Profits, Globalization and Leadership -- Muhammad Yunus: Banker to the Poor

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Part 2- The effects of Globalization on the Microfinance industry, leadership and the qualities of those leaders, and how they factor into the future success of the industry and the social good it brings.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] you have spoken about the downside of a global globalized economy referring to
  2. it during the Nobel Peace Prize ceremony in Oslo as quote a dangerous free-for-all Highway whose Lanes will be
  3. taken over by the giant trucks from powerful economies even as Bangladeshi Rick Shaws will be thrown off the
  4. highway end quote I'm assuming you're referring to the onedimensional profit motive of these giant trucks that focus
  5. more on money than on social good but how do you think how do you think a a a scenario could could realistically be
  6. averted a global scenario and in fact isn't that somewhat desirable uh I was giving an image that
  7. uh globalization is like a multi-lane Highway all the products are moving back and forth in many directions and
  8. everybody on the road carrying their merchandise and giving the idea that uh big countries big economies Rich
  9. economies will have more merchandise to carry big trucks to carry and a very powerful and take over the lanes the
  10. small countries don't have space for themselves because it's all taken over by the big trucks and the big companies
  11. uh so I said if it if it that image fits into the picture then we should have uh
  12. traffic rules so that uh little company and the Little Country little economy have their safe Lanes where they're slow
  13. moving they carry little things and very fragile but they move safely uh so that
  14. they the big trucks don't take over everything so and I'm saying that if we accept the traffic rules idea then we'll
  15. need traffic police so that these rules are obeyed and the idea is to have a traffic Authority so that somebody has
  16. to say this is the rules of globalization that if you are a big company you cannot come to a weak
  17. economy and say I take over the whole economy they can because they have the money power uh so that will be wrong
  18. globalization in globalization both sides must be the winner and the whatever gain in the trade takes place
  19. it should be shared equitably just because I have the power I take out out of 100 I take 99.9 and give you 0.1% and
  20. say this is globalization I don't think that will be tenable that will be sustainable so we have to agree how much
  21. you should get and how much I should get although I could have taken over everything but by agreed principles we
  22. don't do that we give you some and we keep some and what that participation would be how division would be that
  23. would be the traffic police or the traffic Authority will decide that this is how we should do that otherwise
  24. globalization will become I suggested that will be an economic imperialism that uh big economies taken over the
  25. small economies well one effect we see of globalization right now is what's happening happening in the world banking
  26. industry and why I find that very interesting is because if you were to look at grin's own borrowers they are
  27. not just the subprime what are considered subprime but even the sub subprime uh in spite of that Grine
  28. repayment rates are 99% or so and you uh have never required a bailout uh from that perspective I wonder how you see
  29. this global banking crisis and what advice would you give to the CEOs of Institutions like City Bank or Bank of
  30. America about what they could do to salvage their operations it's a it's a paradoxical situation right now because
  31. uh back uh 33 years back when I was trying to start this program in a tiny village with a few people and arguing
  32. with the bankers that this would be a good idea to give loans to the poor people their argument was that poor
  33. people are not credit worthy they will never pay back and so on so today 33 years later you can ask the same
  34. question who is credit worthy the answer obviously will be very different because
  35. it's the poor who turned out to be the better credit worthy than the other category of people because uh the
  36. programs microcredit programs all over the world still function very well still their repayment is very high
  37. uh whereas uh the big Banks and their big uh Landing operations are in situation of collapse it's falling down
  38. uh so uh with this experience uh kind of contradictory experience that we have uh
  39. now we have to uh we have no other way but to redesign the whole system recognizing the fact the strength
  40. in this non-collateralized loans for the poor people and the weakness in the cat
  41. has loan for the rich people so we have to find find a ground where we can have a an inclusive Financial system where
  42. nobody will be thrown out of the system uh not the poorest person not the homeless person or a beggar person
  43. nobody should be thrown out uh they can handle they have already shown examples shown and created a long-term credit I
  44. mean record that what they have done uh so this is one lesson from this uh to redesign the financial syst system uh
  45. the another point I would like to make that uh This Global crisis financial crisis uh is worst In Our Lifetime when
  46. whole world is going through it while we look at the crisis part of it we forget
  47. this is also the greatest opportunity when the system is not working that's the time you unpack it
  48. and redesign it so that not only it uh works it works better than ever before uh unless we do that we'll be committing
  49. a big mistake uh so I I emphasize on the opportunity part of it uh while the crisis will take its time it take its
  50. course to get get through it but we should be focusing attention and then start redesigning uh piece by piece
  51. where it needs to be fixed so that we don't have the same old system that we had before what qualities does one need
  52. to lead a micro Finance institution and how are these different from the qualities needed for another type of
  53. organization uh one idea I was just mentioning that we came from the Direction Where We wanted to bring
  54. Financial Services to the poor people to help them generate income for themselves
  55. and gradually move out of poverty by doing that build confidence build experience and step by step uh take care
  56. of themselves and see that they can move on uh and get out of poverty uh so we would like to keep microcredit in that
  57. fashion in that mood not profit maximization mode because then you are not looking at people's condition you're
  58. looking at your own condition uh so you want to take out as much Poss as possible to improve your uh Financial
  59. strength and so on so that is I think Number One requirement for microc credit that you have the right kind of attitude
  60. and right kind of mood when you get involved with it that here I have come to use my talent my creativity my
  61. management skills to help people get out of poverty uh without losing money losing money pushes
  62. you into another Direction it becomes a uh to it pushes in itself into the charitable uh kind of programs
  63. microcredit is not a charity program microc credit is a business program but business with a social purpose and uh in
  64. a c separate way have called it a social business and defined it in a very clear
  65. terms what a social business like so ideally I would like microc credit to be a social business where profit is zero
  66. for the person who has invested but the company can make profit profit stays with the company with a social objective
  67. in this case the social objective will be to help people get out of poverty but but in terms of individual leadership
  68. skills or or organizational skills how do you nurture these within individuals in say gine
  69. Bank uh within gramine Bank uh we just recruit people and uh let them learn by doing as apprentices with other older
  70. persons in the branches so it's not a classroom training which makes all the difference classroom training is a very
  71. small part of our training we simply introduce what we do and then let them figure out what how it is done and so on
  72. when they join gramine bank for them it's just a job they're looking for job not many jobs are available they got the
  73. job they're very happy they got the job they think now on uh I get I work can I get my salary so the intention of
  74. helping poor and all those things was not part of that job but once you start working with the poor people and get to
  75. know the system get to know the objectives of the system and gradually you are taken by it and more and more
  76. you feel um inspired by it and all these ideas that yes my work helps people excites them uh it's a wonderful
  77. experience uh to be able to touch other people's life it's almost intoxicating experience once you have it uh you
  78. cannot get away from it you want to have it more because you see things are happening in people's life their
  79. children going to school the kid you saw a little kid running around in the village uh now you see he or she is in
  80. school and doing very well and talking about what she wants to be what he wants to be and you remember your own
  81. childhood that how you went through and how difficult it was for you now these kids
  82. lucky kids uh they could have been they they are in a school and some of their older students are now going to higher
  83. education and gramine Bank gives them Education Loans and you say nobody gave me an education loan and my education
  84. finished After High School I couldn't proceed any further only job I could get is this one but I'm happy through my job
  85. I'm helping other kids to go to higher education becoming doctors engineers and University professors and so on so forth
  86. and that excites him that yes uh my service is useful [Music]

Brief Summary

Muhammad Yunus discusses globalization, microfinance, and the banking crisis, advocating for equitable trade and social business models.

Key points

  • The Dangers of Globalization. Globalization can lead to economic imperialism where powerful economies dominate weaker ones.
  • Redesigning Financial Systems. The global financial crisis presents an opportunity to redesign the system for inclusivity.
  • Microcredit's True Purpose. Microcredit should focus on helping the poor rather than profit maximization.

Tension

55/ 100Some tension

Related episodes