Radical Innovation: Creativity vs Structure

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Innovation;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We're continuing our conversation with Kim Wagner of the Boston Consulting Group about corporate innovation. Kim's
  2. an expert in this area and she's co-author of a recent study by BCG titled Managing the Unmanageable Radical
  3. Innovation. And uh it turns out uh based on your study that you co-authored that
  4. radical innovation, everyone might think that it's up because we've got all these
  5. wonderful products and you hear a lot about Apple and and Uber and a lot of innovation going on, but actually when
  6. you look at the numbers as you did, um radical innovation is down from 20% of an average company's innovation
  7. portfolio back in 1990. It's down from 21% to just 10% today. That'll probably surprise a lot of people because uh it's
  8. you know the innovation is a high-profile thing. It gets a lot of coverage. But when you're looking at the
  9. whole base and you're saying it's not not the best picture. Well, it's not that it's a bad picture.
  10. So, I mean, think about what 1990 was, right? 1990 most people didn't have an email address. Nobody had desktop
  11. internet access. It was something you went to the public library to get or a university library to get. Um many
  12. people didn't carry a laptop. uh companies were just starting to implement enterprisewide systems where
  13. they would actually understand what inventory they had where you know who was where all the employee database was
  14. in one place. So you know 1990 was a point where there was a lot of incentive to all of a sudden track things, monitor
  15. things, put metrics against things and the infrastructure, the IT infrastructure was in place to make this
  16. happen. And so innovation did not escape this this you know this desire to have metrics and measurement and so people
  17. started to measure how many projects do we have? What kind of projects you know do we have a future cost of goods
  18. associated with each project? Do we have a future revenue stream associated with
  19. each project? Do we know exactly how many people are on it? And when you start to put all those metrics in place,
  20. you start to say, hm, there's a whole b bunch of stuff we're investing in that is potentially very high return if we
  21. would actually do the calculation intuitively, uh, but is really high risk. And so since we want to be
  22. efficient with our investments and efficient with our resources, let's focus on the things where we can be
  23. where things can be predictable. And so there was a big move towards making investments in innovation much more
  24. predictable and that inadvertently drove most innovation portfolios to being very
  25. incremental. Incremental and more of a linear process than an imaginative one. Well linear. Yeah. So linear like you
  26. know I I have a a particular food item. I can make it low fat. I can make it um I can add ingredients to it. I can make
  27. a new flavor of soft drink. you know, very, you know, I can I can change the color of the toilet paper, that kind of
  28. incremental thing, or I can make a new packaging. Um, and the new packaging may actually create new um benefits to the
  29. consumer, but it's it's not what you would call a breakthrough, right? So, these are refinements.
  30. They're product enhancements and and that kind the management processes that were trying to get more more
  31. control over the process ended up probably changing it into being one of more refinement than
  32. Exactly. managers got tracked on how well did your metrics come out. And when your
  33. metrics started to be what was the success to move from one gate of the process to the next gate, any manager
  34. would choose those projects that are more likely to get from gate one to gate two and gate two to gate three. And so
  35. through both the the talent management process and the project management process, there was a an enrichment of
  36. those projects that were of lower risk and therefore more incremental. And it took a lot of courage, thought and and
  37. basically senior management air cover to keep those truly innovative breakthrough
  38. high-risk projects in the skunk works. And as one of your college men uh colleagues mentioned in a different
  39. setting that sometimes uh you can get overly concerned about metrics and forget about the goal and you just I'
  40. I've completed step one, time for step two, time for step three and oh pretty soon you're worried about step five and
  41. six and not where you're supposed to be ending up. Yes. And sometimes you can even invest
  42. overinvest in a project because you were doing the check off the list steps as opposed to thinking do I really need to
  43. do that for this project? makes it hard to change and innovate mid-stream. Maybe
  44. you're going in the wrong direction and you should be checking what you're doing
  45. and and and moving. You wouldn't do Yeah. And this wouldn't open it because you wouldn't want to
  46. introduce a loop, right? And so even if the interesting thing is if you look at most companies um and and
  47. again I'm talking about 10 years ago, if you looked at their processes, there's flexibility for loops. There's
  48. flexibility for going back. And so if you look at it on paper, you'd say, well, the most breakthrough and
  49. innovative is probably not going to make it through. But reasonably good and breakthrough in quotes incremental will
  50. probably get through. But the other management metrics around it disincentivized anybody from going back.
  51. You know, it was almost a demerit if you had to do a loop back. Um, in a breakthrough world, actually,
  52. it's all about learning. You don't have a failure if you've learned something. It's a lot like science. And so, you
  53. know, that that those two systems just didn't jive. You you were punished in a way if you if
  54. you took too many risks. Well, at least you believed that you were going to be punished even if you
  55. weren't overly punished. So, are there other root causes uh when innovation fails? Root causes of the
  56. problem. Well, oftentimes um so even now companies will say I I want to devote a
  57. portion of my portfolio, my portion of my investment to breakthrough. Um oftentimes kind of forgetting that
  58. breakthrough doesn't happen very quickly, meaning it's not going to be an 18 months to market or a two years to
  59. market. And it will often take different forms as it evolves through the pipeline. And so what often happens is
  60. um a couple of things. one two or three years later there's some need to cut a budget and somebody will say well what's
  61. this crazy project we've been investing in that nobody knows about and it gets cut or it doesn't get cut but somebody
  62. goes and says if you can't turn this around pretty quickly it's going to lose its resource. So something like that
  63. might happen. The other thing that can happen is oftentimes to keep those projects going, they kind of get put
  64. into a skunk works hot house in a back lot somewhere and they get forgotten and because they get forgotten they can
  65. never get incremental resource or or keep going with support. So no internal champion,
  66. no or or a weak internal champion or the internal champion is thinking about bigger things as opposed to this project
  67. and they'll say, "Yeah, I have to I have to give it up." What about the risk with
  68. this of trying to predict the unpredictable, right? Trying to I mean, so you know, Steve Jobs was famous for
  69. saying, I mean, in a way, I'm not really worried about what our customer thinks because I know what they want before
  70. they know it, which is the opposite of how, you know, customer centricity in a way of trying to understand customer
  71. needs and anticipating needs and that sort of thing. You know, there's a balance in there. But um so someone
  72. that's going to be out there and says yes, I want I I want the next flying saucer that's you know going to operate
  73. on magnets like Dick Tracy days or something, right? And someone has to be there to say we love your creativity but
  74. you know you need to reel it in a little bit. So how do you how do you you know encourage but also reel in when you need
  75. to and still encourage the right things. I mean it's got to be more than pizza parties, right?
  76. Exactly. Exactly. And and customer centricity is still important because it's it's not about asking your customer
  77. what they want. It's about knowing your customer so well that you know what they
  78. want before they can even articulate it. Um they may be able to tell you about a
  79. need and you can find a way to to fill that need. And so under deep customer understanding is actually very important
  80. for breakthrough innovation because it gives you the rationale. It's the goal. you know, I am I am creating this
  81. product in order to serve this need. Um, and so in in that instance, you you know, how do you how do you keep
  82. the Dick Tracy stuff from coming up? You know, one is some structure around is the technology there to make this
  83. happen. You know, let's take a step back and say, do I have all the pieces in place and what are the risks associated
  84. with it? Is the risk that I can't get a certain raw material? is the risk that I
  85. this thing can't even be created or it's just the risk I'm not sure if anybody's
  86. going to buy it and I don't know if I can manufacture it reliably because some of those risks around manufacturing and
  87. around marketing you can derisk in an organized way something like I need a new type of plastic that does not exist
  88. right now that's really early technology development that's not ready for radical
  89. product development so you have to legislate keeping an open mind somehow Yeah. And and and that's part of culture also
  90. which I think you referred to uh from your recent best most innovative companies in 2014 report where culture
  91. uh and encouraging that culture is of course very important right and and it's also understanding
  92. that there are sometimes great ideas but not great ideas for that company and then the question is do you have a piece
  93. of the puzzle and it's about potentially finding partners and then as part of a joint venture or as part of a licensing
  94. agreement um you can make something happen. The other thing I think that was interesting in your study about radical
  95. innovation was that that the companies that aren't doing so well that you tend to notice a lack of collaboration within
  96. the company departments or whoever should be collaborating isn't so much but also interestingly externally.
  97. They're not collaborating enough with suppliers in the supply chain or collaborating enough with customers and
  98. however whatever ways that they're able to do that. Right? And actually the data in our 2014
  99. most innovative companies report like reinforced that exactly. You know companies the difference between
  100. companies that um are strong innovators but incremental in nature and strong innovators versus breakthrough. One of
  101. the things that differentiates them is their comfort with external alliances and and partnerships. Um and and how
  102. important it is to bring that in. You know, typically when you're out when you're out there in the brand new space,
  103. there's a lot of unknowns and risks that you're trying to manage. And it would be
  104. foolish to think that all of the experts you need to derisk those problems are within your four walls because you're
  105. talking about something that you don't do right now. So, of course, you're going to go out and find an expert.
  106. Now, there are some companies that really go out and find an expert. I'm thinking right now of the state of the
  107. pharmaceutical industry where they've had some acknowledged problems of coming up with with new blockbuster drugs. So,
  108. one of the strategies to to look around and see what are some of the smaller biotech companies that are doing some
  109. really innovative radical stuff. Um, and there's going to be winners and losers there. So, part of their job now is to
  110. identify who the winners might be and at some point they step in with their checkbook and y
  111. or credit card and they they take them over. they bolt them on to to their company. So, that's a strategy that can
  112. be very workable, right? If you're big enough, it's workable. You have to be careful
  113. because you're going to pay a premium. So, think of it this way. Um, tens of thousands of flowers can bloom
  114. around and you know that one of them is going to give you the, you know, the the
  115. the black rose, you know, the thing that everybody is after. One of them is going
  116. to deliver that and you just don't know which one. So you can let them all go and then you find it and you then say,
  117. "I'm going to pay you a premium for it." Or you can be the one that tries to grow
  118. them all, all 10,000 of them. You pay for all 10,000 of them. You have 9,999 failures that you've paid for and then
  119. you have the one that you got quote at cost, but it's at a huge cost because you paid for all those failures. So it's
  120. what many people don't realize is that the science underpinning mechanisms of disease and the pharmaceutical industry
  121. is moving so fast in so many exciting ways that no one company can do it all and they've realized that and that's a
  122. wonderful thing and so now it's about how do you quickly incorporate the new science as the proof of concepts are
  123. coming. There's also uh some findings in your study about how autonomous organizations with minimal supervision
  124. can work well uh depending on the right circumstances versus other kinds of organizations. Could you talk about that
  125. dichconomy of what that balance is about because that seemed an important element
  126. also. Right. So one of the challenges is sometimes you uh you figure for breakthrough innovation to survive in
  127. your big company of tens of thousands of people, it needs its own little garage to work in. and you're trying to kind of
  128. recreate Five Guys in a garage, um, that can backfire if they don't have a connection back to the mothership, you
  129. continue to need to have access to everything that is in the big company. You continue to need the senior
  130. management um, support and funding and and help essentially to get through the process. And then ultimately to get a
  131. product to market, that new great innovative thing is eventually going to have to click back into the process um
  132. to get through engineering and manufacturing and and the supply chain. Um so what happened in the past is
  133. oftentimes they would get left in the garage alone and then somebody come back two years later and say, "What have you
  134. done for me lately?" Now there's the realization that they need connections back into the organization and it's when
  135. they're more tethered in that it's it's more helpful. The same has been true for
  136. incubators. So in the past old school incubators you wrote a check they were off doing their thing and then if it
  137. worked out you basically had rights to license the technology and the people back. Now it's usually a much more
  138. collaborative. So it's almost like a joint project type incubator that ties into the idea of lack of
  139. collaboration. And if you leave them off on their own, they're not interacting with, you know, the marketing folks are
  140. going to say, "That's a great spaceship you've built, but there's only one customer." And if they don't want it,
  141. we're, you know, we're in trouble here. Yeah. The other thing that's important is most people think about, you know,
  142. crossf functional as crossunctional within the technical lines or the engineering lines or the manufacturing.
  143. Crossfunctional is really everybody. It's the deep customer discovery people with the science and technology people
  144. with the marketing people and the sales people and and supply chain and manufacturing. It is truly crossf
  145. functional. It's all of the functions of the company and oftentimes the HR person
  146. is the most important part because as you think about spooling this thing up finding the right talent is non-trivial.
  147. What else is it important to know about radical innovation that we haven't covered?
  148. It's exciting. I think that might be number one. Yeah, I think the the most important thing is that it
  149. is something to embrace, not be afraid of. It is something that should be managed and controlled, but in a way
  150. that allows the organization to learn as opposed to in a way that squaltches things. And if you have kind of two
  151. paths um and there's many different ways to make that happen, you can do it successfully.
  152. Thank you very much. Thank you.

Brief Summary

Kim Wagner discusses the decline of radical innovation and the importance of collaboration and risk management in corporate innovation.

Key points

  • Decline of Radical Innovation. Radical innovation has decreased significantly, from 21% in 1990 to just 10% today.
  • The Importance of Learning. In breakthrough innovation, learning from failures is crucial for success.
  • Embracing Radical Innovation. Radical innovation should be embraced and managed to foster learning and creativity.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes