Guiding the Next Stage of Impact Investing’s Evolution

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi I'm Cheryl coolin managing director of the wardens social impact initiative and i'm here today with Julia Valentina
  2. Jackie who's here to talk about her new book catalyzing wealth for change a guide for impact investing welcome to
  3. you Leah Thank You Cheryl it's good to have you here so before we talk a little bit about the book in its contents tell
  4. me about your background what what what you know catalyzed your interest in this
  5. kind of work i started in traditional companies in traditional investing about 23 years ago started with mackynzie but
  6. shifted to financial services prejudice soon working with abb financial services
  7. and then arg by 2001 i was managing the direct private equity business of AIG and it was then in 2003 when I got to
  8. know the type of an investment approach that targeted a dual set of returns which is language interested in the
  9. earlier thing exactly financial returns and social returns at that time it wasn't cold impact investing but it's
  10. really very fast attracting my attention because at that time i was searching for
  11. something which would be a purposeful korean no just if traditionally successful korea and then i started an
  12. impact investment fund with neig manage it for five years and then moved on to start an independent advisory and worked
  13. with a broad range of ultra-high-net-worth families around the world and advised financial institutions
  14. international banks within UK government's on setting and implementing impact investment strategies so you have
  15. a great background in the finance area then you've and you've sort of been part of the the development of this field
  16. seen it as its come along how has that affected the content that you've done in your book I think it was it has greatly
  17. impacted they contend what I have seen in the field is that the interest towards impact investing is very very
  18. strong and it continues to grow particularly among the high net worth individuals wealthy families asset
  19. owners and are you also seeing the same kind of interest we're seeing among Millennials and and the the younger
  20. generations in that for younger generations for Millennials is kind of absolutely normal it's a new normal for
  21. them they talk about impact as something which is firmly part of their lives but
  22. the interest to impact investing is not only limited to Millennials we see a lot
  23. of wealth holders both from entrepreneurial backgrounds and inheritors who had drawn more and more
  24. towards this innovative approach which uses the market forces the innovative entrepreneurial solutions to tackle very
  25. very serious social environmental challenges and the interest is there because people understand that we need
  26. private capital government capital and philanthropy is no longer enough and there is an excitement to go beyond
  27. ground-based philanthropy where it can complement the grounds by working with new actors of social change which are
  28. the businesses and enterprises that pursue societal objectives and financial objectives well and that sounds just as
  29. as inspiring as we've seen from the students etc but how do you move from that inspiration to action right because
  30. that's the hard part it's absolutely the hard part and this is the reason for the
  31. book a lot of research has been done which shows that wealth holders absolutely adore this theme and
  32. wholeheartedly want to invest their capital with values with impact the problem is that acting on this intention
  33. to generate impact with their investments has been very difficult it is much more complex area families need
  34. to really find out what is the kind of impact they want to have what kind of themes they want to tackle what is the
  35. rate of return that is appropriate is it too high to low they didn't get a lot of
  36. help with the advisors and as a result there is a huge gap between intention to do impact investing and the actual
  37. action action and successful involvement in the field so that's the reason for the guy so how does your book your guy
  38. your toolkit differentiate itself from some other research and books that are out there there's a lot of great pieces
  39. of work out and they're very inspirational and the things which differentiate this guide is that it is
  40. really focused on triggering action and not just providing inspiration when I read the research and I get inspired I
  41. say I want to know how yes I want to do it but how do I do it a lot of investors
  42. are at the stage where they convinced intellectually but they don't know how to start and whom to trust so this guide
  43. is set in a way that will help those who already convince that they want to try to be meaningfully involved it provides
  44. a lot of peer examples and case studies 45 of them which were selected from 167 in depth face-to-face interviews with
  45. families around the world it has practice step-by-step guidance in all the stages of involvement in impact
  46. investing from understanding what it is understanding how peers have used this approach be the foundation a family
  47. business an egg's Jenner and then developing a strategy getting your family on board with it and then
  48. actually started doing investing so it's really hands-on approach peer learning and adapted style no jargon no financial
  49. language so which will help people with different levels of financial sophistication and experience in
  50. investing to get the benefit of it and start doing it so what are the things here so you're talking about the people
  51. using this right now being the the wealth holders themselves trying to understand how they might approach this
  52. what probable do advisors play in in this kind of decisions one of the learnings actually from oldest
  53. interviews is that advisors play an absolutely critical role in this area and like philanthropy which a lot of
  54. families like to do by themselves many families want to work with their traditional financial advisers in
  55. helping them align their wealth with their values because it is complex field it
  56. quires a financial experience some fat wealth holders don't have this experience the others just don't have
  57. time because they're involved in their family businesses that don't have time to really get entangled into the
  58. nitty-gritty of the actual investment and also they want to work with credible advisors who can influence the
  59. patriarchs and matriarchs of the businesses and get the buy-in from there may be older generation on those who
  60. already have credibility within the family make family harmony happen with that and so what do you think the
  61. resistance on the part of advisors might be if I was an advisor this isn't an easy thing for me to move into sometimes
  62. right so what kind of advice do you give to the advisors to advise us I would say
  63. that it is a tremendous opportunity for advisors to step up and help their clients holistically integrate this into
  64. their portfolios in different approaches in different ways there are a lot of things which makes it naturally bit
  65. difficult for advisors and there are some sort of wood what I called myths that they have in their prejudices that
  66. they haven't they had that prevents engagement first it's a complex field they need to get to grips of what it is
  67. very often advisors thing that impact investing is equivalent to another way another type of philanthropy where you
  68. would need to sacrifice return so it actually even lose the capital they also think that they need to have the full
  69. range of products to offer their clients to be credible and be mission align themselves which is not necessarily true
  70. what clients want is they want advises being a partner and open up this topic discuss what's as possible have air
  71. understanding on their part that there's a desire to generate impact and make a difference with that capital so tell us
  72. that what are the things we see here the university is you know strongly increasing interest in this we are
  73. working to Train we think of this next generation of investors and advisors what kind of advice do you give to would
  74. you give to a recent graduate who looks at this and says well I'm not yet an advisor I'm not you know not part of the
  75. family wealth generation but I'd love to get involved with this what what are your suggestions around that I think we
  76. all are investors at a certain level and there are products currently in the market where you can invest as little as
  77. five hundred dollars in for example in culvert community nodes there are products which are available for retail
  78. investors and trying to put yourself in the shoes of the investor with as little
  79. capital you prepared to do is actually good there are also investment clubs where you can invest in social
  80. enterprises with little amount of money so that's one side and other side is that i would encourage students to think
  81. broader about impact investing impact investing is not only directly placing capital within impact generating
  82. enterprises but it's also thinking of yourself as a catalyst within their organization you you work already in
  83. creating this dual objective strategies for example businesses and corporations can play an important role in impact
  84. investing not only by investing in social enterprises but creating strategies within the corporation which
  85. generate commercial return and find an end social impact for example by creating an inclusive supply chain or
  86. developing the products and services for the disadvantaged populations innovating
  87. with their supply chain innovating with their products innovating with the delivery models and all this can be done
  88. within the conventional businesses the same with pension funds institutional investors being an agent of change
  89. wherever you are consulting companies provider of services because impact investing at the end it has a larger
  90. ecosystem and a lot of services I needed to support this market not only investing directly yeah and I think that
  91. one of the things that that your discussion points to is bad this area will be strengthened as we
  92. continue to see it part of something that everybody does that it's something that corporations can start looking at
  93. pension funds entrepreneurs investors philanthropists that it's part of creating this this larger ecosystem that
  94. balances and looks at profits as well as purpose absolutely I think that's you phrase it very well I think what we see
  95. in the world is a convergence businesses become closer to charities they incorporate impact dimension and their
  96. operations charities become closer to businesses they start full profit social enterprise arms they need to generate
  97. revenues they want to embrace market-based solutions so in this converging world you can find your place
  98. in a large number of institutions well and a question then about accountability and transparency you know when you're
  99. talking about businesses integrating a social impact aspect we think it's now very different than the traditional
  100. corporate social responsibility or the the kind of marketing and philanthropy that corporations do it's more
  101. successful when it's integrated into the business itself and not seen as it as an
  102. add-on how do you are you seeing trends in this as well as the impact investing do you think more corporations are
  103. learning how to be authentically and transparently involved in social impact I think so because I think there is a
  104. larger appreciation and awareness among this among the CEOs and among the corporations that the social
  105. environmental challenges we are facing provide the risks and opportunities which all of us will have to bear the
  106. consequences so it is important that private capital steps up and develop strategies which tackle those challenges
  107. while simultaneously providing the business value this is the shared value approach of Michael Porter I really love
  108. this because it's over embrace it and it's really inclusive where you would say this is the way to go because
  109. corporate social responsibility it's always going to be a little little pockets which will not be may be
  110. taken seriously yes but will not be as impactful as a holistic strategy which generates profitability at the same time
  111. as tackling the social and environmental challenges yes one of the things that we
  112. see is that a lot of times when we're looking at a corporation we see where the corporate social impact aspect lies
  113. if it's just under the marketing department or if it's just under community affairs it's often has less
  114. influence in the business than if it's in one of the the profit centers absolutely and I think now corporations
  115. and particularly family-owned businesses see that the creation of those shared value businesses or shared value
  116. initiatives it becomes an imperative to attracting talent and assuring the succession from the family members
  117. because the next generous they want to see their family business and engine of social change of positive one they know
  118. they want to know how the money is made not only what you do with the money later on but they want to align the way
  119. how their family business works with their values with the values of the family so I think there is a huge
  120. opportunity there so in Julia what kind of trends do you see among the weather wealth holders as you're doing your
  121. research and thinking about these issues and I think there is a couple that I can
  122. think of first of all that impact investing is really a tool which can be used to generate impact to safeguard
  123. wealth and manage it well but also to tackle a number of personal and strategic objectives that the family
  124. phase many families get excited about impact investing because they see that it could be a glue that keeps the
  125. generations of family members together particularly after the sale of the family business for example it could be
  126. a tool to educate next generation about responsible wealth management and assure
  127. that they can find a protective place in the society it can also be a way of transferring wealth with values
  128. and preserving the culture of the family and the longevity of the family business
  129. it's also an important thing but also families more and more thing that impact investing is in many cases and more
  130. effective way of giving back than traditional grounds which they sometimes get a bit worried that maybe the
  131. long-lasting tangible and scalable impact is not necessarily happening and they are very much excited about
  132. market-based solutions and supporting those models which can provide not just alleviate suffering but really have a
  133. systemic change so i think this awareness and this focus on systemic change is really well sin and then
  134. another trend that I see is trend towards integration where you would see that impact investing in the earlier
  135. stages of involvement of families used to be more like a carve-out we will do it with part of the assets but nowadays
  136. a lot of families are thinking that we want to have impact to be one dimension through which or a prism through which
  137. you will look at all the financial decisions that they will make and therefore they will integrate different
  138. types of approaches responsible investing sustainable investing and impact investing in order to achieve a
  139. holistic larger impact with their wealth thank you we've been delighted have Julia Balan Dina Jackie a author of
  140. catalyzing wealth for change in our studio with us today thank you you

Brief Summary

Julia Valentina Jackie discusses impact investing and her book, highlighting its growth among wealthy families and the challenges of translating intention into action.

Key points

  • The New Normal for Millennials. Impact investing is becoming standard for younger generations, reflecting their values and priorities.
  • Bridging the Gap. There's a significant gap between the intention to invest impactfully and the actual action taken.
  • Catalyzing Wealth for Change. Julia Balan Dina discusses her book on impact investing, emphasizing actionable strategies.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes