Nicholas Kristof's 'Path' to More Effective Giving

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof discusses how to use your time and money for the greatest good. More: http://knlg.net/1wLGvMA 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Madam Grant I'm here with Nick Kristoff co-author with his wife Cheryl Wun of a path appears a brilliant book
  2. that's been called inspiring by the likes of Bill and Melinda Gates Bill Clinton Angelina Jolie and many others
  3. Nick welcome delighted to be with you well I I've been a fan for a long time uh two pullit surprises New York Times
  4. column what inspired you to write this book well Cheryl and I had written a previous book uh half the sky about
  5. empowering women in other countries and then after we wrote that then so many people would come up to us and they
  6. would ask you know a well what about the US and B so what can I do and we wanted
  7. to try to address that and it seemed to us that there are so many Americans who want to make a difference in some form
  8. but the problem seem too vast uh they don't really they're suspicious about corruption inefficiency and they don't
  9. really know that they can accomplish anything in fact we think there's been a pretty good evidence base that has
  10. emerged that shows what does work what doesn't work that's one of the big points that you Hammer home in the book
  11. that we need to take evidence more seriously in this domain why why aren't we doing it and how do we change
  12. it you know I think that it's so tempting just to go with our gut and that's always been the way we've done it
  13. I think it's also just a little bit more work um but I think it is gradually coming and now you have randomized
  14. control trials where you can uh test a intervention the way you would a pharmaceutical and um it gives you a
  15. real sense of what the impact is at what cost and I find it so useful because you
  16. know every every Aid group in the history of the world has always found that its own interventions are
  17. incredibly successful and they always come to me and want me to write about them and I you know I'm frankly a little
  18. bit skeptical but when I see an outside measurement um using randomized trial then I'm much more confident that this
  19. is real well one of the things that that I found challenging reading the book was
  20. it led me to question how I actually make my everyday choices and I I have a feeling I'm Not Alone um
  21. did you find that writing the book transformed your own thinking about giving um you know it challenged me a little
  22. bit I think Cheryl and me both because you know frankly we do a certain amount of giving that is not particularly
  23. optimized to create opportunity you know I mean I um we give to some cultural organizations we give to our Alma
  24. modders uh the beneficiaries of those are going to be you know kids that are better off than average and um and so
  25. that kind of forc me to think about that and I think where I came down is that it's a little like a a bouet and that we
  26. don't everything we do isn't intended to you know add a little bit of utility and
  27. some kind of utilitarian scheme uh but Cheryl and I also go out to dinner and um that money might be better spent in
  28. Bangladesh but so be it and as long as our donations to a cultural organization or to where Alma moders are coming out
  29. of the go to dinner money rather than out of the Bangladesh money then we're in good shape so there there are a lot
  30. of powerful stories along with with studies looking at different ways of of trying to successfully make a difference
  31. um I thought cure violence was one of the most fascinating ones how did you come ac across that story and uh what
  32. did you take away from it you know I've always been interested in public health approaches because it seems to me that
  33. we have this yearning for silver bullets and that that is not in fact how change
  34. comes about change comes about through silver Buckshot you know just a lot of little things that that achieve results
  35. and that's kind of a classic public health approach and indeed that is what Gary slutkin the founder of cure
  36. violence did he was an expert in epidemiology and uh looking at at the way contagious diseases spread in Africa
  37. and he then came to Chicago and looked at the way gang violence was spreading and he realized this is a public health
  38. problem it's not a criminological problem and we have tools from public health about stopping infections that we
  39. can apply to stop gang violence and he began to to do that uh and it worked and it worked incredibly cheaply uh and so
  40. and he's been able to measure that and now try it in other cities it's been it's even being introduced in Syria
  41. right now um so um you know the this idea of just trying creative new approaches measuring them carefully
  42. tweaking the model in this sort iterative process to get the most impact you can at the cheapest price I think
  43. it's just such a powerful model what can companies learn from this approach social impact is a theme that runs
  44. throughout the the book and what do you think businesses should be doing differently based on everything that
  45. you've been learning and studying well I've got to say I think businesses right now tend to approach um CSO far as this
  46. kind of Fringe activity on the side boards and and CEOs spend very little time on it it has very little effect I
  47. think they've got to completely rethink this if they want to recruit and retain young people from the millennial
  48. generation for Millennials these are issues that really matter deeply and if you're not competing in this space then
  49. you are undermining the long-term future of your company uh and and that goes to
  50. the long-term future of your share price as well if you can't get good people um
  51. I think that companies can have a huge impact on uh Society for good if they exercise it and uh but right now it's
  52. this kind of peripheral thing it's not well thought out not much measured people know within the company that if
  53. they go off and CSR you know their career may be stalled I I think we'd all be much better off if companies um made
  54. this much more front and center you talked not just about you know thinking about social responsibility but about
  55. creating opportunity how did you settle on that as as your lens and your sort of
  56. focus within the domain of making a difference CHL and I sort of feel that the basic aphorism for the 21st century
  57. is that Talent is universal but opportunity is not that just seems to sum up so much of the challenges we face
  58. and earlier we wrote about women's empowerment because one of the main reasons why um opportunity is not fully
  59. exercised is gender around the world but it's not the only one and there are an awful lot of people who don't exercise
  60. their talent can't fulfill their contributions to society because of other reasons they don't get a good
  61. education they're living in poverty they're stuck in a poverty cycle um and uh try to create that opportunity is a
  62. way of addressing inequities in society um we tend to measure uh inequality through metrics of income or wealth the
  63. greatest inequality of all is inequality of opportunity and these are things we can do something
  64. about and one of the things that that I found I would say striking at minimum um
  65. maybe even unsettling at maximum is how close you got to people who are experiencing this equality inequality of
  66. opportunity um you there there are some stories in the book that were absolutely
  67. gut-wrenching um and what's what's also inspiring is that many of them turn around and are able to discover
  68. opportunity but but what was it like to to engage with people both in the developing world and here in the United
  69. States who are just experiencing some of the worst of what life has to offer and
  70. and still come away with a sense of hope you know it is so frustrating when you see um people who we let down because
  71. they slip through the cracks there's a four-year-old kid in West Virginia who we saw who um had had uh ear infections
  72. that weren't addressed early he went deaf there was no hearing screening and so as his bra is developing he's not
  73. getting any auditory stimulus and so he can't speak it's not clear if he's ever going to bounce back and I think what I
  74. find most frustrating is that there's a tendency of successful people to harp on
  75. personal responsibility and that's you know absolutely true one there's a lot of self-destructive behavior that goes
  76. with poverty and of course we want personal responsibility on the part of the poor but we also want responsibility
  77. on the part of society and we let kids get by without a hearing screening or not able to get to a good school or not
  78. have access to family planning at a time when onethird of teenage girls become pregnant by age 19 then that's
  79. irresponsibility not just on their part but on all of our parts especially when we have the toolboxes now and the
  80. evidence about what works and yet we don't implement it what would you like to see happen in in schools let's take
  81. business school as an as an example if you want to teach the Next Generation to think differently about solving these
  82. kinds of problems where would you start start Business Schools have so much to offer because one of the problems in the
  83. nonprofit sector has been you have people with very good intentions who were very very well-meaning but
  84. productivity in the nonprofit sector has hugely lagged productivity in the for-profit sector and because you're not
  85. getting Market signals people are much more inclined to invest in nonoptimal uses and over the last 15 or 20 years it
  86. has really been quite useful to have more people coming from the business world into the doter world with a real
  87. emphasis on measurement on bang for the buck uh and that is useful but there's a
  88. lot more that can be done and in particular the nonprofit World often doesn't have people who are good at um
  89. kind of the um some of the peripheral areas in marketing for example uh nonprofit systematically don't Market
  90. well and marketing is so much more important if you're encouraging girls education than it is
  91. if you're you know trying to sell a Coke do you think the same skills apply though or do we need to rethink the way
  92. that we actually teach people to Market in this new domain I think that in that for that
  93. example in marketing probably the same skills apply I think that we do need to rethink um a lot of business skills and
  94. um you know in in finance for example I think that um social impact bonds are potentially a way of providing capital
  95. for Investments That save the public money in a context in which often government does not invest in things
  96. that would save it money um and so I think they're I think it's going to be a mix uh both applying existing uh
  97. business tools to the nonprofit world but also rethinking some um some of the conventional business tools for a new
  98. context and if you think about your typical business reader coming away from the book what actions would you like to
  99. see them take that they're not doing currently you know one of my frustrations is that we in society
  100. generally we have this um sort of bifurcation in how we see the world so uh probably a little less true of
  101. business audience but in general there tends to be this view that um for-profit companies greedy nonprofits Noble um and
  102. it's obviously more complicated than that what matters is whether there's impact and and some businesses
  103. for-profit companies can have tremendous impact for good and some nonprofits can
  104. have none um likewise when we allocate our Capital at the end of the year you know we divert a little bit of it toward
  105. charity and we want no return we give it all away we want to lose all our investment and then much of it we will
  106. invest in the market or for our retirement and there we want the highest possible return and you know no
  107. compromise on that and we don't look at all about social impact there know there
  108. should be something in between the two maybe uh people are willing to invest their Capital but not get their not get
  109. a return or to lose part of their capital or you know there should be something in between these two poles
  110. where do you stand on on B Corps as an example of falling in the middle I think that b Corps are a great idea uh I think
  111. that uh the whole idea of trying to find Alternatives uh to these two extremes is
  112. is a really useful one um I think that in practice it's been um you know hard to figure out how you manage the
  113. tradeoffs uh but uh in general I think it's a great idea and on a similar note U buy one give one models are I think
  114. exploding in popularity if you think of a tom shoes or Warby Parker how does that fit into the picture for you I
  115. think that works really well uh as a marketing technique for the companies I'm less convinced that it's always
  116. always the optimal way of addressing that social need you know but on the other hand if if the marketing works and
  117. it's a way of getting customers then then then it may in the in the long run be successful uh there
  118. too there was a a very moving review in the New York Times by an Oxford professor of the book uh who warned if
  119. you don't want to reink the way that you spend your time don't read this book uh
  120. and I I think that that was a very accurate way of characterizing the effect it has what was your reaction to
  121. that review we were incredibly flattered because you know we wrote the book not just to
  122. inform but ultimately we want people to to then take action and the most flattering thing for us has been when a
  123. book club reads a path of peers and then decides okay what are we going to do now
  124. and when they decide to to do something and um you know we would love to see uh people who read it then decide okay
  125. they're going to not only support um a business school With Their donation but also support a nursery school for
  126. example you know I think that would be I I think that there really is a toolkit out there to have an impact on
  127. the world that we are underusing right now and I hope that people will pick that up and do things with it what if
  128. you were going to take away one major message from the book what would be the the driving point
  129. there I think one can I get two so you know one would be that we really can indeed uh have an impact and that by
  130. having an impact on others we have an impact on ourselves and that nothing you know that purely altruistic behavior is
  131. pretty much impossible because of the selfish Pleasures we derive from it and the other is that both in this country
  132. and abroad one reason why we haven't had more uh luck in chipping away at poverty
  133. has been that we typically start too late that it is an awful lot easier to help a troubled six uh six-month-old
  134. than a 16-year-old down the road and you know that's the lwh hanging fruit these
  135. early interventions and yet we invariably try to pick the high hanging fruit of building prisons later on to
  136. address those who slipped through the cracks that we put there I think early intervention is a message we can all get
  137. behind and we're grateful that you came and joined us today thank you I'm delighted to be here
  138. [Music]

Brief Summary

Nick Kristof discusses social impact, evidence-based giving, and the importance of creating opportunities in addressing inequality.

Key points

  • Inspiring Book on Social Impact. A path appears a brilliant book called inspiring by notable figures.
  • The Challenge of Giving. The authors reflect on their own giving practices and the need for optimization.
  • Cure Violence Approach. Exploring innovative public health strategies to combat gang violence.
  • The Inequality of Opportunity. Discussing the greatest inequality of all: opportunity.
  • Early Intervention is Key. The importance of addressing issues early to prevent future problems.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes