Opportunities in Microfinance

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello i'm tyler i an assistant professor of entrepreneurship here at the wharton
  2. school today I have with me David Sims who's been involved in various leader leadership capacities over the past
  3. thirty years with an organization called opportunity international which operates
  4. in 28 countries using microfinance tools to try and address problems associated with global poverty so David thank you
  5. very much for being here with me today I'm looking forward to getting some of your insight on this very interesting
  6. space well Tyler thanks for the invitation I'm looking forward to our conversation and just delighted to be
  7. here wonderful so maybe we can start off with just a basic question for those of
  8. us who don't know can you see just a little bit about what microfinance is and how it actually works to try and
  9. address global poverty sure at its core microfinance is about bringing financial
  10. tools to people that wouldn't otherwise have access to them so that's small savings small loans small insurance and
  11. training we like to think about it as a ladder if you think about a ladder that's helping people move up out of
  12. poverty frequently it's missing the bottom two rungs and microfinance is a way in which we can rebuild rungs on the
  13. ladder to help people that are living on a couple of dollars a day move up out of
  14. poverty that's terrific and can you tell me is there anything unique about the approach that opportunity International
  15. takes to this versus some other microfinance organizations that are out there well I'd start by saying there's a
  16. lot of great microfinance organizations so lots of people doing great work across the globe and there's 200 plus
  17. million people that are being served across the globe with microfinance last year opportunity helped about 14 million
  18. people have the ability to transform their lives their children's futures and their communities we like to think that
  19. we really are anchored in a couple of places we like to go where others don't we went to sub-saharan Africa to start
  20. banks when nobody in the right mind was thinking you could run a savings led institution in banking we were
  21. innovating in the micro insurance space to provide life insurance for people when there was no way in the world you
  22. could think about how do you do life insurance in HIV ravaged communities in sub-saharan Africa given
  23. the economics of the market we've started small holder farmers rural outreach where the pure business
  24. economics from what they taught us here at Wharton don't make sense if you can't
  25. really think about why I know there's going to be changes in technology that are going to allow us to do that so
  26. we're opportunity really is unique is innovating at the base of the pyramid listening to the customers and saying
  27. how do we serve you what are your needs and let's figure it out together well it's really terrific now one of the
  28. things that I've read that opportunity focus is on is entrepreneurship amongst your clientele could you talk a little
  29. bit about that and how venture creation feeds into poverty reduction sure let me
  30. use I could use either of two examples but I guess the one that's sort of nearest and dearest to my heart which is
  31. also one of the the newer innovations if you will and the opportunity portfolio Tyler is that several years ago we were
  32. at a global conference in the Dominican Republic and the woman that was running the program there chief operating
  33. officer was making loans to women that had started private schools it was kind of interesting who's making loans -
  34. these are women that started schools because the kids in the Dominican Republic didn't have a chance to go to
  35. government schools if they didn't have a birth certificate well long story short
  36. but we ended up using that idea to go create a pilot to save jisse elsewhere in the world are there people trying to
  37. do private schools these are private schools where the tuition per term maybe ten dollars just to give people a sense
  38. of you know people starting schools on their back porches in the outskirts of Kampala and Uganda as an example in in
  39. Africa well those entrepreneurs end up being really good banking clients that by giving them loans and training the
  40. chance for savings they're creating a small business a small business that helps educate kids hires teachers hires
  41. people that are preparing food hires construction workers to build buildings and I could take you to a school in
  42. Uganda where a woman started school on our back porch and there are 900 children today in a
  43. three-story building well that's an example of financing an entrepreneur that the entrepreneurs doing job
  44. creation and the job creation and the education of children is a key core to poverty alleviation as I'm sure you know
  45. from all of your research yes that's wonderful now one of the things that you mentioned was you do
  46. training for entrepreneurs now as someone who does training for entrepreneurs in a very different
  47. context this is really interesting today right can you talk a little bit about what you do pragmatically to support
  48. entrepreneurs in these countries that don't have some of the infrastructure and some of the you know the basic
  49. considerations that you need to start a venture you know in North America yeah and I can do it in two different places
  50. if I do where the predominance of our training occurs opportunities core operating model is called a trust group
  51. we bring people together 90 plus percent women turns out that they're better clients they pay back the loans well and
  52. they take their profits and pour them back into food for the family and better housing and whatever so most of the
  53. clients that we serve are women but we bring them together in weekly or bi-weekly groups and that group meeting
  54. gives us a chance to actually do some kind of business training now these are basic business training but it's things
  55. around customer skills it's things about should you loan to your clients are you
  56. providing credit to your clients or what does it cost you to provide credit to your clients when you have a loan that
  57. you've borrowed from opportunities so basic training around the value of savings the value of customer service
  58. its core simple business to people that would be in in America or certainly at Wharton but it's not core to the people
  59. that may never have had any kind of education in their own lives but they've had to become entrepreneurs if I gave
  60. you the other example go back to the woman leading the school well she needs help in running a small business she
  61. needs to know okay I'm hiring people I'm trying to do things with a staff of 35 or 40 in
  62. her case with all of the teachers and and support staff supporting that school in Uganda so what we're trying to do is
  63. to bring training to her to help her run a small business which is much bigger than a typical microfinance business and
  64. kind of some of the neat stuff we're doing right now is saying how do we use technology how do we use tablets and
  65. cell phones which she now has access to what kind of training can we bring to her what kind of training can we bring
  66. to her teachers in order to help them be better at doing their jobs in the places
  67. in which they were administering the kids so that's fascinating so if I understand correctly in these
  68. third-world contexts you're using tablets iPads technologies you know associated to the first world to deliver
  69. entrepreneurial training so is there a lot of access to this technology it's just something that you you know can use
  70. the scale up in the third world so it's interesting to just see over the last decade how much the world has has
  71. changed in the use of technology so at the proprietor level at the school proprietor level there's access to this
  72. kind of technology but even among our clients even across India across sub-saharan Africa well over two-thirds
  73. of our clients and these are people living on a couple of dollars a day have access to a cell phone and it turns out
  74. if you think about it what's really exciting is the pace in which banking services are now being rolled out across
  75. technology you'd know that in Kenya you know a greater over a hundred percent of
  76. the GDP now it's a total transaction volume flows through cell phones you know Kenya which is at the tip of the
  77. spear if you will the farthest along but Bangladesh the same thing I think brac is now perhaps have has the biggest
  78. programme through its be cash programme with technology and they're doing that because if you're a poor person living
  79. in the developing world you have to get on a bus you have to spend time you're away from your business you're away from
  80. your family you could be gone for hours in order to go visit a bank or go get cash or you could have a bank in your
  81. hand with your cell phone as long as there's a cell tower nearby so technology in the developing world is
  82. just rapidly surpassing anything that we're even doing in this country with the exception that smartphones aren't
  83. yet there they're too expensive which is part of the issue and the other issue with smartphones is they chew up battery
  84. and if you don't have access if you're not on the grid we have to solve the energy issue to solve the smartphone
  85. issue sure I'm sure and you get a sense that the entrepreneurship training that you're doing with these clients makes a
  86. difference in their businesses we do we do because you just do basic repayment rates and how are we helping people
  87. succeed you know our repayment rates across the globe or 98 to 99 percent I spent five years of my career with a
  88. large bank in America to be unnamed at this point but I can assure you that with our credit card portfolio in the
  89. u.s. we didn't touch anything like 98 to 99 percent repayment rates some of that
  90. is because you're helping people understand how to use credit properly and that takes training it's an
  91. opportunity you earlier your question was what's different about us we have never thought it was just about
  92. providing savings and credit in the absence of training because we think then you're not equipping the people
  93. that are uneducated they just haven't had the chance to learn how do you what's the power of savings why is
  94. credit useful and how do you get in trouble if you get over indebted how do you actually keep customers and build a
  95. business those kinds of core training concepts allow them to succeed and we want them to move out of poverty and
  96. without that kind of training we think it's less likely that they could succeed so from our start 45 years ago we
  97. believed in the power of training plus credit savings insurance as what was required and so we've been involved in
  98. this for the past 45 years you must have a very broad sense of how the trends have evolved in terms of you know
  99. microcredit training all of the rest may be going right back to the genesis of the industry I mean if you're looking
  100. across that historical scope you know what impressions do you have about how the field is evolved has
  101. training evolved with it is this something that we still see or is it starting to be a situation where the
  102. commercialization of microfinance is leading to it looking more like traditional banks and some of this
  103. training maybe goes along out the door with that yeah no that's a that's a great question I if I think about the
  104. industry it's clear to me that the products have evolved in the innovation in the industry I think has evolved
  105. faster than the training has because I mean I've been around for 32 years not the full 45 but I've seen from
  106. individual loans to group loans to savings nobody was doing savings early on to insurance to these education and
  107. agriculture smallholder farmer so we've had huge growth in the types of of products but we haven't kept the
  108. evolution to do cutting-edge training as much as I think we need to and I think some of that is the cost structure of
  109. delivering training is expensive because you're bringing people it's expensive for the clients to come together in
  110. weekly meetings and it's expensive for us to send stay eff out there to do it so I think that the technology now is
  111. giving us the mobile technology is giving us an opportunity to turbocharge training and to allow training to catch
  112. up and I think for the banks that you mentioned which clearly want to do more in this space
  113. there's several billion people on earth living on less than $2 a day the future markets for our financial big financial
  114. institutions are still in that level of billions of people for them to help these people succeed as good customers
  115. they know they need training we need a cost effective way to deliver training so that they become good customers and
  116. move up out of poverty that's just terrific so I want to pivot back a little bit to another question about
  117. entrepreneurship as someone who's involved with this you know at the Wharton School you see a lot of ventures
  118. you see a lot of ideas good and bad and one of the characteristics of these is that most fail is this something you see
  119. with these micro enterprises and if so how do you deal with losing your money with an entrepreneur well it does I mean
  120. the things about the power of the model the operating model is that because we start small we start with the average
  121. first time loan is around a hundred and eighty dollars so it's a small amount of
  122. money it's put into a group setting where people are mutually supporting one another they're guaranteeing one another
  123. so the repayment rates can be supported because others in the community make sure that the business succeeds but
  124. where people from the outside may not see the power of this model is in the developing world Tyler if you were sick
  125. and you couldn't go to your market stall in that day that would mean that you don't have any income for that day which
  126. means that you don't have any income to buy food for your family for that day now if you weren't in a group you
  127. wouldn't have somebody that may be able to step in and help support your business maybe they'll be in the market
  128. stall next to you and they'll handle your business for the day while you're sick you're in the same trust group
  129. because you've mutually guaranteed one another they'll also share their tips about how they're succeeding and growing
  130. their business with newer people that are part of these trust groups so you you minimize the risk early on and then
  131. the natural entrepreneurs the people that really have the ability to grow and scale businesses migrate out of a group
  132. based lending into an individual loan and those go up over time so that you're you're watching the risk profile as
  133. people prove that they have a business model that succeeds as they get more money and as they have more income they
  134. get larger loans they get to the point they're hiring people and growing a business
  135. that's kind of the way you're managing the riskiness of microfinance and with these lending groups are there any
  136. considerations that you have when you're putting together the group's do you try
  137. and keep women with women or men with men are people from certain plans and castes together or is this you know
  138. these are the people who came and wanted a loan and we put them together and and
  139. that's how it goes it's a great question there's a bit of art and science to it because 90 plus percent of our clients
  140. are women they still tend to be women in some countries there are a hundred percent women in other countries it's
  141. mixed gender you're trying to build group cohesion where people are going to work with one another
  142. but one of the most powerful things I've ever seen in my life is when we started in Rwanda more than a
  143. decade ago right now that was post genocide some of your viewers may be familiar with the Hotel Rwanda which was
  144. the movie version of the atrocities that that were just so devastating to that country but as you're there today to see
  145. the transformative power of people that have committed to reconciliation and working together it's absolutely
  146. transformational to you as a person that might visit it in our trust groups in Rwanda there are people that are working
  147. together helping one another succeed mutually guaranteeing one another's loans and they would have been in the
  148. two opposite tribes back in the day really and those people are working together so the power of reconciliation
  149. and putting groups together that art and science shows we believe that the part of the work that we do which is really
  150. helping to transform communities is building bridges where previously there could have been hostility and so when
  151. you're looking at doing things like building communities and addressing poverty as the outcomes of your efforts
  152. this gets into one of the really tricky things in any sort of social outreach which is how do you assess your impact
  153. can you give me some insight into what opportunity's doing to try and line up cause and effect and actually show that
  154. you're moving the needle on this yeah yeah it's you sound like a donor throughout history for as long as we've
  155. been around opportunity has always talked about that we have a triple bottom lines unlike most people that go
  156. to Wharton they're used to one bottom line we said no we think there's three that we care about the first everybody
  157. would understand there's financial performance are you sustainable a non-profit world
  158. your revenues exceed cost if you can continue in business and the truth is the opportunity model is sustainable so
  159. if we didn't raise another donor dollar the microfinance institutions in the field would continue because that
  160. revenues exceeded cost so they're operating businesses and the model of a donor dollar that helps them grow more
  161. rapidly allows them to continue to serve so first bottom line is financial performance second for us was went
  162. around scale so how many people are we serving and for all of 45 years if you said how many
  163. clients this opportunity serve any given point in time we could tell you today we're actually serving 14 million people
  164. back when Kim and I wrote our first check we were serving a thousand people 1983 so that's been some pretty
  165. phenomenal growth but to your question then people would say but what's going on in the lives of our clients
  166. so the third bottom line for us we call transformation what are the outcomes that we're achieving that our clients
  167. are achieving in their lives their children's futures in theirs communities and for most of history I could regale
  168. you with story after story of fabulous life change around the people who have opportunity today that didn't before and
  169. how their kids are in school and they're in a better place but I couldn't give you metrics but in the last three four
  170. years and and I was part of the core team that was really pushing on this again the power of technology we started
  171. to equip our loan officers with tablets or cell phones so that when they're going out to visit clients were actually
  172. collecting client data we're able to collect does the client have a cement floor are the kids in school in
  173. particular are the girls in school because very frequently the girls are the ones left behind
  174. go fetch water do the things that the girls can do because it's your not important in the society is the cultural
  175. thing that we're trying to break that sense of of not having the girls be importance and with the use of
  176. technology were then able to track what's the status of people from a whole range of social metric dimensions now
  177. your academic colleagues are going to say can you prove causality and I'll say I can't prove causality but I can show
  178. over time and we have reports on our website opportunity org that would show our we call it social performance
  179. management will show you what percentage of clients have access to potable water
  180. today that didn't have potable water what percentage of our clients have kids in school that didn't have kids in
  181. school previously what's the nutritional situation do they have toilets huge chunk of the world where we serve
  182. there's no access to toilets in many of the countries in the rural regions in which we serve so we're able to now
  183. start capturing that data and then track it because our clients stay with us that client retention rates are
  184. phenomenal across the opportunity portfolio and as long as Tyler you were a client that was with us we'd track you
  185. overtime that again can't prove causality but we have lots and lots of correlations so you're a client of ours
  186. and you're moving up out of poverty you're getting above that $2 a day of income and moving yourself and your
  187. family forward that's really wonderful stuff and so when you start with your clients and you start giving them small
  188. loans and giving them on the path to success then graduate them to larger loans do you ever get them to the point
  189. where you graduate them into the formal financial system yeah and and historically we used to say geez we're
  190. not going to serve them we'd we'd work up to a certain level and then they go off to be the the bigger banks the ones
  191. that anybody could name that are working in Africa and it was funny our clients would come back to us including this
  192. woman that was at the school I mentioned earlier and she said wait a minute those
  193. banks wouldn't serve me when I was starting my business not only would they not serve me I wouldn't be welcome in
  194. their Lobby because I'm a you know woman in the rural area and I don't have any assets so why would I want to go to them
  195. now instead of serving continue to be served by you so that has forced us to say we think we need to stay with our
  196. clients for a longer time period now and some of our clients will be with us for
  197. a very long time and have certainly multi-thousand dollar loans this particular woman would be tens of
  198. thousands now that's unusual we don't have lots of clients up up there at that end of the spectrum but it has caused us
  199. strategically to shift to serve clients that are individual loan clients that have more resources now because they
  200. built successful businesses that we never would have served back in 20 years ago and then are you able to use some of
  201. the revenue from those bigger loans to finance further social outreach or does this just sort of get rolled into the
  202. bottom line increases the health of the organization it really is the the the bigger loans
  203. and the ability to serve clients that are you know in pure wharton terms more profitable allows us to make sure that
  204. we can keep reaching down to those clients that are under $2 a day I mean our core mission is how do we help to
  205. eradicate extreme poverty that's what really gets so many of us excited and the people living on less than $2 a day
  206. are really really hard to serve and expensive to serve one of one of my colleagues who ran our African operation
  207. for many many years worked for a big bank for 20-plus years in his career and he came to me one day and he said David
  208. you know what you're paying me to do today and I said no Colin what am I paying you to do today well in my old
  209. job all of the clients that I had to get rid of because they weren't profitable those are the clients want me to go find
  210. and serve so good you got it right so this finding the clients thing is interesting so you said that the people
  211. living on two dollars or less a day or expensive to to lend to are they also expensive to find yeah yes and no if
  212. you're out in the community if you're out working in the places that we work it's not that you can't find people it's
  213. that certainly in the rural areas it's expensive because you're still sending staff out into less densely populated
  214. areas so the core microfinance model that others do and we have done many urban based settings the pure economics
  215. of the model work really well if you can find a thousand clients within a hundred
  216. yards of where you're sitting which you can in India and Bangladesh Indonesia places in the world that are really
  217. densely populated the economics of the bottle work better when we start going to rural outreach in India rural
  218. outreach in Africa and then the economics become more difficult so it's not that it's hard to find them but but
  219. finding the number that you need per hour of Steff time changes so you know the economic model becomes the challenge
  220. okay so the demands there you just have to have the boots on the ground to go serve it yeah yeah you got
  221. it that's terrific now looking ahead where do you see microfinance going in general
  222. and opportunity specifically yeah well and I think we're still sort of among the leaders in the pack here we've said
  223. and I think the industry understands that the power of microfinance and the ability to do that rural outreach the
  224. ability to drive cost down to get training out through through things is based on technology so we think that the
  225. future really is around what's the role of Technology and banking coming together people may be familiar with the
  226. term thin tech stands for financial technology and we've agreed to a partnership that will be part of our
  227. banks in Africa will now be owned by a fin tech company so opportunities sort of at the forefront of the strain of
  228. this change because when we looked at what it was going to take to serve clients and to make sure that we could
  229. do it with safety and security for their funds to make sure that we could do the
  230. outreach to do the growth that we needed to do all the regulatory compliance we have to meet all the any monterrey anti
  231. money laundering rules and and terrorists things that all banks have to do we have to do all those
  232. same things too because we're running regulated financial institutions so we think the future around financial
  233. technology bringing that into the microfinance that marrying it together finding ways that as the clients move
  234. increasingly to the cell phones smartphones will start to penetrate all of that allows the FinTech
  235. partnership to allow us to serve more clients more cost-effectively and if we want to reach those two billion people
  236. on earth living on a couple of dollars a day that's the way we think we can do it
  237. and I think others in the industry also are spending a lot of time and attention
  238. now saying how do we do this we know we have to how do we do it all right well I
  239. think that is a perfect note to end on inspirational and challenge and at the same time
  240. David thank you so much for taking your time to be with us here today and sharing your insight on microfinance and
  241. really the vision for how to address poverty using these financial tools thanks very much
  242. Tyler thank you really appreciate it you

Brief Summary

David Sims discusses microfinance's role in poverty alleviation and entrepreneurship with Tyler at Wharton, highlighting innovative approaches and technology's impact.

Key points

  • The Power of Microfinance. Microfinance provides financial tools to those in need, helping them escape poverty.
  • Innovating at the Base of the Pyramid. Opportunity International focuses on unique solutions for underserved communities.
  • Impressive Repayment Rates. Opportunity International boasts a remarkable repayment rate of 98 to 99 percent.
  • Transformational Reconciliation in Rwanda. Trust groups in Rwanda are fostering reconciliation and economic growth post-genocide.
  • Client Retention Rates. Client retention rates are phenomenal, showing the impact of long-term support.
  • A Shift in Strategy. The organization is shifting to serve clients with more resources than before.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes