Why Happiness Isn't Everything

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Happiness can tell a lot about the decisions people will ultimately make, but new Wharton research shows that the nuances of most decisions go far beyond simply achieving contentment. More: http://knlg.net/1AOl7pB 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. and so for the group of us uh at a very high level we're interested in understanding the relationship between
  2. the trade-offs people are willing to choose to make and the trade-offs that determine their happiness or a little
  3. more practically we're interested in thinking about situations where you have data on what makes people happy but you
  4. don't have data on what people choose and you want to try to use this happiness data to forecast things about
  5. their their decision- Mak process uh so to give you a little bit of background uh there's an increasing practice in
  6. economics of trying to use happiness data to augment uh typical choice-based analysis uh so to give you a you
  7. particular example let's say we were trying to think about how we should uh value a public policy and figure out how
  8. much a particular person would be willing to pay to have that public policy in place so one way of
  9. approximating this is by taking uh existing happiness data estimating how policies like this affect happiness in
  10. the past estimating how money plays into determining happiness and then figuring
  11. out the trade-off between these two things and we could use that to basically determine uh the amount of
  12. money a person would be willing to pay to put that policy in place under the assumption that choices and happiness
  13. are aligned right so that people are choosing whatever makes them most happy so that's the practice that's currently
  14. being followed uh by by some economists and we're basically interested in assessing that trying to figure out if
  15. these two trade-offs really do reflect one another uh so to get at that we ran a large scale study of medical students
  16. as they were participating in the medical residency match uh so in case you're unfamiliar with the training of
  17. doctors in the United States uh after uh young doctors uh graduate from medical school they go through a period of
  18. several years uh where they get really intensive Hands-On training in their specialty called a medical residency
  19. they have to go through an elaborate process to match from their medical school to a residency and so at this
  20. point you're probably asking well why are we talking about medical students now and we were just talking about
  21. happiness and happiness data and the reason why we're looking at this particular setting is because it has
  22. these really nice properties that allow us to get really high quality Cho data side by side with really high quality
  23. happiness data so in order to go through this matching process I just described medical students have to basically uh go
  24. through a period of interviewing with medical schools and consider really carefully the trade-offs they're willing
  25. to make about say The Prestige of a school versus a city location or things like this and then determine their
  26. choice ordering over those schools and say this is my first choice school this is my second choice school and so on and
  27. actually make a list like that and submit it to a centralized matching agency and that list is to determine the
  28. final assignment of where everyone will go uh and that mechanism was designed very carefully to make sure that
  29. students uh it's in their own best interest to report their preferences truthfully so basically we'll be
  30. piggybacking off of that existing field mechanism we'll be seeing their choice ordering uh and pairing that up with
  31. excellent survey data about how happy they think they'll be at these different options and the trade-offs they're
  32. making as they're making this decision so to generate that happiness data I just described we ran a large large
  33. scale survey of medical students as they participated in the 2012 residency match
  34. uh so in the leadup to that residency match I contacted basically all the medical schools in the United States uh
  35. and uh you know due to my uh my my uh requests I got 23 schools to agree to participate and at those schools
  36. students going through the matching process uh were given the opportunity to participate in a web survey where they
  37. could uh basically report their top four choices we get to see their choice ordering over them we also get to ask
  38. them how happy do you think you would be if you went to this res how happy do you
  39. think you would be if you went to this other residency and also for these residencies we collect all the features
  40. that they're trading off when they're making this decision things like Prestige or stady quality or how much
  41. their spouse cares about being in that location things like that so with this data we now have everything we need to
  42. basic uh to basically put happiness data and choice data side by side and uh kind
  43. of compare the analysis that you could do with with each of these these types of data so our main results from this uh
  44. are basically twofold so the first main one is that uh Happy data is actually reasonably useful for forecasting
  45. choices in this setting uh so if you were to say know that some resident or some future medical Resident was
  46. considering between two options we don't know which one he chooses but we just know that one of them uh he thinks will
  47. make him happier 70 to 80% of the time that's the one he will choose um now on one hand you know we know that people
  48. like to be happy right that's not that shouldn't be surprising but on the other hand this is a particular setting where
  49. we don't really think decisions are are necessarily made just to be happy right no one's going to to a medical residency
  50. to have fun uh this is a big investment and important decision in their lives and even in this situation uh happiness
  51. data is very useful for forecasting so that's you know a positive uh spin on how to use happiness data in economic
  52. settings there's a bit of a negative side uh in our data too that's the second main result and that's if you try
  53. to use happiness data to infer the tradeoffs people are willing to make so again like how how they tradeoff
  54. Prestige against City quality for example we find that the trade-offs you would estimate from happiness data are
  55. pretty dramatic rically different than the trade-offs you would estimate from Choice data uh these different factors
  56. wait very different uh very differently in determining these two things uh and that's a bit of a problem for a lot of
  57. economic analysis because for uh you know many questions economists are asking understanding tradeoffs is really
  58. the key thing we're trying to understand how we how we price various things you know how we trade off one attribute of a
  59. of a good versus another things like that and for these types of questions happiness data is not getting us the
  60. kind of answers we need um so kind of overall our main goal in this entire project was trying to get a better sense
  61. of how to how to use happiness data in economic applications and how far you can go with that and we found some
  62. positive results that it is actually useful for just raw forecasting of choices uh but some negative results
  63. that it doesn't do a great job in answering nuanced questions about how you trade off different attributes of a
  64. of an option you face so one way or one dimension where you can see differences in the way
  65. trade-offs are made across happiness data and across Choice data is looking at the importance of say considerations
  66. about your family's wellbeing or your spouse's well-being uh so if we compare how important uh you know say your
  67. spouse's happiness is in determining your choices it's actually dramatically more important uh in determining your
  68. choices than it is in determining your predictions about how happy you'll be so if we're thinking about trading off say
  69. going to a more prestigious residency in a location that your spouse likes less you're more likely to choose that and
  70. you're more likely to wait your spouse's uh your spouse's opinion more heavily in
  71. your choice then you would in your forecast about how happy you'll be in the future so in some sense this could
  72. be evidence that people are willing to uh to sacrifice their own happiness uh you know to to benefit their spouse in
  73. these kind of decisions I came at this problem from the point of view of an economist but it
  74. does have a lot of implications for how people uh conduct you know General exercises and marketing so uh reasonably
  75. commonly uh you know both economists and marketers find themselves in situations
  76. where we have lots of data about say customer satisfaction consumer satisfaction happiness things like that
  77. and we're trying to infer from that how people you know value different attributes of a product we're trying to
  78. sell uh how people make trade-offs in various economic environments and the results I was discussing for economists
  79. translate immediately to the kind of same kind of decisions in marketing environments so basically if you're
  80. trying to forecast what your consumers will choose or what they will like our results suggest that happiness data can
  81. help you make those kind of forecasting uh forecasts accurately however uh if you're trying to infer more nuanced
  82. question questions about how say customers are trading off different attributes of a product you're trying to
  83. sell our results suggest that happiness data doesn't really get you all the way there to estimating those kind of uh
  84. tradeoffs so I think this study speaks to uh to to countering misperceptions on two ends of a spectrum right on on one
  85. end of the spectrum uh some people believe that happiness is basically everything that maximizing happiness is
  86. the ultimate goal of all of our actions and our research suggests that at least when we're thinking about how happiness
  87. is currently measured in surveys and things like that that's not the case that happiness is something that's very
  88. important to people and it's an important goal they're pursuing uh but people will explicitly trade off the
  89. pursuit of happiness against uh you know to to pursue other goals uh now on the other end of the spectrum I think some
  90. people believe that happiness is not particularly informative for economic analysis uh this is a view held by by
  91. many economists this is sort of a frivolous psychological variable that isn't really fundamentally related to
  92. how we make choices and our results actually suggest that's not quite right either um so even in this setting that
  93. is unambiguously you know a very serious decision a very important decision not made for fun by any by any stretch of
  94. the imagination uh understanding or having access to happiness data really helps us understand how the decision
  95. process is made and helps us forecast the choices people will make so there are a few things that set
  96. my research apart from uh other analysis done looking at the alignment between choice and happiness and I think the
  97. main thing is we're coming at it from a little bit of a different attitude uh so
  98. there's a great deal of research out there demonstrating that people don't always choose what'll make them happy
  99. but the way that's typically discussed and the way that's typically presented is as evidence that people are making
  100. some sort of mistake or or they're bad at forecasting so the idea is that they would they're trying to to maximize
  101. their happiness and the only thing that's stopping them is either they they messed up the decision somehow or they
  102. they guessed wrong about what would make them most happy and so on and thus we can attribute the entire gap between
  103. Choice data and happiness data just to these mispredictions we were coming at it from a little bit
  104. of a different a different kind of Bas background we were thinking well okay you know maybe mispredictions are
  105. important but also it could be that people aren't even necessarily trying to maximize happiness maybe they could just
  106. be thinking of it as one of many goals they're pursuing and explicitly trade off that goal uh against other goals and
  107. so this led us to look at a situation where people are making uh a decision that's very considered very deliberated
  108. very high stakes where we're not particularly worried about mistakes driving any deviations we see
  109. uh and basically trying to see if we still see a wedge in that setting uh and of course we did and by by looking in
  110. this particular type of environment we were better able to get at uh how much of this wedge between choice and
  111. happiness is driven by people's initial intentions versus just their uh their mispredictions about what actually makes
  112. them happy in terms of what's next we're thinking about continuing this line of research uh by continuing to investigate
  113. basically the relationship between happiness data uh and choice data which is the more
  114. typical object in economic analysis we want to continue to think about uh how much you can infer about how choices are
  115. made based only on happiness data uh a particular Dimension that I'm interested in is in trying to build build happiness
  116. data into a more standard price theoretic economic analysis so rather than thinking about happiness as just a
  117. way of approximating the thing people are trying to maximize think of it as this kind of abstract good that people
  118. are willing to uh you know in some sense buy and also trade uh and explicitly trade off against other goals in their
  119. life and uh we're starting to work on a theoretical approach to uh to modeling that and thinking about how we can uh
  120. better use that type of framework to import uh psychological data and happiness data into economic analysis
  121. [Music]

Brief Summary

Happiness data can forecast decisions but fails to accurately reflect trade-offs in choices, as shown in a study of medical students.

Key points

  • The Role of Happiness Data. Happiness data can effectively forecast choices, even in high-stakes decisions like medical residency.
  • Trade-offs in Decision Making. People often prioritize family well-being over their own happiness when making choices.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes