No Nonsense Plan for Smart Wealth Management

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Charlotte Beyer, author of ‘Wealth Management Unwrapped,’ shares insights on what can be done to improve the relationship between investors and advisors. More: http://knlg.net/1AYCjIV 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Our Guest today is Charlotte berer founder of the institute for private investors and author of the book wealth
  2. management unwrapped uh Charlotte thanks so much for joining us today I'm delighted to be here with you mle great
  3. so you say in the introduction to the book that it really grew out of your experiences creating an educational
  4. Community for investors and advisors can you tell us a little bit about how the book came about as a result of your
  5. experiences in creating this community it's so interesting when you think about Investors and advisors
  6. because so often they're put at loggerheads and they're each protecting and not wanting to be sold in the case
  7. of investors and in the case of advisors needing to sell something or be seen as
  8. very smart so I noticed that the dialogue wasn't quite as candid and open and addressing the real issues that
  9. needed to be addressed and so teaching private wealth management at important and also having
  10. the content at The Institute for private investor forums allowed me to try to break down that wall that existed
  11. between the two and improve the way they related right now is there a case to be
  12. made for whether uh investors need advisors in the first place uh or can can't wey
  13. investors just be the CEOs of what you call my wealth Inc uh and manage their own money they certainly can and part of
  14. what is in my book is a way for an investor to decide whether he's the CEO and can do it all but I use the analogy
  15. of a real CEO let's say as a CEO you have to buy a telecom system and youve do you go down and actually do the
  16. switches and routers yourself or do you know enough to delegate that and hire someone else who can put it in so I
  17. think that's the distinction and each investor knows their management style as a CEO they're going to either be very
  18. Hands-On or they'll be slightly less Hands-On more of a really smart delegator you also compare to renovating
  19. your kitchen right renovating your kitchen how many times I mean I feel this you go
  20. into Home Depot and you think okay what size what am I doing how could I renovate a kitchen as I walk into Home
  21. Depot I'd be overwhelmed on the other hand some people know exactly what they're buying and they're almost like
  22. contractors or Carpenters or very skilled Craftsmen they love being in Home Depot
  23. they know exactly what size Lumber and cabinets to get right uh going back to the question of uh advice versus a
  24. different approach whether or not a CEO or a wealthy investor is Hands-On uh there are people who believe that
  25. passive indexing uh a passive approach based on indexing is better than trying to second guess the market because you
  26. diversify your risk so much more uh by just spreading it out across the entire Market what do you think are the pros
  27. and cons of that approach well what I describe in the book is the danger of thinking that wealth management and
  28. being the CEO is just about investing and picking one strategy putting it on autopilot and going away I call that not
  29. delegating but abdicating so in terms of passive versus active I think most investment
  30. professionals would really agree that the key is asset allocation so even if you're all passive
  31. you still need to be aware of how you're allocating and life changes you may have
  32. one allocation at this age or in these circumstances and quite another later in your life and that's where an advisor
  33. can come in or not depending on how you see your own needs so let's say uh an investor decides not to abdicate but to
  34. delegate uh to an advisor what are some of the most important considerations in choosing an advisor and and especially
  35. how how do you avoid advisers who may be too salesy in their approach well it's hard because some of
  36. the best salese are very very appealing and compelling you want to work with them and yet you're being in an
  37. oldfashioned word you're being snowed and a lot of investors are lary of that so so the most important pieces I
  38. believe that I detail in my book are this you need to know what kind of investor you are first and foremost and
  39. then you really need to set out your needs and your outcomes what are you really looking to do with this wealth
  40. what's the purpose of it and then how are you going to judge whether you've hired the right advisor or not now all
  41. of these exercises are ones that you can and should do with an advisor and guess
  42. what more than one because in the interview process if you take your time and really hear more than just one
  43. wonderful salesman you'll begin to get very Discerning and can see who's really talking about risk and return in a way
  44. that not only you understand that's going to suit your own personal needs and goals right you recommend something
  45. called a five PS exercise tell us about that that's where investors can both learn but also be incredibly blindsided
  46. the five PS are in somewhat uh oversimplified the components of an investment or an advisory firm and
  47. that's the philosophy what they believe in their values the process how they make their decisions the performance
  48. which of course is their returns and then also the people and then lastly the fees spelled pH EES so if you take a pie
  49. of 100% And you a portion among those five and you overweight one that's going to be the place where you're most
  50. vulnerable to being too captivated so if people is everything you're going to pick a firm with people like you People
  51. Like Us syndrome I call it if you think it's performance and you put 50% on performance you're going to keep hiring
  52. and unfortunately keep firing firms who have hot hands that suddenly go cold MH so what's the best way to hedge your
  53. risk uh in in uh how you choose an adviser practice makes perfect interview four five have the same exact questions
  54. for each firm give them start them all on a Level Playing Field I think I shared one story where this one advisor
  55. came in and had this incredible track record beginning in March of 2009 to the week before the meeting with the
  56. Prospect and of course it looked great however the other three firms they were interviewing weren't giv the same chance
  57. to use that exact same timeline so that really can be very deceiving but having a system such as I
  58. suggest in my book and doing the exact same questions with each of the contenders is a much fairer beauty
  59. contest than saying we're going to have a beauty contest for apples and we're going to have apples bananas and pears
  60. all and bananas everybody can come into it but how are you going to make a decision great one of the most uh I
  61. would say interesting areas between advisers and investors the question of fees uh what are your thoughts on uh uh
  62. what's the right way for investors to know what the right level of fees uh should be paid for
  63. advice there are two things here that I think are really critical fees are first
  64. the explosion waiting to happen in our industry the more transparency comes to the four the more more investors are
  65. losing faith and trust in the industry because fees are kept hidden so that's number one but number two investors can
  66. ask are you being paid directly or indirectly for what you're suggesting I buy tell
  67. me that puts you as the investor immediately as a more informed questioner and lastly um we did a study
  68. with W knowledge at Wharton together where we showed that if you can show fees in
  69. context and that means here's our fee for you and here's how our competitors how they charge at different levels of
  70. wealth that chart if you ask for it from a potential advisor will not only show them that you're well informed but will
  71. also give you a wonderful context for realizing whether this is a fair fee because if you go for the cheapest
  72. provider that may look very alluring the problem is you may get what you pay for
  73. and be missing some other aspects of advice that you really are going to come to want and depend on you know I
  74. remember that thank you for bringing up that study that we had done that IPI and
  75. knowledge at Wharton had done together I think with State Street several years ago uh one of the very interesting
  76. aspects of that study I remember was that uh advisor thought that investors trusted them at this level was while
  77. investors actually trusted them at a much lower level uh what does that tell you about uh the value of trust uh
  78. especially in the aftermath of the financial crisis and how can the trust be established between investors and
  79. advisers trust is the glue that holds any investor advisor relationship and creates the partnership
  80. trust is the glue and it's a word people misuse and short change all the time I would
  81. say that the way to develop that trust is to create metrics for valuing the advice and create a report card so that
  82. you can say here's what we said we do here's what your goals are here's how we're doing versus your goals and that
  83. builds trust trust is not an instant earning trust is something that gets shown over time being predictable I can
  84. rely on this advisor but you know what it's a two-way street the advisors if they are professional as well they need
  85. to expect investors to be trustworthy to share the information that will help them do a better job for their family
  86. and so often it's both sides are being a little less than candid right so do you
  87. see trust primarily as a matter of of metrics or as a matter of communication or both it's definitely both it's
  88. Communications on a foundation of real metrics the classic error is that too many advisers will say in an
  89. interview oh we help you sleep better at night but what does that mean and the first time an investor hears that they
  90. go oh thank goodness I finally found an investor that an adviser that will help me sleep better at night I don't think
  91. so they begin to realize it's a cliche so how do you do that is the question so it's all about Communications and
  92. unfortunately the investment industry speaks a language of its very own that is merely a separator and I believe
  93. creates mistrust right you know one of the things I found very interesting about your book is that you identify
  94. these four major risks that can send uh an investment strategy off the cliff uh what what are those risks and how can
  95. investors guard against them well this was actually um the work of a man by the name of Jeff Davy from phom metrica in
  96. Australia and he said too often we look at risk it's just standard deviation or the required risk the one that we chart
  97. and that Wharton professors are always citing but there are three others that are equally important and one is risk
  98. tolerance which is more of a personality characteristic another is the perceived
  99. risk how does the investor see the world today are they panicked by last week's volatility for instance on the stock
  100. market and then so it's risk required risk risk tolerance perceived risk and then the um risk that they can take
  101. because of who they are how old they are what they can expect in the future so that's just the risk situation that
  102. they're in right know one of the people I I I uh you invest you quote in your book is someone who
  103. complained that when he asked his advisor about the time the adviser told him how to make a watch uh uh tell us
  104. how uh advisor should communicate with investors about risk and other issues without bombarding them with so much
  105. detail that they put them to sleep yeah well that's where I believe emotional IQ
  106. comes in and many many investment professionals have a dir of emotional or EQ they have a huge amount of IQ and so
  107. what smart advisers do is they try to figure out who in their firm can do the conversation or the dialogue that
  108. determines the personality of the investor sitting across the table and too often they just bring the entire
  109. dictionary and say here or the entire instruction manual and say here not realizing that each investor sitting
  110. across from them has a different hunger interest curiosity but one thing holds true
  111. across all investor types and that is show me the picture show me whether it's a mon Carlo simulation or a risk return
  112. chart that shows how much risk did you have to take to get that much return a simple chart a simple graphic is going
  113. to be compelling to any investor uh how should investors measure their advisor performance and when is
  114. the and and and when is the right time to know that it's time to let an adviser go
  115. okay well that's two big questions um how to measure your advisor and then how to know whether it's time to fire um
  116. well let me start with the last question um an investor came to me right after the crisis and said my adviser lost me
  117. so much money Charlotte I want to fire him right away and I need to hire somebody right away and can you give me
  118. three names and of course I said no I can't give you three names but I will give you a system for looking at how
  119. you're going to do this and I said the first and most important thing is include your current adviser whom you're
  120. about to fire in the competition for your assets going forward and guess what using a the
  121. system of questions that I gave him he ended up hiring the adviser he was about to fire because suddenly the adviser
  122. gave him a context for understanding the performance he'd had and he actually did
  123. better than most endowments most investors most pension plans and he hadn't realized that when you broke down
  124. the asset classes and how they performed versus a benchmark so all of those things came into play now you might ask
  125. why didn't he get given all of that by his advisor without having to ask well the evolution of our industry is such
  126. that the more investors and advisors talk the more advisers realize oh our clients really want this now back to
  127. your first question how should you measure your advisor that's something I believe you decide before you hire the
  128. adviser and before the adviser lets you hire them and you may think that's odd why am I saying let's the more discovery
  129. about expectations what is our outcome what is our risk Target what are returns are we
  130. looking for when do I want to get a call from you when do I want to get an email
  131. how often do I want to meet with you and then each and every meeting you're looking at the metrics that you set
  132. before you even hired it and it really starts with the investment policy statement and a statement of goals
  133. purpose of the money well let me ask you one last question uh let's assume that in this room with us right now we have
  134. one investor and one advisor what's the one piece of advice you would give to each of them about how to optimize their
  135. working relationship dare to say it [Laughter] and what I mean by that is the investor
  136. needs to dare say I don't understand what you're talking about or I'm not happy with the relationship manager I've
  137. been assigned might you think of someone different or I don't feel comfortable in
  138. this market and on the advisor side she or he needs to dare to say we're not always going to agree we're not always
  139. going to agree you say you want this report done this way but if you want my firm to remain profitable and in
  140. business we cannot customize every report for every client so they both need an extra dose of
  141. Courage Charlotte thanks so much for speaking with knowledge at whorton you're very welcome
  142. [Music]

Brief Summary

Charlotte Berer discusses investor-advisor relationships and strategies for selecting the right advisor in wealth management.

Key points

  • Charlotte Berer on Wealth Management. Charlotte Berer discusses her book and the dynamics between investors and advisors.
  • The Importance of Trust. Trust is essential in the investor-advisor relationship, according to Charlotte.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes