Women & Work: Does Diversity Training Work? | Katy Milkman – Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW: After years of conducting research on gender bias in the workplace, Wharton professor Katy Milkman has reached a singular conclusion: Systemic change is necessary to create long-lasting progress towards diversity, equity, and inclusion. On this episode of the Ripple Effect podcast, shares some insights from her most significant studies on diversity training and hiring bias.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:01 - What inspired Prof. Milkman’s research? 6:18 - Encouraging company transparency 7:43 - Are there downsides to diversity training? 12:15 - Increasing diversity in organizations 19:38 - How do social norms impact the workplace? 26:06 - Recommendations for organizations 28:58 - Strategies for leveling the playing field

PODCAST OVERVIEW: Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. make sure you shine a light on how things are going in different groups because scrutiny increases the social
  2. pressure people feel to make different kinds of hiring and promotion decisions and attend to a lack of diversity so
  3. scrutiny matters highlighting social norms when they're positive social norms meaning hey you're the only group in the
  4. company that hasn't yet promoted a woman to this a senior ranks that kind of scrutiny and those kinds of social norms
  5. matter welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey through the
  6. minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind
  7. the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring
  8. how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse range of topics bringing you the latest
  9. insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get ready to dive into new ideas with the
  10. ripple effect [Music] so you have done a lot of research around gender in the workplace and
  11. that's obviously a very important topic these days a lot of questions have been answered there are still a lot of
  12. unanswered questions out there what are some of those that have kind of inspired
  13. your research in this area yeah I think some of the important the most important questions are frankly how
  14. do we solve it how do we solve the issue that women are still underrepresented at
  15. the top of organizations and uh we are trying so many things is it that we need to
  16. eliminate bias and change the individuals and the organizations to be more open-minded about uh working with
  17. women and that's one possibility is it that we need to change the structure of organization so we can make them more
  18. accommodating to the different needs and preferences and strengths and challenges
  19. that women face is it that we need to eliminate the biases that women face not by changing the shape of the
  20. organization but the way decisions are made inside the organization so there's all these different possibilities in
  21. terms of what can fix what I think most people at this point agree is a real problem because
  22. enormous amount of talent is not being tapped to generate the best outcomes for organizations and we the truth is we
  23. still don't know we don't know the right combination of solutions but my research
  24. and the research of many who I collaborate with is trying to pick away at some of the big questions there and
  25. and get some answers so going back a few years you had done a study on the effectiveness of diversity
  26. training if you can't go back and take us through that study what were you setting out to do what did you learn and
  27. and really particularly about how these programs affect women thank you for the show and this is a really exciting
  28. project that I got to work on with a massive team at Wharton several years ago and it came about because at the
  29. time I was co-directing the Wharton people analytics initiative along with Adam Grant and Angela Duckworth and Kade
  30. Massey and others and the four of us in particular felt that one of the most pressing questions in people analytics
  31. that needed to be answered was whether or not these diversity trainings that so many organizations were pouring money
  32. into we're adding value and also you know could we build one that was really effective that was our real goal as well
  33. let's let's prove whether or not this works and let's build the best version of a diversity training we can given
  34. what we know about the science of discrimination and bias in organizations so we found first of all an incredibly
  35. Brave organizational partner it was a Fortune 500 company that was ready to team up with us and do this project and
  36. the reason I call them Brave is because it's a really challenging thing to do as
  37. an organization to open yourself up to to testing to see whether or not there's potential gender bias and if you can
  38. combat it in your organization it opens you up to lawsuits and a lot of organizations are not brave enough to
  39. team up with academics and do that kind of science so we found an amazing partner we had a at the time first year
  40. PhD student passionate about this topic Edward Chang at the Warren school now he's a professor at Harvard Business
  41. School we're very proud of having mentored him in the amazing work he did leading this and we built a roughly one
  42. hour online diversity training program was primarily focused on introducing people to the idea of gender bias
  43. teaching them about the science showing that women are often facing backlash when they do things like
  44. negotiate for higher salaries that uh there are implicit biases that influence the way we judge other people even if we
  45. don't explicitly intend to discriminate that we have different associations with
  46. women we expect them to spend time in the home uh and it's easier for us to sort words that we associate with women
  47. with words we associate associate with doing work in the home um than it is for us to sort those words
  48. with with men it's easier for us to sort words related to Career with um men than it is for us to sort those
  49. words with women and there's speed tests called implicit Association tests that you can take that show you that even
  50. when you'd say I a hundred percent support women at work I do not hold any belief that women need to be at home as
  51. opposed to in the office uh in spite of that you'll still show these implicit associations because it's like smog it's
  52. been around your whole life and you absorb these stereotypes that are in the world so we had participants take one of
  53. these tests and then we armed them with tools that they could use to actually try to combat bias at work we uh pointed
  54. out to them for instance that one strategy that's been proven effective for reducing gender bias is say you're
  55. evaluating CVS and you're worried you might be giving priority to men rather than
  56. women who are otherwise equally qualified for a job just because of your implicit biases well one thing
  57. you can do is you can evaluate CVS without names associated with them it's called blinding that's a way that you
  58. can eliminate bias from that process so we gave them a series of tools of that sort and walked them through some
  59. scenarios so they could think about how to use them we're really proud of what we built
  60. so let me go back for a second because the company that you worked with Fortune 500 company and you call them Brave how
  61. did you convince them in the first place to do this study because this could be as you said some fairly sensitive areas
  62. that they would be going into yeah it's a really great question it was honestly a company that was really intrinsically
  63. motivated they care deeply about being a thought leader in this space and they were hopeful that if we could build
  64. something together and I should say they contributed a lot of insights because um ideally in my from my perspective and
  65. I know for my collaborators perspectives as well when we're trying to build something that can go in and improve
  66. organizations it's really helpful to have people inside those organizations thinking through these issues with you
  67. not just scientists who sit all day and read academic papers and teach but people who are on the front lines so
  68. they they wanted to contribute to building the best possible training that could exist and then proving out you
  69. know whether it added value and if it did they would they would be a thought leader in being able to share those
  70. insights with the world and say that that they were on the The Cutting Edge so that was the motivation with the
  71. recognition that there was a big risk if things didn't work or if things looked bad in the organization of of some kind
  72. of lawsuit ensuing so it was a it's a tricky balance to walk and I will say in the end I'm not allowed to say the name
  73. of the organization that we partnered with and that was one of the stipulations that we all agreed to to
  74. protect them when we started the project so when you're talking about diversity training programs are there downsides
  75. that that you see to that uh type of uh concept and are there limitations as well
  76. yeah well it's a fantastic question whether or not there may be some downsides to diversity trading programs
  77. and that's really what we set out to test by developing this partnership with the Fortune 500 company doing a
  78. randomized controlled trial to evaluate whether or not randomly assigning some people to complete a diversity training
  79. program and others to complete an unrelated program for an hour would produce benefits or not for women at the
  80. organization we did this with thousands of employees and we measured a number of
  81. different outcomes we looked first at attitudes at the end of both programs both the diversity training and uh I'll
  82. call it a placebo training program that focused on entirely unrelated material we asked people questions about their
  83. attitudes towards women in the organization and in general and and you know ways of supporting them we had some
  84. little scenario questions where we asked in this scenario you know how might you
  85. try to problem solve and the scenarios related to supporting women so those that's a simple sort of attitudinal or
  86. scenario-based way of evaluating whether the training had an impact but we also really cared about Downstream
  87. consequences would women be treated differently in the organization would people uh make more of an effort for
  88. instance when they had an opportunity to nominate women for awards would they be
  89. more willing to Mentor women when mentoring opportunities came up and so we had a number of different measures
  90. where we looked at exactly those kinds of outcomes mentoring sign ups Award nominations and even what we call
  91. an a little audit experiment where people an email went out and invited people to offer support and information
  92. to a new female employee at the company or male employee and we looked at was there a difference in the willingness to
  93. support new female versus male employees as a function of whether you'd been through the training or not
  94. okay so these are all different measures and the question is what did we find does it backfire does it work does the
  95. diversity training produce the outcomes we had hoped for all right I wish I had a really simple answer for you if I had
  96. to boil it down to one thing I would say diversity training wildly underperforms
  97. expectations but it's subtler than that so um on average we see that it has bigger
  98. effects on attitudes than on actions very little evidence of movement in terms of behavior in terms of the
  99. attitudinal lift though we do see that it's having an impact particularly on those who uh
  100. the subpopulation they belong to suggests they had more room for growth because the average attitudes in that
  101. subpopulation started out lower at Baseline um this means it's helping maybe change
  102. the attitudes a bit more for uh men in international settings uh in particular how about Behavior change what I think
  103. is really interesting about the behavior changes was actually the opposite so the
  104. people who whose Behavior was shifted most tended to be the people whose attitudes were most aligned to begin
  105. with with the training um in fact women and women are the the group that ended up changing their
  106. behaviors the most but one of the interesting things is that some of the behavior change we saw was not the kind
  107. we were expecting so we were expecting to lead more people to sign up to Mentor women if they'd gone through the
  108. training for instance and we do see that but we actually also saw women looking for mentorship themselves at a higher
  109. rate when they'd gone through the training which was really interesting so one of the key results and PS this also
  110. happens with minorities who go through the training is that we may through the training have made it more Salient to
  111. women and minorities that they needed sponsorship that there were threats to their success in the organization and
  112. they needed to look out for themselves and find other women and minorities to support them that's not normally what we
  113. think of as the goal of a diversity training right the goal of a diversity training is how do we ensure that our
  114. Workforce um particularly those in positions of Power are providing more support to
  115. women and minorities instead what we're doing is alerting women and minorities to look out for themselves so it's not
  116. necessarily a bad result that may be beneficial but it's not the intention of the program it's it's not the reason
  117. that billions of dollars are being poured into these kinds of uh programs at companies around the world so I guess
  118. there is part of this that a lot of people will think about the quote unquote fixing the people but I would
  119. think there's also have to be a focus to a degree on fixing the system as well correct
  120. yeah I think that's one of the most important takeaways from all the work that I have done and all of the work I
  121. have read in the last several decades of blossoming amount of research in this area of how do we increase diversity in
  122. organizations that when we try to fix people and say you know we're just going to make the managers better at treating
  123. women and minorities with respect or we're going to make the organization friendlier by by changing
  124. um the way that we talk about diversity these Solutions I'm put I should put Solutions
  125. in air quotes there these Solutions generally if not lived up to expectations for instance our diversity training well
  126. I should say a key limitation of the research we did is that we're looking at a one-hour online training you might see
  127. something really different if you did a week of training with a trained facilitator and and you know really
  128. hammered these points differently so that's a limitation of the work but still every study I have seen points in
  129. the same direction of if we just try to you know fix attitudes change beliefs um
  130. try to change people the result it's just much harder to do that this is true not only when it comes to
  131. gender diversity issues in organizations which is what we're talking about now but any kind of human biases and I tend
  132. to study decision making more broadly I look at gender diversity but I also look
  133. at other biases and judgment besides biases against certain groups of people that
  134. can lead us to make mistakes they're incredibly hard to train away what we find in both situations is that works
  135. what works much better than training is changing systems so Systems Support better decisions
  136. and and that's really what we're finding time and again don't fix the person fix
  137. the system they're embedded in so the system is more is better structured to support the outcomes we want to see and
  138. I can talk more about what that means exactly if you'd like well and can you also uh talk about this concept of
  139. isolated Choice effect and and how that does work as well so this is an example of changing
  140. systems as opposed to changing people and it's a project that actually I just want to highlight we just talked about
  141. this wonderful doctoral student from Wharton who came in as a first year LED this amazing team
  142. um and in testing the value of diversity training his name is Edward Chang and Edward also is one of the co-lead
  143. authors on this work on isolated Choice effect along with another former Wharton
  144. PhD student Erica kyrgios who's now a professor at Chicago Booth so the folks who were training and doing this work
  145. are now thought leaders at all of our peer institutions which just makes us incredibly proud so um Edward and Erica
  146. LED this project along with Anish Rai and myself where what we were trying to do is figure out whether or not we could
  147. restructure the way that selection decisions are made to improve outcomes for women
  148. what do I mean by selection decision so you can think of a selection decision as
  149. who am I going to hire for this job or who am I going to put on this prestigious uh committee or panel or you
  150. know put up in front of my organization and highlight as a as a star so who is going to get selected for opportunities
  151. that are important and and one way we could make those kinds of selections is um normally when we think about
  152. promotions hires we can make those decisions one at a time right we have at the Wharton School we hire a bunch of
  153. new faculty every year and you know we often will have a separate search for each and every faculty hire you know now
  154. we're looking for someone in marketing now we're looking for somebody in operations and we're gonna look for one
  155. person this spring in operations another person in the fall so we isolate those choices one Higher at a time
  156. but another way you can make choices in hiring decisions is actually in sets you
  157. could say we're gonna have a cluster higher we're gonna hire five new faculty in this department right in the spring
  158. we're gonna hire um or we're gonna put five people in this award category as opposed to one at a time so we have
  159. options because any organization that is growing is you know it has opportunities and they can be
  160. clustered or not and what we hypothesized is that when people hire or promote or select people for
  161. opportunities one at a time they focus on just the attributes of the person in front of them and don't think globally
  162. about how that person is contributing to the diversity of the organization they're just looking at the one person
  163. that's their focus when they hire in sets our hypothesis was they're going to because of the nature of the set attend
  164. to what the group looks like right so if I hire five people in a row at the Wharton School one at a time I probably
  165. don't even notice how those five people look at it as a group because I'm zoomed in looking at
  166. the candidate set and choosing oh this is the person I think is best for this role this role and so on but if I hire
  167. five at a time instead I'm thinking wow oh gosh how did I end up hiring five people who were all from the exact same
  168. University and the exact same have the exact same you know dissertation advisor uh they all look the same they all walk
  169. the same and talk the same I might notice if there's a lack of diversity because
  170. hiring in a set forces me to attend to that and that is what we found in study after study actually when we randomly
  171. assign people to make selection decisions one at a time versus in sets people select more diverse pools of
  172. candidates when they're choosing from exactly the same applicant pool for each hire they make more diverse Selections
  173. in sets than in Singletons the set forces a focus on the aggregate on whether you're creating a pool that has
  174. diversity that that supports your values that um that reflects the diversity you
  175. want to have in uh an effective organization but when you hire an isolation you don't have that so that's
  176. a structural change it's not I'm not changing the people who are making higher decisions hiring decisions I'm
  177. not training them I'm not suggesting to them to focus on diversity but what naturally happens when we look at sets
  178. is we think about diversity and when we look at Singletons we don't and PS this is something that's been known for a
  179. while when people make product choices right you're you're ordering snap you know you get to order five days of lunch
  180. for the week ahead all at once or you order Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday people order more diverse menu
  181. sets if they're choosing all once because they're like oh I don't have salmon every day but if they're if
  182. they're ordering every day they pick the same dish every day in and day out because they're they're focusing just on
  183. that one choice so it's interesting that the same phenomenon that would lead to different behaviors when we're thinking
  184. about products also leads to these different patterns of hiring behavior that can be so important if you want to
  185. create a diverse organization you've also looked at how social norms uh affect a group composition and tend
  186. to contribute to underrepresentation of women what did you find happening there yeah yeah so you will laugh because yet
  187. who was leading this work my amazing former student Edward Chang who's now professor of the Harvard Business School
  188. so I I do a lot of work with doctoral students on this topic and Edward was an incredibly productive
  189. um student who really is passionate about understanding gender diversity or in organizations and we had a great
  190. series of collaborations um this is actually though I have to say this is a project the idea came from my
  191. husband so I just have to give him a shout out he's a physics Professor here at Penn and he said to me
  192. Katie I have noticed that it seems like when a physics department decides they lack gender diversity they panic
  193. they put a whole lot of effort into a higher finding stealing a woman from another top institution they get one and
  194. then they breathe a sigh of relief say our problem is solved and they never think about it or talk about it again
  195. and he said does that happen is it just like are people just trying to grab tokens and then they they put a check
  196. box and they quit and I said you know that's a really interesting question I have this amazing new doctoral student
  197. his name is Edward Chang let me see if we can come up with a way to test your hypothesis but in a setting that we
  198. think might be more consequential even than academic physics departments um we decided to take it to the
  199. boardroom and what we wanted to do and this is Joint work I should say with um midupak
  200. andola of Colombia and Dolly chug of NYU is we grabbed the universe of data on who sits on corporate boards at Fortune
  201. 500 companies we actually also looked at for the fortune 1500 in the study but we
  202. zoomed in particularly on the Fortune 500 and some of the analyzes and um we looked for at the distribution of
  203. the number of women on boards and we realized that if there were cliffs in that distribution meaning if there was a
  204. point at which you could clearly see a giant discontinuity in the representation of women that might
  205. suggest something about organizations satisficing trying to sort of reach a specific point and then quitting on
  206. their efforts to achieve diversity in the boardroom along the lines of my husband's hypothesis in physics
  207. departments so um we actually did something that I'm very proud of we created this little
  208. simulator it's like taking all the board directors and and all the fortune 1500 companies and playing musical chairs
  209. with them and we'll say you know imagine there's no these are the people who are
  210. on boards and well even you know people are on multiple boards will keep them on
  211. multiple boards but we're going to Resort them and reshuffle and we'll do it a thousand times and we'll figure out
  212. what would the distribution of women look like if this is how boards were created with no attention to the uh
  213. diversity just taking the people who are available and and shuffling them randomly and then we're going to compare
  214. that random shuffle to what we actually see and see if it looks like there's any
  215. contortions any Cliffs suggesting a magic number above which boards stop making an effort to achieve women and
  216. when we compare the two distributions the musical chairs that's gender neutral and the reality we see a huge gap the
  217. huge gap is actually not at the magic number one it's at the magic number two so boards you can see this giant
  218. discontinuity boards are racing to get exactly two women and then they stop trying there's a a giant drop off
  219. relative to what you'd expect if they were just you know seeding women uh at the same rate as as any other member of
  220. the population that's out there and available for board seats um and interestingly when we do a
  221. historical analysis we can go back in time with our time machine because boards the seed who's Seated on boards
  222. has been tracked for ages we can actually see that there was a transition point from tokenism it used to be the
  223. ones where the magic number when boards quit to tucanism um about a little over a decade ago uh
  224. so um what's going on you might be asking it turns out the social Norm at this point is most boards have two of them
  225. that's the average number and if you have less uh you are deviating from all the others and you might be called out
  226. in the media and uh you might be you know labeled the kind of company that's not supporting women and putting them on
  227. your boards and so we actually see that um companies that tend to be more scrutinized seem to show this Cliff to a
  228. greater degree companies of the Fortune 500 which are particularly under the microscope more than the 1500 show a
  229. greater degree of this bias and we ran little experiments where we showed um when you're choosing who to add to a
  230. group outside of the boardroom right just any sort of selection decision social Norm information is very Salient
  231. and leads to these kinds of clustering effects nobody wants to be the outlier has fewer women than usual because they
  232. worry that that will yield you know negative repercussions so I think this is another really interesting finding
  233. and what's important about it to me is what it shows is the power of scrutiny that one of the reasons that
  234. organizations especially at the highest levels are attending to diversity and and making an effort is they don't want
  235. to be called out and that gives us power because if we as a as a community we is
  236. a society want to see greater diversity then we need to continue to point out when organizations aren't achieving it
  237. and that is highly motivating and leads them to better Behavior now does that mean that we're going to see some
  238. bizarre actions as a result like clustering and sort of everybody else has two so we're
  239. okay if we have two yeah it does um but net net it means that the pressure and the scrutiny are working
  240. and we're seeing this upward pressure continue and the number of women on boards the average keeps creeping up and
  241. just as we saw a Tipping Point where eventually um tokenism gave way to tokenism hopefully we'll get to the
  242. point where it's humiliating to have a board with uh less than three women and we need to put the same pressure I
  243. should say in terms of board diversity in my opinion on um on on minority representation uh so I think we're doing
  244. better with gender representation and creating that scrutiny right now than than we have with
  245. um creating scrutiny around minority representation so what then should organizations do uh in terms of
  246. confronting gender bias what are the recommendations that you believe they should consider
  247. few recommendations so one thing I want to start with is I don't think you should use diversity training as your
  248. solution that is not going to fix your problem um to a thing that you can do is make
  249. sure you shine a light on how things are going in different groups because scrutiny increases the social pressure
  250. people feel to make different kinds of hiring and promotion decisions and attend to a lack of diversity so
  251. scrutiny matters highlighting social norms when they're positive social norms meaning hey you're the only group in the
  252. company that hasn't yet promoted a woman to this a senior ranks that kind of scrutiny and those kinds of social norms
  253. matter um third when you can hire in sets rather than in Singletons that is going
  254. to lead to Greater diversity in your hiring pool because only when we hire in sets do we seem to really attend to
  255. these issues of diversity and then a final Point that's unrelated to my research but I think an incredibly
  256. important finding that should be used more here is that there's been some really wonderful research done led by
  257. um Joyce he of UCLA and Sonia Kang of the University of Toronto showing that uh women
  258. because of probably stereotypes and the backlash they sometimes face when they um self-nominate for things like
  259. promotions are very much less likely to put their hand up when it's time to be promoted even when they've performed at
  260. the same level as others and this this is research also by Muriel neederly of Stanford showing women under compete
  261. relative to men when they have the same credentials so what Sonia and Joyce did is they they experimented with changing
  262. organizational defaults meaning in most organizations if you want a promotion you have to say I would like to apply
  263. for this promotion but what if you flipped the structure and you said everyone who has met a
  264. certain qualification threshold is going to be considered for a promotion you you're
  265. welcome to opt out if you really don't want to be leveled up in this organization there may be personal
  266. reasons you really don't but but you will be considered unless you request that you not be considered and guess
  267. what women ended up being in the consideration set and therefore promoted dramatically more
  268. in the second system where the default the the situation is that you'll be considered whether you volunteer or not
  269. so thinking about the fact that women may be more hesitant to put their name forward they may be less willing to
  270. compete and creating structures where it's easier because the friction is in the other direction where everyone's
  271. going to compete and you have to actually exert some energy to avoid it that can create a More Level Playing
  272. Field as for women in the workplace what you think they can do to try and level that
  273. playing field well one thing that I think is really important is having a strong group of
  274. mentors we know that's important and that women tend to have weaker networks than men
  275. um because uh frankly we we uh we know about homophily which is a tendency to affiliate with others who are like
  276. ourselves and if you're at the top of an organization and you're a woman you'll find fewer people who are like you you
  277. can affiliate with and chat with at the water cooler so that's a challenge um and and recognizing that and actually
  278. making extra efforts to to look out for opportunities to connect with others to make sure you have strong networks and
  279. strong bonds and that's really important um I actually have a group in my own life that is a no club and this is based
  280. on Research that was done by Linda Babcock at Carnegie Mellon University and collaborators showing that women are
  281. too willing to say yes to non-promotable tasks at work we're too quick to do sort
  282. of the office housework taking those votes in a meeting organizing the holiday party the kinds of things that
  283. aren't ultimately rewarded but can be very time consuming and um Linda and her collaborators their
  284. solution to this and they've written a wonderful book by the way called the no Club was to create a group of women who
  285. were at a similar career stage who helped support each other in saying no when it was necessary because
  286. interestingly even though we're bad at saying no for ourselves women are are just as good at men as saying no for
  287. others recognizing when others should make a certain decision um we're very good at arguing for other
  288. people so uh and we're good at arguing for ourselves too when we're comfortable doing it it's just there's a lot of
  289. pressure against it and often we conform or or fold in the face of that pressure
  290. so I actually have a no Club in my life it includes a couple of other female academics at a similar career phase and
  291. when we Face challenges about things that we're not sure is this a yes or isn't a no and frankly advice in general
  292. we reach out to each other and it has been the most amazing resource for a few reasons
  293. um one is the expected I expected it would be a great resource because they'd give me wisdom and sort of Consulting
  294. from brilliant people it also creates social connection and makes me enjoy my work more to have these awesome
  295. supporters in in my camp and to be supporting these other terrific women um but the third reason which I didn't
  296. anticipate but his really been there too is that every time they ask me for advice I'm learning so they will face a
  297. challenge they will need to figure out you know should I do this or not and from an arm's length View and when it's
  298. not me I Can See Clearly what the answer is and then once I've said oh no you should definitely say no to that
  299. opportunity I'm confident that this is the wrong thing for you when I face a similar challenge it's built my
  300. confidence and competence to respond and handle that situation myself and what's
  301. really interesting actually is I've gotten to be involved in some research led by Lauren s Chris Winkler now at
  302. Kellogg former Wharton postdoc showing that when we give advice to others it actually improves our own outcomes not
  303. just in the domain of you know this no club that I'm describing where a lot of the decisions have to do with gender and
  304. work but you know high school students who we randomly assign to give advice to their younger peers get better grades
  305. because they just coach someone else on how to get good grades and when you coach you learn so I think a really
  306. interesting thing that women can do is actually build these kinds of advice clubs so that they have stronger
  307. networks stronger social connections they're benefiting from others who can see clearly in places where they can't
  308. how to not conform to stereotypes but make those decisions that are better for their career and in advising others
  309. they're going to gain benefits to competence confidence and social support so I would advise all women to have
  310. advice clubs and PS men should have them as well but this may be a particularly useful tool for women who can't say no
  311. where do you think that the gender equality question ends up taking us let's say a
  312. decade from now honestly I'm such an optimist especially after doing for instance the work we
  313. discussed on toucanism and corporate boards and seeing how things have evolved now
  314. they've evolved slowly I wish they'd evolved a lot faster but we're seeing progress in the right direction and I
  315. think the pressure and scrutiny have accelerated um so I'm hopeful I'm feeling very
  316. hopeful that things are going to continue to get better and there's certainly a lot of scientific attention
  317. on this question when I was a graduate student first starting to do some research related to race and gender bias
  318. and and how can we solve it it was not a very popular area and I think as it's become easier and easier to collect
  319. massive data sets as a b testing has become more straightforward to do in organizations and more accepted maybe in
  320. part because of the you know Tech being such a a big part of um the corporate world and and so much a
  321. b testing there it's becoming more part of the culture we're accelerating insights about what works and as those
  322. insights become more widely adopted I think a along with the increased attention to these issues and desire for
  323. equality I'm optimistic that we can use science to get where we want to be [Music]
  324. Katie thanks very much for your time today all the best thank you so much for the great
  325. questions and for having me on the show thank you Katie Milkman who's a professor of operations information and
  326. decisions here at the Wharton School thank you for listening to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode
  327. informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  328. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the warden School

Brief Summary

Katie Milkman discusses gender diversity in the workplace, the effectiveness of diversity training, and systemic solutions for improving representation.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton professors.
  • Diversity Training Study. A study reveals diversity training underperforms expectations, impacting attitudes more than actions.
  • Diversity in Hiring. Organizations often quit after hiring a couple of women, leading to tokenism.
  • The Power of Scrutiny. Increased scrutiny leads organizations to prioritize diversity to avoid negative attention.
  • Advice Clubs for Women. Creating support networks can help women navigate workplace challenges and promote their careers.
  • Optimism for the Future. Despite slow progress, there is hope for continued improvement in gender equality.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes