Radical Innovation: Creativity vs Structure
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
📂 Innovation;Management
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- We're continuing our conversation with Kim Wagner of the Boston Consulting Group about corporate innovation. Kim's
- an expert in this area and she's co-author of a recent study by BCG titled Managing the Unmanageable Radical
- Innovation. And uh it turns out uh based on your study that you co-authored that
- radical innovation, everyone might think that it's up because we've got all these
- wonderful products and you hear a lot about Apple and and Uber and a lot of innovation going on, but actually when
- you look at the numbers as you did, um radical innovation is down from 20% of an average company's innovation
- portfolio back in 1990. It's down from 21% to just 10% today. That'll probably surprise a lot of people because uh it's
- you know the innovation is a high-profile thing. It gets a lot of coverage. But when you're looking at the
- whole base and you're saying it's not not the best picture. Well, it's not that it's a bad picture.
- So, I mean, think about what 1990 was, right? 1990 most people didn't have an email address. Nobody had desktop
- internet access. It was something you went to the public library to get or a university library to get. Um many
- people didn't carry a laptop. uh companies were just starting to implement enterprisewide systems where
- they would actually understand what inventory they had where you know who was where all the employee database was
- in one place. So you know 1990 was a point where there was a lot of incentive to all of a sudden track things, monitor
- things, put metrics against things and the infrastructure, the IT infrastructure was in place to make this
- happen. And so innovation did not escape this this you know this desire to have metrics and measurement and so people
- started to measure how many projects do we have? What kind of projects you know do we have a future cost of goods
- associated with each project? Do we have a future revenue stream associated with
- each project? Do we know exactly how many people are on it? And when you start to put all those metrics in place,
- you start to say, hm, there's a whole b bunch of stuff we're investing in that is potentially very high return if we
- would actually do the calculation intuitively, uh, but is really high risk. And so since we want to be
- efficient with our investments and efficient with our resources, let's focus on the things where we can be
- where things can be predictable. And so there was a big move towards making investments in innovation much more
- predictable and that inadvertently drove most innovation portfolios to being very
- incremental. Incremental and more of a linear process than an imaginative one. Well linear. Yeah. So linear like you
- know I I have a a particular food item. I can make it low fat. I can make it um I can add ingredients to it. I can make
- a new flavor of soft drink. you know, very, you know, I can I can change the color of the toilet paper, that kind of
- incremental thing, or I can make a new packaging. Um, and the new packaging may actually create new um benefits to the
- consumer, but it's it's not what you would call a breakthrough, right? So, these are refinements.
- They're product enhancements and and that kind the management processes that were trying to get more more
- control over the process ended up probably changing it into being one of more refinement than
- Exactly. managers got tracked on how well did your metrics come out. And when your
- metrics started to be what was the success to move from one gate of the process to the next gate, any manager
- would choose those projects that are more likely to get from gate one to gate two and gate two to gate three. And so
- through both the the talent management process and the project management process, there was a an enrichment of
- those projects that were of lower risk and therefore more incremental. And it took a lot of courage, thought and and
- basically senior management air cover to keep those truly innovative breakthrough
- high-risk projects in the skunk works. And as one of your college men uh colleagues mentioned in a different
- setting that sometimes uh you can get overly concerned about metrics and forget about the goal and you just I'
- I've completed step one, time for step two, time for step three and oh pretty soon you're worried about step five and
- six and not where you're supposed to be ending up. Yes. And sometimes you can even invest
- overinvest in a project because you were doing the check off the list steps as opposed to thinking do I really need to
- do that for this project? makes it hard to change and innovate mid-stream. Maybe
- you're going in the wrong direction and you should be checking what you're doing
- and and and moving. You wouldn't do Yeah. And this wouldn't open it because you wouldn't want to
- introduce a loop, right? And so even if the interesting thing is if you look at most companies um and and
- again I'm talking about 10 years ago, if you looked at their processes, there's flexibility for loops. There's
- flexibility for going back. And so if you look at it on paper, you'd say, well, the most breakthrough and
- innovative is probably not going to make it through. But reasonably good and breakthrough in quotes incremental will
- probably get through. But the other management metrics around it disincentivized anybody from going back.
- You know, it was almost a demerit if you had to do a loop back. Um, in a breakthrough world, actually,
- it's all about learning. You don't have a failure if you've learned something. It's a lot like science. And so, you
- know, that that those two systems just didn't jive. You you were punished in a way if you if
- you took too many risks. Well, at least you believed that you were going to be punished even if you
- weren't overly punished. So, are there other root causes uh when innovation fails? Root causes of the
- problem. Well, oftentimes um so even now companies will say I I want to devote a
- portion of my portfolio, my portion of my investment to breakthrough. Um oftentimes kind of forgetting that
- breakthrough doesn't happen very quickly, meaning it's not going to be an 18 months to market or a two years to
- market. And it will often take different forms as it evolves through the pipeline. And so what often happens is
- um a couple of things. one two or three years later there's some need to cut a budget and somebody will say well what's
- this crazy project we've been investing in that nobody knows about and it gets cut or it doesn't get cut but somebody
- goes and says if you can't turn this around pretty quickly it's going to lose its resource. So something like that
- might happen. The other thing that can happen is oftentimes to keep those projects going, they kind of get put
- into a skunk works hot house in a back lot somewhere and they get forgotten and because they get forgotten they can
- never get incremental resource or or keep going with support. So no internal champion,
- no or or a weak internal champion or the internal champion is thinking about bigger things as opposed to this project
- and they'll say, "Yeah, I have to I have to give it up." What about the risk with
- this of trying to predict the unpredictable, right? Trying to I mean, so you know, Steve Jobs was famous for
- saying, I mean, in a way, I'm not really worried about what our customer thinks because I know what they want before
- they know it, which is the opposite of how, you know, customer centricity in a way of trying to understand customer
- needs and anticipating needs and that sort of thing. You know, there's a balance in there. But um so someone
- that's going to be out there and says yes, I want I I want the next flying saucer that's you know going to operate
- on magnets like Dick Tracy days or something, right? And someone has to be there to say we love your creativity but
- you know you need to reel it in a little bit. So how do you how do you you know encourage but also reel in when you need
- to and still encourage the right things. I mean it's got to be more than pizza parties, right?
- Exactly. Exactly. And and customer centricity is still important because it's it's not about asking your customer
- what they want. It's about knowing your customer so well that you know what they
- want before they can even articulate it. Um they may be able to tell you about a
- need and you can find a way to to fill that need. And so under deep customer understanding is actually very important
- for breakthrough innovation because it gives you the rationale. It's the goal. you know, I am I am creating this
- product in order to serve this need. Um, and so in in that instance, you you know, how do you how do you keep
- the Dick Tracy stuff from coming up? You know, one is some structure around is the technology there to make this
- happen. You know, let's take a step back and say, do I have all the pieces in place and what are the risks associated
- with it? Is the risk that I can't get a certain raw material? is the risk that I
- this thing can't even be created or it's just the risk I'm not sure if anybody's
- going to buy it and I don't know if I can manufacture it reliably because some of those risks around manufacturing and
- around marketing you can derisk in an organized way something like I need a new type of plastic that does not exist
- right now that's really early technology development that's not ready for radical
- product development so you have to legislate keeping an open mind somehow Yeah. And and and that's part of culture also
- which I think you referred to uh from your recent best most innovative companies in 2014 report where culture
- uh and encouraging that culture is of course very important right and and it's also understanding
- that there are sometimes great ideas but not great ideas for that company and then the question is do you have a piece
- of the puzzle and it's about potentially finding partners and then as part of a joint venture or as part of a licensing
- agreement um you can make something happen. The other thing I think that was interesting in your study about radical
- innovation was that that the companies that aren't doing so well that you tend to notice a lack of collaboration within
- the company departments or whoever should be collaborating isn't so much but also interestingly externally.
- They're not collaborating enough with suppliers in the supply chain or collaborating enough with customers and
- however whatever ways that they're able to do that. Right? And actually the data in our 2014
- most innovative companies report like reinforced that exactly. You know companies the difference between
- companies that um are strong innovators but incremental in nature and strong innovators versus breakthrough. One of
- the things that differentiates them is their comfort with external alliances and and partnerships. Um and and how
- important it is to bring that in. You know, typically when you're out when you're out there in the brand new space,
- there's a lot of unknowns and risks that you're trying to manage. And it would be
- foolish to think that all of the experts you need to derisk those problems are within your four walls because you're
- talking about something that you don't do right now. So, of course, you're going to go out and find an expert.
- Now, there are some companies that really go out and find an expert. I'm thinking right now of the state of the
- pharmaceutical industry where they've had some acknowledged problems of coming up with with new blockbuster drugs. So,
- one of the strategies to to look around and see what are some of the smaller biotech companies that are doing some
- really innovative radical stuff. Um, and there's going to be winners and losers there. So, part of their job now is to
- identify who the winners might be and at some point they step in with their checkbook and y
- or credit card and they they take them over. they bolt them on to to their company. So, that's a strategy that can
- be very workable, right? If you're big enough, it's workable. You have to be careful
- because you're going to pay a premium. So, think of it this way. Um, tens of thousands of flowers can bloom
- around and you know that one of them is going to give you the, you know, the the
- the black rose, you know, the thing that everybody is after. One of them is going
- to deliver that and you just don't know which one. So you can let them all go and then you find it and you then say,
- "I'm going to pay you a premium for it." Or you can be the one that tries to grow
- them all, all 10,000 of them. You pay for all 10,000 of them. You have 9,999 failures that you've paid for and then
- you have the one that you got quote at cost, but it's at a huge cost because you paid for all those failures. So it's
- what many people don't realize is that the science underpinning mechanisms of disease and the pharmaceutical industry
- is moving so fast in so many exciting ways that no one company can do it all and they've realized that and that's a
- wonderful thing and so now it's about how do you quickly incorporate the new science as the proof of concepts are
- coming. There's also uh some findings in your study about how autonomous organizations with minimal supervision
- can work well uh depending on the right circumstances versus other kinds of organizations. Could you talk about that
- dichconomy of what that balance is about because that seemed an important element
- also. Right. So one of the challenges is sometimes you uh you figure for breakthrough innovation to survive in
- your big company of tens of thousands of people, it needs its own little garage to work in. and you're trying to kind of
- recreate Five Guys in a garage, um, that can backfire if they don't have a connection back to the mothership, you
- continue to need to have access to everything that is in the big company. You continue to need the senior
- management um, support and funding and and help essentially to get through the process. And then ultimately to get a
- product to market, that new great innovative thing is eventually going to have to click back into the process um
- to get through engineering and manufacturing and and the supply chain. Um so what happened in the past is
- oftentimes they would get left in the garage alone and then somebody come back two years later and say, "What have you
- done for me lately?" Now there's the realization that they need connections back into the organization and it's when
- they're more tethered in that it's it's more helpful. The same has been true for
- incubators. So in the past old school incubators you wrote a check they were off doing their thing and then if it
- worked out you basically had rights to license the technology and the people back. Now it's usually a much more
- collaborative. So it's almost like a joint project type incubator that ties into the idea of lack of
- collaboration. And if you leave them off on their own, they're not interacting with, you know, the marketing folks are
- going to say, "That's a great spaceship you've built, but there's only one customer." And if they don't want it,
- we're, you know, we're in trouble here. Yeah. The other thing that's important is most people think about, you know,
- crossf functional as crossunctional within the technical lines or the engineering lines or the manufacturing.
- Crossfunctional is really everybody. It's the deep customer discovery people with the science and technology people
- with the marketing people and the sales people and and supply chain and manufacturing. It is truly crossf
- functional. It's all of the functions of the company and oftentimes the HR person
- is the most important part because as you think about spooling this thing up finding the right talent is non-trivial.
- What else is it important to know about radical innovation that we haven't covered?
- It's exciting. I think that might be number one. Yeah, I think the the most important thing is that it
- is something to embrace, not be afraid of. It is something that should be managed and controlled, but in a way
- that allows the organization to learn as opposed to in a way that squaltches things. And if you have kind of two
- paths um and there's many different ways to make that happen, you can do it successfully.
- Thank you very much. Thank you.
Brief Summary
Kim Wagner discusses the decline of radical innovation and the importance of collaboration and risk management in corporate innovation.
Key points
- Decline of Radical Innovation. Radical innovation has decreased significantly, from 21% in 1990 to just 10% today.
- The Importance of Learning. In breakthrough innovation, learning from failures is crucial for success.
- Embracing Radical Innovation. Radical innovation should be embraced and managed to foster learning and creativity.
Episode highlights
- Decline of Radical InnovationRadical innovation has decreased significantly, from 21% in 1990 to just 10% today.“That’ll probably surprise a lot of people.”0:45Nov 11, 2014
- The Importance of LearningIn breakthrough innovation, learning from failures is crucial for success.“You don’t have a failure if you’ve learned something.”5:20Nov 11, 2014
- Embracing Radical InnovationRadical innovation should be embraced and managed to foster learning and creativity.“It’s exciting. I think that might be number one.”15:10Nov 11, 2014
Tension
50/ 100Some tension





