Social Media or Social Minefield

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Social media has made it easy to connect with others on many different levels -- but it's also opened us up to a host of unintended consequences.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1j2YJOz 📂 Management;Human Resources 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so with my colleagues what I was trying to look at was this question of online social media and how that's impacting
  2. our work lives social media is really all around us in the recent in recent years and we see this in organizations
  3. in terms of how organizations are using it to Market Etc but how it affects people's work lives is what we were
  4. interested in and this this is really where the title When Worlds Collide comes into play we were really
  5. interested in how the personal and professional lives of employees can become blurred on online social media
  6. and so this is where we really um we really see both opportunity but also challenge for people one of our uh we we
  7. did some interviews uh as we were doing this work and one of our interviewees said social media or social mindfield
  8. right this is and really sums up really beautifully I think the inherent Paradox
  9. here we have both A New World opening up for us where social media has so many amazing uh opportunities to connect and
  10. to enhance relationships and to build new relationships but it also poses challenges for us as we think about how
  11. to manage the relationships that we that we have one of the big challenges is this notion of the invisible audience
  12. when we connect to people on Facebook or on Twitter or Instagram there are some people who are really following us and
  13. are responding to us or liking us or favoring us or they're they're they're very visible because they're interacting
  14. with us in a much more visible way but there's often a whole host of people who are invisible who are just sort of in
  15. the background who are watching what we're saying or doing but are not actively responding and what happens is
  16. that we can often times forget about them when we're posing these uh when we're posing
  17. questions when we're posting information uh and what'll happen is sometimes that
  18. information that we post has some unintended effects in terms of how people respond to us and that's really
  19. what we were focusing on in this research focusing on what are the consequences of different online social
  20. media strategies that people have we identified four strategies that people use now these are archetypal
  21. strategies people might use a hybrid of of these as well but the four strategies
  22. that we identified were one the first is called the open strategy so this is where the people who are willing to
  23. connect to anyone and everyone and they post anything and everything right so the good bad the ugly uh they'll reveal
  24. they'll they'll share it with everybody and this is this is sort of the the the strategy of authenticity openness trying
  25. to uh connect broadly and fully that's the open strategy the second strategy that we identified uh was one where
  26. people are much more careful about the audience that they choose to connect to and we call that the audience strategy
  27. as a result so they they limit the audience who they are they're they are conferring with and this by the way
  28. helps with invisible audience problem that I mentioned earlier um they they also though will use a strategy of
  29. authenticity so they've they've carefully curated who Their audience is but they will Express fully The Good Bad
  30. and the Ugly to that carefully chosen audience Okay the third strategy is what we call the content strategy so here
  31. people will choose to connect broadly to multiple audiences but they will carefully instead curate their content
  32. they will choose uh pick and choose what kinds of uh information to post they will typically choose things to post
  33. that is more self-enhancing that manages the impression that they're that they're
  34. giving to other people uh and so we call that the content strategy the last strategy is what we call the custom
  35. strategy these are folks who carefully manage uh the the the the worlds where they separate the the audiences they
  36. they'll connect to multiple audiences but they'll carefully manage what gets seen by which audience and so this is a
  37. more difficult strategy to manage if you you need to have some technologically uh
  38. sophisticated skills and you need to monitor it right and so uh this is where for example on Facebook there are things
  39. like lists that you can use where you have different lists and you put and you have one list see maybe everything and
  40. then another list see only a a sub selection of of what you're posting um and and so this strategy will again
  41. allow you to connect broadly but and but it will uh and it will allow you to verify and to you know
  42. uh be authentic to one set of your audiences but to be more careful about what another audience
  43. sees so each of these strategies has important consequences for respect and liking so one of the in the workplace
  44. how you're seen professionally by others right and one of the things that we see
  45. is that the open the open strategy might be very very um it might make you likable deeply likable to some people
  46. but again with that invisible audience there could be a whole bunch of people who might be offended even by some of
  47. the things so if you're posting political views some of your audience might be rah rah right with you and
  48. others are kind of silently um a little bit taken aback by what you're what you're expressing right
  49. and so there are there are some different consequences in in terms of these different strategies the audience
  50. strategy allows you typically to you know preserve the respect of others around you but not not not necessarily
  51. enhance it if you're not connecting with them um the the custom strategy is the one which we would argue has the
  52. highest uh sort of ability to both maximize respect and liking but it's hard to do and if you make a mistake
  53. then it can have a backlash because then people realize oh wow you're actively managing this and you're managing me Etc
  54. um the content strategy also will have the opportunity to enhance professional respect and liking but again you could
  55. go overboard on that if you're if you're too you know enhancing people might be put off by that right and so there might
  56. be some there might be some backlash there as well so all of these have tradeoffs and they they need to be
  57. chosen carefully we have a couple of different thoughts about how to do that so I think that there's a couple of
  58. different steps that you want to think about when you think about the strategy that you're choosing and what the
  59. consequences are for your online social uh media presence and how that affects your professional reputation so firstly
  60. you need to choose your strategy think about think think about what your strategy is and what it should be right
  61. maybe what you're doing isn't what you should be doing right so be be thoughtful about what your strategy is
  62. secondly you want to think about whether what your goals are on social media is your goal to express yourself or to
  63. impress others right so thinking about whether you want to let the good Bad and the Ugly all hang out and whether you
  64. want everybody to see that or whether you want to be more aware of your professional reputation and what the
  65. impact that has on others and how that how that's seen by others right and so the impression management piece may be
  66. more important in terms of your goal the third piece that we really think is important in terms of how you manage
  67. this behavior is to also assess your fit with the professional context that you're in so if you're a lawyer uh and
  68. uh you you may not be able to be connected with a judge on online social media because that would there are
  69. regulations around that however if you're in a technology startup company the norm and the culture may be that all
  70. of you are connected and that's how you interact and you do online chat and you do Facebook and you do Instagram and and
  71. all of that is part of how you relate to your co-workers and so you need to be really aware of both your personal
  72. preferences as well as your on as well as your environment and how that all fits
  73. together so I think that the Gaff is actually really important because the a lot I think people are very inertial in
  74. terms of their strategies until they either have something where there's there's a big sort of Gaff that happens
  75. where they get feedback negative feedback about what happened or if they are switching their professional context
  76. right there's some there's usually some impetus for people to change their strategy it doesn't happen that that
  77. frequently um so uh as an example one of our interviewees had a situation where she was she worked at a synagogue and uh
  78. her Rabbi uh had asked her if he could connect with her on Facebook and so she said sure she was very active on
  79. Facebook and one of the things that this is a a reform uh synagogue where they um
  80. you know it they they they they they abide by a lot of the you know regulations that the more strict uh Jews
  81. would but it was not necessarily uh it's not as strict right and so she she was um posting a picture of her son who was
  82. playing a soccer game on a Saturday and um so her Rabbi saw that and said to her
  83. you know as an employee of the synagogue I don't think it's a good idea for you to be posting a picture of your son even
  84. though it's this wholesome soccer game on a Saturday because it's giving the you know the wrong impression because
  85. it's Shabbat and that he shouldn't be playing soccer on a Saturday and she was really taken back by this and uh was a
  86. little surprised and she ended up um unfriending him as a result um but it was really I mean it was a real wakeup
  87. call to her that you know she needed to be more aware of who was in her audience and so you know these these
  88. gaffs really do I think sometimes make people much more aware of what strategy they have so sometimes gffs can be good
  89. because they they bring to light what your what Your strategy is and if you do need to correct it because you need to
  90. be much more aware of how people are responding to you so our research shows that
  91. what what's changed really is that people need to be much more careful about thinking about their communication
  92. strategy when we communicate face to face or over the phone or dietic or in a small group typically what happens is we
  93. automatically tailor our Communications to our audiences we read their facial expressions we look at their nonverbals
  94. their body language we H we usually know something about them and so we're we're
  95. more careful about how we are automatically careful about how we are tailoring what we are saying and how
  96. we're saying it in online social media what's happened is that the whole point is that we're connected to a broad
  97. audience right and and that's that's really the purpose of it but what happens is it makes it much more
  98. difficult to tailor our Communications in an effective way and there are as as we were talking about earlier there are
  99. gaffs that people can make where they are not tailoring their Communications in a way that they would just naturally
  100. do in these other in these other media right and so one of the re there's some there's some really spectacular examples
  101. from the media recently um there was a a a US Marine uh core member who was uh running a tea party website uh Facebook
  102. page and what he did was he posted negative comments about Obama not really realizing and forgetting about the fact
  103. that uh there there was actually a policy a pentagon policy about that Limits The Free Speech rights of their
  104. uh of of uh military members and so what ended up happening was he was um discharged not honorably because he had
  105. really violated this policy when he said something extremely negative about Obama
  106. uh there's another example uh where that involved Twitter where um Bob Parsons who was the CEO of GoDaddy uh he's he
  107. was an avid Game Hunter and he had gone and had he posted a video of himself you
  108. know I think shooting elephants in Zimbabwe and uh you know Peta got and and posted this on Twitter and um Peta
  109. really uh got very very um exercised about this and he ended up having to step down a CEO and so there are a lot
  110. of uh ways in which we see that this new online social media has one opened up doors right opened up amazing doors in
  111. terms of allowing us to connect really broadly and impactfully in ways that personalize who we are and make people
  112. feel connected to us but it also has the the challenge of how do we do this in a
  113. consistent and positive way such that we don't have some of these really spectacular disasters that can befall uh
  114. and or even small disasters that can befall us um along the way we're going a lot of different
  115. directions one of the directions that I'm really excited about is a project that's looking at online social media
  116. and how that helps with teams one of the things that is really challenging in today's environment is we're oftentimes
  117. working in global teams where everybody's not collocated so we're interested in seeing how online social
  118. media can be really positive for people who are working in non-collocated teams and asking the
  119. question do some of these online social media strategies help more than others uh another way that we're looking at
  120. going forward in in this research is looking at the question of hierarchy one of the things that came up in a lot of
  121. the interviews that we did with folks initially around online social media usage was the question of hierarchy and
  122. how uh the the online uh the online relationship is um thinking about connecting with
  123. your boss thinking con about connecting with your subordinates so once you cross
  124. those hierarchical lines how does that really impact your work relationships a lot of our uh interview subjects
  125. actually likened their boss being Facebook friends for example with their boss to being Facebook friends with
  126. their mothers and so you know that hierarchical line I think is a really important one and we're we're also doing
  127. some research trying to understand and when PE how people react to that and what the consequences are for crossing
  128. those lines in the workplace

Brief Summary

The episode covers social media's impact on work lives and strategies for managing personal and professional boundaries.

Key points

  • When Worlds Collide. Exploring how social media blurs personal and professional lives, presenting both opportunities and challenges.
  • Strategies for Social Media. Identifying four archetypal strategies for managing online presence and their consequences.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes