Scott Sonenshein on Unlocking the Power of Less
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
More: http://knlg.net/2mQYUHL 📂 Leadership
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] thank you again to Adam and for putting on this event I'm really honored to be
- able to speak to you today about stretch my name is Scott Simon chine and I'm not
- just the author of stretch but I'm also a professor of organizational behavior at Rice
- now before I got into academia when I was around the age of many of you in this room I was working my first job in
- Washington DC and I got a phone call out of the blue from a recruiter and the recruiter said come to Silicon Valley
- there's lots of excitement here we'll pay you a lot more money we'll give you a lot of stock options well feed your
- breakfast lunch and dinner every day this is a job you should be taking so three weeks later I left family and
- friends and I took the job I never really reflected on why I was taking the job and of course when I got there
- there's also some rather bizarre behavior too because the way that organizations were judging their success
- was very much about what type of resources they were getting how much venture capital Oh could they raise how
- many new employees would come in each week how many customers could they get notwithstanding if even these customers
- are actually profitable if any of you remember pets.com of course that was the poster child of the dot-com era so I got
- me starting to think about some of these behaviors where we're so focused on our
- lives around chasing resources because we developed this dependence that we think in norther to find success and
- satisfaction we need more resources and we orient all of our energy in all of our efforts to trying to get more
- resources as opposed to doing more and oftentimes that's because we think that is the only pathway to success and
- satisfaction so that started getting me thinking and I've been doing research ever since about well what might be an
- alternative way of doing this and that led me to the idea of stretching which is a simple but powerful shift and how
- we think about resources everything from time money relationship connections knowledge it's not so much what we have
- it's how do we use those resources how can we be more creative in using what we have
- so there's some important differences in how our mindset approaches resources when we are stretching we believe that
- any resource is changeable so we're trying to get a picture hung on the wall and we don't have a hammer
- we don't give second thought we just take the shoe off of our foot and we we get the job done when we're chasing we
- got to find that hammer we got this search and search for it if we don't have it we're gonna go out and get it
- when we're stretching our whole focus is on how do we expand what we have to do more with it how might we take what we
- know in one context and put it in another context as opposed to when we're chasing it's all about what we're going
- to do to acquire the next thing because unless we require that next thing we can't actually do more we can't take
- ourselves to the next level we can't become happier if we don't have it and often what's driving this chasing
- behaviors what psychologists call social comparisons we look around other friends
- or colleagues or neighbors and we see what they have and we think we need the same in order to find that success in
- satisfaction but what's lost in this whole process are the goals that we have whether the inward goals that we're
- actually trying to accomplish for most people it really isn't just about giving more resources those are usually and
- those are usually means to a certain ends but we lose sight of whether actual goals are when we're chasing so
- stretching is the psychology of resourcefulness and helping teach us what we can do better with what we have
- but when we think of resourcefulness we usually think of something that's used for those in less fortunate
- circumstances so it could be for the poor or maybe someone who had just come to this country and doesn't know a lot
- of people or have a lot of money well my challenge in the book is really about how do we embrace the same
- psychology of resourcefulness because if you look at the history of many successful people who have also found
- satisfaction in their lives they started off resourceful they started off with not a lot and then the challenge is how
- do we maintain this type of mindset as we find ourselves with access to more and more resources can we maintain that
- scrappiness the same thing with organizations we have the classic garage startup but those organizations grow
- they want to show their success so they tend to change the way that they they do
- business so what I'd like to convince you of is there are there are times where if we
- embrace less we can actually end up doing more in the same notion of resourcefulness that fuels a lot of
- success in satisfaction really in our careers when their backs are against the wall can help bring us success as we
- move forward so the first thing is to own it now ownership is not a word that you think would describe a retail
- employee who barely makes above minimum wage but what I learned in my research is that it has a profound impact on the
- way that people approach their resources and I'll tell you an example I was doing
- a study of a chain of women's fashion boutiques and I went to the most successful store in this chain and to
- the most successful employee in this company and I said tell me how you do it or would he do this he gave me an
- example he told me about this time where he had a whole host of dresses that weren't selling he quite frankly
- described them as a piece of crap I mean they were falling off the hanger no one
- wanted to buy them so what he did is rather remarkable he took a pair of scissors and he cut the straps off and
- he rolled up the dress he put a tie around it and created a sign and said beach cover-up
- it went from a worst seller to a best seller now in many organizations of course this would get you fired right
- it's called damaging the goods in this organization he was celebrated I spent the next two years traveling around the
- country talking to his colleagues and hearing about their own cut off the straps moments and there wasn't just
- about physical products it was how they thought about training how they thought about customer service how they thought
- about operations in the overarching pattern in the day there was this when we believed that we owned not literally
- owned but psychologically owned our resources we give ourselves the license that creative freedom to solve problems
- in ways that are not anticipate a bull to constraints unleash creativity and the land of chase and constraints are
- absolutely terrible because we judge the worth of projects and we even judge the
- worth of ourselves by how many resources who's got the bigger office who's got more people on their team who's got the
- largest budget but it actually turns out that there are times we're having less unlocks that creativity
- to allow you to sell problems so in one study what researchers did is they brought in groups of students and they
- randomly divided them into two groups group a was told think of how the time as a child when you grew up not having a
- lot that was the scarcity group the second group were told think about the time growing up when you did have a lot
- that was the abundance group both groups were then told to solve a practical problem the universities computer lab
- had some extra bubble wrap what should we do with this well it turns out that simply thinking about scarcity led to
- more creative and innovative ideas and the reason is rather simple when we surround ourselves with abundance the
- way that the mind works is it focuses on the most conventional way of using a resource but we embrace scarcity and me
- think about scarcity we give ourselves that licence to use objects and think about objects in very different ways so
- in this case having less gave us the freedom to actually do more right three Outsiders solve problems and I should
- probably start with a caveat that I don't mean to diminish expertise you know if someone were the COO one of you
- were to come into my office for office hours and say you know dr. something trying they need a tooth pulled I would
- send you to the dentist and tell you I'm not that type of doctor so there's a there's a reason why we have experts but
- there's also something to be said about the role of outside there is those who actually know less about a specific
- topic so in one study what researchers did is they looked at all of the studies that examine the relationship between
- expertise measured by the amount of practice someone has and how it relates to performance and it turns out that for
- games like chess the relationship between performance and expertise is 26% now that's not bad although my guess is
- it's probably lower than you were the guest when it comes time to music it's 21% sports 18% this next one gives me a
- lot of pause because it's education and it's largely college students it's 4% and professional work it's less than 1%
- now there's also a clear pattern in the way that the data are trending which is essentially as you move from structured
- activities like games where the rules are knowing in advance and they never change to less
- structured activities where the rules are often changing or unknowable and these are the things where we spend most
- of our waking lives doing the role of expertise dramatically diminishes and the reason for this is quite simple
- experts are very good at what they're doing but they use tools in very specific ways because that's that's how
- they've been trained so they have a hard time applying their tools to different types of problems when the environment
- changes around them this was backed up by some other research that looked at 10 10 different countries 166 scientific
- labs researchers wanted to ask a very simple but important question what is the relationship between what you know
- about a specific scientific domain and your likelihood to actually solve a problem in that domain seems like a
- straightforward question and in fact they found a positive relationship the more that someone knew about a specific
- scientific domain the less likely they were to solve the problem in other words biologists were better at solving the
- chemistry problems and the chemists and vice-versa for success comes from doing not
- planning now again there is important times in our lives where we want the plan but we often over plan and we over
- plan and we trick ourselves into thinking that the reality that's captured in our plans all of that
- information all of that data is actually true when the reality is is it's very hard to know what's gonna happen in five
- years in fact it's very hard to know what's gonna happen in the next day and the times that we find ourselves in
- right now and in fact if you look at the research there's very little correlation
- between strategic planning and organizational performance so I learned this firsthand the very first class I
- taught is at the University of Michigan I was still a PhD student is undergraduate introduction to management
- class and lo and behold this is probably no surprise to many of you in the room but when you put participation in the
- syllabus lots of people want to participate so I have a treasure trove of hands up in the air everyone was
- vying for airtime so I thought okay there's a really simple way of managing this what I'm gonna do is I'm just gonna
- say okay you're going to talk knew they knew then you know I've literally go around the horn in the
- classroom and I designate eight or nine different people to speak but what would
- happen is I get to the fourth or fifth person and with the bravado that you might have in some of your classes and
- more than where someone is just so confident that what they're saying is the most remarkable thing they deliver
- yeah you guys are all laughing for a reason they deliver they deliver you know this this comment and they'd be so
- proud and it has that big smirk on their face and everyone else in the room had a
- look of horror and they couldn't figure out why why is everyone looking at me so
- funny well it turned out what they did is they had just repeated the exact comment of the person sitting right next
- to them who had just spoken so we have a name for this it's called the next-in-line effect and what happens is
- when we are so focused on preparation and we have a speaking order so like I had a speaking order the mind shuts out
- as much as nine seconds before it's our turn to speak and as much as nine seconds after it's our turn to speak and
- that makes sense because there's nine seconds before we're planning our performance we want that we want to get
- that plan we want that really clever comment that we actually miss what just unfolded in front of us in those nine
- seconds afterwards we're thinking how did I perform did I meet the plan was a well received and so we end up not
- listening so what I try and do is you know put some more improvisational activities into my classroom to get
- people to more spontaneously just start acting and gather this idea that when we
- plan everything we end up with better results and I think I want to kind of leave you with one story that really
- captures this I'm guessing no one in the room knows who this is anyone really surprised you might know his name his
- name is Dan Wyden he's an advertising executive and one day he had a problem on his hands he had a client who needed
- a slogan to kind of make all of the different media campaigns come together so dan why there's a resourceful person
- he was in the scrappy makeshift office it was in the basement of a building because he couldn't afford prime real
- estate he didn't even have a phone back then there were no cell phone so he had a payphone that was his office phone
- with his back up against the wall he had a deadline and he recalled a rather bizarre situation for what he was trying
- to accomplish about ten years before and they a man by the name of Gary Gilmore was not a very nice person
- was in the news because he had killed two people Gilmore was a lifelong criminal you know
- horrible person but unlike many people on death row Gary Gilmore did not wanted to die right away
- so his mother interjected and Gary Gilmore's go away I really want to just die mom and he kept saying this to all
- of these associations when it was finally his turn to die in the execution chamber his last words were let's do it
- so that gave Dan why then enough material to finish his job because his advertising slogan that they came up
- with is arguably the most successful one in business history and I think it's a great example for three reasons
- one that you think about the context in which Dan why then produced this back against the wall time constraints came
- up with this idea to you think about what he repurposed something that didn't seem valuable at all I mean first of all
- you won't find this on the Nike homepage I can tell you that for sure but he took
- the slogan of a lifelong criminal his last words and turned it into this cultural icon and has sold lots and lots
- of stuff and changed our society because it's a third part that I really want to
- emphasize here because the phrase itself really activates us to start doing things and not to wait for the plan or
- the ideal resources think about how many times you might hear from other people or you might even say to yourself if I
- only had more time or more money or more information or more connections this is
- what I could do when we're stretching the time to act is right now so what I'd like to leave you with is just to
- reflect on those times where you think that you don't have enough are there ways that you might be able to better
- use what you have to stretch those resources and find great success and satisfaction thank you
- [Applause] [Music] [Applause]
Brief Summary
Scott Simon Chine discusses resourcefulness and creativity in his book "Stretch," emphasizing innovative use of resources over mere acquisition.
Key points
- Chasing vs. Stretching. A powerful distinction between chasing resources and creatively using what we have.
- The Psychology of Stretching. Scott Simon discusses how stretching resources can lead to greater success and satisfaction.
- Dan Wyden's Iconic Slogan. The story of how a last-minute slogan became a cultural icon.
Episode highlights
- Chasing vs. StretchingA powerful distinction between chasing resources and creatively using what we have.“When we are stretching, we believe that any resource is changeable.”2:19Mar 17, 2017
- The Psychology of StretchingScott Simon discusses how stretching resources can lead to greater success and satisfaction.“Stretching is the psychology of resourcefulness.”3:33Mar 17, 2017
- Dan Wyden's Iconic SloganThe story of how a last-minute slogan became a cultural icon.“His last words were 'let's do it.'”13:52Mar 17, 2017
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





