Providing Positive Social Impact for Profit

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] we're meeting today with Jean Philipe dosal founder of new Orchard a leading
  2. micro finance company and CEO of bamboo Finance welcome to knowledge award thank
  3. you very much would you offer a brief history of blue Orchard its Mission accomplishments
  4. and um and how you grow it into a$1 billion fund over 10 years well the the original idea was uh uh to seek how to
  5. promote micr Finance globally because um we were convinced that micro Finance if
  6. properly done uh can have a tremendous impact on on on poverty uh what was attracting us as well well to micr
  7. finance was the ability to have um in one go an investment uh for social impact and financial returns and this
  8. idea that you don't have to trade uh social impact for financial returns and that you can actually achieve both at
  9. the same time so that was very appealing to us especially as X you know wart and
  10. grat um and uh so the combination of willing to do something good and using the traditional tools of mainstream
  11. Finance was was was attractive we were in in Geneva surrounded by you know private Banks and and Wealthy uh family
  12. offices and uh the ID very quickly emerged to sort of create a for-profit management company asset management
  13. company trying to channel private investors money into micro finance and delivering for them financial and social
  14. returns so that that was the beginning that you know that's the DNA of the company we called it blue Orchard so
  15. that people would remember the name uh we didn't call it mic micro invest or micro you know something um and um and
  16. then yes we started with a a very uh small seed uh money in our first fund with $10 million essentially seed money
  17. given by a bank um that took the risk of trusting us um and then progressively through our investments and then uh you
  18. know participations to conferences discussions with investors we attracted an increasing number of originally
  19. individual investors coming at micr Finance intrigued by the social impact and essentially impact First Investors
  20. and then you know realizing that actually they were getting their Capital back with some decent returns and some
  21. Market level returns in other words they well I don't know if you call it Market
  22. level returns it it all depends on your risk perception of micro Finance but we consider that given the the low default
  23. rates of micr Finance portfolios um over the actually a long period of time delivering a net Li plus 2% in US dollar
  24. uh in a very Diversified portfolio of microf Finance Loans to microf finance company was a market return and um
  25. actually I think uh institutional investors um voted with their feet because after four or five years of
  26. track record of um you know attracting wealthy individuals we suddenly uh were able to talk to uh fun of funds uh
  27. Pension funds and even um in the last two years Sovereign wealth fund so we we saw it as a as a grading increase in our
  28. of course investment processes but also uh as a as a as a demonstration that we could actually deliver the returns and
  29. and and be very effective investors in micr finance now that was blue Orchard um from the start you know very focused
  30. on fixed income in micro finance and then around 20072 2008 we decided to go into private Equity um because it was a
  31. need of the sector because we knew the sector quite well as well uh and were able ble to identify the the good
  32. opportunities for Investments and we created a second company called blockchain Investments to do private
  33. Equity investments in micr finance and then at the same time um we realize that uh obviously Financial inclusion is
  34. important but it's not the end of it right it's not it's just a little little piece of what low-income communities
  35. need to to have access to they need access to healthare you know uh affordable housing clean water clean
  36. energy um and we had this intuition and some other people have done it before as
  37. well um that there were probably out there social entrepreneurs uh for-profit companies trying to meet the needs of
  38. those low-income communities in those sectors and so we created another company called bamboo Finance um to do
  39. private Equity investments in non-micr finance related sectors right and we raised the fund uh very much a Pioneer
  40. fund uh $50 million now uh under management um for years you know in terms of investment activity and a
  41. decent portfolio of uh we think attractive you know uh portfolio companies the goal is the same uh to
  42. demonstrate to uh mainstream finance that you can actually have social impact while doing what they do every day which
  43. is investing money for financial returns and the reason why we're so much focused
  44. on on this combination of Social and and financial returns is um that although we admire philanthropy and and
  45. charity we believe that uh it will never be sufficient enough to to tackle the size the magnitude of the problem of
  46. poverty in the world and therefore private capital and mainstream those huge pools of private Capital waiting to
  47. be deployed should be deployed to also solving the most critical issues of the world today so that's what we're after
  48. right uh and and our success is uh uh you know important but beyond our own little personal success what we're
  49. really after is demonstration replication and as we've seen in micr finance I mean 10 years ago when we
  50. launched the dexia microc credit fund with blue Orchard we had $10 million and we were probably the one of the two
  51. funds out there in the in the market uh today if you look at the the World Bank uh website C gap on on on micr finance I
  52. think you have 100 micr Finance investment vehicles uh and and you know channeling collectively something like
  53. six to8 billion US dollars to the micr finance industry so and that's in the space of 10 years um the idea with
  54. bamboo Finance today and our private Equity business is to actually hopefully do the same and then um you know be
  55. competed against be replicated be copied and then progressively be called a sector because if you're by yourself
  56. you're not a sector and you're not an asset class right so uh you're a Pioneer you're a Pioneer you you you you try to
  57. open paths and and and and show what what what you what people could do but then when you start talking about you
  58. know five six eight 10 billion dollars uh a multitude of uh of practitioners and those practitioners start talking in
  59. networks uh and start organizing themselves um um and start discussing about uh how do you rate a micr finance
  60. company uh how do you assess your social impact uh you developed a common vocabulary a common language that is
  61. recognized by mainstream investors then you progressively become an impact investing sector uh I don't think we're
  62. there yet uh but we're you know progressively going there so how big is bamboo Finance so together uh bamboo
  63. Finance is a a 25 person uh Team managing $250 million of through two private Equity Funds um and we're close
  64. to full investment and are about to launch you know generation funds so so 250 million in four or five years in
  65. four or five years exactly and and people were actually amazed that we could raise this amount of money in a
  66. new field in in in what is uh uh a difficult financial situation worldwide right I mean 2008 2009 were not
  67. precisely the best years to raise money we raised $250 million on on on micro finance and non- microf finance so very
  68. happy about that the mix of investors that we have in our funds is is also quite interesting we have you know uh
  69. obviously High net worth individuals family offices but also um uh significantly actually in micr finance
  70. Pension funds European Pension funds um and then we were very proud of being able to convince uh an Abu Dhabi based
  71. Sovereign wealth fund to uh to test uh you know micr finance and impact investing in bamboo so um so that that
  72. makes for a very uh uh interesting uh key investor group if you want so they're investing in the in the blue
  73. Orchard micr Finance in the bamboo in the bamb in the bamboo private Equity Fund in both funds exactly so uh bamboo
  74. operates globally also then yes we operate globally uh as a matter of fact we have now offices in Bogota uh in uh
  75. Singapore we're looking at opening in East Africa uh somewhere to cover uh East Africa which is a very active
  76. region for uh social investing we have a a smaller office in San Francisco and of
  77. course our BAS in Luxemburg Geneva and Zurich uh and the ID is to progressively have most of our investment management
  78. capacity in in the regions so as a private Equity Firm uh you are then investing in companies around the world
  79. and tell me what kinds of companies you look for a particular size a particular stage of development and of course I'm
  80. assuming in a particular sector because they're they're aimed at some kind of a social impact result sure so so um uh
  81. typically so we're investing private Equity growth stage uh growth stage today in Impact investing uh means
  82. tickets you know of about 3 to7 million um we are investing and looking essentially uh for the first fund uh at
  83. all kinds of uh sectors and companies we wanted this first fund to be fully Diversified by sectors and by
  84. geographies but we quickly realized that a few sectors are are emerging in terms
  85. of uh absorption capacity and and impact one is Healthcare uh another would be affordable housing a third would be
  86. energy those are clearly the the three you know prominent uh sectors of investment for us um we'd love to do
  87. some educational deals we have found uh two so far that were in our opinion worthy of Investments and um so growth
  88. stage means that those companies for us have a proven track record have tested their their business models in the
  89. market have a a beginning of a revenue they don't need to be totally break even yet uh but they need to have a very uh
  90. defined and aggressive growth plan and and and the capacity to deploy the equity that we're investing of course we
  91. will never take majority Stakes the the the objective for us is not to to own or
  92. control uh it's to be one of the partners of this group of initial promoters we uh take a very active uh
  93. relationship to the portfolio companies we are sitting on the board that's a a condition Quon uh we uh and then we
  94. engaged uh we engage on a monthly basis very very actively or investment managers have a limited set of portfolio
  95. companies three to four portfolio companies maximum that they're monitoring and always on a four eyes
  96. Principle as well um and they bring uh very significant value added I believe in terms of uh uh organization of
  97. governance in terms of definition of business plan in terms of financial management uh operation and um so far I
  98. think the feedback uh from the portfolio companies was very positive in terms of
  99. our engagement do you help do you help them to find new personnel and talent as they grow absolutely so so actually as a
  100. matter of fact on our website WE Post their job postings uh we we we help them look for a key personel uh obviously
  101. we're we're you know CFO level CEO um in the organizations um for some of them we
  102. even help in fundraising um uh you know see for Co investors uh introduce them to our Network um yeah could you give me
  103. some examples of the kinds of projects that you've done so far um one example that we are very proud of is uh an
  104. investment We Made in India uh in a chain of rural hospitals uh problem in India 80% of the health care sector is
  105. urban when the needs are rural 80% of the healthcare sector is tertiary care when most of the needs are primary and
  106. secondary we uh met a group of doctors had started their hospitals uh no thrills high quality 50 B hospitals in
  107. one state in kataka they had four hospitals two of them break even two of them on the way to break even and they
  108. had this grandio plan of you know going to 50 Hospital serving a million low-income people well today uh two
  109. years after our investment they have 12 hospitals they serve 250,000 patients from low income communities in cartica
  110. they're entering a second state and you know they just closed an additional round of of fundraising attracting you
  111. know much larger private Equity Funds than ours which we see as a success um and I think they'll be on track to to
  112. getting their 50 hospitals in two to three years and serving this 1 million um uh client or patient uh Bas and then
  113. this is just the beginning because if they have proven this business model you imagine how many states you have in
  114. India and how many you know low income you have in India it's just mindboggling to so the beginning of you defining a
  115. sector here absolutely uh and and of signaling to much larger private Equity Funds that there is a
  116. sustainable financially attractive business model but with huge social impact and the fact that we have or we
  117. will be proving hopefully that the intrinsic part of the business model is helping low-income communities get
  118. access to Primary Healthcare will um so we hope um prevent follow on investors not to divert the mission of the of the
  119. company right because in itself serving low income in rural areas will be proven
  120. very profitable so that's at least the the the the theory that's what we what we hope for we have not made any exit
  121. yet uh on the impact investing where the jury is still out in terms of our will fair for our investors but we believe
  122. that we have a strong case you mean when it comes to when it comes to exiting our
  123. private Equity Investments obviously that's one example another example that I find very uh very attractive again in
  124. India is um one of U electrification of uh uh villages in in in Bihar which one of the poorest state in in in India um
  125. and and that's you know I'm not an engineer but essentially the rise husk of the rise production is then burn to
  126. produce from biomass produce electricity uh through gasifiers uh that they can install in in villages I mean to me uh
  127. again knowing that we'll be investing a couple million dollars alongside others uh in this company help them Electrify
  128. the whole of bear uh villages that have never seen the light in in in their history I think it's a it's a
  129. fascinating story as well um again on track to uh to I think being also a solid Financial investment but with
  130. tremendous social impact another example um let's see um access to education to higher
  131. University education in Mexico I mean uh hundreds of thousands of poor students with no access to University
  132. and still capacity to do it right with skills intelligence we are invested since two years in in a company lending
  133. money to very poor people to get access to University thinking that we'll hopefully
  134. with them and with others uh be able to to send uh you know the students to to universities is is is going to be very
  135. rewarding uh socially for the people financially for or investment but also think about the human capital of the
  136. country that you're building uh for generations and for the very long term that's also very satisfactory so I mean
  137. those are three examples and and there are many more but um tell me how you see um bamboo evolving over the next 3 to 5
  138. years oh if I had my way I I think um one thing I've learned over the last the last 10 years is that even though
  139. you you grow fast you don't have to to rush it um better to and again in the spirit of being able to demonstrate
  140. something better to build steadily your case and deliver results to your first set in of investors and then build from
  141. there and and and and send very positive signals so today we manage $250 million
  142. were 25 people you know working from three Regional Offices my goal for the next two years
  143. is probably to double that um with economies of scale so you know probably less stuff as we as we increase or our
  144. our funds on of management that's one set of ambition that's very selfish you know uh having also exited a few
  145. Investments and and proven to our initial investors that they were right to trust us uh prove to uh all the
  146. wouldbe investors that they should come come into the sector and then and then and then hopefully contribute to the
  147. learning of the industry and the creation of the sector by sharing best practices and and and examples and uh
  148. hopefully returning to uh knowledge at foron in five years and telling you about great stories and and exits that
  149. we will have realized uh there there's been a lot of publicity uh when it comes to microf
  150. finance now just shifting back I guess to Blue Orchard um over the last you know several months uh some micr finance
  151. companies uh um have had problems there's been more defaults than there had been originally as it got so
  152. successful that success saw some of even the nonprofits develop a profit making arm uh and then some commercial Banks
  153. moved into this space And so there's this perception U that that there's you know the phrase is bleeding the poor for
  154. for example right um and so I'm just wondering what your what your view is of that um and how uh how you your company
  155. views that and and whether how how extensive that problem is it's a difficult question um and one
  156. that calls for a a balanced answer um I do think that um problems are still limited to a few geographies and uh uh I
  157. would call saturated markets I think they usually are triggered by a combination of causes
  158. some internal some external I don't think well the first thing I would say is that it to me and
  159. to Bamboo and blue Orchard it doesn't put into question the role of micro Finance
  160. fundamentally and and the objective of financial inclusion for the so-called unbankable people and so so let's not
  161. throw the baby with bath water that's that would be the first answer um so yes Financial inclusion is important yes
  162. micr Finance is important and that's why I said at the beginning if you do it properly micr Finance works anywhere
  163. right now where do you see the problems uh fast uh and exponential growth of some companies usually uncontrolled with
  164. weak management with weak weak monitoring with weak management information system um and essentially problems that
  165. are building and are factually hidden by the sheer growth of the assets and the portfolio right that could be one the
  166. other um probably uh an excess of competition in some saturated markets I mean urban markets
  167. in Central America where you have 10 15 micro finance companies chasing the same
  168. you know low income communities in the same slums or in the same suburbs I mean of course lead to to over ineptness of
  169. clients um and and you have some I would say lenders or micro Finance operators that are less regarding than than than
  170. others when it terms when it when it comes to to um uh credit worthiness and and and checking the credit you know
  171. quality of of the would be borrower so probably some uh overheating or over competition in in those Urban centers
  172. and then um probably some meula from from the micr finance investment vehicles where you know at the beginning
  173. as I said we were by ourselves and the world was ours uh when suddenly you have 100 funds
  174. chasing the same 200 micr finance companies willing to land to those micr finance companies then suddenly the same
  175. thing happens just as micr Finance Banks become a bit more uh uh uh softer or less regarding when
  176. it comes to credit quality of their own borrowers some micr Finance investment vehicles may have done the same thing
  177. with micr Finance Banks so so that's uh unfortunately a a NE negative consequence of of success if you want um
  178. now to the opposite you have some geographies where you have uh a huge need of resources you have micr Finance
  179. operators because they're operating in difficult you know legal environments or political environments in some parts of
  180. Africa uh that do not get access to finance so is there a need for finance and should this Finance be challenged
  181. where it's really needed absolutely but to me again it doesn't put into question
  182. the need of micr Finance and um also what has been termed the commercialization of microfunds see when
  183. we we started and and I started more than 12 years ago but uh when when when we started looking at micro Finance
  184. programs or micro Finance operations first of all it was called micr credit not micro finance and it was usually
  185. credit only institutions not for profit or for profit that were lending to you know small
  186. entrepreneurs but the idea has always been at least for us and a few players in the industry to actually
  187. progressively specialize grow professionalize those credit only companies into progressively
  188. full-fledged Banks because what poor people really need is not so much credit in fact it's savings the first the First
  189. Financial need that poor person will tell you is is actually be able to put at work the money that he has saved in
  190. some safe place convenient location and getting him some return on his money instead of putting it you know under the
  191. mattress that's the first need and you only get that if you have a Commercial Bank regulated so to me the the term
  192. commercialization is very positive the fact that you have specialized very professional commercial microf Finance
  193. Banks able to offer saving Services different kinds of credit services but also now wiring transfers and even some
  194. insurance uh is is a very positive trend that I hope will not be put into question right now
  195. obviously as as always when you have fast growth and some saturation and high competition and and you know
  196. excitement you have some players uh that that you know believe that they can take
  197. advantage of uh of an an attractive uh environment and and business development and then sometimes uh essentially spoil
  198. the market for for everybody so I really think that that's what happened okay well thanks very much for joining us
  199. today my pleasure appreciate for coming by [Music]

Brief Summary

Jean Philippe Dossal discusses microfinance growth, impact investing, and successful projects in healthcare and education.

Key points

  • The Birth of Blue Orchard. Blue Orchard was created to channel private investments into microfinance for social impact.
  • Bamboo Finance's Vision. Bamboo Finance aims to demonstrate that social impact can coexist with financial returns.
  • Investing in Healthcare in India. A successful investment in a chain of rural hospitals aims to serve low-income communities.
  • The Need for Savings. Poor individuals prioritize savings over credit, seeking safe places for their money.
  • Commercialization of Microfinance. The evolution of microfinance into professional banks is seen as a positive development.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes