little pact with a buddy to show up because you feel guilty if you don't show up those are sort of social
  67. incentives those are very powerful also at in healthcare we often think of healthcare so private that we don't want
  68. to engage two people together with it but we do that with so many other aspects of her life and going to the gym
  69. or taking your medicines it's really not that private so what a misperception I thought that with the research address
  70. that I thought was very interesting is this idea of you know like you said education is obviously important and
  71. it's obvious important to be transparent about what you're offering someone what
  72. you're doing but at the same time one of the things i think the research gets that that's very interesting a
  73. misperception it kind of corrects is this idea of sometimes it is possible to give people too much information if you
  74. maybe throw too much at them that they actually miss what you're actually trying to tell them or get them to do
  75. absolutely and and so there is like a fine line between enough information and too much information I think the best
  76. example for that are the very health insurance plans that employers you know give to their employees so it's April
  77. right now the University of Pennsylvania has open season few no benefits open season I've got like I've got to do that
  78. I think it's actually due tomorrow or something and I have to select a bunch of hell I have to select the best health
  79. care plan for me and my family well at Penn I spent 15 years as the director of the Leonard Davis institute of health
  80. economics I have to think of myself as someone pretty knowledgeable about health insurance and health benefits and
  81. I can't figure out what the best health insurance is for me and my family and the reason is is that there are these
  82. complicated tables of deductibles and co-payments and out-of-pocket maximum HSAs and all these other kinds of things
  83. each one of those is a financial incentive designed to try to help me move my health care in a particular
  84. direction but I would submit that a set of financial incentives you don't understand is a set of financial
  85. incentives that can't be effective it's just too complicated I think we need to greatly simplify our almost our approach
  86. design largely by economists and actuaries and turn it into an approach that's understandable by humans now I
  87. feel like sometimes maybe they companies don't do this because they feel like they're gonna insult people's
  88. intelligence like of course you can figure this out of course you want all this information but maybe really people
  89. don't they just want to know what's best for them really in the end is what they
  90. want to know I don't think it should be insulting I mean you know I think I know a lot about
  91. health insurance and yet it's just complicated and I'm busy and it's not about cognitive demand or you know
  92. cognitive ability it's just more about like we should be making it easy for people and not rely on their ability to
  93. handle hard things lots of our employees are smart and they can handle hard things but why should we rely on that we
  94. should be making it easy and I think so much of behavioral economics is about that also how do we make it so that it's
  95. easier to walk how do we make it so that it's easier to take your antihypertensive medications to lower
  96. your blood pressure why we have co-payments for antihypertensives they're not drugs of abuse no one's
  97. going to go and take lots of blood pressure medicines for the fun of it we want people to take their blood pressure
  98. medicines why do we make it so hard for them to get that medication and I think that there once we take a step back we
  99. can find lots of things that we're doing that don't have a good reason psychologically right we could we should
  100. be defaulting patients into automatic refill plans so they don't run out of their medications and fall off the wagon
  101. we should be you know lots of approaches once we recognize what are the steps required for certain goals and what are
  102. the psychological pitfalls that we all have as we approach those goals now I mean health incentive programs i mean
  103. have really been in I mean if not the news there's sort of in our cultural lexicon now it seems like every company
  104. has them and if they're not they're probably gonna have one next year or the year after that so as companies are
  105. adapting these things I mean do you think people our company's being thoughtful enough when they're adopting
  106. these things are they kind of being adopted in a vacuum without thinking about the particular particulars of that
  107. company of that company's employee population or about some of the things you're talking about about how do we
  108. design a program that doesn't just work for the short-term to get us what we want but actually makes for people who
  109. are healthier in the long term yeah so it is about more than eighty percent of us companies are using some form of
  110. financial incentive to promote the health of their employees and or their spouses and dependents and the leg so it
  111. is widespread is probably going to grow more than that now what I think is interesting and I hear it I don't want
  112. to be too insulting but I think that a lot of employers are not using these techniques as efficiently as they could
  113. and one of the reasons is you know as I've alluded to is they've got almost to ration
  114. own perspective they the assumption is well I'm using economics to improve behavior therefore i'm doing behavioral
  115. economics that's not behavioral economics that's economics right paying someone to do something is a highly
  116. transactional approach it becomes behavioral economics and much more potent when you use psychological tricks
  117. that that require these little clever design elements and actually that's not widely understood those those little
  118. tricks you know take take some experience and it turns out that subtle difference is as I mentioned the framing
  119. of a reward as a gain or a loss a very subtle difference can can have a huge impact so unless you know what you're
  120. doing it's actually hard to make use of behavioral economics in the workplace so
  121. what would you say sets this research apart from other research can bid that's being conducted on this topic so um you
  122. know there isn't a lot of work that is currently being done and behavioral economics and health that combines work
  123. in the Wellness space how do I get people to walk more or to lose weight with our insights from really clinical
  124. medicine how do I get someone who actually already has an illness let's say congestive heart failure and gets
  125. them to stay out of the hospital and so the that the acknowledgement that we can
  126. learn something from both of those settings and combine them now if you're an employer for example it's easy and
  127. comfortable to think about wellness but actually well this is not going to save you a lot of money in your employee roop
  128. it's not where the money is the money is in the very few employees that you have
  129. who have some serious illnesses and so the ability to improve the health and health care of those employees is going
  130. to have a much larger effect on your bottom line then the important but i would say highly diluted effects of the
  131. wellness activities for your employees and so what's next for your research what do you were you going to go from
  132. here so we've done a lot of work on the use of financial incentives to motivate people and again financial incentives
  133. that are designed with psychology and mind not just transactionally and there's been tremendous success in
  134. identifying ways to manipulate financial incentives to motivate employees I think
  135. we're increasingly interested in using social incentives people sometimes freaked out about it financial
  136. are you paying people to lose weight or to stop smoking can seem a little creepy
  137. or like a little bit of a nanny state but actually I think people are much more motivated by the social
  138. interactions that they have they want to feel good among their colleagues they don't want to be a dead weight they care
  139. what other people people think about them and to the extent that we can harness those very legitimate and very
  140. pro-social emotions and apply them to health settings I think we can advance individual and population health forward
  141. a lot one of the barriers to that has been as i mentioned that people have often thought of health and healthcare
  142. is very very private but if you were to watch what people say about themselves on twitter or on facebook you would
  143. realize in an instant that actually people are quite open about their health and I think that privacy is important
  144. but honestly it's probably not as important as many people think it is David thank you so much for being here
  145. today thank you you

Brief Summary

David Ash discusses using behavioral economics to improve employee health incentive programs.

Key points

  • Behavioral Economics in Health. David Ash discusses how behavioral economics can improve employee health programs.
  • Surprising Incentives Study. A study shows loss-framed incentives lead to better health outcomes than gain-framed ones.
  • Simplifying Health Insurance. David Ash highlights the complexity of health insurance and the need for simplification.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes