Emily Esfahani Smith on Crafting a Life that Matters

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

More: http://knlg.net/2mQYUHL

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I want to begin by thanking you Adam grant for having me here and thanking Wharton for hosting me and thank all of
  2. you guys for being here my name is Emily Esfahani Smith and I'm the author of the
  3. power of meaning I've been working as a journalist and a writer for for several years now and it's really special for me
  4. to be here with you because but the idea for my book was born in this very building several years ago when I was a
  5. grad student sitting downstairs listening to a lecture about the difference between a happy life and a
  6. meaningful life and so I was so excited by what I heard that I eventually wrote a book about it so it's really it's
  7. amazing for me to be here with you in this place I want to begin by telling you the story of a woman named Ashley
  8. Richmond who I had the chance to spend some time with several years ago so Ashley doesn't lead a very glamorous
  9. life she doesn't work for a fortune 500 company she didn't go to a fancy school like Penn she doesn't shop at places
  10. like Whole Foods what she does do is spend the majority of her time shoveling animal poop from one place to another
  11. her hours are terrible and so is her pay and she rarely gets vacations off and yet Ashley told me that this is her
  12. dream job Ashley is a zookeeper who cares for giraffes Wallabies and kangaroos at the Detroit Zoo Ashley
  13. doesn't always feel happy or good when she's working in fact 80% of her time she said is spent cleaning animal waste
  14. which can be physically grueling when you're dealing with large animals like giraffes and yet she told me that her
  15. job is really meaningful in fact she thinks of it as a calling when I asked her several years ago what makes your
  16. life meaningful this is what she told me my purpose she said isn't cleaning up animal waste my purpose is caring for
  17. the animals and doing everything I can to make their lives as good and as rich as possible none of the animals here she
  18. said chose to be here and yet I have a responsibility to ensure that their lives are as healthy and assume
  19. is I can make them so my book was inspired by the stories of people like Ashley people whose stories I thought
  20. weren't being celebrated in our culture and in our conversations about what a good life is in our culture we're
  21. constantly getting the message that a good life is a happy life that we should pursue happiness and a life of comfort
  22. and ease and that if we do we'll end up being healthier and more successful better liked more attractive even the
  23. whole point and purpose of life were led to believe is to feel happy but as I was
  24. reflecting on that message several years ago in this building I realized that so
  25. many of the people who I admire most and who I look up to weren't focused on the
  26. single-minded pursuit of their own happiness they were devoted instead to leading meaningful lives in other words
  27. they were focused on how they could contribute to and improve the world around them so these were you know the
  28. quiet heroes of everyday life the nurses the teachers the parents the plumbers the bureaucrats who through their
  29. contributions helped made the world go round but they were also the great men and women of history Socrates and the
  30. Buddha Martin Luther King jr. and mother Teresa people who led hard lives but good lives so I think at this point I
  31. should say I don't have any problems with happiness I like to feel happy and I want the people I love to be happy as
  32. well but I do think that the happiness zeitgeist has led us astray so happiness is a positive emotion it comes and goes
  33. it's ephemeral and scientists have found that when we chase happiness and when we
  34. set it as our goal and pursue it single-mindedly that we ultimately end up feeling unhappy and even lonely but
  35. it's different with meaning so meaning the defining feature of a meaningful life is connecting and contributing to
  36. something that's bigger than you are and when we devote ourselves to this when we
  37. devote ourselves to leading meaningful lives we ultimately experience a deeper and more enduring form of well-being we
  38. feel more satisfied more at peace more content and I think this makes sense because human beings are meaning seeking
  39. creatures we yearn for meaning when we look up at the stars for example we don't see random balls of fire
  40. we see constellations we see warriors and bears we craft myths and stories about what we see we wonder about our
  41. place in the universe how the world came to be how we can make our individual lives count in the grand scheme of
  42. things we all want to know that our lives amount to more than the sum of our experiences that they matter
  43. we all need a why or reason to help us get through the good and the bad of life and no to people I found researching my
  44. book will necessarily have the same why so for the last several years I've traveled all across the country and I've
  45. spoken to dozens of people about what makes their lives meaningful people like Ashley but also a former drug dealer and
  46. astronaut a woman dying of cancer I spoke to psychologists and sociologists and philosophers and I
  47. wanted to know what exactly the building blocks of a meaningful life are and how
  48. we can build them up in our own lives along the way no two people told me the exact same things we all find meaning in
  49. our own individual ways at the same time there were four themes I found that came
  50. up again and again in the stories that I heard and in the research that I read when people talk about what makes their
  51. lives meaningful they talk about having a sense of belonging so being in relationships where we feel valued and
  52. like we matter and where we treat other people like they're valued and like they
  53. matter they talked about having purpose so something worthwhile to do with their
  54. time they talked about storytelling or crafting narratives that help them understand themselves and their place in
  55. the world and they talked about transcendence these moments in nature or through prayer and ritual where they
  56. felt a sense of self loss and connected to something much bigger than themselves
  57. so those are the four pillars or building blocks of a meaningful life purpose belonging storytelling and
  58. transcendence so I talked about all of them in my book but I want to dive a little bit more closely into
  59. storytelling right now because I think it might be the most interesting and perhaps unexpected of the pillars so
  60. storytelling is really about your own life story what's the story that you tell yourself about
  61. life it's the act of taking our experiences and weaving them into a narrative that explains who we are and
  62. where we came from it's it's how we make sense of our experiences and the person
  63. that we've been and it's the act itself and not necessarily even sharing our story with others that really builds
  64. meaning because it provides a framework it helps us see the patterns within our lives and it gives our lives a sense of
  65. coherence and integration but not all stories it turns out are created equal when it comes to leading a meaningful
  66. life the psychologist Dan McAdams at Northwestern University has studied people leading meaningful lives and he's
  67. found that they all tell particular kinds of stories about their lives in particular they tell stories of
  68. redemption which are stories that move from bad to good so let me give you an example I spoke to a man several years
  69. ago named Carlos Eyre so Carlos he's in his 50s now and he grew up in Havana Havana Cuba and he was just a child when
  70. the Cuban Revolution happened and he talks about the Revolution as the place in his where his narrative broke into so
  71. before the Revolution he was leading a really happy pampered life in Havana doing what mischievous boys do and after
  72. the Revolution he was forced to flee to America his parents did not come so he was an orphan he lived in dire poverty
  73. experienced discrimination daily for being Cuban so it was it was a very difficult life and yet as he was telling
  74. me his story he said even though that was hard and even though the Revolution completely changed the path of my life I
  75. grew as a result of it I became a more compassionate person because I suffered and so I began to understand the
  76. suffering of others more deeply my spiritual life deepened he said I was able to discover what my purpose
  77. ultimately is which is he's a historian so he that that's what his purpose is it
  78. was difficult for him and it took him years to make sense of that traumatic experience in his life and it was a
  79. painful process but it was one that ultimately brought him a sense of peace and resolution about a difficult chapter
  80. in his life story now you can imagine Carlos taking the same exact events and experiences and
  81. crafting a very different type of story about them so he could have said I was leading a really wonderful life in Cuba
  82. in my childhood and then the Revolution happened and it ruined everything he never saw his father again for example
  83. but he didn't tell that story he chose to tell a different story and psychologists find that when people
  84. tell the negative kinds of stories the stories that move from bad if Empress excuse me from good to bad I was in
  85. Havana Cuba and then the revolution happened and then everything was ruined but they actually experienced more
  86. depression and they're more likely to experience their lives as less meaningful but Carlos chose to tell a
  87. different story and we all have the power to do that we're all the authors of our own stories we can interpret our
  88. stories we can revise them and we can edit them to lead more meaningful lives and to experience more meaning in life
  89. and one of my favorite studies about this was actually by Adam grant and a researcher at the University of Michigan
  90. named dick Jane Dutton and they had participants come into their lab and they divided them into two and they told
  91. half of them to tell a story about themselves being a generous person and they told the other half to tell a story
  92. about themselves as being the recipient of someone else's generosity and what they found was that the people who told
  93. the story about themselves being generous ultimately went out after the study and were more generous the story
  94. they told changed their behavior and led them to lead life in more meaningful ways there's a myth in our culture that
  95. this search for meaning that leading a meaningful life is some grand pursuit that you have to cure cancer or write
  96. the great American novel in order to lead a meaningful life but that's not true if you want to lead a meaningful
  97. life be a storyteller take ten minutes of your day and reflect on what the defining moments of your life are ask
  98. yourself how do these experiences make me grow it might be a painful process because some of us are shaped most
  99. profoundly through suffering and law but try to find a positive meaning in those experiences we all have the power
  100. to tell and to retell our life story in more positive ways so tell a story that moves you forward thank you
  101. [Applause]

Brief Summary

Emily Esfahani Smith discusses finding meaning in life through storytelling, purpose, belonging, and transcendence, contrasting it with the pursuit of happiness.

Key points

  • Ashley the Zookeeper. A story of Ashley Richmond, a zookeeper who finds meaning in her challenging job.
  • The Power of Meaning. Emily Esfahani Smith discusses the difference between a happy life and a meaningful life.
  • Four Pillars of Meaning. Emily identifies four key themes that contribute to a meaningful life: purpose, belonging, storytelling, and transcendence.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes